U.S. Markets closed

Baker: The Story of the Housing Crash Recession That Politicians Don’t Want to Tell

Yahoo! Finance
The Exchange

By Dean Baker, co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research

The economy is certain to occupy center stage in the presidential race this fall. Unfortunately, neither Governor Romney nor President Obama is likely to give us an accurate account of the economic problems we are now facing.

Romney's efforts seem intended to convince the public that President Obama has turned the country into the Soviet Union, with government bureaucrats shoving aside business leaders to take the commanding role in the economy. He will have lots of money to make this case, which he will need since it is so far from reality.

Corporate profits are at their highest share as a percentage of the economy in almost 50 years. The share of profits being paid in taxes is near its post-World War II low. The government's share of the economy has actually shrunk in the Obama years, as has government employment. Perhaps Romney can convince the public that the private sector is being crushed by burdensome regulation and taxes, but that has nothing to do with reality.

A Better Explanation

Unfortunately, President Obama's economic advisors have not been much more straightforward with the American people, never offering a clear explanation of why the economy has taken so long to recover. They have pointed out that economies often take long to recover from the effects of a financial crisis like to the one we experienced in the fall of 2008, but that is not an explanation for why we have not recovered.

The basic story is actually quite simple. The housing bubble had been driving the economy prior to the recession. It created demand through several channels. A near-record pace of housing construction added about 2 percentage points of GDP to annual demand or more than $300 billion in the current economy.

The $8 trillion in ephemeral housing wealth created by the bubble led to a huge surge in consumption. Tens of millions of people borrowed against bubble-generated equity or decided that they didn't need to save for retirement. When house prices were going up 15 percent-20 percent a year, the house was doing the saving. The result was a huge consumption boom on the order of 4 percent of GDP or $600 billion a year.

In addition, there was a bubble in non-residential real estate that followed in the wake of the housing bubble. This raised non-residential construction above its normal levels by close to 1 percent of GDP, or $150 billion a year.

A Bubble Generated

Adding these sources of demand together, the bubble generated well over $1 trillion in annual demand at its peak in 2005-2007. When the bubble burst, this $1 trillion in annual demand vanished as well. That is the central story of the downturn.

To recover we must find some way to replace this demand; however, that is not easy. People will not go back to their old consumption patterns because they know they need to save more. Tens of millions of people have much less wealth than they expected at this point in their lives after they saw the equity in their homes largely vanish. Tens of millions of baby boomers are approaching retirement with almost nothing but their Social Security to support them.

Given the huge loss of wealth from the collapse of the housing bubble, it is not reasonable to expect consumption to rise to fill the demand gap. It doesn't make much more sense to expect investment to do the job. Historically, investment in equipment and software has been close to 8 percent of GDP. It is pretty much back to that level today. To fill the demand gap created by the collapse of the housing bubble, the investment share of GDP would have to nearly double to 14 percent.

This would be almost impossible to imagine at any time, but it is especially far-fetched at a time when much of the economy is operating far below its capacity. Businesses are unlikely to spend a lot of money expanding their facilities when the existing capacity is sitting idle regardless of how nice we are to job creators.

Boosting Demand

Over a longer term we can expect that net exports will fill the demand gap. If we bring our huge trade deficit close to balance by selling more abroad and importing less, it will provide a substantial boost to demand. However, this will require that the dollar fall in value relative to the currencies of our trading partners, making U.S. products more competitive. That is a process that will take time. With many of our trading partners also in severe slumps, we cannot expect any major improvement in our trade balance in the immediate future.

This leaves government as the only remaining source of demand. This is not a question of whether we prefer the government or the private sector. We need the government sector to fill the gap in demand because the private sector will not do it. And that will be true no matter how much we love the private sector and its job creators.

Until we get our trade deficit closer to balance, we will need large government deficits to fill the gap in demand created by the housing bubble. That is the simple reality that neither party seems anxious to tell the people.

Dean Baker is an economist and co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research. He has written extensively on a wide range of topics, including the housing bubble. His most recent book is The End of Loser Liberalism: Making Markets Progressive (free download available here).

  • Kushner Cos. subpoenaed by feds after AP report
    Business
    Associated Press

    Kushner Cos. subpoenaed by feds after AP report

    The Kushner Cos. has been subpoenaed by federal prosecutors for information related to an Associated Press report that the company filed dozens of false documents about its buildings in New York City. The statement Thursday acknowledged that the federal subpoena arrived last month, a day after the AP reported the Kushner Cos. routinely filed false paperwork with the city stating it had zero rent-regulated tenants in buildings across the city when, in fact, it had hundreds. The AP report covered a three-year period when the real estate company was run by Jared Kushner, President Donald Trump's son-in-law who is now a senior adviser.

