While car brand reputation can be a strong influence on purchase decisions, such perceptions can be misleading. The reality is, every brand offers models that perform across a spectrum, with some are clearly better than others.
As we see in our annual Car Brand Perception survey, how consumers view brands can often be a trailing indicator and not reflect the current reality. To further illustrate this point, we have compiled a list chronicling the best and worst models by brand based on our overall test scores.
The test performance variation differs from brand to brand, with some brands' worst model being still doing rather well, while others span a wide range making any generalities quite misleading. Take Acura, for example. Even its worst model, the ILX, scores a 77 (out of 100) and meets our performance standards, safety, and reliability criteria to be Recommended. Meanwhile, the best Jeep is the Grand Cherokee Laredo V6. It earns 71 points in our tests, six points less than the worst Acura. However, the Jeep Wrangler Unlimited marks the low point in our current ratings, scoring only a 20.
The gap between best and worst can be even broader. Chevrolet, for instance, spans from the Corvette Z06 (92) to the Spark (34).
Check out our Annual Auto Issue special section for quick access to the latest Ratings, articles, and videos
The list below includes all brands for which Consumer Reports has tested at least three different models recently, thereby excluding Fiat, Jaguar, Land Rover, and Smart.
|Audi||A6 3.0 Premium Plus Quattro||A5 Premium Plus (2.0T)*|
|BMW||135i||X5 35i Premium|
|Buick||Regal CXL (turbo)||Verano Leather (2.4)|
|Cadillac||CTS Premium (3.6)||Escalade (base)|
|Chevrolet||Corvette Z06||Spark 1LT|
|Chrysler||300 Limited (V6)||200 Limited (V6)|
|Dodge||Charger SXT Plus (V6)||Avenger SXT (4-cyl.)|
|Ford||Fusion SE Hybrid||Fiesta SE (sedan)|
|GMC||Acadia SLT2||Yukon Hybrid|
|Honda||Accord EX-L(V6)/LX (4-cyl.)||Insight EX|
|Hyundai||Genesis 3.8||Accent GLS (sedan)|
|Infiniti||G37 Journey (sedan)||QX 56|
|Jeep||Grand Cherokee Laredo (V6)||Wrangler Unlimited Sahara|
|Kia||Optima SX (2.0T)||Rio EX|
|Lexus||LS 460L||GX 460|
|Lincoln||Navigator Ultimate||MKS (base, 3.7)|
|Mazda||MX-5 Miata Grand Touring||2 Touring|
|Mini||Cooper (base, hatchback)||Cooper Clubman|
|Mitsubishi||Lancer Evolution GSR||Galant ES (4-cyl.)|
|Nissan||370Z Coupe Touring||Versa SV (sedan)|
|Porsche||Boxster 2.7||Cayenne (base V6)|
|Subaru||Impreza WRX STi||Tribeca Limited|
|Toyota||Camry Hybrid XLE||FJ Cruiser|
|Volkswagen||Golf TDI (manual)||Beetle 2.5L/Jetta SE (2.5)|
|Volvo||S60 T5||XC90 3.2|
Even if you have models in mind when you're shopping, it is wise to look at their Ratings. You just might be steered to a better car than you would have otherwise considered, and as we often find, the smart choices often are not necessarily the most expensive.
For detailed ratings and road test on any model featured here, just click on the name to visit the appropriate model page.
Consumer Reports has no relationship with any advertisers or sponsors on this website. Copyright © 2007-2013 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc. No reproduction, in whole or in part, without written permission.