Is Zillow overstating the size of its user base?

August 12, 2014 12:27 PM

View gallery

Is Zillow overstating the size of its user base?

When Zillow reported second quarter results last week, the company highlighted in its press release that it achieved record all time traffic during the quarter of 89 million unique users in July, a 45% y/y increase.  That sounds great, except that when you step back for a moment and really think about that number, it doesn’t make a whole lot of sense.

Zillow only covers the US real estate market, and there are only 121 million households in the US, which means that if Zillow really had 89 million monthly unique users, 74% of all US households would be visiting Zillow every single month.  Moreover, existing home sales are currently only running at about a 5m unit annual pace.  Are 18x that many people really using Zillow each month?  Even Twitter claims fewer monthly unique users in the US than Zillow, and Facebook claims just 2.3x more.

Sure enough if you look at Zillow’s 10-K or Q, they imply that the monthly unique data probably overstates its user count:

“If an individual accesses our mobile applications using different mobile devices within a given month, the first instance of access by each such mobile device is counted as a separate unique user. If an individual accesses our websites using different web browsers within a given month, the first access by each such web browser is counted as a separate unique user.”

In other words, if you were to visit Zillow on your phone, your PC and your tablet, you count as three users. If you visited once on Chrome and once on Safari, you count as four.

This method of counting monthly active users is not unique to Zillow.  The company pulls the user count from Google Analytics.  Still, this is an important thing to keep in mind as an investor because monthly user counts could overstate users by a factor of 2-4x.  Zillow definitely does not have 89 million engaged users.

Also, different companies measure their user counts in different ways.  Twitter explicitly says that it counts logins, Facebook only cites “internal company data.”  Both companies are explicit in their SEC filings that these are very difficult metrics to accurately count though due to duplicate users, spam, bots, etc.  They try to adjust for these factors, and estimate that these variables impact user counts by a mid to high single digit percentage.  Funnily enough though, when an analyst asked Twitter about the duplicate user issue on its most recent conference call the call abruptly ended:

“On duplicative accounts, there is some usage of multiple accounts by single users but again that’s not a number of that we just…[call ends]“

Accurately counting users should be an extremely important issue for investors because these companies all trade at high multiples of revenue on the assumption that they will be able to monetize their large user bases.  If it turns out that those user bases have been overstated by a potentially large amount, it could have a material effect on these companies’ valuations. Further, it’s not clear that any of these counts are currently independently verified.  That  probably could be an issue that requires SEC attention.

This is also an extremely important issue for advertisers on these platforms.  Currently advertisers are being drawn to these platforms with the promise of high user counts and engagement.  It’s clear that advertisers, long skeptical for reasons like the ones mentioned here, are starting to test these platforms.  However, the ROI on advertisers’ investments (on a platform saturated with other ads) still remains to be seen.

For Zillow, this actually may be an advantage because its advertisers are real estate agents who can have a more measurable sense of lead generation from the platform.  On Zillow’s most recent call they said that existing agents are spending more, which implies that agents are happy with the value that they are currently receiving.

Brand advertisers (e.g. Coca Cola, Procter and Gamble) are never able to measure the ROI of their advertising directly though because their ads don’t generate direct leads.  Therefore the ad spend on any form of media, including one like Facebook’s, requires a significant amount of trust that the ads are reaching their intended targets.  If customers start to believe that ads aren’t reaching their targets, then revenue could evaporate.  The customers of these businesses are the advertisers, not the users.  The advertisers had better be able to trust that the users are there.

Photo thanks to Wally Gobetz

View Comments (42)

Recommended for You

  • Unhappy Target customers send strong message on pill bottles

    Longtime customers of Target's pharmacies are finding a change in pill bottle design hard to swallow.

    Associated Press
  • Here’s Who the Betting Markets Are Saying Will Win the Election

    Anyone who missed last night’s presidential debate and turned to social media to try to determine how it went might have a difficult time figuring out whether Hillary Clinton or Donald Trump came away on top. Trump supporters and the candidate himself are busy declaring victory and promoting…

    The Fiscal Times
  • Japan conglomerates seek to merge loss-making nuclear fuel operations: sources

    Three Japanese conglomerates are in talks to combine their loss-making domestic nuclear fuel operations, people with direct knowledge of the matter said, as the outlook for restarts of reactors following the Fukushima nuclear crisis remains bleak. Hitachi Ltd , Toshiba Corp and Mitsubishi Heavy…

  • Toyota drops diesel from new model, signals likely phase-out

    By Laurence Frost PARIS (Reuters) - Toyota has decided to drop diesel engines from its new C-HR compact in the wake of Volkswagen's emissions scandal and will probably do the same for future model renewals, the carmaker's second-ranking global executive said on Thursday. The Japanese automaker…

  • Play

    Cramer's Stop Trading: Apple

    CNBC's Jim Cramer explains why he is watching Apple.

