U.S. Markets close in 5 hrs 20 mins

Buried Treasure in Academic Journals

Daniel Solin

Most Americans get their investment advice from the financial media. Unfortunately, much of this "advice" is unreliable and misleading. The most glaring example is Jim Cramer's show, "Mad Money". Allan Roth recently calculated Cramer's stock-picking skill level. He observed that Cramer made four sell recommendations on stocks that ended up being the four best performers out of 749 stocks for the six-month period ending May 13. Roth determined the odds of doing so at 1 in 13.1 billion.

An article in Barron's took a broader look at Cramer's stock picking expertise. The author concluded that "Cramer's recommendations underperform the market by most measures."

Much of what passes for financial news consists of musings by self-styled pundits giving predictions about the future. They freely dispense their views about the direction of the markets, "hot" funds managers and stocks you need to "buy now." The background for this advice is often the floor of the NYSE, injecting a sense of urgency and instilling fear and anxiety.

In stark contrast, sound financial advice based on hard, irrefutable data is often found in obscure financial journals with very limited circulation. The authors of these articles are typically academics who study the capital markets. They write for other academics and not for the general public.

A recent example is an article in the Journal of Economic Perspective authored by Burton Malkiel. Malkiel is best known for his seminal book, "A Random Walk Down Wall Street". He is an emeritus professor of economics at Princeton University.

In his well-researched article, Malkiel notes the staggering increase in total assets managed by the mutual fund industry. These assets rose from $26 billion in 1980 to $3.5 trillion in 2010. You would think economies of scale would have driven the management fees of these funds down, but that has not occurred. More than 70 percent of stock mutual funds are actively managed (meaning the fund manager attempts to beat a designated benchmark). The management fees of these funds has increased from 0.66 percent in 1980 to 0.90 percent in 2010. In contrast, management fees for index funds and exchange-traded funds can be found for 0.07 percent, and even lower.

What are investors getting for these higher fees? Malkiel found that, for the five-year period ending in 2011, the majority of actively managed funds underperformed their benchmarks. Fixed income funds fared worse. In excess of 90 percent of actively managed, government long funds, investment-grade long funds and high-yield funds underperformed their benchmarks.

The cost of chasing returns by purchasing actively managed funds is staggering. Malkiel found that over the past 20 years, investors paid 0.64 percent of the aggregate value of the total market capitalization "in the (futile) search for superior returns." He finds the willingness of sophisticated investors to pay higher fees for lower returns "puzzling" and attributes it to the misperception that branded funds are superior to generic index funds, extensive and often misleading advertising by the mutual fund industry and the overconfidence of investors.

Malkiel notes the misleading way fees are charged by actively managed funds. Few investors realize that if those fees were calculated as a percentage of the incremental returns (the amount earned by the fund over its designated benchmark), they "are likely to exceed 100 percent", not even counting the adverse tax consequences triggered by portfolio turnover.

Instead of watching CNBC, maybe you should get a subscription to the Journal of Economic Perspective.

Dan Solin is the director of investor advocacy for the BAM Alliance and a wealth adviser with Buckingham Asset Management. He is a New York Times best-selling author of the Smartest series of books. His latest book, 7 Steps to Save Your Financial Life Now, was published on Dec. 31, 2012.

The views of the author are his alone and may not represent the views of his affiliated firms. Any data, information, and content on this blog is for information purposes only and should not be construed as an offer of advisory services.



More From US News & World Report

  • Finance
    Market Realist

    Why Baozun Inc. Is Soaring Over 15%

    Baozun Inc. (Nasdaq: BZUN), often referred to as “the Shopify of China,” is up over 15% at the open of today’s trading session following the release of its third-quarter earnings results earlier this morning.

  • Jamie Dimon and Warren Buffett Have the Last Laugh on Bitcoin
    Business
    Bloomberg

    Jamie Dimon and Warren Buffett Have the Last Laugh on Bitcoin

    Bitcoin was meant to make all of its investors rich, something that held particular appeal to a millennial generation hungry for a financial boost in a world of crushing student debt, income inequality and low quality jobs.

