I’m going to show you two portfolios — I’m not initially going to tell you much about either one, but then you can consider which one you might like better. Here’s portfolio A:
And here is portfolio B:
There is one obvious difference in the two portfolios: portfolio B has gone up more than portfolio A in the past year. But the hidden story is that portfolio A’s stocks have had price returns of -85% or worse over the past four years, whereas portfolio B’s stocks have has price returns of 1000% or better. They are the only stocks with current market caps of over $100 million that meet those criteria.
Now, which one would you choose, if you had to hold one portfolio for the next year? The next four years?
Oddly, the right answer might be portfolio A. Currently, I am reading through a book called Deep Value, which I will review in a week or two, and they cite in Chapter 5 some research by Thaler and De Bondt which indicates that portfolios that have gone through extreme failure tend to outperform portfolios that have gone through extreme success.
Though the momentum anomaly (weak as it has been recently) usually favors portfolios with stronger price momentum, the relationship breaks down over longer periods of time, and more severe moves, where mean-reversion tends to take over. One thing that I can tell looking at the two portfolios — the expectations are a lot, lot higher for portfolio B than portfolio A. Things only have to stop getting worse for there to some positive price action there.
Sometimes I like to run a screen for stocks have done badly over the last four years, but have begun to outperform over the last year. This can point out areas that are still ignored by most of the market, but where trend may have shifted. I’ll post that screen after my software has its weekly update on Saturday. Until then.
PS — as an aside, it will be fun to review the relative performance of these portfolios.
Recommended for You
Nearly a week after Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) announced his bid for the White House, the Republican senator from Florida is attacking Democratic presidential contender Hillary Clinton—especially on matters of foreign policy. Rubio continued to bash the president’s foreign policy and blamed Clinton…The Fiscal Times39 mins ago
BOSTON (AP) — Ben Affleck requested that the PBS documentary series "Finding Your Roots" not reveal he had a slave-owning ancestor, according to emails published online by whistleblower site WikiLeaks, and the information never appeared on the program.Associated Press
Some oil stocks have sold off well below oil prices.USA TODAY
Why does Guy Adami think Ben Bernanke is going to be one of the most vilified people of the 21st century?CNBC
Before you get too excited and start booking flights to Las Vegas for the $400 million May 2 fight between Floyd Mayweather Jr. and Manny Pacquiao, let us be clear: These $10 tickets are not for the actual fight, but for the weigh-in. Under Nevada State law, weigh-ins have always been free for the…The Fiscal Times
247 Wall St. could not help but notice four analyst calls this past week in which upside of 50% to 100% was predicted for four biotech and specialty pharma stocks.24/7 Wall St.
Being disorganized can cost you money, and if you trim your stuff, you may slim down, too.USA TODAY
Angels outfielder Josh Hamilton has put his mansion-estate in Newport Coast on the market for $16.5 million.Los Angeles Times
As Iraqi Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi was meeting President Obama and his cabinet in Washington, D.C. this week to ask for more U.S. military aid, ISIS was regaining its momentum and recapturing territory in Iraq. The group took control of Iraq's largest oil refinery for a day and is threatening…The Fiscal Times
By Alan Baldwin MANAMA (Reuters) - Formula One world champion Lewis Hamilton won the Bahrain Grand Prix for the second year in a row on Sunday with Ferrari's Kimi Raikkonen back on the podium to deny Mercedes another one-two finish under the floodlights. "I am gunning for it," Hamilton told triple…Reuters
WASHINGTON (AP) — United Airlines stopped a prominent security researcher from boarding a California-bound flight late Saturday, following a social media post by the researcher days earlier suggesting the airline's onboard systems could be hacked.Associated Press
BEIJING (AP) — China's Central Bank said Sunday that it will cut its bank reserve requirement ratio by 1 percentage point to stimulate more lending into a slowing economy.Associated Press
Want to buy your first home with little or nothing down and maybe get a refund on part of your realty agent's commission?Los Angeles Times
Dear Liz: What can I do to stop my broker from deducting trading fees from my Roth IRA contributions, which I make monthly? Let's say I invest $420 each month, but the broker takes $7, or $84 a year. Shouldn't ...Los Angeles Times
Comcast and Time Warner Cable will hold a vital meeting with the US Justice Department this week in an attempt to allay the concerns of antitrust officials about a merger of the country's two largest cable ...Financial Times
Issues of margin trading, a surge of individual investors into local shares, a ballooning stock market, and a slowing of the world’s second largest economy sent the largest China ETF by assets plunging ...24/7 Wall St.
For many people, working at Google is a dream...Business Insider
Tech industry giants Steve Jobs, Andy Grove and Bill Gates were not cast from the mold of the model business leader.Los Angeles Times
A confident OPEC stated that demand for its oil is likely to increase in 2015. Additionally, it believes that U.S production will decrease, starting this fallOilprice.com