U.S. Markets open in 6 hrs 30 mins

The bellwether district that could portend a 2018 Democratic wave

Andrew Romano
West Coast Correspondent
Rep. Mimi Walters, R-Calif. (Photo: Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call)

LOS ANGELES — At first glance, Rep. Mimi Walters doesn’t seem like the sort of Republican who’s about to lose her job.

A former investment banker who climbed the Republican ladder in ritzy Laguna Niguel, Calif., before heading to Washington, D.C., Walters has always felt like a good fit for California’s 45th Congressional District — a conservative-leaning, business-oriented patch of suburban Orange County, itself a traditional GOP stronghold. In 2014, voters there first elected Walters to Congress by 30 percentage points; two years later she won reelection by 17 points, even as Donald Trump lost the district to Hillary Clinton by 5.

Clinton’s win was unprecedented — no Democratic presidential candidate had ever captured CA-45 before — and thanks to demographic changes and local anti-Trump sentiment, the former secretary of state also flipped the rest of Orange County. Yet while Walters’s fellow O.C. Republicans have suddenly found themselves in the hot seat as a result — Reps. Darrell Issa and Ed Royce decided to retire, setting off fierce succession fights, and Rep. Dana Rohrabacher faces several strong Democratic and Republican opponents — Walters has largely flown under the radar, the assumption being that she’s the safest of the lot.

But what if the very factors that make Walters seem less vulnerable than her GOP neighbors are same factors that could make her reelection campaign 2018’s best bellwether: the race to watch for signs not just of a Democratic win, but of a Democratic wave?

To regain control of the House, Democrats need to net 24 seats. That seems increasingly doable: The party is performing better than Republicans in generic ballot polls — surveys in which people are asked which party they would support in a congressional election — and President Trump’s approval rating is historically low. Swings of 24 or more seats aren’t historically uncommon, either; they’ve happened in half the midterm elections since 1994.

A wave election, however, would be something else: A transcontinental tide more akin to 2010, when the GOP’s tea party momentum was so strong that it didn’t really matter how solid a particular incumbent was, or how salient some local issue. The Republican Party flipped 63 seats, and the House, and there wasn’t much any individual Democrat could do about it.

Which is where Walters comes in.

In three key ways, her reelection fight is typical of 2018 as a whole — and that’s why it could be telling.

The first factor is Walters herself. Unlike Issa or Rohrabacher — or any Republican running in a Trump-era special election, over which Democrats have obsessed and in which they have overperformed — Walters has not been the focus of national controversy or the target of national Democratic hostility. Issa was an aggressive antagonist of Barack Obama; Rohrabacher has been called Vladimir Putin’s “favorite congressman.” Walters, in contrast, is not a name politician; she is not a left-wing bête noire. She is, instead, a perfectly ordinary, mostly overlooked Republican incumbent, with views that mirror the party consensus. If Walters were to lose in November, it wouldn’t be because she is exceptional in some way; the same would be true if she were to win. She is the opposite of an outlier.

Rep. Mimi Walters at a press conference with House Speaker Paul Ryan. (Photo: Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call)

Even Walters’s relationship to Trump is typical. Like most of the rest of the Republican Party, she has wagered that it will benefit her more to stick with the president than to strike out against him, despite his many deviations from conservative orthodoxy and decorum.

Initially Walters supported Jeb Bush for president, then Marco Rubio; she only came around to Trump after her preferred candidates tanked. But when Trump’s “Access Hollywood” tape surfaced shortly before the 2016 election, Walters refused to rescind her endorsement, or to comment in any way. And since the start of his administration she has compiled one of the most pro-Trump records in the House, voting in line with the president’s position 98.6 percent of the time, according to FiveThirtyEight — including votes to repeal the Affordable Care Act and pass Trump’s tax plan, both decisions that were broadly unpopular in California, where many voters rely on the state’s version of Obamacare and will lose valuable deductions under the new tax law.

In short, if the 2018 midterms are a referendum on the president, as most midterms are, Walters hasn’t given voters inclined to vote against Trump any particular reason to vote for her. Their agendas are identical.

The second “typical” factor at work in CA-45 is Walters’s Democratic opposition. Ever since Conor Lamb, a somewhat moderate 33-year-old Marine and former federal prosecutor, defeated his Republican rival, Rick Saccone, earlier this month in PA-18, a district that Trump won by 20 percentage points, politicos have argued over whether Lamb was a “political unicorn” — an impossibly perfect one-off candidate whose victory had more to do with his own performance than any underlying trend. The same went for newly minted Sen. Doug Jones, the Democrat who last year defeated accused pedophile Roy Moore in deep-red Alabama. Democrats can’t possibly hope to run such idiosyncratically well-suited challengers nationwide, the thinking goes — and therefore they can’t possibly hope to keep scoring such big upsets.

