U.S. Markets closed

The Best Cash-Back Credit Cards in America

Jason Steele

As airlines and hotels continue to decrease the value of the points and miles they offer through their co-branded credit cards, cash back remains the reward of choice for many cardholders. And credit card issuers understand their customers’ need for a simple program that offers the one reward that no one will likely ever have trouble redeeming.

When looking for the best cash-back credit cards for this month’s Best Credit Cards in America, we weighed several factors. First, we looked at the rate of return as a percentage of spending. The problem is that some cards offer a fixed rate of return on all purchases, while others offer bonus rewards for purchases from certain categories of merchants. Individual cardholders can find the best cards by estimating how much of their purchases will qualify for the bonus, or they can maximize their returns by using one card at some merchants, and another card at others.

Next, we looked at fees. The biggest one that cardholders may face is the annual fee, as some of the most rewarding cash-back credit cards will have this charge. Nevertheless, there are still plenty of competitive products without this fee. Also, we considered all of the other perks that a credit card may offer. This can include travel insurance and purchase protection policies, along with some new, innovative benefits.

Finally, we did not factor in the interest rates when looking for the best cards. That is because anyone using a cash-back credit card should be paying their balance in full and on time, every month. To do otherwise would mean incurring interest charges that would likely exceed any cash-back rewards. Instead, those who tend to carry a balance will need to look for a card with the lowest possible interest rate, which will not be a rewards card.

As you shop for a cash-back credit card, it can help to know your credit scores so that you apply for a credit card for which you’re more likely to be approved. You can check your credit scores for free through Credit.com, along with an analysis of your credit and a plan to build or maintain your credit.

The Winner: Fidelity Investment Rewards American Express Card

Why it won: These cards continue to lead the market by offering 2% cash back on all purchases, which is deposited into a qualifying investment account with Fidelity.

What this card offers: For every $2,500 in purchases made, cardholders earn 5,000 points, which can be automatically redeemed for a $50 deposit to their designated Fidelity Investments account each time they meet this minimum. Cardholders can choose to have their rewards deposited into a qualifying brokerage account, investment account, 529 college savings account or retirement account. Cardholders earn 2% cash back on all purchases, and there is no limit to the amount of cash back they can receive. According to Sam McLimans, Fidelity’s Senior Vice President of Cash Management, this card continues to experience tremendous growth due to the fact that it is a simple, easy to understand offer of 2% cash back on everything, all the time. Or as he puts it: “Customers just get it.”

Other features: Instead of cash back, cardholders can choose to redeem their rewards in the WorldPoints program, which offers gift cards or travel rewards.

The cost: There is no annual fee for this card, and the foreign transaction fee is just 1%. That is significantly less than the 2.7% foreign transaction fee charged by most American Express cards.

1st Runner-Up: Capital One Quicksilver Cash Rewards Credit Card

Why it won: This new Capital One card offers 1.5% cash back on all purchases, with no annual fee.

What this card offers: Cardholders earn 1.5% cash back on every transaction, and receive their rewards every month. There is no limit to the amount of rewards that can be earned, and the rewards never expire.

Other features: New applicants receive a $100 sign-up bonus after they use their card to make $500 in purchases within three months. As a Visa Signature card, customers receive extended warranty coverage, access to travel upgrades and savings, and the use of a complimentary concierge service.

The cost: There is no annual fee for this card, and no foreign transaction fees on charges processed outside of the U.S.

2nd Runner-Up: American Express Blue Cash Preferred

Why it won: Although cardholders only receive 1% cash back on most purchases, this card offers up to 6% cash back at select merchants.

What this card offers: Cardholders can earn 6% cash back on up to $6,000 spent each year at U.S. grocery stores. They can also get 3% cash back at stand-alone gas stations in the U.S. and at select department stores such as Sears, Macy’s and JCPenney, while 1% cash back is earned on all other purchases.

Other Features: New applicants earn a $100 statement credit after spending $1,000 within the first three months of becoming a card member. Purchase protection and travel accident policies are also included, but the latest new feature to be added is a year’s subscription to Amazon Prime. This service normally sells for $99 and features free two-day shipping as well as online streaming of television and movies.

The Cost: There is a $75 annual fee for this card and a 2.7% foreign transaction fee imposed on all charges processed outside of the U.S.

Note: It’s important to remember that prices for various products can change. As a result, the prices for products cited in these articles may have changed since the date of publication. Please be sure to verify current prices directly with the offering party.

More from Credit.com