    CNBC Videos
  • New Adidas CEO sets off in pursuit of Nike

    Closing the gap on clear market leader Nike is the challenge facing new Adidas boss Kasper Rorsted when the Dane takes charge of the world's second biggest sportswear brand from the start of October. Investors are banking on Rorsted, 54, repeating improvements to profitability he achieved at…

  • U.S. approves Boeing, Lockheed fighter jet sales to Gulf: sources

    The United States on Wednesday began notifying lawmakers that it has approved $7 billion in long-stalled sales of Boeing Co fighter jets to Kuwait and Qatar, and more than $1 billion in Lockheed Martin Corp jets to Bahrain, sources familiar with the decision said. The sales had been pending for…

  • Credit Suisse, Barclays Said to Be in Mortgage-Settlement Talks

    Deutsche Bank AG isn’t the only lender wrestling with the U.S. to resolve an investigation into toxic mortgage bonds: Credit Suisse Group AG and Barclays Plc are also each in settlement talks with the ...

  • Oil marches higher on OPEC optimism; analysts question deal

    Oil prices rose nearly 3 percent on Thursday, extending their rally on optimism over OPEC's first output cut plan in eight years, despite some analysts' doubts that the reduction would be enough to rebalance a heavily over-supplied market. OPEC said other details of the plan will be known at its…

    Reuters43 mins ago
  • U.S. software firm Apttus raises $88 million from private investors after delaying IPO

    By Heather Somerville SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - Software maker Apttus has raised more money from private investors, postponing plans for an initial public share offer until next year because of the current uncertainties facing markets, including the U.S. presidential election. Apttus was putting…

  • Play

    Why investors should look at listed real estate

    The return and risk characteristics of listed real estate are exactly the same as real estate assets, says AMP capital's Charles Wong.

    CNBC Videos
  • China Bond Defaults Tick Up After Lull as Dye Maker Delinquent

    Defaults in China’s local corporate bond market ticked up this week as dye-and-paint maker Yabang Investment Holding Group Co. missed payment on notes due Thursday.

  • Man Group CEO Sees Pressure on Event-Driven Funds as Perry Shuts

    Larger discretionary macro and event-driven hedge funds are most at risk of shutting down as low returns weigh on the industry, according to the chief executive officer of the world’s largest publicly ...

  • Is it possible to retire in your 30s or 40s?

    Retiring super early can be a downright dangerous idea, says Mike Lynch, vice president of strategic markets at Hartford Funds. "If you stop funding your retirement and start using it 30 years ahead of schedule," says Lynch, "it is therefore unlikely that you will receive Social Security benefits.
  • Nike and AT&T slip, while Molson Coors and Cintas rise

    Stocks that moved substantially or traded heavily on Wednesday: Nike Inc., down $2.09 to $53.25 The athletic apparel maker reported solid quarterly results, but investors worried about its North American ...

    Associated Press
  • Play

    Redstone's National Amusements to call on CBS, Viacom to explore merger -sources

    National Amusements is the controlling shareholder of both media companies, which separated from each other 10 years ago. A merger would give Viacom, whose networks include Comedy Central, Nickelodeon and MTV, a seasoned media executive at the helm with CBS CEO Leslie Moonves at a time when its TV…

  • Bassett posts 3Q profit

    On a per-share basis, the Bassett, Virginia-based company said it had profit of 38 cents. The furniture seller posted revenue of $104.7 million in the period. Bassett shares have fallen nearly 5 percent ...

    Associated Press
  • As Deutsche struggles, German lawmakers say no more help for ailing banks

    Germany will not help ailing lenders such as Deutsche Bank, senior lawmakers in Chancellor Angela Merkel's conservative bloc said on Thursday, as resistance grew to any possibility of staging a rescue. With Merkel meeting European Central Bank chief Mario Draghi on Thursday, Berlin has already…