U.S. Markets closed

Why Best Buy may be a bad buy: Strategists

Lawrence Lewitinn
Talking Numbers
Why Best Buy may be a bad buy: Strategists

It had 246% returns so far in 2013 but should you avoid Best Buy's stock?

In 2012, Best Buy was one of the worst performing stocks in the entire S&P 500. This year, however, Best Buy has wowed investors, returning 246% to those who owned the stock since the start of the year. While the numbers say this is the best holiday season for online retailers yet, does Best Buy's "click-and-mortar" business model mean its stock will continue to perform in the coming year?

Joe Greco, managing director at Meridian Equity Partners, is pessimistic.

"I would not be an investor here and, true to my profession, I would definitely trade the stock," says Greco on CNBC's Street Signs' Talking Numbers segment. "But, you've got to be careful. You've got nearly a 10% short interest in the stock."

(Read: These retailers broke their Christmas delivery promise)

Greco says the stock is sensitive to headline risk and has now at the end of the most important season for the retailer. And, it's because of management's operating choices during the holiday season that Greco is skeptical the company's future prospects.

"If you took note from Thanksgiving until now, most of their inventories in store were running really low, if not sold out, at almost all times," says Greco. "Their obviously angling towards keeping inventories low and selling things online which now they're competing against the Amazons and eBays. It's not necessarily going to work out in the long run. They painted themselves in a corner. It's going to be interesting to see how they juggle that fundamentally quarter-to-quarter."

Katie Stockton, Chief Technical Strategist at BTIG, is also not so sure Best Buy is the best buy based on the stock's technicals.

"We've seen Best Buy lose momentum as most stocks have gained momentum since about November," say Stockton. "So, despite the impressive gains for the year, the stock is actually deteriorating on its chart."

(See: CNBC's Retail coverage)

For Stockton, $39.75 per share is an important level for Best Buy's stock. If it breaks below that, she believes its next support is $36.25. "Of course, that would be pretty significant downside risk from current levels," says Stockton.

"Obviously, the long-term trend is still very higher, but I think short-term, you just want to stay on the sidelines here."

To see the rest of the analysis on Best Buy by Greco and Stockton, watch the video above.

More from Talking Numbers:

Why FedEx beats UPS: Strategist
Why IBM (yes, IBM) may be the best Dow stock for 2014: Strategist
Peter Schiff: Why Wal-Mart can’t pay $15/hour wages

________________

Follow us on Twitter: @CNBCNumbers
Like us on Facebook: facebook.com/CNBCNumbers

  • Want to motivate your team? Try insults
    News
    MarketWatch

    Want to motivate your team? Try insults

    Athletes do it. CEOs do it. People in the office and home do it. Trash-talking is as natural as breathing to some people. But how does it affect those who are the targets of such biting insults? Wharton visiting scholar and Georgetown professor Jeremy Yip and Maurice Schweitzer, Wharton operations, information and decisions professor, discuss the topic in their latest research, “Trash-Talking: Competitive Incivility Motivates Rivalry, Performance and Unethical Behavior.” An edited transcript of the conversation follows. Knowledge@Wharton: How would you define trash-talking? Jeremy Yip: We conceptualize trash-talking as competitive incivility. That is, uncivil remarks or aggressive communication

  • Kate Middleton, Prince William, and Prince Harry Are Hiring for a Pregnancy-Related Reason
    Celebrity
    InStyle

    Kate Middleton, Prince William, and Prince Harry Are Hiring for a Pregnancy-Related Reason

    Kate Middleton, Prince William, and Prince Harry have put out a call for applications for a job in Kensington Palace, and the whole thing sounds like a dream come true. The royals are officially hiring someone for the Senior Communications Officer job for maternity-related reasons, and you can throw your hat into the ring if you think you're the right fit. "We require a Senior Communications Officer to support the work TRH The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge and HRH Prince Henry of Wales on a Maternity Cover contract," the job posting says.