This is unlikely to be an issue in Walters’s district. There are four Democrats angling to unseat the two-term congresswoman, and none of them are obvious unicorns. Instead, they make up a remarkably representative cross-section of the Democratic Party’s class of 2018, which is defined by its abundance of rookie candidates, many of them women and/or minorities, who have decided to run for office in order to “resist” Trump’s agenda. There’s Katie Porter, 43, a Harvard-educated consumer protection attorney and law professor at the University of California, Irvine, who has worked with Sen. Elizabeth Warren and Sen. Kamala Harris. There’s Dave Min, 42, another Harvard-educated UC-Irvine law professor and a former economic aide to Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer. There’s Brian Forde, 37, a former tech adviser in the Obama White House. And there’s Kia Hamadanchy, 32, the son of Iranian immigrants and a former adviser to Ohio Sen. Sherrod Brown.

Katie Porter, Dave Min, Brian Forde and Kia Hamadanchy, Democratic candidates in CA-45. (Photos: Rachel Murray/Getty Images, davemin.com, forde.com, Thomas McKinless/CQ Roll Call)

Unlike Walters, who was a city councilwoman, mayor, state assemblywoman and state senator before running for Congress, none of her Democratic challengers has ever campaigned for elected office before. None is personally wealthy (like, say, entrepreneur Harley Rouda, who is running to replace Rohrabacher in CA-48). None has been touted as a top Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee recruit (like, say, stem-cell pioneer Hans Keirstead, who is also competing in CA-48). And none has benefited from a surge in out-of-state attention and donations (like, say, prosecutor Andrew Janz, who has become a progressive cause célèbre because he is battling controversial Trump loyalist Devin Nunes in CA-22).  In terms of experience, fundraising, connections, national interest and raw political talent, each CA-45 challenger is close to the 2018 Democratic mean. They are your quintessential resistance candidates.

Their primary clash has been typical as well. (In California’s nonpartisan primary system, the top two finishers proceed to the general election regardless of whether they’re Democrats, Republicans or independents; with Walters a lock for first, the fight for second place basically amounts to a Democratic primary contest.) No clear frontrunner has emerged, and the two most prominent candidates, Porter and Min, have been staging a small-scale version of the argument dividing the Democratic Party as a whole: Should Dems run as proud progressives and hope the base turns out in 2018? Or should they try to convert disillusioned Trump voters by burnishing their centrist credentials?

Porter has chosen the first path, touting her endorsements from left-wing icons Warren and Harris and pushing for single-payer health care; Min has hewed a little closer to the center, opposing Medicare for All as “a tremendous tax increase” that wouldn’t play well in such “a conservative district,” according to his campaign manager. (“Dave is not the candidate who is furthest to the left,” she added.) The race has been very close, with Min just barely clinching the state party’s endorsement at last month’s convention — his slim margin triggered a bitter floor fight — and Porter leading in some recent polls.

Whatever happens in California’s June 5 primary, the surviving Democrat is likely to have survived because his or her campaign was more in tune with the mood of the party. And if a Democrat defeats Walters in November, individual attributes probably won’t be the biggest reason, either. Walters has enough advantages — money, incumbency, local political infrastructure — that her Democratic challenger will almost certainly need to ride a national wave to win.

Which brings us to the last “typical” aspect of the CA-45 contest: the district itself. Even though Clinton won there by more than 5 points — and even though Republicans have an 8-point registration advantage — its “partisan lean,” according to FiveThirtyEight, is actually tiny: just 1 or 2 percentage points in the GOP’s favor. This means that in presidential elections, with presidential-level turnout, the results in CA-45 almost exactly mirror the national results. The district has become a bellwether of sorts.

Rep. Mimi Walters at the Capitol. (Photo: Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call)

Of course, midterm elections aren’t presidential elections, and a lot of voters — especially Democratic voters — tend to skip them. But demographics could play a part here as well, as Clare Malone of FiveThirtyEight has also pointed out. CA-45 is much more diverse than it was in Ronald Reagan’s day, with a population that is 18 percent Latino and 22 percent Asian; it’s also far more educated than the country at large, with 79.3 percent of residents having completed some college or more, versus 59 percent overall. In 2016, Trump underperformed among white college graduates, and even lost college-educated women to Clinton by 7 percentage points. Combine that weakness with Trump’s widespread unpopularity among Latinos and other minorities, and you start to see why CA-45 (and the rest of Orange County) flipped to Clinton: Trump was a particularly bad fit for its evolving electorate.

