Did the Options Market Just Fire a Major Warning for Stocks?

View gallery

Did the Options Market Just Fire a Major Warning for Stocks?

We’re making new highs and everything is great, right?  Well, maybe things are a little too good and the masses are just buying everything they can now, which is a huge contrarian warning.  

The ISE Sentiment Index is a proprietary put/call ratio that uses only opening long customer transactions.  In other words, it is measuring how many people are buying a new position in bullish call options or bearish put options.  I like to use put/call ratios to see if the masses are getting too one-sided.  Remember, once everyone is expecting something, it rarely happens when it comes to investing.  

This ratio is actually constructed as a call/put ratio and it just had three straight days over 200, meaning there were twice as many calls opened versus puts.  Again, when everyone is buying calls (especially on equities like this ratio tracks) that could be a warning traders are a little too excited.  

Here’s what really has Twitter buzzing right now.  The previous two times we saw three straight days >200 were 1/16/14 and 7/22/11.  The S&P 500 (SPX) dropped -3.43% and -10.83% just 10 days later.  

Here’s the chart so far YTD.  The only meaningful weakness so far this year took place just after the last time this happened.  Could a quick drop happen again here?  

image

You have to go back nearly three years for the most recent time other than January we saw three straight days >200.  Back in July ‘11 we saw five straight days and this took place just ahead of the huge August correction.  

image

So on the surface this indeed does seem pretty scary.  Now I’m not a big fan of just using two data points and saying it matters.  It could be random.  Going back to 2006 and I found there were 42 other times this ratio was >200 for 3 straight days.  Here are the returns after.  

image

Not much to like about those stats if you are bullish.  Negative across the board, that is tough to do.  

My pal @Market_Time created this great chart last night on the subject.  It shows all the signals with a chart of the SPX since 2006.

Finally, here are the longest streaks (since 2006) of consecutive trading days with this ratio >200.  A few things stand out to me.  First off, the longest streak ever took place just a few months before a major market peak.  Also there was a streak of six in a row in October ‘07, right as the market peaked.  April 2010 saw two streaks of six in a row and this took place just as the market was forming a major peak that took nearly seven months to get back above.  Lastly, we simply haven’t seen this phenomena the last few years.  

image

There’s no other way than to say this is a worry if you are bullish.  Now one trait of this bull market since 2013 is it has ignored nearly all previous bearish signals that once worked in the past.  Can it do it again?  

Photo courtesy of Eduard Titov.  

View Comments (13)

Recommended for You

  • Bill Gates Is At Least $6 Billion Richer Than He Was Six Months Ago, But Not From Microsoft

    In July, Bill Gates may or may not have lost his title as the world's richest man. According to Forbes, Gates has a net worth of almost $82 billion, which puts him in the No. 2 spot behind Mexican telecom magnate Carlos Slim, who's worth $85.4 billion. According to Bloomberg, Gates is still the…

    Business Insider
  • Why Choose Medicare Supplement Insurance?

    AARP® Medicare Supplement by UnitedHealthcare® Insurance Company. Get a free decision guide!

    AdChoicesUnitedHealthcare® Ins Co.Sponsored
  • Live blog: What’s happening with Alibaba’s IPO?

    Live blog: What’s happening with Alibaba’s IPO? The big day has arrived, and the Chinese company that 88 percent of Americans have never heard of is making history on the New York Stock Exchange. We’re rounding up all the facts, sass and stories you need

    Gigaom
  • Can Sears Close 2,300 Stores?

    In a widely publicized note to investors, Gary Balter of Credit Suisse said that it is best that Sears Holdings Corp. (SHLD) close its Sears and Kmart locations while they, and the inventory they sell, still have value. Sears Holdings operates about 2,350 stories. Sears is generating negative…

    24/7 Wall St.
  • Chinese buyers lead charge in iPhone 6 global debut

    Buyers from China, deprived of the latest iPhone launch at home, were Friday among the first in line in Japan to grab the "6" and its new large-screen cousin as Apple hit back at rivals. Licensing problems in China meant the global rollout went ahead without the huge and lucrative market, in a blow…

    AFP
  • PepsiCo boss decries NFL problems, backs Goodell

    PepsiCo Inc.'s CEO Indra Nooyi has made a double-edged statement on the NFL's problems handling domestic violence, calling some players' behavior "repugnant" but saying that Commissioner Roger Goodell is "a man of integrity." The boss of the maker of Pepsi, Gatorade and Doritos, one of the league's…

    Associated Press
  • Lacker Says He Opposes Fed Plan to Hold Mortgage-Backed Assets

    Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond President Jeffrey Lacker said he couldn’t fully support the central bank’s revised exit strategy released this week because he opposes a measure to hold mortgage-backed securities. “I believe this approach unnecessarily prolongs our interference in the allocation of…

    Bloomberg
  • How Boeing's bumpy 787 launch is paying dividends

    New Boeing 787 Dreamliners taking off from Paine Field in Everett, Washington. It took Boeing Co. 10 bumpy years to turn its 787 Dreamliner concept into a commercial success. At least that's the conclusion from aerospace analysts at Jefferies, who in a note published Thursday write that all those…

    MarketWatch
  • Master's in Organizational Development-No GRE

    Get a master's degree 100% online in organizational development in 2 years! Top ranked by US News & World Report. No GRE or GMAT required. Apply now!