  • Here's Why Investors Should Bet on Twitter (TWTR) Right Now
    Finance
    Zacks

    Here's Why Investors Should Bet on Twitter (TWTR) Right Now

    Twitter TWTR is firing on all cylinders. This Zacks Rank #1 (Strong Buy) stock has gained 29.4% year-to-date outperforming the S&P 500 Composite’s decline of 1.2%. The company’s focus on adding plethora of new features and security initiatives that are

  • Boeing's plan to clarify the technology is the right thin...
    Business
    CNBC Videos

    Boeing's plan to clarify the technology is the right thin...

    Eric Dezenhall, Dezenhall Resources CEO, joins 'Squawk Box' to discuss Boeing's fallout after the Indonesia plane crash.

  • Avoid NVIDIA, Add These 4 Top-Ranked Semi Stocks to Portfolio
    Finance
    Zacks

    Avoid NVIDIA, Add These 4 Top-Ranked Semi Stocks to Portfolio

    NVIDIA Corporation’s NVDA lower-than-expected top and bottom-line results left it tremendously stressed ever since its quarterly earnings release on Nov 15. Further, this Zacks Rank #5 (Strong Sell) stock is currently one of the worst performers, lagging the S&P 500 index and the industry it belongs to over the past year. Shares of NVIDIA have plunged 31% in the past year compared with the industry’s 9% decline.

  • Finance
    Investopedia

    The Worst is Yet to Come for Stocks: Morgan Stanley

    Investors looking for solace amid the wave of market sell-offs may argue that the S&P 500 has fallen only 9% from its all-time highs in September, hardly a devastating decline. “Not only does the price action this year suggest we are in the midst of a bear market—more than 40 percent of the stocks in the S&P 500 are down at least 20 percent—but it also trades like a bear market,” wrote the bank’s analysts.

  • Trump just sent the wrong message on a brutal day in the stock markets
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Trump just sent the wrong message on a brutal day in the stock markets

    On a brutal day in the stock markets the last thing investors want to see is another attack on the Federal Reserve by President Donald Trump. Trump reportedly told a group of reporters on Tuesday that he would like to see lower interest rates from the Federal Reserve. The president added that the biggest problem right now isn’t the trade war with China (among other geopolitical issues), but rather the Jerome Powell led Federal Reserve.

  • What You Must Know About AT&T Inc’s (NYSE:T) Financial Strength
    Finance
    Simply Wall St.

    What You Must Know About AT&T Inc’s (NYSE:T) Financial Strength

    Investors seeking to preserve capital in a volatile environment might consider large-cap stocks such as AT&T Inc (NYSE:T) a safer option. Today we will look at AT&T’s financial liquidity and debt levels, which are strong indicators for whether the company can weather economic downturns or fund strategic acquisitions for future growth. Remember this is a very top-level look that focuses exclusively on financial health, so I recommend a deeper analysis into T here.

  • Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) Gains As Market Dips: What You Should Know
    Finance
    Zacks

    Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) Gains As Market Dips: What You Should Know

    This has lagged the Computer and Technology sector's loss of 5.96% and the S&P 500's loss of 2.57% in that time. AMD's full-year Zacks Consensus Estimates are calling for earnings of $0.46 per share and revenue of $6.54 billion. As a result, we can interpret positive estimate revisions as a good sign for the company's business outlook.

  • Business
    Motley Fool

    The "War on Cash" Basket of Stocks: Third-Quarter Review

    Third-quarter earnings season is just about over, and all four of our stocks in the "War on Cash" basket -- PayPal (NASDAQ: PYPL), Square (NYSE: SQ), Visa (NYSE: V), and Mastercard (NYSE: MA) -- have now reported their results. In this segment from Industry Focus: Financials, host Jason Moser and Fool.com contributor Matt Frankel, CFP, take a look back at each company's earnings and what stood out to them.