  • This Woman's Heart Actually 'Broke' After Her Dog Died. Here's How It Happened
    Health
    Time

    This Woman's Heart Actually 'Broke' After Her Dog Died. Here's How It Happened

    In fact, the pain could be enough to break your heart, suggests a new report published in the New England Journal of Medicine. Last year, shortly after the death of her treasured Yorkshire terrier Meha, then 61-year-old Joanie Simpson woke up with symptoms consistent with a heart attack, reports the Washington Post. The condition can occur after a physical or emotional stress, like the death of a loved one, says Dr. Ilan Wittstein, a cardiologist at Johns Hopkins and a broken-heart syndrome researcher (who was not involved with Simpson’s case or the new report).

  • What's in Store for Advanced Micro (AMD) in Q3 Earnings?
    Business
    Zacks

    What's in Store for Advanced Micro (AMD) in Q3 Earnings?

    Advanced Micro Devices Inc. AMD is set to report third-quarter 2017 results on Oct 24. Notably, the company has a positive record of earnings surprises in the trailing four quarters, with an average surprise of 35%.In the last quarter, the company reported

  • This Mobile Carrier Says Apple iPhone 8 Sales Are 'Anemic'
    Business
    Fortune

    This Mobile Carrier Says Apple iPhone 8 Sales Are 'Anemic'

    Apple’s iPhone 8 sales have disappointed at least one carrier. Speaking to Reuters in an interview published on Thursday, Rogers Communication CEO Joe Natale said iPhone 8 and iPhone 8 Plus sales have so far been “anemic.” Natale, who helms Canada’s largest wireless carrier network, didn’t say exactly how many units his company has sold since the iPhone 8’s release last month. Reports have been swirling for weeks that suggest the iPhone 8 and iPhone 8 Plus haven’t been selling well.

  • Singapore Airlines to finalize $13.8 billion Boeing order next week
    Business
    Reuters

    Singapore Airlines to finalize $13.8 billion Boeing order next week

    By Jamie Freed SINGAPORE (Reuters) - Singapore Airlines Ltd said on Friday it will finalize an order for 39 Boeing Co aircraft worth $13.8 billion at list prices when Singaporean Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong visits Washington D.C. next week. The airline said in February it would order 20 777-9 and 19 787-10 widebodies as part of plans to modernize its fleet over the next decade, but the deal is yet to be finalised and placed in Boeing's order book as a Singapore Airlines order. The deal was viewed as a major blow to Airbus SE as it battles against Boeing in the widebody market.

  • The Most Common Financial Mistakes To Avoid
    Business
    HuffPost

    The Most Common Financial Mistakes To Avoid

    Whether you’re living paycheck to paycheck or managing a healthy nest egg, there are certain classic money blunders you’ll want to avoid. Between hidden fees, budgeting mishaps and poor communication around finances, it’s almost too easy to throw money away.

  • Business
    Fortune

    Chipotle’s New Menu Item Could Create a Worse Queso Scenario

    Chipotle Mexican Grill has a queso problem that could have a spillover-effect on sales, analysts at RBC Capital said Friday in a research note. Chipotle stock was trading at $323.46 at 1 pm ET. Avocado prices have been noted as a hurdle to Chipotle’s recovery before.

  • Kobe Bryant breaks down his plan to make BODYARMOR the No...
    Business
    CNBC Videos

    Kobe Bryant breaks down his plan to make BODYARMOR the No...

    CNBC’s Eric Chemi catches up with five-time NBA champ Kobe Bryant on his investment in sports drink company BODYARMOR, his business idols and his views on innovation.

  • North Korea's Nuclear Tests Could Be Changing the Country's Geology
    World
    Time

    North Korea's Nuclear Tests Could Be Changing the Country's Geology

    The North Korean mountain used for the underground testing of nuclear weapons might be suffering from “tired mountain syndrome,” according to experts studying satellite photos of the test site. “Tired mountain syndrome” is the name for increased fractures and permeability in the surrounding rock, caused by multiple underground nuclear tests. Mount Mantap is a 7,200-foot-high peak in the north of the country, which scientists say “visibly shifted” during North Korea’s most recent detonation on Sept. 3.

