Why You Should Value the S&P Using “As Reported” Earnings Data
When people quote analyst earnings expectations, they are usually referring to “operating” earnings which adjusts “as reported” (GAAP) earnings for non-recurring items. People use operating earnings because they show a cleaner picture of results that is more comparable to past or future periods. If the charges are one-time in nature, they don’t necessarily have to be counted in future projections.
This makes sense for an individual company; however, when you look at the S&P 500 as a whole, it’s not so valid. That’s because when you aggregate the S&P 500, “unusual” charges end up becoming “usual” charges that should be expected to repeat in the future. One-time charges will come different companies in different periods, but in aggregate a baseline amount of charges should be counted on to detract from earnings.
As shown in the chart above, “as reported” earnings has consistently been below “operating” earnings for the last 25 years. In recessions, unusual charges tend to run at greater levels than in flush times, but unusual charges outweigh unusual gains even in boom times. In other words, you can count on one time charges happening in every period.
In the median trailing twelve month period, as reported earnings trail operating earnings by 10%. That’s the “usual” amount of “unusual” charges. Because unusual charges do fluctuate, it might make sense to normalize operating earnings by adjusting them lower by 10%, but it doesn’t make sense to leave operating earnings alone completely because that assumes that these one time charges wont keep happening.
If you adjust by 10%, adjusted operating earnings would still be higher than as reported earnings during recessions (when one-time charges tend to run higher), but adjusted operating earnings would be lower than as reported earnings during booms when one time charges tend to be less prevalent. This methodology is more consistent with why analysts are excluding one-time charges to begin with. Currently, as reported earnings are only 7% below operating earnings ($103.68 vs. $111.67), which suggests that the “normalized” earnings number for the S&P 500 should be lower than as reported earnings.
This has important implications for market valuation metrics. Forward earnings multiples are based on operating earnings as well. “Non recurring” charges represent the difference between the S&P selling for 17.2x operating earnings and 18.5x as reported earnings. If normalized earnings are assumed to be 10% less than the value of operating earnings, then current normalized earnings are $100.50, which means the S&P 500 trades for 19.1x.
Recommended for You
PAJU, South Korea (AP) — North Korea on Thursday ordered a military takeover of a factory park that had been the last major symbol of cooperation with South Korea, calling Seoul's earlier suspension of operations at the jointly run facility as punishment for the North's recent rocket launch a…Associated Press
British health authorities announced Thursday they have issued criminal charges against the producers of 'Star Wars: The Force Awakens' over the on-set accidentAssociated Press
Sears is closing 50 stores. Sears is struggling.Business Insider
Tea party Republican Matt Bevin had to tone down his anti-Obamacare rhetoric in order to win election as governor of Kentucky last November. Since then, there has been intense speculation over what Bevin would do to make good on his campaign promise to phase out Kynect, Kentucky’s state-run health…The Fiscal Times
New Hampshire voters gave Donald Trump his first victory in the Republican presidential primary on Tuesday, and less than 12 hours later he fed red meat to the most radical among them when he speculated about assassinating the leader of North Korea on live television. Whether it’s theater or…The Fiscal Times
Americans owed more than $987 billion in outstanding auto loans in the last quarter of 2015, according to the latest report from Experian Automotive. It's the highest amount of outstanding auto loan debt since the company first started publicly reporting the data in 2006. Auto loans as a whole grew…Credit.com
The beverage and snack giant also reported better-than-expected profits.Fortune
Private tech companies are having a tough go of it — and they're starting to make some...Business Insider
Feb. 10 -- Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen testifies about monetary policy before the House Financial Services Committee. She speaks on "Bloomberg Markets."Bloomberg Video
In 2015, the Internal Revenue Service audited only 0.84% of all individual tax returns. Although the overall individual audit rate is only about one in 119, the odds increase dramatically as your income goes up, as it might if you sell a valuable piece of property or get a big payout from a…Kiplinger
Yahoo Inc (YHOO.O) announced Wednesday it will lay off 107 employees in the first of what is expected to be more than 1,500 job cuts. The layoffs take effect April 11 and affected employees received 60-day advance notice of the move, Yahoo said in a notice filed with the California Employment…Reuters
Feb. 10 -- Dougherty & Co. Analyst Andrea James discusses her outlook for Tesla. She speaks "Bloomberg Markets."Bloomberg Video
Find out the reasons that it is not a good idea to sell after a market downturn. There are lessons to be learned from the last major market downturn.Investopedia
T. Rowe Price and Microsoft are among companies that can provide you with income for years to come.MarketWatch
Cramer says Skyworks' stock is too low and he remains a believer in Wyndham.TheStreet.com
Since Chuck Robbins took over as CEO of Cisco a mere six months ago, Cisco has bought eight...Business Insider
SunEdison, the solar-energy company that's been collecting scalps across Wall Street since July...Business Insider
It depends on whether there's a Social Security cost-of-living adjustment.Kiplinger
Norfolk Southern (NSC) has shed 15.6% of its value so far in 2016.Zacks