Why You Should Value the S&P Using “As Reported” Earnings Data

August 6, 2014 1:00 PM

View gallery

Why You Should Value the S&P Using “As Reported” Earnings Data

When people quote analyst earnings expectations, they are usually referring to “operating” earnings which adjusts “as reported” (GAAP) earnings for non-recurring items.  People use operating earnings because they show a cleaner picture of results that is more comparable to past or future periods.  If the charges are one-time in nature, they don’t necessarily have to be counted in future projections.

This makes sense for an individual company; however, when you look at the S&P 500 as a whole, it’s not so valid.  That’s because when you aggregate the S&P 500, “unusual” charges end up becoming “usual” charges that should be expected to repeat in the future.  One-time charges will come different companies in different periods, but in aggregate a baseline amount of charges should be counted on to detract from earnings.

As shown in the chart above, “as reported” earnings has consistently been below “operating” earnings for the last 25 years.  In recessions, unusual charges tend to run at greater levels than in flush times, but unusual charges outweigh unusual gains even in boom times.  In other words, you can count on one time charges happening in every period.

In the median trailing twelve month period, as reported earnings trail operating earnings by 10%.  That’s the “usual” amount of “unusual” charges.  Because unusual charges do fluctuate, it might make sense to normalize operating earnings by adjusting them lower by 10%, but it doesn’t make sense to leave operating earnings alone completely because that assumes that these one time charges wont keep happening.

If you adjust by 10%, adjusted operating earnings would still be higher than as reported earnings during recessions (when one-time charges tend to run higher), but adjusted operating earnings would be lower than as reported earnings during booms when one time charges tend to be less prevalent.  This methodology is more consistent with why analysts are excluding one-time charges to begin with.  Currently, as reported earnings are only 7% below operating earnings ($103.68 vs. $111.67), which suggests that the “normalized” earnings number for the S&P 500 should be lower than as reported earnings.

This has important implications for market valuation metrics.  Forward earnings multiples are based on operating earnings as well.  “Non recurring” charges represent the difference between the S&P selling for 17.2x operating earnings and 18.5x as reported earnings.  If normalized earnings are assumed to be 10% less than the value of operating earnings, then current normalized earnings are $100.50, which means the S&P 500 trades for 19.1x.

View Comments (0)

Recommended for You

  • France suspends delivery of warship to Russia

    PARIS (AP) — France suspended the delivery of a warship to Russia on Tuesday, after months of speculation about what would be the biggest arms sale ever by a NATO country to the Kremlin.

    Associated Press
  • Apple breaks through the $700 billion mark

    Apple is the first S&P 500 company to reach a $700 billion market cap, but it has a way to go to become the most valuable company of all time.

    CNBC
  • Why Travel Leads to a Healthy Retirement

    The secrets to a long and healthy life are often thought to be diet and exercise. But you might also want to add travel to that list. While many people travel simply for enjoyment or the desire to do something different, along the way they also broaden their horizons, relieve day-to-day stress and…

    U.S.News & World Report LP
  • Merrill Lynch Issues Upside 2015 Price Target For S&P 500

    After an extremely strong 2013 and a strong 2014, now the bull market is nearing its sixth year. This has investors and analysts alike wondering what sort of upside to expect in 2015. Merrill Lynch’ Savita ...

    24/7 Wall St.
  • Look for stocks to be significantly higher in 2015

    This market continues to do the unexpected, stretching higher and higher despite overbought conditions, and as a result, the technical picture now suggests that if certain conditions are met, a large move ...

    MarketWatch
  • How a Little Student Loan Deal Could Spell Big Trouble for Borrowers

    Wells Fargo is selling $8.5B in student loan debt to Navient. What could this mean for borrowers?

    Credit.com
  • Top Analyst Upgrades and Downgrades: GE, Honeywell, JetBlue, Level 3, Pandora, Petrobras and More

    Stocks were indicated higher on Tuesday, and this will effectively be the last day full of major analyst calls this week as Wall Street and Main Street get ready for Thanksgiving. Still, investors have ...

    24/7 Wall St.
  • 10 Colleges With Low Fees for Room and Board

    T he U.S. News Short List, separate from our overall rankings, is a regular series that magnifies individual data points in hopes of providing students and parents a way to find which undergraduate or graduate programs excel or have room to grow in specific areas. Be sure to explore The Short List:…

    U.S.News & World Report LP
  • Play

    Correction: Bogus Bonus story

    HONOLULU (AP) — In a story Nov. 22 about Island Air taking back bonuses paid to pilots, The Associated Press reported erroneously the reason for the bonuses. They were from an agreement to pay bonuses 30 days before the arrival of new planes, not for Christmas.

    Associated Press
  • Cramer's recipe for high prices in 2015

    Money managers are looking for a reason to buy right now, and Jim Cramer is here to help. He goes sector by sector to offer his pick of hot stocks.

    CNBC
  • Facing health law hikes, consumers mull options

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Consumers across most of America will see their health insurance premiums go up next year for popular plans under President Barack Obama's health care law.

    Associated Press
  • ROBERT SHILLER: This Is What Finance Actually Is

    Over the weekend, Yale professor and Nobel...

    Business Insider
  • Atlantic City casino profits up in 3rd quarter

    ATLANTIC CITY, N.J. (AP) — Atlantic City's casino industry saw its operating profits rise in the third quarter of this year, helped by Internet gambling money and the absence of large losses racked up last year by weaker casinos.

    Associated Press
  • Venezuelans Dollarize Christmas Bonuses as Bolivar Dives

    The bolivar has declined the most in 10 months as Venezuelans use their Christmas bonuses to buy U.S. dollars amid the world’s fastest inflation and shortages of basic goods. A dollar fetched a record ...

    Bloomberg
  • Apple soars to new high as Black Friday approaches

    Apple stock continued its journey into record high territory Monday as Wall Street awaits a brisk holiday shopping season, starting Thanksgiving weekend. Apple (AAPL) stock was up 1.5% near its intraday ...

    Investor's Business Daily
  • PayPal co-founder aims to reinvent banking

    Max Levchin wants to attract millennials with a bank they can love rather than loathe.

    CNBC
  • Tepper to return billions to clients despite loss

    David Tepper plans to return billions of dollars to clients amid a year of poor performance by his hedge funds.

    CNBC