(Bloomberg) -- Nobody saw it coming. Biogen Inc. stunned investors with its surprise Alzheimer’s drug submission on Tuesday, reviving hopes for an experimental medicine that investors had mostly left for dead. Shares surged a record 42% on Tuesday, and at least one analyst says they may have room to go.
SVB Leerink analyst Geoff Porges estimates the stock could rise to the $400-range as investors warm up to the drug’s prospects. If approved, the treatment, known as aducanumab, could price the stock as high as $485-$525, he wrote.
Still, despite the newfound optimism, Porges and other Wall Street analysts have cautioned that FDA approval is far from a done deal. Here’s what they’re saying:
RBC, Brian Abrahams
“Somewhat incredibly,” Biogen reported clinical activity from its Phase 3 Alzheimer’s drug, aducanumab, which had been halted back in March. It’s still unclear whether the data would meet the bar for FDA approval or broader commercial adoption, Abrahams said.
New data in Biogen’s earnings slides indicate a “shakier ground” for aducanumab’s prospects, the analyst wrote. The data from the “Engage” study, which did not reach its primary goal but which Biogen had indicated as supportive for the filing, show that at the high dose, the medicine did not show any benefit and even worsened symptoms for some patients.
“Though FDA apparently provided some endorsement for the idea of filing, which could maintain some probability of approvability, we believe the new details suggest the data may be more mixed than initially perceived,” he wrote.
Sector perform, PT $236
Cowen, Phil Nadeau
Biogen’s “rationale makes sense, but it’s unclear to us if the totality of the data support FDA approval,” the analyst said. “Nonetheless, as people had thought BIIB’s Alzheimer’s program was not viable today’s news suggests that there may still be a path to market.”
Outperform, PT $275
SVB Leerink, Geoffrey Porges
“At first pass the results still appear to be marginal, with inconsistent treatment effects between the two studies and for different endpoints, but the critical question will be what reassurance the company has received from the FDA,” the analyst wrote. “This could range from ’the agency has reviewed all the data with us and has guaranteed approval’ to ’you can file whatever you want and we’ll review it’.”
Biogen’s filing will now come down to a “torturous discussion” of data, statistics, treatment effects and safety liabilities and will likely not include the societal and economic costs of further studying the devastating disease.
Shares could trade in the $400 range as investors give “partial” credit for aducanumab, Porges estimates. Full value for the drug probably prices the stock as high as $485-$525, he wrote.
Market perform, PT $256
Jefferies, Michael Yee
Investors and analysts will continue to debate the potential approval but its drug submission makes it another binary outcome for shares next year. The stock is now pricing in around a 35%-50% chance as it is back to $300 and where it was around the time before the drug failed, the analyst said.
Yee also agrees it makes sense for Biogen to file and try to get the drug approved since it has done the work and spent money on studies. “There is some argument FDA might accept all of this data given the significant unmet need, but our questions would be mostly on how convincing is the data for FDA,” he wrote.
Hold, PT $255
Evercore ISI, Umer Raffat
“Ultimately, I realize there are lots of cuts of data here ... given the unmet need and the signal seen in high dose EMERGE, its not inconceivable that FDA is open to this filing,” he wrote. “However, whether FDA approval means major commercial acceptance is a whole different debate.”
Questioned whether the departure of Biogen’s head of R&D earlier this month was related to the new data. Raffat notes Biogen’s earnings call suggested that’s not the case.
Citi, Mohit Bansal
Given the stock move today, consensus estimates are implying about $3 billion in adjusted sales for aducanumab to Biogen. As a reminder, the biotech firm takes roughly half of total sales, given its partnership with Japan’s Eisai Co.
$3 billion to $4 billion in peak sales would take Biogen’s fair value to $345-$375 a share
(Updates shares, adds Evercore, Citi remarks)
To contact the reporter on this story: Tatiana Darie in New York at email@example.com
To contact the editors responsible for this story: Catherine Larkin at firstname.lastname@example.org, Scott Schnipper
For more articles like this, please visit us at bloomberg.com
©2019 Bloomberg L.P.