Note: If you cannot see the images, click on “Chris Ciovacco’s Tumblr” above. 2013-2014: Not A Good Benchmark: It has not been difficult to find “as long as the Fed is in charge, we will never have another serious correction”comments in recent weeks. The July 31 selloff in risk assets may have brought some back closer to reality. Key points regarding the real world and investment stress:
If you are relatively new to the investing world, you may not have a realistic reference point to understand how painful stock market corrections can be.
A trip down the memory lane of market corrections (1982-2014) reminds us of what a typical year in the stock market can look like.
Is there any way to reduce stress related to the fear of a correction or bear market?
A Trip Down Correction Memory Lane
Since weekends offer an opportunity to study markets and improve our approach to investing, it may be helpful to take a quick refresher course on stock market corrections. We will focus on two questions:
- How far can stocks drop?
- How long can corrections last?
Sample of Corrections 1982-2014
In 1984, stocks dropped 14.63%. Unlike the multiple-day pullbacks in 2013 and 2014, this correction lasted two hundred and eighty-eight calendar days (288).
The 1987 stock market crash occurred within the context of a bull market, and the bull market resumed relatively quickly. Therefore, it is relevant to our correction study and 2014.
In 1990, stocks corrected sharply, dropping 20% over eighty-seven calendar days.
We have covered the importance of the investment landscape in 1994 numerous times, including this March 21 article. Stocks slid just under 10%.
In 1998, the correction may have felt like a bear market based on the sharp declines witnessed on brokerage and 401k statements. The 1998 correction was outlined in more detail on April 2.
The 2010 Flash Crash was quite a bit more than a one-day media event. Stocks dropped 16.71% over sixty-seven calendar days.
A political stalemate in Washington and escalating fears of the end of the euro, helped push stocks down over 21% in 2011.
2014: Numerous Concerns
If you know your market history, you probably remember the fundamental drivers behind the corrections in 1984, 1987, 1990, 1998, 2010, and 2011. The drivers in 2014 could come from a combination of concerns. From Bloomberg:
“Investors have been looking for an excuse to sell,” Angus Gluskie, who helps oversee more than $550 million at White Funds Management in Sydney, said by phone. “We’ve got a range of convenient reasons for investors to take some money off the table. The geopolitical risks have been rising and data flow in the U.S. is suggesting that the Fed may have to raise interest rates sooner rather than later. The Argentine issue is another piece of adverse news flow.”
Corrections Can Be Harmful To Your Portfolio’s Health
What are the answers to our questions of how far can stocks drop and how long can corrections last? Based on the examples presented above, the average loss was 19.50% and the average duration was 114 calendar days. Can corrections be less painful? Sure, there are countless examples of more shallow pullbacks. However, understanding what is possible helps with investment contingency planning.
Markets Are A Difficult Nut To Crack
Anyone who has worked on Wall Street or managed their own investments will have little trouble agreeing with the following statement:
The financial markets are a difficult place to succeed, even for those who have flourished in other areas of their life or career.
Therefore, there is no shame in having some missteps on your investment resume. Like anything in life, we cannot expect to see improvement unless we are willing to make some positive changes.
Stress Is A Call To Action
It does not matter whether you are a professional trader or someone who is investing for retirement; the odds are good you have some holes in your approach to the financial markets. Stress is nature’s way of helping us identify those holes. While there is no system or investment approach that can eliminate stress, there are things you can do to improve your odds of investment success, while greatly reducing stress related to bullish and bearish scenarios for both stocks and bonds. If you are tossing and turning at night, the first step toward sounder sleep is to leverage the simple and powerful concepts from David Schwartz’s book The Magic Of Thinking Big:
Stress Reduction Through Contingency Planning
What causes investment stress? The biggest contributor is uncertainty…how far could stocks drop?…what should I do?…when should I do it?…what happens if we see a 20% correction?…What happens if it morphs into a bear market and my stocks drop 50%?…how will I ever be able to retire?…will I have to go back to work?
Stress Will Drop If You Can Handle Extreme Cases
When testing your current approach to the markets, it is helpful to look at extreme outcomes. If you can handle the extremes, then you can handle almost anything in between. Therefore, if the questions below induce a high level of stress and uneasiness, it may be time for you to provide some leadership for your portfolio. Do you have specific and implementable plans in place for the three scenarios below?
- Case A: stocks and bonds fall simultaneously as they did in 1994.
