U.S. markets closed
  • S&P 500

    +40.81 (+0.80%)
  • Dow 30

    +90.99 (+0.23%)
  • Nasdaq

    +183.02 (+1.14%)
  • Russell 2000

    +21.55 (+1.05%)
  • Crude Oil

    +1.55 (+1.98%)
  • Gold

    +36.90 (+1.80%)
  • Silver

    +0.46 (+2.01%)

    +0.0032 (+0.29%)
  • 10-Yr Bond

    -0.0720 (-1.69%)

    +0.0029 (+0.23%)

    +0.0800 (+0.05%)
  • Bitcoin USD

    -361.72 (-0.58%)
  • CMC Crypto 200

    0.00 (0.00%)
  • FTSE 100

    +52.48 (+0.69%)
  • Nikkei 225

    +744.63 (+1.90%)

15 Best Car Insurance Companies of 2023

In this article, we will be taking a look at the 15 best car insurance companies of 2023. If you are not interested in reading about the auto insurance market in detail, head straight to the 5 best Car Insurance Companies Of 2023.

In 2023, the world of insurance is witnessing a dynamic and rapidly evolving landscape, with consumers and businesses seeking protection and financial security from many potential risks. 

Emerging Trends in the Car Insurance Industry 

The car insurance industry is experiencing substantial transformations driven by emerging trends and technologies, and these changes have notable implications for the sector. Among the key trends, data-driven personalization demands that insurers utilize data analytics to comprehend customers and offer tailored coverage.  

Integrating connected cars and telematics technology will redefine auto insurance, necessitating real-time risk assessment and usage-based insurance. However, the industry faces increasing premiums, prompting insurers to explore ways to balance profitability and affordability, possibly through more flexible coverage options or discounts.  

Automation is becoming critical, particularly for rapid claims processing after natural disasters, requiring investment in automation technologies to enhance efficiency. Additionally, insurtech innovations are continually emerging, potentially reshaping insurance markets and necessitating insurers to stay abreast of evolving trends.  

McKinsey's recent report explores how autonomous driving, connectivity, and embedded telematics are reshaping auto insurance and influencing manufacturers. These technologies offer manufacturers better customer access and data but challenge traditional insurers. Insurers adopting real-time, usage-based coverage can succeed.

Autonomous vehicles are anticipated to reduce accidents, shifting auto insurance to a "predict and prevent" model. Liability is also expected to shift from human operators to self-driving car manufacturers. The insurance risk pool's size and composition will change, with some liability moving to commercial products. By 2030, about two-thirds of the auto insurance market will consist of Level 0 (L0) or Level 1 (L1) vehicles with standard insurance.

Expert Market Research reveals that the global car insurance market is projected to grow at a 7.1% CAGR from 2023 to 2028. On the other hand, the US commercial auto insurance market expected to reach $71.68 billion by 2030. Average US car insurance costs $2,014 annually, and minimum coverage averages $622 per year.

AI-Driven Startups Transforming the Auto Insurance Landscape 

The auto insurance industry is increasingly transforming itself with AI technologies. According to Solera Innovation Index of 2022, 79% of customers would prefer auto-insurance claims powered by AI, a 7% year on year increase. So the auto-insurance industry adapting to AI is just supply meeting demand.

In the United States, Lemonade stands out, utilizing AI and behavioral economics to take advantage of more fine-grained underwriting. In March, 2023, Lemonade expanded its business to Oregon, with the launch of Lemonade Car.

Lemonade Car provides a flexible pricing model that allows drivers to pay based on the actual miles they drive, in addition to a cost-effective monthly base rate. Through the Lemonade app, drivers can access innovative car insurance with integrated safety features, including complimentary crash detection and emergency services, as well as a streamlined and speedy claims process.

Meanwhile, Shift Technology, a French startup, employs data science to help insurers detect fraud, reduce loss adjustment expenses, and enhance customer experiences. 

In commercial auto insurance, US-based startup Fairmatic is pioneering the use of AI to reduce risk, having secured $46 million in venture funding by early 2023, as reported by TechCrunch. These developments highlight the profound influence of AI on the insurance industry. 

Other startups, such as Lemonade, have raised substantial funding to support their AI-driven initiatives, with Lemonade amassing $480 million in funding from investors, including SoftBank and Allianz. Metromile, which offers pay-per-mile auto insurance and employs AI to track mileage for personalized pricing, has received $293 million in total funding, backed by investors like NEA and Index Ventures.

Root Insurance, another insurtech startup, utilizes AI to analyze driver behavior and provide personalized pricing, accumulating $523 million in funding with support from investors such as DST Global and Coatue Management, per reports from Business Wire. Additionally, Zest AI, specializing in assisting insurers with more accurate and efficient policy underwriting through AI, has raised $163 million in total funding, with investments from Insight Partners and Lightspeed Venture Partners. These startups are revolutionizing the insurance sector by harnessing the power of AI and data analytics to enhance speed, efficiency, and customer satisfaction. 

Largest Auto Insurance Companies

State Farm, Geico, Progressive, AllState and USAA are the biggest companies in the car insurance industry in the US. State Farm has the highest market share at 16.8%.

According to recent comparisons by The Zebra, Geico, and USAA are top choices for auto insurance. They offer coverage options that cater to most customers and boast affordable prices below the national average. USAA stands out for providing the lowest rates, particularly for drivers with clean records, although USAA and Geico are competitively priced. ValuePenguin's assessment underscores USAA's cost-effectiveness and the breadth of coverage options it presents. USAA is the fifth-largest car insurance provider, holding approximately 6% of the market.

Conversely, Geico ranks as the second-largest auto insurer in the US, commanding a market share of 14%. Despite USAA's lower rates, Geico still offers quality customer service, as noted by ValuePenguin. For those seeking the lowest premiums, NerdWallet advises comparing rates from at least three insurers, including Geico, Progressive, and State Farm, and regional auto insurance providers. 