  • Finance
    CNBC

    Amid sell-off, top analysts are getting bullish these 5 defensive stocks including Merck

    With tech stocks looking like an increasingly risky bet, analysts have been getting more bullish on some key defensive names. Here we use TipRanks' Trending Stocks tool to pinpoint the best-rated defensive stocks right now. All five stocks covered below have received only buy ratings from top analysts in the last three months.

  • Where Will Home Depot Be in 5 Years?
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Where Will Home Depot Be in 5 Years?

    For longtime Home Depot Inc. (NYSE: HD) investors, third-quarter 2018 was more of the same. Net sales rose to $26.3 billion, a 5.1% increase year over year, and diluted earnings per share (EPS) grew to $2.51, a 36.4% jump year over year, as reported by the company earlier this month. Shareholders are used to the giant home-improvement retailer realizing strong quarterly results, yet shares of Home Depot are now down about 7% year to date, trailing the S&P 500 index by about 10% over the same period.

  • The Possibility of a Presidential Run by Beto O’Rourke Has Democratic Donors in a Holding Pattern
    Politics
    Fortune

    The Possibility of a Presidential Run by Beto O’Rourke Has Democratic Donors in a Holding Pattern

    Democratic donors are waiting to hand out support for the 2020 presidential election until hearing their options, Politico reports, with many hoping to send Beto O’Rourke to the White House. Mikal Watts, a San Antonio lawyer and major Democratic money bundler, told Politico several donors who heard from other presidential hopefuls have called asking if O’Rourke was running. “They’re not wanting to sign on to other presidential campaigns until they know whether Beto is going,” Watts told Politico.

  • What Do Analysts Think About The Southern Company’s (NYSE:SO) Future?
    Finance
    Simply Wall St.

    What Do Analysts Think About The Southern Company’s (NYSE:SO) Future?

    As The Southern Company (NYSE:SO) announced its earnings release on 30 September 2018, analysts seem fairly confident, with earnings expected to grow by 25% in the upcoming year relative to the past 5-year average growth rate of -3.8%. In this article, I’ve outline a few earnings growth rates to give you a sense of the market sentiment for Southern in the longer term. The 15 analysts covering SO view its longer term outlook with a positive sentiment.

  • Democrat Stacey Abrams is a sore loser: Deneen Borelli
    Politics
    Fox Business Videos

    Democrat Stacey Abrams is a sore loser: Deneen Borelli

    Liberal radio host Ethan Bearman and Conservative Review correspondent Deneen Borelli on how Democratic gubernatorial candidate Stacey Abrams claimed that the Georgia gubernatorial election wasn’t fair.

  • XOM, CVX, Shell, and BP’s Valuations after Their Earnings
    Finance
    Market Realist

    XOM, CVX, Shell, and BP’s Valuations after Their Earnings

    XOM, CVX, RDS, and BP Stocks Fell in Q4, Oil Prices Fell 25% (Continued from Prior Part) Integrated energy stocks’ valuation Previously, we reviewed the changes in integrated energy stocks’ short interest. In this part, we’ll compare ExxonMobil (XOM)

  • 10 Beaten Tech Stocks to Consider
    Finance
    InvestorPlace

    10 Beaten Tech Stocks to Consider

    No need to mince words — the past few weeks have been rough ones for tech stocks. The S&P 500 Technology Sector Index has fallen more than 14% since early October, reaching a new multimonth low on Friday. The third quarter was a record-breaking one for the technology sector’s stocks.

  • What's Driving Shares of Sonos 12% Lower Today?
    Business
    Motley Fool

    What's Driving Shares of Sonos 12% Lower Today?