  • Nissan shows Leaf electric car revamped with more range
    Business
    Associated Press

    Nissan shows Leaf electric car revamped with more range

    Nissan's new Leaf electric car goes farther on a charge and comes with a new type of drive technology and the possibility of single-pedal driving. The zero-emissions vehicle — which Japanese automaker Nissan Motor Co. unveiled in the U.S. late Tuesday and in a Tokyo suburb Wednesday — promises a range of about 400 kilometers in Japanese driving conditions or 150 miles in the U.S., before needing another charge. The distances depend on driving conditions and how much other items in the car such as heating are used.

  • US Senate chops key obstacle to Trump tax reforms 
    Politics
    The Telegraph

    US Senate chops key obstacle to Trump tax reforms 

    A key hurdle to Donald Trump’s tax reforms has been eliminated, as last night’s US Senate vote in favour of a 2018 budget resolution means the president will only need a simple majority of 51 senators, rather than 60, to pass his tax cuts. A major programme of tax cuts was key to the president’s election campaign, with pledges to slash income and business taxes, as well as cutting some of the deductions and loopholes which complicate the system. The latest budget bill opened the way for tax cuts of $1.5 trillion (£1.1 trillion) over 10 years, and also allows for extra spending in areas such as defence.

  • Catch This Falling Knife — Go Long Celgene Corporation
    Business
    InvestorPlace

    Catch This Falling Knife — Go Long Celgene Corporation

    Last night, Celgene Corporation (NASDAQ:CELG) released a headline that they canceled phase three for their potential solution to Crohn’s disease. The stock is now trading down 10%. This means that it would now be down 16% since early October. Source:

  • Bank of America Is Continuing to Slash Expenses
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Bank of America Is Continuing to Slash Expenses

    Bank of America (NYSE: BAC) announced a little over a year ago that it would lower its annual expenses to $53 billion by 2018. You can see this by looking at Bank of America's third-quarter performance. Noninterest expenses for the bank came in at $13.1 billion in the three months ended Sept. 30, down 2.5% from the year-ago period.

  • The Orionid Meteor Shower Peaks This Weekend. Here's What Time You Can Watch
    Science
    Time

    The Orionid Meteor Shower Peaks This Weekend. Here's What Time You Can Watch

    Turn off Netflix this weekend and head outdoors to watch the peak of the Orionid Meteor Shower instead. This year’s Orionid meteor shower should be especially good because there will be little moonlight that could otherwise drown out the meteors. “The Orionids peak on October 20 — a dark, moonless night,” wrote NASA’s Jane Houston Jones in a recent statement.

  • Sears' Grim Fate Seems Nearly Inevitable
    Business
    The Street

    Sears' Grim Fate Seems Nearly Inevitable

    The games seem to be ending for Sears Holdings (SHLD) . Because of CEO Eddie Lampert's big position in the stock and his ability (via his hedge fund) to finance, loan and pull out almost every stop in the book, Sears had been prone to sharp rallies. This is despite the growing short-interest betting against its demise. Well, that demise has certainly gained momentum. Shares hit new 52-week lows earlier this week, bottoming out at $5.48 before rallying back to $6. Can it continue to stay afloat? Only for so long. With or without the powerful force of e-commerce, Sears was struggling. Its Canadian operations are all but shot, K-Mart was desolate. The company sold off strong brands like Craftsman

  • This High-Yield Oil Giant Could Offer Retirees Sustainable Income
    Business
    Motley Fool

    This High-Yield Oil Giant Could Offer Retirees Sustainable Income

    Integrated oil and natural gas giant Royal Dutch Shell plc (NYSE: RDS-B) is making impressive progress as it comes back from the worst of the oil downturn that started in mid-2014. One of the big problems for Shell today is debt. At the end of 2014, long-term debt stood at roughly $38 billion. First, Shell tends to hold much more cash than Exxon.