Also see 12 Best Life Insurance Companies.

15 Best Car Insurance Companies Of 2023
15 Best Car Insurance Companies Of 2023

Pixabay/Public Domain

Our Methodology  

We curated a list of the top 15 car insurance companies in 2023 based on sources like BankrateNerdWalletForbesValuePenguinWalletHub, and US News. Our approach involved calculating an average rating for each company based on these sources. We then ranked these companies based on average ratings in ascending order. It's crucial to note that these ratings rely on quantitative data and may not represent individual experiences with each company. 

Here is our list of the 15 best car insurance companies in 2023.  

15. Mercury 

Average Rating: 4 stars  

Mercury Insurance, one of the best car insurance companies of 2023 offers auto coverage in 11 states, providing discounts like anti-theft and good driver incentives. Their rates are below the national average, averaging $1,032 annually for minimum coverage and $1,547 for full coverage, according to Bankrate. They emphasize customer service, competitive rates, and financial stability, offering additional options like usage-based insurance and rideshare coverage.

14. Farmers  

Average Rating: 4 stars 

Farmers Auto Insurance, a widely known insurer, offers a range of coverage options but tends to have higher-than-average premiums. According to NerdWallet, their full coverage car insurance averages $2,807 annually, exceeding the national average by over $650. Drivers with accidents causing injury may pay even more, averaging $3,074, as per Forbes. Elderly drivers at ages 70 and 80 face premiums about $350 above the national average of $2,498. Farmers also provides coverage for various vehicles, including off-road, motorcycles, and more, along with unique perks like accident forgiveness and diminishing deductibles.

13. Liberty Mutual  

Average Rating: 4.1 stars 

Liberty Mutual is an auto insurance company with a yearly average premium of $1,090, which is higher than the national average. They offer various digital tools and discounts, like RightTrack and bundling policies, to help customers save money. However, they tend to be more expensive for full-coverage policies, costing about $200 more annually and $15 more per month than Allstate. In Q2 2023, they reported a net loss of $585 million, down from $343 million in 2022, while offering innovative partnership models for Auto, Home, and Pet Insurance.

12. The All-State Corporation (NYSE:ALL)

Average Rating: 4.1 stars 

The All State Corporation (NYSE:ALL) is one of the best auto-insurance providers in the US. It provides various insurance products, such as auto, home, motorcycle, and RV insurance. In Q4 2022, their auto insurance combined ratio was 112.6, 8.3 points higher year on year. The All State Corporation (NYSE:ALL) offers Allstate Rewards for safe drivers. They also consider credit information in policy evaluations and provide customers with their insurance score's rate impact. 

11. COUNTRY Financial 

Average Rating: 4.2 stars 

COUNTRY Financial, established in 1925, provides a variety of insurance products, including home, car, business, farm, and life insurance and stands eleventh among the best car insurance companies of 2023. They have a client-focused approach, boasting over 3,000 employees and 2,000 insurance agents who aim to understand clients' unique needs. COUNTRY Financial supports claims through online reporting and local representatives and also offers retirement planning services.

10. The Travelers Companies, Inc. (NYSE:TRV)

Average Rating: 4.2 stars 

In 2022, The Travelers Companies, Inc. (NYSE:TRV) generated $37 billion in revenue and achieved $3.0 billion in core income with an 11.3% core return on equity. They set a record with $35.4 billion in net written premiums for 2022, returned $2.9 billion to shareholders, held $80.5 billion in total investments, and had a book value per share of $92.90 in 2022. The Travelers Companies, Inc. (NYSE:TRV) offer automobile insurance through Travelers Texas MGA, underwritten by Consumers County Mutual Insurance Company (CCM). 

9. Amica 

Average Rating: 4.3 stars 

Amica Mutual Insurance is a significant player in the U.S. insurance industry, with consistent financial strength. In 2022, the company reported earned premiums of $2.7 billion, a net income of $110 million, and a surplus of $3.3 billion. Their total coverage in force reached $47.4 billion. Subsidiary Amica Life Insurance also maintained a strong financial position, generating $7.4 million in new life premium in 2022. The company's commitment to giving back was evident, with nearly $5 million donated to nonprofits in 2021.

8. Erie  

Average Rating: 4.3 stars 

Erie Insurance, a Fortune 500 company and one of the largest auto insurance companies in the US, provides services to Erie Insurance Exchange. Erie Indemnity Company, serving policyholders. Erie offers various coverage options, including new car replacement, accident forgiveness, and pet coverage. It's highly rated for basic insurance coverage and customer satisfaction, making it a top choice in states where it writes policies. 

7. The Progressive Corporation (NYSE:PGR

Average Rating: 4.4 stars 

The Progressive Corporation (NYSE:PGR)  is a major U.S. insurance company, with a strong financial presence. In 2022, their total net-premiums-written reached $42.6 billion, primarily driven by the Personal Lines business. The company had substantial investments, with holdings of $29.6 billion in fixed maturity securities, $7.1 billion in equity securities, and $2.2 billion in short-term investments as of December 31, 2022. The Progressive Corporation (NYSE:PGR) also experienced premium growth in their insurance subsidiaries during the second quarter of 2022.

6. State Farm 

Average Rating: 4.5 stars 

State Farm is one of the top auto-insurance providers in the United States, providing various insurance products. In 2022, they wrote approximately $46.7 billion in premiums, with an underwriting loss of $13.4 billion due to rising claims severity.

Click to see and continue reading the 5 Best Car Insurance Companies Of 2023.

Suggested Articles:

Disclosure: none. 15 Best Car Insurance Companies in 2023 is originally published on Insider Monkey.