  • Pot politics: Schumer joins politicians rethinking marijuana
    News
    Associated Press

    Pot politics: Schumer joins politicians rethinking marijuana

    The top Senate Democrat is using marijuana's informal holiday to announce a change of heart about the drug, another sign of the growing political acceptance of pot. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer of New York said Friday he'll introduce a bill taking marijuana off the federal list of controlled substances — in effect decriminalizing its use. Under the measure, the federal government would still enforce laws against moving pot into states where it's illegal and would still regulate advertising so it isn't aimed at children.

  • Wells Fargo hit with $1 billion fine
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Wells Fargo hit with $1 billion fine

    The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) and the Office of the Comptroller of Currency (OCC) announced a combined fine of $1 billion against Wells Fargo (WFC) on Friday. The consent orders from the two agencies described how the bank unfairly disregarded its advertised process of locking-in interest rates for mortgages, as well as unfairly foisting insurance on customers taking out auto loans. If a closing of a mortgage dragged on due to Wells Fargo and not the customer, the bank still charged customers to keep the rates locked — despite this being contrary to policy, the consent order notes.

  • President Trump to Skip Barbara Bush's Funeral for Mar a Lago, 'Out of Respect for the Bush Family' Says White House
    Politics
    Time

    President Trump to Skip Barbara Bush's Funeral for Mar a Lago, 'Out of Respect for the Bush Family' Says White House

    President Donald Trump won’t be joining his wife in attending the memorial service of former first lady Barbara Bush, matriarch of a political dynasty that Trump often clashed with during his 2016 campaign. The White House said Thursday that Trump would not attend “to avoid disruptions due to added security, and out of respect for the Bush Family and friends attending the service.” Trump is expected to be at his Florida estate this weekend during Saturday’s funeral in Houston for the wife and mother of presidents. Flags have flown at half-staff over the White House and at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate in Florida since Bush’s death at the age of 92, and Trump added his voice to the tributes that have poured in for the wife of President George H.W. Bush and mother of President George W. Bush.

  • 'I Wrapped My Arm Around Her.' Southwest Passenger Describes Helping Victim After Engine Explosion
    News
    Time

    'I Wrapped My Arm Around Her.' Southwest Passenger Describes Helping Victim After Engine Explosion

    Just as Hollie Mackey was about to get up from her seat to go to the bathroom during Tuesday morning’s Southwest Airlines flight from New York to Dallas, flight attendants asked passengers to stay seated due to continual turbulence. Mackey put her seatbelt back on, shared a glance of disappointment about the bumpy ride ahead with the woman seated at the window to her left and settled back in. Mackey, 42, was seated in the aisle seat on the same row as Jennifer Riordan, a mother of two and bank executive from Albuquerque, New Mexico, who was killed when Flight 1380’s left side engine exploded just 20 minutes into their trip.

  • Advanced Micro (AMD) Q1 Earnings: Is a Beat in the Cards?
    Finance
    Zacks

    Advanced Micro (AMD) Q1 Earnings: Is a Beat in the Cards?

    Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. AMD is scheduled to report first-quarter 2018 earnings on Apr 25.Notably, the stock has delivered an average four-quarter positive earnings surprise of 35%. In the last reported quarter, the company came up with a positive

  • Boeing, Brazil's Embraer close to tie-up: report
    Business
    Reuters

    Boeing, Brazil's Embraer close to tie-up: report

    Talks aimed at a tie-up between planemakers Boeing Co and Embraer SA that also involve Brazil's government are at an advanced stage, O Estado de S. Paulo newspaper reported on Friday, citing unnamed sources. The Boeing and Embraer partnership would create a new company in which the U.S. planemaker would have an 80.01 percent stake and the Brazilian firm 19.99 percent, the paper said, adding this was a model supported by the Brazilian government. Boeing, Embraer and Brazil's Defense Ministry did not have an immediate comment on the report.

  • Oil recovers after sliding on Trump tweet criticising OPEC
    Business
    Reuters

    Oil recovers after sliding on Trump tweet criticising OPEC

    Oil prices edged up on Friday, stabilizing after an earlier slide driven by U.S. President Donald Trump's criticism of OPEC's role in pushing up global oil prices. Brent crude oil futures (LCOc1) gained 28 cents, or 0.4 percent, to settle at $74.06 per barrel. "Looks like OPEC is at it again," Trump tweeted.

  • What It's Like to Study at the Strictest School in Britain
    News
    Time

    What It's Like to Study at the Strictest School in Britain

    In silence, the children sitting either side of me pass their plates to the end. On surrounding tables, other adult visitors scramble to finish their meals in the face of outstretched hands trying to take their plates, as teachers time the students’ progress. This is just one element of life at Michaela Community School.