And so, if any voting groups are going to fuel an anti-Trump tsunami in 2018, it’s these two: white suburban college grads and minorities. Both have been telling pollsters they disapprove of the president’s job performance in record numbers. Both have been propelling Democrats to victory in special elections. And CA-45 has both in droves, making it a perfect testing ground for the larger proposition.

Is Mimi Walters the most endangered GOP incumbent of 2018? Far from it. But due to the demographics of her district, the nature of her Democratic challengers and her own low-profile, pro-Trump orthodoxy, she may be the most typical — and telling. If you’re searching for signs of a Democratic wave, watch Walters. It could start sweeping through her corner of California first.

Read more from Yahoo News:

  • Kevin O’Leary is right about cars, and his logic can save your retirement

    Kevin O’Leary is right about cars, and his logic can save your retirement

    Financially speaking, though, car ownership today is a terrible idea, O’Leary said. You’re thinking about buying a car. Let me give you a new idea: Don’t,” O’Leary said on CNBC.

  • Business

    Saxo Bank to buy Dutch BinckBank for $480 million

    Denmark's Saxo Bank has agreed to buy all shares in Dutch online bank BinckBank (BINCK.AS) for around $480 million (382 million pounds) in an all-cash public offer. Saxo Bank will pay 6.35 euros (5.71 pounds) per share, representing a premium of 35 percent to BinckBank's closing price on Friday, valuing the deal at 424 million euros, the two firms said in a joint statement on Monday. "As the investment and trading industry matures and faces new regulation as well as rising expectations for digital client experience, scale, technology and multi-asset capabilities become increasingly key to long-term success," Saxo CEO Kim Fournais said in the statement.

  • Is Dynavax Technologies Corporation (DVAX) Going to Burn These Hedge Funds?
    Insider Monkey

    Is Dynavax Technologies Corporation (DVAX) Going to Burn These Hedge Funds?

    Because of Carl Icahn and other elite funds' exemplary historical records, we pay attention to their small cap picks. In this article, we use hedge fund filing data to analyze Dynavax Technologies Corporation (NASDAQ:DVAX). DVAX was in 19 hedge funds' portfolios at the end of the third quarter of 2018.

  • Boeing Delivers Its 1st 737 Jet From Completion Center in China

    Boeing Delivers Its 1st 737 Jet From Completion Center in China

    The first 737 MAX airliner was delivered from Boeing’s new Zhoushan factory in a ceremony to Air China on Saturday. This comes amid the 90-day truce in the U.S. and China’s trade war. The 100-acre completion site is the first of its kind for Boeing and is part of the U.S. aerospace company’s plan to deepen its connection to what will soon be the biggest aviation market in the world.

  • Business

    Foxconn not in settlement talks with Qualcomm in Apple battle - attorney

    The lead attorney for the group of Apple Inc (AAPL.O) device assemblers seeking at least $9 billion (7 billion pounds) in damages from Qualcomm Inc (QCOM.O) said on Sunday the contract manufacturers are not in settlement talks with the mobile chip supplier and are "gearing up and heading towards the trial" in April. The conflict is but one aspect of the global legal battle between regulators, Apple and Qualcomm, which supplies modem chips that help phones connect to wireless data networks. Last week, Qualcomm secured a preliminary victory in a patent lawsuit in China that would have banned sales of some Apple iPhones there.

  • Jennifer Lawrence speaks out against new lawsuit claiming she had affair with Harvey Weinstein
    Yahoo Entertainment

    Jennifer Lawrence speaks out against new lawsuit claiming she had affair with Harvey Weinstein

    A new lawsuit filed against Harvey Weinstein alleges that the disgraced Hollywood producer bragged about having an affair with Jennifer Lawrence — and the actress isn’t having it.

  • Better Buy: Advanced Micro Devices vs. NVIDIA
    Motley Fool

    Better Buy: Advanced Micro Devices vs. NVIDIA

    Capital returns Another advantage of having more cash resources is being able to distribute more capital to shareholders in the form of dividends and share repurchases. Between 2015 and 2017, AMD's cumulative amount of free cash flow generation was negative $354 million. The company's recent growth has helped it generate positive free cash flow of $178 million over the last year.