    AdChoicesAbilene Christian Univ.Sponsored
  • 'Bubble in everything, everywhere': Marc Faber

    Even after the Dow (Dow Jones Global Indexes: .DJI) and the S&P 500 (^GSPC) closed at new all-time highs, closely followed contrarian Marc Faber keeps sounding the alarm. Faber has long argued that the Federal Reserve's massive asset purchasing programs and near-zero interest rates have inflated…

    CNBC
  • Play

    Analyst: Alibaba Stock Is Priced Conservatively

    Morningstar director of equity research R.J. Hottovy joins MoneyBeat and explains why he views the company's shares priced conservatively at its IPO.

    WSJ Live
  • Toyota recalling 20,000 late-model vehicles on potential fuel leak

    Toyota Motor Corp said on Thursday it will recall about 20,000 vehicles worldwide for possible fuel leaks. Most of the affected vehicles are in the United States but were also shipped to other countries, Toyota said. Toyota Motor Sales USA said the recall involves vehicles with its 2GR-FE engine.

    Reuters
  • Jack Ma set to be one of the world's 20 richest?

    Jack Ma -  If you don’t know his name already, you’ll likely know it before the week is out. Ma is the richest man in China, and stands to add billions to his net worth before the end of the week. In the early 90s, Jack Ma was a schoolteacher in China.

    Yahoo Finance
  • What Roth Owners Should Do if They Exceed the Income Limit

    You can avoid the 6% penalty on the money you contributed if you take your 2014 contributions (and any earnings on them) out of the Roth before the tax-filing deadline on April 15, 2015 (or October 15, 2015, if you file an extension). You can also avoid the penalty and taxes if you have your IRA…

    Kiplinger
  • 3 Lessons An Investor Learned After Losing His Job, Reputation, And $1.6 Million

    The late Jim Paul went from a poor Kentucky boy to serving on the board of governors of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange through a series of lucky breaks and smart investments. By 1990 he was working in the futures research department at Morgan Stanley Dean Witter & Co., managing a team that…

    Business Insider
  • Degrees for Aspiring & Current Teachers

    Grand Canyon offers bachelor's degrees for those wishing to teach & master's degrees for teachers seeking advancement. Learn more!

    AdChoicesGrand Canyon UniversitySponsored
  • Why It Pays to Join the Company Wellness Program

    My employer just announced a new wellness program and says it will charge me more for my health insurance if I don't participate. The Kaiser Family Foundation's study of 2014 health benefits found that almost all large employers (those with 200 or more employees) and nearly three-fourths of smaller…

    Kiplinger
  • Silver Is Getting Crushed

    Silver is getting crushed. On Friday, Silver fell more than 3% to less than $18 an ounce, its lowest level in more than four years. The price of gold also fell about 0.8% and touched its lowest level since January.

    Business Insider
  • Bitcoin tanks, is Alibaba to blame?

    The price of bitcoin has plummeted in the past few days, and some are blaming the Alibaba IPO for the virtual currency's fall. Members of the bitcoin community are pointing fingers at the e-commerce giant's IPO, suggesting that tech-minded China-centric money is being pulled out of the currency in…

    CNBC
  • Larry Ellison’s Legacy, Ego, Mentorship: Industry Comments

    Larry Ellison stepped down as chief executive officer of Oracle Corp. (ORCL) , closing a chapter in a career filled with aggressive competition, flamboyant spending and spectacular profits. Scott McNealy, former CEO of Sun Microsystems Inc., an Oracle competitor that Ellison eventually acquired:…

    Bloomberg
  • Play

    A Favorable Prognosis for This Pharma Stock

    Recent clinical success in cystic fibrosis positions Vertex as a dominant player in this attractive rare-disease market.

    Morningstar
  • Pabst Brewing to be sold to Russian company

    The maker of Pabst Blue Ribbon beer is being sold to Russian company Oasis Beverages for an undisclosed sum. Oasis is buying Pabst with TSG, an investment firm known for its work with consumer products companies. TSG Consumer Partners will take a minority stake in Pabst.

    Associated Press
  • Anyone With $40 Could Become A Millionaire

    1 simple Warren Buffett quote explains the key investing strategy that could create unimaginable long term wealth for you and your family.

    AdChoicesThe Motley FoolSponsored
  • Jefferies: Intel's Dividend Could Rise 45% In 2 Years

    Shares of Intel (INTC) have climbed 19% since the start of 2014 thanks in part to improving PC sales. Sure, the capital gain is great, but what about the dividend? At $35.03, the stock yields 2.6% and generates a quarterly cash payment of 22.5 cents

    Barrons.com