  • Jim Cramer: GE was run like a country club, it was a disg...
    Business
    CNBC Videos

    Jim Cramer: GE was run like a country club, it was a disg...

    GE has done the single biggest Kabuki act I have ever seen, says CNBC's Jim Cramer talking about Jeff Immelt's tenure at General Electric.

  • Costco: 5 Reasons to Load Up
    Business
    barrons.com

    Costco: 5 Reasons to Load Up

    Costco (COST) is higher Friday, helped in part by a bullish note from Oppenheimer. Analyst Brian Nagel and David Bellinger reiterated an Outperform rating and $185 price target on Costco, following a meeting with a senior management yesterday at the company's Washington headquarters. Nagel and Bellinger had five main takeaways from the meetings, which reinforced their bullish thesis on the shares and make them think that worries about the threats of ecommerce are overblown. From the note: 1) Management indicates clearly that the company is pleased with results lately and views strengthening sales as a function of a culmination of factors, including new merchandising initiatives and price investments;

  • Philip Morris International Inc. Is a Smoking Deal — Go Long!
    Business
    InvestorPlace

    Philip Morris International Inc. Is a Smoking Deal — Go Long!

    Philip Morris International Inc. (NYSE:PM) reported earnings yesterday and Wall Street hated it. The stock fell 4%, and what made matters worse is that yesterday we also had a market-wide tizzy that exaggerated the negative reaction in PM stock. Source

  • GE Badly Misses Q3 Earnings, Lowers View & Defers Dividend
    Business
    Zacks

    GE Badly Misses Q3 Earnings, Lowers View & Defers Dividend

    Industrial goods manufacturer General Electric Company GE reported relatively lackluster third-quarter 2017 results and badly missed earnings estimate despite top-line growth. GAAP net earnings from continuing operations for the reported quarter were

  • Wall Street banks are starting to sound the alarm on a stock-market correction
    Business
    Business Insider

    Wall Street banks are starting to sound the alarm on a stock-market correction

    Bank of America Merrill Lynch is the latest Wall Street firm to issue a warning about a stock-market correction. BAML joins Morgan Stanley in the ranks of big firms that have sounded the alarm this week. The most recent firm to sound the alarm is Bank of America Merrill Lynch, which forecasts a pullback of at least 10% — the historical definition of a correction — by Valentine's Day.

  • FDA approves better vaccine against painful shingles virus
    Health
    Associated Press

    FDA approves better vaccine against painful shingles virus

    U.S. regulators have approved a new, more effective vaccine to prevent painful shingles, which is caused by the chickenpox virus. Drugmaker GlaxoSmithKline said the Food and Drug Administration approved it late Friday. It will be the second shingles vaccine in the U.S. market.

  • Finance
    CNBC

    A top Microsoft HR exec says you should apply to jobs in these 2 industries

    Companies like Microsoft (MSFT) are working hard to secure top talent for new roles . Cloud computing and artificial intelligence, says Chuck Edward, Microsoft's head of global talent acquisition, in an interview with CNBC Make It . You can work in consultative sales, data science and analytics to help customers or nab a job marketing cloud computing, he explains.

  • You Should Buy Rite Aid Corporation Stock Only If This Happens
    Business
    InvestorPlace

    You Should Buy Rite Aid Corporation Stock Only If This Happens

    Rite Aid Corporation (NYSE:RAD) investors certainly haven’t been faced with a shortage of things to chew on of late. The failure of Walgreen’s initial plan to outright acquire all shares of RAD stock in 2015 followed by the no-go on 2016’s revised plan to only buy 2,186 Rite Aid units — WBA is now only acquiring 1,932 of Rite Aid’s 4,560 stores — spurred mounds of investor concern, as a large cash infusion was seen as the only way to save the struggling Rite Aid Corporation. Here’s the thing: Rite Aid was in trouble, maybe even doomed, well before Walgreen’s was interested.