  • Watch Lockheed Martin drop a new combat ship into a river
    American City Business Journals

    Watch Lockheed Martin drop a new combat ship into a river

    A shipbuilding team led by Bethesda-based Lockheed Martin launched its littoral combat ship 19 into the Menominee River in Wisconsin over the weekend. The so-called sideways launch, at the Fincantieri Marinette Marine Shipyard in Marinette, Wisconsin, is something that needs to be seen to be believed so here’s video of it. LCS 19, the future USS St. Louis, is the second littoral combat ship christened and launched by Lockheed (NYSE: LMT) this year.

  • Surprise! The Largest U.S. Pension Fund Just Bought These 2 Marijuana Stocks
    Motley Fool

    Surprise! The Largest U.S. Pension Fund Just Bought These 2 Marijuana Stocks

    When big institutional investors pour money into marijuana stocks, you know the cannabis industry has hit the big time. The California Public Employees' Retirement System (CalPERS) filed its report of holdings with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) a few weeks ago. It takes a while to scroll through all the stocks that CalPERS owns in its massive portfolio, but there were a couple of surprising new additions on the latest filing.

  • The 5 Best Selling Handguns of 2018
    Motley Fool

    The 5 Best Selling Handguns of 2018

    It's been said that America loves its guns. Exactly what guns Americans are buying, however, is much harder to know. In place of sales data, financial analysts can use the total number of background checks to gauge interest in firearms -- but that data offers no way of determining what guns are being purchased, and offers only limited insight into repeat buyers.

  • Dow Jones Futures: The Worst Part About This Market Rally
    Investor's Business Daily

    Dow Jones Futures: The Worst Part About This Market Rally

    Dow Jones futures were little changed Sunday, along with S&P 500 futures and Nasdaq futures. The stock market rally is barely hanging on, with the S&P 500 index and Dow Jones ending Friday at multi-month closing lows. While tumbling Apple stock gets and deserves a lot of attention, the best stocks are the worst part of this stock market rally.

  • Will Micron Technology Pass This Litmus Test?
    Motley Fool

    Will Micron Technology Pass This Litmus Test?

    For comparison, analysts are looking for $2.93 per share in earnings on $8.05 billion in revenue, indicating that the company is on track to beat expectations if it can hit the midpoint of its own guidance range. Analysts were originally expecting $8.4 billion in revenue from Micron and earnings per share of $3.06, but they dialed that back significantly thanks to the company's muted outlook. The market punished Micron big time for this slip, as the stock has declined nearly 25% since September, when its last set of results came out.

  • Balancing the Ledger: Bain Capital Ventures Managing Director Salil Deshpande
    Meredith Videos

    Balancing the Ledger: Bain Capital Ventures Managing Director Salil Deshpande

    Deshpande dishes on the Basis shutdown, discusses the future of Bitcoin, and talks about why he's bearish on enterprise blockchain.

  • Here is What Hedge Funds Think About BHP Group Limited (BHP)
    Insider Monkey

    Here is What Hedge Funds Think About BHP Group Limited (BHP)

    In this article, we will take a closer look at hedge fund sentiment towards BHP Group Limited (NYSE:BHP). BHP Group Limited (NYSE:BHP) was in 19 hedge funds' portfolios at the end of September. BHP investors should be aware of an increase in enthusiasm from smart money of late.

  • 3 Stocks Value Investing Legend Seth Klarman Bought in Q3 (and 2 He Dumped)
    Insider Monkey

    3 Stocks Value Investing Legend Seth Klarman Bought in Q3 (and 2 He Dumped)

    Consistent with his value investing approach, the billionaire's hedge fund made only a small number of moves in its highly concentrated portfolio during Q3, opening new positions in six stocks while selling out of just one former holding. Communications stocks continued to grow in weighting within Baupost's 13F portfolio, rising to 31.19% by the end of Q3, compared to just 8.17% a year earlier. Utilities also jumped to 6.87% from just 1.73% in the middle of 2018.

  • Hedge Funds Are Betting On Nokia Corporation (NOK)
    Insider Monkey

    Hedge Funds Are Betting On Nokia Corporation (NOK)

    Insider Monkey's flagship best performing hedge funds strategy returned 6.3% year to date (through December 3rd) and outperformed the market even though it draws its stock picks among small-cap stocks. This strategy also outperformed the market by 18 percentage points since its inception (see the details here). That's why we believe hedge fund sentiment is a useful indicator that investors should pay attention to.

  • See what the IHS Markit Score report has to say about AbbVie Inc.

    See what the IHS Markit Score report has to say about AbbVie Inc.