  • Mueller team skeptical of Giuliani claims probe will end in weeks: Gasparino
    Business
    Fox Business Videos

    Mueller team skeptical of Giuliani claims probe will end in weeks: Gasparino

    FBN's Charlie Gasparino on reports Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein told President Trump he was not a target of the Mueller investigation and Rudy Giuliani's claims the probe will end in a matter of weeks.

  • Philip Morris International Inc. Stock Went Up in Smoke — Go Long
    Finance
    InvestorPlace

    Philip Morris International Inc. Stock Went Up in Smoke — Go Long

    Since the February stock market correction started, Philip Morris International Inc. (NYSE:PM) stock has had a turbulent period of trading. Compare that with a flat stock market — both Philip Morris and Altria Group, Inc. (NYSE:MO) stocks have been decimated. Meanwhile, cannabis stocks like GW Pharmaceuticals plc (NASDAQ:GWPH) have fared much better and are in line with the stock market in general.

  • 2 black men arrested at Starbucks get an apology from police
    Finance
    Associated Press

    2 black men arrested at Starbucks get an apology from police

    Rashon Nelson initially brushed it off when the Starbucks manager told him he couldn't use the restroom because he wasn't a paying customer. A few minutes later, they hardly noticed when the police came into the coffee shop — until officers started walking in their direction. Nelson and Robinson were led away in handcuffs from the shop in the city's well-to-do Rittenhouse Square neighborhood in an incident recorded on a white customer's cellphone.

  • Arista Networks runs fast — but keeps its employees’ lives balanced
    News
    San Francisco Business Times

    Arista Networks runs fast — but keeps its employees’ lives balanced

    Arista Networks Size category: Large (250-999 employees) Rank: 9 CEO: Jayshree Ullal HQ: Santa Clara Bay Area employees: 840 What it does: Software-driven cloud networking solutions for large data center storage and computing Score: 89.38 Silicon Valley, renowned as a center for innovation and fresh ideas, is also notorious for creating and promoting environments where employees feel pressured to work long hours to help those ideas come to fruition. At Santa Clara-based Arista Networks, however, employees can look forward to a reasonable approach to work-life balance. “Employees have the right to balance work and other things they need to do with their life,” said Isabelle Bertin-Bailly, vice

  • Walmart Dress Code to Get a Lot More Flexible
    Finance
    InvestorPlace

    Walmart Dress Code to Get a Lot More Flexible

    Walmart is testing new dress codes in a small number of U.S. stores with the hopes that this more relaxed environment will help to reel in and retain staff in an increasingly tighter labor market. This means that workers will be allowed to wear shirts of any solid color, which marks a shift from its previous option of only having blue or white shirts, according to an employee manual obtained by Bloomberg News. Walmart adds that visible facial tattoos will be forbidden for those hired after April 14, according to the manual.

  • E. Coli Outbreak Blamed on Contaminated Lettuce Spreads to 16 States, CDC Says
    News
    Time

    E. Coli Outbreak Blamed on Contaminated Lettuce Spreads to 16 States, CDC Says

    Health officials said more people have reported cases of E. coli, as a multi-state outbreak linked to chopped romaine lettuce continues to spread. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said about 53 cases of E. coli have been reported across 16 states, with 18 new cases reported after April 13. The CDC said 31 people have been hospitalized, including five who have developed hemolytic uremic syndrome, a type of kidney failure.

  • Southwest Airlines pilot pushed Navy boundaries for flying
    Finance
    Associated Press

    Southwest Airlines pilot pushed Navy boundaries for flying

    Tammie Jo Shults was determined to "break into the club" of male military aviators. One of the first female fighter pilots in the U.S. Navy, Shults flew training missions as an enemy pilot during Operation Desert Storm, while working with other women to see a rule excluding them from combat flights repealed. Twenty-five years later, Shults was at the controls of the Dallas-bound Southwest Airlines Flight 1380 Tuesday when it made an emergency landing in Philadelphia after one of the engines on the Boeing 737 exploded while the plane was traveling 500 mph (800 kph) at 30,000 feet (9144 m) with 149 people on board.

  • Cryptocurrency Market Surges to $365 Billion, Start of a Bull Rally?
    Business
    CCN

    Cryptocurrency Market Surges to $365 Billion, Start of a Bull Rally?

    Earlier today, on April 20, strong performances of major cryptocurrencies like bitcoin and Ethereum have led the valuation of the cryptocurrency market to surge to $365 billion. With the deepest liquidity and largest volume in the global market, bitcoin was able to sustain some stability while many cryptocurrencies recorded a free fall. Over the past seven days, alternative cryptocurrencies (altcoins) and other major cryptocurrencies have consistently reported gains against the most dominant cryptocurrency in the market.

