SPY Volume Extremely Skewed On Down Days
We don’t typically pay a whole lot of attention to volume unless we see some anomalous behavior going on. Well, considering this unique market environment, you probably wouldn’t be surprised to learn that we see evidence of that. As we have mentioned a few times here regarding the Nasdaq, volume as a whole has been much heavier on down days than up days over at least the past few months. This skew is particularly evident in the S&P 500 SPDR ETF (SPY), the subject of our Chart Of The Day, where the average volume over the past month has been a staggering 40% greater on down days than on up days.
Intuitively, one would think that such a skew is either a negative harbinger or a sign of a washed-out market. There is evidence that both those arguments are correct. A peak at history (at least since 2000), reveals only a handful of times when SPY volume was anywhere near this skewed on down days vs. up days. Those handful can be broken down into 3 regimes. The first regime from 2000 to 2006 saw just 1 occurrence, in March of 2001, at the culmination of a pretty relentless 7-month decline. The washout in volume led to a decent bounce over the next few months but more intermediate-term damage afterward.
The 2nd regime saw occurrences in March and July 2007, February and May 2010 and March 2011. These all occurred after the first bout of weakness following extended low-volatility rallies. This makes sense as a long, slow grind higher creates complacency but not necessarily a lot of volume along the way. After the first sniff of weakness, everybody tries to rush for the exits at the same time. It’s as if several months worth of light volume on the upside is forced into a relatively few bad down days.
The other similarity among the 2nd regime occurrences was that the weakness was not over after that initial bout of selling. Indeed, except for the May 2010 Flash Crash episode which preceded continued selling pressure for a few more months, each of the other examples saw an intermediate-term bounce before experiencing an even greater decline. It was as if the initial weakness that produced the down volume skew was a shot across the bow warning of a larger impending drop.
The 3rd regime consists of occurrences in July 2013 and February 2014 (and perhaps the present example). These episodes were similar to the 2nd regime ones in that they occurred following moderate weakness within a steady, low-volatility uptrend. The difference is, there was no second shot. The market simply resumed its grind higher. Will this be the way the trend continues? Not forever, no. But given the similar manner is which the market is behaving versus the past two examples (including the recent V-Bottom), we have no reason to expect it to change yet.
What is our takeaway? Our feeling is that the downside volume skew is an unhealthy condition. It likely is not a catalyst for something bad to happen. However, it can exacerbate a negative situation should one occur. In recent years, the market has been able to stave off any serious declines so this skew condition hasn’t resulted in too much pain. However, when the next big decline hits, the skew is likely to make things even worse as everyone rushes for the same exit at the same time.
Recommended for You
Japan needs a weaker yen for its economy, but investors need a safe haven even more. Which one will win the day?CNBC
Markets hemorrhaged more than $2 trillion on Friday, according to data from S&P Global, the worst on record.CNBC
PANAMA CITY (AP) — Fireworks exploded as a huge container ship made the inaugural passage through the newly expanded Panama Canal on Sunday, formally launching the Central American nation's multibillion-dollar bet on a bright economic future despite tough times for global shipping.Associated Press
June 26 -- Former U.S. Treasury Secretary John Snow discusses his support of the Republican Party and presumptive nominee Donald Trump. He speaks with Bloomberg's David Gura on "Bloomberg Markets."Bloomberg Video
She now expects her son to give her expensive birthday gifts.MarketWatch
If 2016 is not one of the more weird years in financial markets, then what honestly is? Now we have an unexpected Brexit that threatens the future structure European Union to add to the mix. As if terrorism, ...247wallst.com
Democrats took important steps towards reconciling festering differences between former secretary of state Hillary Clinton and Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont on key domestic and foreign policy issues that could affect the course of the presidential campaign this fall. Sanders fell well short of…The Fiscal Times
Chinese biopharma talent is leaving the Valley for Shanghai.Bloomberg
It's a proposal that would unite two companies on shaky financial ground as they plow into relatively new markets. One makes electric cars, the other installs solar panels. There are few obvious synergies. ...Associated Press
OPEC lost $349 billion in revenue last year due to low oil prices, almost a 50 percent reduction, but this year may well be worse again for the oil cartelOilprice.com
Watch your savings magically grow as you make withdrawals a headache and deposits a breeze.Investopedia
CNBC's Melissa Lee, and the "Fast Money" traders, predict where the market trades Monday after the Brexit vote, and where to put your money.CNBC Videos
More than 1.5 million Costco Wholesale customers who had questions about their new co-branded Visa cards were met with long wait times with Citigroup customer service early this week as almost 12 million ...Puget Sound Business Journal
An Institute of Directors survey suggests that a quarter of its members are considering freezing recruitment following Britain's vote to leave the European Union.BBC News
MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — Thousands of nurses returned to work Sunday at five Allina Health hospitals in the Minneapolis area following a seven-day strike mainly over the cost of their health insurance.Associated Press
New York’s landmark Waldorf Astoria hotel is scheduled to close in spring 2017 so owner Anbang Insurance Group Co. can begin converting most of the more than 1,400 rooms to luxury condominiums, said a ...Bloomberg
U.S. stock futures opened to the downside in early trading Sunday.CNBC.com
As many people around the world are trying to wrap their minds around what just happened in Britain, you may also be wondering "What does the Brexit mean for my money?"Associated Press
BEIJING (AP) — Japanese and Chinese stocks rose Monday but other Asian markets declined, crude prices fell further and U.S. shares appeared headed for a lower opening as jittery traders watched for more fallout from Britain's vote to exit the European Union.Associated Press24 mins ago
Money managers who suffered through Friday’s rout say uncertainty about the details of Britain’s exit from the European Union has them girding for more volatility as markets open in Asia on Monday to start ...Bloomberg