US interest rates fell again today, just as they have for most of 2014. After starting the year at 3%, the 10 year yield is now 2.4%. Falling long term interest rates has been the single most important financial story of 2014. The interest rate lens explains most of the market movements that we’ve seen so far this year.
It’s been a strange environment for rates to be falling though. The US economy appears to have been improving, inflation appears to be more stable (even according to the Fed), growth expectations have mostly risen throughout the year, and the Fed has been tapering. These have been thematic elements of 2014, and all of these themes would usually suggest higher interest rates, yet interest rates have fallen.
My hypothesis as to why rates have been falling while growth expectations have been rising is that investors are comparing US interest rates to other developed countries. US interest rates are much higher than many other countries including Germany, France, Canada and, of course, Japan. However, while foreign countries’ interest rates are lower than ours, the spread is probably justified because their growth is lower than ours too.
Below is a chart of interest rates vs. nominal GDP growth of 30 different countries. It shows that interest rates track nominal GDP growth fairly well. This isn’t too surprising because nominal GDP captures both inflation and growth, which are two main inputs to interest rates. Historically nominal GDP has been closely correlated to US interest rates.
The US and UK have much higher interest rates than Germany and France, but we also have higher growth. In 2013, nominal GDP grew by 3.7% in the US and 3.5% in the UK compared to 0.88% in Germany and 1.17% in France.
Importantly, our 10 yr interest rate seems justified by the growth-defined trend-line. If anything, our rates could be a little higher based on our nominal growth rate. On average the 10 year yield of these 30 countries is 36 basis points less than the trailing growth rate of nominal GDP. That implies that US interest rates should be 3.3% based on last year’s growth. US nominal GDP has grown 4% over the last 12 months, meaning that rates could be justifiably above 3.5%.
Just like with earnings, trailing growth is not as important as future growth though, so it’s possible that rates are falling because investors are expecting lower growth and lower inflation down the road. However, if growth and inflation are slowing, then S&P earnings estimates are almost certainly too high. Interest rates and earnings estimates are painting a contradictory view of the world that will need to be reconciled.
Source: Factset Data
Photo courtesy of: cgc76
Recommended for You
NEWARK, N.J. (AP) — Actor-comedian Tracy Morgan and other people in a limousine struck from behind by a Wal-Mart truck on a highway in June are at least partly to blame for their injuries because they weren't wearing seatbelts, the company said in a court filing Monday.Associated Press
A man ended up with a $500,000 cellphone bill after a thief used it in a foreign country, and at first, the carrier wanted the victim to pay.Credit.com
Most of us would love to leave a nice inheritance to our loved ones. However, many baby boomers will instead leave a very different kind of legacy: debt.Credit.com
Whenever we try something new, the excitement of getting started frequently overtakes us. We begin with unrealistic expectations and end disappointed. The investing experience of many people follows this ...U.S.News & World Report LP
Al Gore's investment fund is pouring $30 million into Seventh Generation, the maker of eco-friendly household products, to help build a war chest for acquisitions. CEO John Replogle joins MoneyBeat. Photo: Getty.WSJ Live
Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates topped Forbes' latest list of the 400 richest Americans for the 21st straight year. The list, released on Monday, was largely unchanged for 2014 and showed the rich getting ...Associated Press
These are the top analyst upgrades, downgrades and initiations covered by 24/7 Wall St. for Tuesday, September 30, 2014.24/7 Wall St.
Investor sentiment has soured so fast, a rebound is likely, writes Mark Hulbert.MarketWatch
Markets are reacting in real time to tension in Ukraine following Russia’s March incursion into Crimea and subsequent annexation of the Black Sea peninsula. The ruble fell 0.8 percent to 39.5000 per dollar, bringing its drop since Feb. 28, the day before President Vladimir Putin ’s incursion, to…Bloomberg
NEW YORK/LONDON (Reuters) - Gold prices dropped on Monday after U.S. Mass protests in Hong Kong stirred unrest in the global financial hub and in China, which rules its special administrative region under a "one country, two systems" formula that accords the territory only a degree of democracy.Reuters
As General Motors (GM) went through its recalls this year, it was easy to feel confident in Ford Motor (F), which appeared to have avoided most of its competitor's missteps. Shares of Ford plunged more than 7% today, with much of that occurring during the last hour of trading, after the automaker…Barrons.com
Ever since the bombshell announcement of Bond King Bill Gross' decampment from Pimco to the much smaller Janus Capital, Wall Street pundits and players have been offering their takes on what happened. ...Los Angeles Times
PARIS (Reuters) - China's role in supplying cheap consumer goods to the West could end in coming years due to rising domestic consumption and worker pay, stoking inflation and unsettling retailers in Western markets, the chairman of logistics group Li & Fung warned. "China will disrupt the world,"…Reuters
Apple, eBay, Move, Walgreen and Netflix are among the stocks the Yahoo Finance team will be watching for you today.Hot Stock Minute
These states impose the highest taxes on retirees, according to Kiplinger's 2014 analysis of state taxes.Kiplinger
China will begin direct trading between its yuan currency and the euro starting on Tuesday, the national foreign exchange market's operator said, as Beijing seeks to broaden the unit's global usage.AFP
Apple denies it has done anything wrong.Business Insider
Was the biggest IPO of all time a huge signal to sell stocks?Talking Numbers