- Case B: stocks rise an additional 91% over the next three years as they did during the final leg of the dot-com bubble (1997-2000).
- Case C: stocks drop over 50% as they did in the 2000-2002 and 2007-2009 bear markets.
Two Paths To A Better Night’s Sleep
Individual investors have two “action cures fear” paths to take to improve their odds of investment success and worry less about the three market scenarios listed above:
- Path One: Build your own system to address the three extreme cases above.
- Path Two: Find an existing system or strategy that can handle all three cases.
The First Step Is Making A Decision To Take Action
Acknowledging the need for contingency plans and making a decision to do something about it will have a stress-reducing effect. A good next step is to set aside some quiet time when the markets are closed to outline a plan to move down one of the two paths above. If you want to build your own system, an article from last October may spark some ideas. If you decide to get some help from an advisor or money manager, make sure their approach to the markets passes the “that makes sense to me” test. Even the best systems in the world experience frustrating periods that require patience. A manager’s system is useless if you cannot stay invested during bumpy periods. Compatibility of philosophy between you and your manager will make it much easier to stay within the confines of the disciplined approach.
Investment Implications – Contingency Plans In Action
Our contingency plans are governed by our market model. The model entered Friday’s session with a very large allocation to cash to offset the market’s increasingly vulnerable risk-reward profile. Are contingency plans helpful in the area of stress reduction? We think so. Our approach has called for recent reductions in portfolio risk - lower risk is highly correlated with better sleep. The first tweet is from July 25 and the second from July 31.
What prompted the risk-reduction chess moves on July 25 and July 31? Observable shifts in the market’s tolerance for risk. Here are three examples of recent 2014 evidence that said “risks are increasing from a probability perspective”; last Friday’s video outlined evidence of waning bullish conviction, a July 26 article showed a lower high that was forming on the weekly NYSE Composite chart, and a July 30 piece showed evidence of concern on the ratio of stocks (SPY) relative to bonds (AGG).
While we are not fans of forecasting, the big picture in March 2014 is more in line with the increasing probability of a stock market correction, rather than a shift into a full-blown bear market. However, corrections can last several months and can do considerable damage to your portfolio and sleep cycle. Even if a corrective episode is averted in the short run, it is only a matter of time before the correction-less investment fantasy land comes to a painful end.
Stress-Reducing Plans vs. Stress-Inducing Plans
If your plan for investment success can be summed up with “I will figure it out as the investment landscape shifts over time”, your probability of success will be quite low. Traders have much shorter time horizons than investors, but they traders have one thing in common; ad hoc and seat-of-the-pants traders are rarely successful. Professional traders who have a long history of producing above average results tend to spend much less time tossing and turning at night since:
They have identified and understand what their edge is in the markets.
They have risk management rules or systems in place to protect their hard-earned capital.
They have backtested, but not curve-fitted, their approach to investing.
They understand how markets price assets and their role within the bigger picture.
They follow their systems and rules religiously. They do not rationalize away information from the markets.
They have decided in advance how they will approach both favorable and unfavorable markets.
Further Weekend Study
Contingency planning is a quadrant two activity – important, but not urgent. Many of you know the importance of getting into quadrant two from Covey’s book, The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People.
Weekends are a good time for getting into quadrant two. The articles below expand on the concepts covered above:
2014: Where Do We Go From Here?
Since this post was penned before the August 1 release of the monthly labor report, and before Friday’s trading session, it should be acknowledged that things are always subject to change, for better or worse. Entering Friday’s session, we were allocated in line with the evidence as of July 31. We have a good stake in cash, stocks (SPY), and a relatively small stake in Treasuries (TLT). If the evidence continues to deteriorate, we will continue to cut risk and possibly add defensive assets, such as a diversified basket of bonds (BND). If the evidence improves, we are open to redeploying our cash into growth-oriented assets, such as stocks (VTI).