    Shares of Sonos (NASDAQ: SONO), a provider of home sound systems -- with products that include speaker sets, mounts, stands, and cables -- were down 12% as of 2:41 p.m. EST following broader market declines and a tech sell-off. Thanks to a solid launch of its Beam smart soundbar, fourth-quarter revenue jumped 27.5% versus the prior year, and Sonos sold 1.12 million products, which was a 47% jump. Going forward, and ignoring day-to-day swings such as today's 12% decline, the company appears positioned to provide investors with sustainable growth in a strong economy.

  • Finance
    InvestorPlace

    Follow Citron and Buy the Dip in Nvidia Stock

    A few weeks ago, everyone on Wall Street was talking about how chipmaker Nvidia (NASDAQ:NVDA) was ready to rally to $400 on AI and data-related tailwinds. Now, one cryptocurrency plagued quarter later, Nvidia stock is trading down at $140 and no one wants to buy it. The widely followed short-seller, who has been a vocal bear on Nvidia stock for the past several years, turned bullish on NVDA after the recent correction.

  • How Low Can Micron Stock Go?
    Business
    Motley Fool

    How Low Can Micron Stock Go?

    Six months ago, investors in Micron Technology (NASDAQ: MU) were on cloud nine. Shares of the memory-chip manufacturer were trading above $60, a sixfold increase from lows carved out in early 2016. Revenue and profits were booming thanks to strong demand

  • NVIDIA’s Moving Average Shows Further Downside Ahead
    Finance
    Market Realist

    NVIDIA’s Moving Average Shows Further Downside Ahead

    NVIDIA (NVDA) stock has been in a downtrend since October. To understand whether NVIDIA stock has bottomed out or if there’s the potential for a further decline, let’s look at its technical indicators. NVIDIA’s current trading price is lower than its 50-day moving average, which is lower than it 200-day moving average, indicating technical weakness. Rival Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) stock reported technical weakness on October 25, a day after its weak fourth-quarter earnings guidance—but its price didn’t breach its 200-day moving average resistance, which helped it recover partially after a week.

  • What Do Analysts Think about Qualcomm?
    Finance
    Market Realist

    What Do Analysts Think about Qualcomm?

    Qualcomm (QCOM) has removed most of the uncertainty surrounding its business. Analysts are divided between a “buy” and a “hold.” For Qualcomm, 12 out of 24 analysts monitoring the stock having a “buy” recommendation, while 11 analysts have a “hold” recommendation. Analysts have a median target price of $70 and a bearish target of $55 for Qualcomm.

  • Is Canopy Growth the Google of Weed?
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Is Canopy Growth the Google of Weed?

    When CEOs compare a company to Google, it's usually viewed as a positive for the company. Of course, such comparisons typically actually reference Alphabet (NASDAQ: GOOG) (NASDAQ: GOOGL), the parent company of Google, which was known as Google prior to 2015. After all, Alphabet is one of the world's largest, most successful, and most innovative companies.

  • Business
    Barrons.com

    George Soros Sold Facebook, Netflix, and Goldman Stock Just Before They Tumbled

    Soros Fund Management, which Soros founded and chairs, exited social-network giant (FB) (FB) completely in the third quarter, while also slashing positions in (NFLX) stock (NFLX) and (GS) stock (GS). High-flying streaming-content giant Netflix has tumbled almost 29% since the end of September. Soros saved a chunk of cash by selling: Barron’s estimates that, had he maintained positions in those stocks, he would have unrealized losses of about $17.7 million so far in the fourth quarter.

  • Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Calls for Election Day to Become a National Holiday, Replacing Columbus Day
    Politics
    Fortune

    Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Calls for Election Day to Become a National Holiday, Replacing Columbus Day

    Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, the politician who soon will become the youngest woman to serve in Congress, proposed replacing Columbus Day with a national voting holiday on Election Day. In short order, David Martosko, U.S. political editor for Britain’s Daily Mail, weighed in to accuse Ocasio-Cortez of “angling for more vacation days.” That tweet struck many as a not-so-subtle reference to the inaccurate yet longstanding stereotype of Hispanics as lazy.