  • GM is pulling Cadillac back from its bold luxury experiment by dismissing division boss (GM)
    Business
    Yahoo Finance Video

    GM is pulling Cadillac back from its bold luxury experiment by dismissing division boss (GM)

    On Wednesday, General Motors announced that Johan de Nysschen would be replaced as head of the carmaker's Cadillac luxury division by Steve Carlisle, a relative unknown who started at GM in 1982 and had most recently been running Canadian operations.

  • Air Canada, WestJet offer cheap basic economy fares for no-frills seekers
    Business
    CBC

    Air Canada, WestJet offer cheap basic economy fares for no-frills seekers

    Think again: Air Canada and WestJet are selling "basic economy" fares that cost less and offer even fewer features, such as no options to change your flight. ​"Basic economy fares are getting you a seat, that's it " says Ottawa-based travel blogger Anshul Singh. Variations of basic economy fares are already widespread in the U.S., adopted by some major airlines to compete with encroaching discount carriers.

  • Harley Wins Biggest-Ever TradeMark Infringement Case
    News
    RideApart

    Harley Wins Biggest-Ever TradeMark Infringement Case

    Harley-Davidson has a well-deserved reputation for, shall we say, aggressively protecting its various trademarks. Case in point is the latest trademark situation with SunFrog.com. Back in 2017, word got back to Milwaukee that Michigan-based SunFrog.com—an online print-on-demand outfit that churns out custom made-to-order shirts, mugs, hoodies, mousepads, etc.—was selling wares featuring assorted images that infringed on Harley’s trademarks.

  • General Electric reports $1.2 bn loss in 1Q; reaffirms outlook
    Business
    AFP

    General Electric reports $1.2 bn loss in 1Q; reaffirms outlook

    General Electric reported a $1.2 billion loss in the first quarter Friday following a large legal charge, but shares surged after operating profits topped analyst expectations. GE, which has been hit by weakness in its power and oil and gas businesses, set aside $1.5 billion in legal reserves connected to lawsuits from its discontinued US mortgage business, WMC. "The first quarter is a step forward in executing on our 2018 plan and we are seeing signs of progress," said chief executive John Flannery.

  • Finance
    InvestorPlace

    Activision Blizzard, Inc. Will Finish What ‘Fortnite’ Started

    On paper, most analysts will agree that Activision Blizzard, Inc. (NASDAQ:ATVI) is enjoying a solid start to this year. Against the January opener, ATVI stock has gained nearly 9%. Despite Activision’s immense reputation in delivering the most compelling first-person shooter games, another company has unexpectedly taken its throne.

  • 7 REITs With Big Dividend Raises Coming
    Business
    InvestorPlace

    7 REITs With Big Dividend Raises Coming

    “First-level” investors – those who buy and sell on headlines – mistakenly believe that real estate investment trust (REIT) profits will suffer if rates continue to rise. Overall, rising rates are actually good for the best REITs because it signals a rolling economy. Take the Vanguard REIT ETF (NYSEARCA:VNQ), which is now paying its highest current yield since 2009.

  • Bitcoin Loses Out to Bitcoin Cash – Is it the Beginning of the End?
    Business
    FX Empire

    Bitcoin Loses Out to Bitcoin Cash – Is it the Beginning of the End?

    The Bitcoin bulls didn’t get the memo on Wednesday, with Bitcoin only managing a 3.56% rise on day, partially reversing Monday and Tuesday’s losses, to end the day at $8,169.5. A morning rally saw Bitcoin break out from the 23.6% FIB Retracement Level of $7,996.57 to hit a morning $8,168.8 high, breaking through the first major support level of $8,098.87 before seeing a pullback to an early afternoon $7,907.4 to call on buyer support at the 23.6% FIB Retracement Level of $7,996.57. A late afternoon rally saw Bitcoin hit an intraday high $8,237.2, testing the day’s 1st major resistance level for a 2nd time and this time managing to hold on through to the day’s end.

  • Lockheed Martin Is One Step Closer to Building Hypersonic Missiles That Are Faster Than Today's Anti-Aircraft Systems
    Finance
    Fortune

    Lockheed Martin Is One Step Closer to Building Hypersonic Missiles That Are Faster Than Today's Anti-Aircraft Systems

    The Pentagon has given Lockheed Martin lmt a $928 million contract to develop and build hypersonic missiles, which will be able to travel at more than five times the speed of sound. Hypersonic missiles are a priority for the U.S. military because they are so difficult to defend against—they’re just too fast for today’s anti-aircraft and anti-missile defense systems to counter—and because the country’s biggest geopolitical rivals are steaming ahead. China said last year that it was almost ready to demonstrate its own hypersonic weapons, and Russia claims that it too has conducted successful tests of a hypersonic missile that can carry nuclear or conventional warheads.