Recommended for You
Alan Colmes, the radio and television host and commentator best known as the amiable liberal foil to the hard-right Sean Hannity on the Fox News Channel, has died. Fox spokeswoman Dana Klinghoffer confirmed ...Associated Press
Former House Speaker John Boehner (R-OH) has been watching the controversy over health care play out from the sidelines, and he understands better than most how hard it is to forge a compromise within his party, even under the best of circumstances. Boehner is no fan of President Donald Trump, and declared last December that the election campaign had been “the most bizarre political year that we've seen in 100 years.” In the new Trumpian political era, Boehner is persona non grata among many Republicans he once led. While the former speaker’s comments will be taken with a grain of salt by diehards determined to repeal and replace the Obamacare later this year, Boehner on Thursday predicted that Trump and the Republicans would fall far short of their goal.The Fiscal Times
Although President-elect Donald Trump has pledged to cut federal taxes, state taxes are rising across the U.S. as financially strapped states search for funds to repair deteriorating infrastructure and close widening budget shortfalls. Alaska currently has no income or state sales tax. Raising existing state taxes or imposing new ones could backfire if they lead to fewer taxpayers.Kiplinger
Feb.23 -- Saudi Arabia has said oil giant Saudi Aramco is worth more than $2 trillion, enough to consume Apple twice, and still have room for Google parent Alphabet Inc. The kingdom may have to settle for less. A lot less. Bloomberg's Richard Stubbe has more on "Bloomberg Daybreak: Asia."Bloomberg Video
In January, J.C. Penney CEO Marvin Ellison said the department store chain was getting ready to downsize its fleet.CNBCJCP $6.46 -5.83%
Former U.S. vice president and Apple (AAPL) board member Al Gore sold about half his holdings in Apple stock on Wednesday, garnering more than $29 million. According to an SEC filing, Gore sold 215,437 shares on Wednesday, leaving him with 230,137 shares remaining. Apple shares hit an all-time high of $134.54 earlier this month.CNBC.com q
Vanguard is lowering fees again and ETF investors are winning.Investopedia q
For nearly a decade, rock-bottom mortgage rates have fueled the housing market, but that could end as rates start climbing. More than half of current home shoppers consider rising interest rates among the top factors affecting their ability to buy a home, according to a new survey from Zillow Group Mortgages. On the median priced home, an increase in mortgage rates from 4 percent to 5 percent would add $100 to the monthly bill, according to Zillow.The Fiscal TimesZ $35.17 -0.48%
There are other effective ways to reach your savings goals.CNBC
The company has nearly a decade of declining sales and earnings with no turnaround in sight.The Street q
Coming in at around $86 billion, Bill Gates has ridden his Microsoft fortune straight to the top of the Forbes list of the world’s richest men. Then again, the business magazine doesn’t take into account ...MarketWatch q
Sears laid off 130 employees at its corporate offices on Thursday as the company struggles to...Business Insider
Employers that provided generous matching contributions and a menu of low-cost investments to workers scored well on this retirement benefits ranking.CNBC
Feb.23 -- Ivanka Trump has urged lawmakers writing a tax overhaul to include a deduction for child care expenses, but with a price tag of as much as $500 billion over a decade, she may have trouble finding support in Congress. Bloomberg’s Shannon Pettypiece reports on “Bloomberg Markets: European Close.”Bloomberg Video
White House Chief Strategist Steve Bannon made a rare public appearance on Thursday, speaking at the Conservative Political Action Conference outside Washington, DC, where he described what he sees as a “new political order” forming in the US. Bannon was making a joint appearance with White House Chief of Staff Reince Priebus that was moderated by Matt Schlapp, chairman of the American Conservative Union.The Fiscal Times
The South China Sea question is rolling toward the Trump White House like a long, low Pacific wave. The strategy is just a piece of what President Trump has to provide. Trump could find a place in the White House attic for Barack Obama’s over-reaching “pivot to Asia” in favor of a wiser policy that acknowledges China’s emerging role in the region as inevitable.The Fiscal Times
Norwegian is expanding its network of flights to the United States starting in mid-June after receiving long-awaited U.S. approval in December for its Irish subsidiary Norwegian Air International to operate routes across the Atlantic. Established U.S. carriers have been forced to consider restricted cheaper fares and redesigned cabins with more seats to win budget-conscious travelers to compete with Norwegian and rival Icelandic carrier Wow Air. Norwegian's $65 fares will be for a one-way ticket to UK and Irish destinations from smaller airports in New York state, Providence, Rhode Island, and Hartford, Connecticut.Reuters
Master limited partnership Phillips 66 Partners offers steady dividend payouts thanks to quarters of impressive growth.The Street q
Applied Materials, Fitbit, NVIDIA and Intel highlighted as Zacks Bull and Bear of the DayZacksINTC $36.53 0.97%