How Expensive Are Stocks? Comparing today to 2000 & 1929…
I spend a lot of time scouring the market for short-term tactical trading opportunities such as key reversal points, but it’s also very important to consider the big picture.
Sometimes I like to step back and try to figure out which general direction the wind is blowing in the market. In other words, what is the overall trend? Is the market cheap or expensive?
Some of my clients are “slow money investors.” They include 401(k) investors and buy-and-hold advisers who only make a few trades a year. My “big-picture” research is geared to them.
So, occasionally I do a deep dive into market valuations. Now, my experience is that broad measures of market valuation such as price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios don’t have much value for short-term, market-timing trades. After all, the market can remain “overvalued” for years at a time when investors are enthusiastic about stocks and keep bidding up valuations. Think the late 1990s.
However, looking at historic valuations can help long-term investors roughly gauge what they can expect the market to offer in the future. Of course, no one has a crystal ball. But the idea is to look at current valuations to figure out whether the market seems expensive, cheap, or fairly valued, relative to history.
Check out the chart below put together by my friend Doug Short
The chart goes back to 1990 and combines four common valuations measures into one line.
A few things jump out at me. According to this valuation yardstick, the market is similar to where it was just before the crash of 1929. It is also more expensive than it was in 2007 before the financial crisis, but by this measure, valuations are just half of what they were in 2000 leading up to the dot-com crash.
Recently, the S&P 500 has hit a rough patch the past couple weeks on geopolitical concerns in Ukraine, Gaza and Iraq. Still, the index’s price level remains a stone’s throw from all-time highs.
Put it all together, and I’ve been telling my Members that pulling back some “slow money” exposure to the market may not be a bad thing right here.
Can U.S. stocks rally more and become more “expensive?” Sure they can. But the fact remains that when you look at long-term valuations, this is rare territory. So that’s the fundamental picture.
My technical research also suggests that discretion is the better part of valor in the current climate. The chart below shows the performance of the S&P 500, on both a cap-weighed and equal-weighted basis. We’re seeing signs of weakness.
Finally, I also look at small-cap stocks to measure risk appetite. Below is an inverted (upside-down) chart of the Russell 2000. It could be carving out a pattern that may lead to trouble for small-cap stocks, which could then spill over into the S&P 500.
My idea here is NOT to scare investors. We’ve had a great run from the 2009 low and it has paid to buy every dip. The bears seem to have gone into hibernation.
Yet looking at all the evidence, I think now is the time to remain long and take a little off the table on the exposure front. Something we might want to ask and consider is…. how many long lasting buy and hold bull markets have started from these type of valuation levels in the past 100 years? So far none! Let’s see if it’s different this time.
"This article was originally published on "See It Market"
Recommended for You
NEW YORK (AP) — Chipotle, still struggling to win back customers after a series of food scares, plans to open its first burger restaurant this year.Associated Press12 mins ago
"If we are unable to obtain sufficient orders and/or market, production and other risks cannot be mitigated, we could record additional losses that may be material, and it is reasonably possible that we could decide to end production of the 747," Boeing said on Wednesday. Boeing said it had…Reuters
Beijing deflated a bubble on the ChiNext, where companies trade at 1,000 times earnings.Bloomberg
If Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer leaves the company, she will be able to take home more than double what the company originally reported. After Verizon announced the deal to buy Sunnyvale-based Yahoo, its terms revealed that Mayer could collect as much as $55 million, according to a Fortune report…Silicon Valley Business Journal
Netsuite shares rose 18.6 percent to $108.64 in premarket trading, just shy of the offer price of $109 per share. Like rivals SAP SE and Microsoft Corp, Oracle has focused on moving its business to the cloud-based model, essentially providing services remotely via data centers rather than selling…Reuters
Read about the differences between money market accounts and savings accounts, and see why a depositor would elect a money market over a savings account.Investopedia
Why did Hillary Clinton reward Debbie Wasserman Schultz after WikiLeaks published emails that exposed how the supposedly neutral DNC Chair helped undermine Bernie Sanders and abused her office? Clinton elevated the disgraced operative to Honorary Co-Chair of her campaign, further enraging Bernie’s…The Fiscal Times
Retirees may find living on a cruise ship makes financial sense when compared to other options.CNBC Videos
Jim Cramer cracked the case on how Apple managed to pull off a better-than-expected quarter, leaving investors salivating for more.CNBC
SEATTLE (AP) — As crude oil trains began rolling through its downtown a few years ago, Spokane was among the first cities to pass a resolution calling for stronger federal safety regulations.Associated Press
Alcoa Inc. plans to cut the number of its publicly traded shares with a 1-for-3 reverse stock split, as the aluminum maker prepares to split into two companies.MarketWatch
If you've ever wondered if you could take advantage of a cash-back or rewards credit card to make your monthly mortgage payment, here's your answer.Credit.com
Crude oil prices will remain in the $45-$50-a-barrel range till mid-2017, with little to change the global supply and demand situation, Goldman Sachs said.CNBC
The The Woodlands, Texas-based company said it had net income of 36 cents per share. Earnings, adjusted for restructuring costs and non-recurring costs, were 53 cents per share. The results beat Wall Street ...Associated Press
SPARKS, Nev. (AP) — It's Tesla Motors' biggest bet yet: a massive, $5 billion factory in the Nevada desert that could nearly double the world's production of lithium-ion batteries.Associated Press
Generic competition to cholesterol buster Crestor in the U.S. market pushed second-quarter core earnings down by nearly a third at drugmaker AstraZeneca, which is now banking on new cancer medicines to revive its fortunes. Its new lung cancer drug Tagrisso achieved stronger than expected quarterly…Reuters
July 27 -- On “With All Due Respect,” Mark Halperin and John Heilemann discuss Virginia Governor Terry McAuliffe’s controversial comments on Hillary Clinton’s stance on the Trans-Pacific Partnership.Bloomberg Video
Italian fashion group Roberto Cavalli said on Thursday it had named former Versace head Gian Giacomo Ferraris as its new chief executive as it seeks to relaunch under a new owner. Ferraris, an engineer who also worked for Italian luxury groups Gucci and Prada, radically turned around Versace in his…Reuters
The fiscal policy we need is not the fiscal policy we're likely to get.Bloomberg
The New York Times Co reported its second quarterly loss in a row as advertising sales declined, but the publisher said it expects a rebound in digital ad revenue growth in the current quarter. Digital ad revenue, which accounts for about a third of total ad revenue, dropped 6.8 percent in the…Reuters