    NYSE:ABBV Score: Positive (89) 108 days at current score. Upgraded from Neutral on August 30th 2018 Summary This company ranked positively in all 3 IHS Markit categories and the Healthcare sector ETFs holding this stock are seeing positive inflows Bearish sentiment is low Economic output in this company's sector is expanding Short interest | Positive Short interest is extremely low for ABBV with fewer than 1% of shares on loan. This could indicate that investors who seek to profit from falling equity prices are not currently targeting ABBV.

  • Hitachi’s ABB Deal Isn't Just an Escape Hatch

    Hitachi’s ABB Deal Isn't Just an Escape Hatch

    Hitachi is nearing an agreement to buy 80.1 percent of Swiss engineering giant ABB Ltd.’s power-grid unit, in a deal that values the entire business at $11 billion. ABB has an option to sell its 19.9 percent stake three years after the current deal – Hitachi's largest-ever purchase – is completed. In its statement, ABB noted that Hitachi would help provide access to new markets as well as financing.

  • Apple Stock Could Double Over 3 Years
    Motley Fool

    Apple Stock Could Double Over 3 Years

    Despite a strong start to the year, Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL) is ending 2018 on something of a sour note. The company hit a $1 trillion market cap in August, becoming the first U.S. company in history to achieve that benchmark. However, since hitting an all-time high in October, shares of the iPhone maker have lost more than 25% of their value, due to fears of slowing iPhone sales and a possible trade war with China.

  • Trade war: Signs of progress in US-China talks

    Trade war: Signs of progress in US-China talks

    Though markets are on edge and the arrest of a top Chinese executive threatened to spark a crisis, there are signs the US-China trade war can be resolved without further collateral damage to the global economy. The whole world is watching the talks between Washington and Beijing, hoping a 90-day tariff truce will hold and the sides can end a dispute that threatens hundreds of billions of dollars in trade. In recent days the small signs of progress, and perhaps more importantly the absence of new threats from President Donald Trump, have cheered investors worldwide, reversing some of the bloodletting that erased all of 2018 gains on Wall Street.

  • Better Buy: PepsiCo vs. Altria
    Motley Fool

    Better Buy: PepsiCo vs. Altria

    Financial fortitude Let's now look at some key financial metrics to see how Pepsi and Altria compare. Pepsi produces about 150% more revenue than Altria. Yet Altria is far more profitable, with an operating margin of nearly 38%, compared with 16% for Pepsi.

  • Better Buy: Netflix vs. Amazon
    Motley Fool

    Better Buy: Netflix vs. Amazon

    That better-than-expected subscriber growth propelled Netflix shares up as much as 120% this year, though the stock has since given up much of those gains as investor sentiment has cooled on high-growth tech stocks in recent months. Although subscriber growth remains strong, other investor concerns have arisen for this high-priced stock that trades at a P/E of 99. For instance, in its third-quarter earnings call, Netflix said it would burn through $3 billion to $4 billion in free cash flow next year, and that it would take a few more years to reach breakeven, though CFO David Wells stressed that the company was optimizing for long-term free cash flow and long-term profitability.

  • This Tiny Marijuana Stock Could Be Better Prepared for the Coming Supply Glut Than Canopy Growth and Tilray
    Motley Fool

    This Tiny Marijuana Stock Could Be Better Prepared for the Coming Supply Glut Than Canopy Growth and Tilray

    A supply glut in the Canadian recreational marijuana market might be the last thing on everyone's minds right now. Marijuana producers can't ship enough cannabis to meet the heavy demand. Make no mistake about it, though, a supply glut is on the way.

  • Where Will ExxonMobil Be in 5 Years?
    Motley Fool

    Where Will ExxonMobil Be in 5 Years?

    The oil giant expects to invest $24 billion on capital projects this year, with that ramping up to $28 billion in 2019 before averaging around $30 billion annually in the 2020 to 2025 time frame. Exxon will invest the largest portion of this capital on the upstream side, where it expects to grow its production volumes from around 4 million barrels of oil equivalent per day (BOE/D) up to 5 million BOE/D by 2025. The company believes this will triple its upstream earnings without any improvement in oil prices since Exxon will focus on investing in its highest margin opportunities.

  • Better Buy: General Electric vs. Verizon
    Motley Fool

    Better Buy: General Electric vs. Verizon

    Industrial companies like GE often have large finance arms, but they are intended to help facilitate the purchase of company-made products. GE's finance division spread to include things like mortgage financing, which was way beyond the company's industrial focus and, unfortunately, a key factor in the recession. When that finance-led recession hit, GE was forced to cut its dividend, take large one-time charges, sell off assets, and accept a government bailout.