U.S. Markets closed

Consumer Reports yanks recommendation for Tesla's Model 3, citing reliability

By Nick Carey
1 / 3

FILE PHOTO: A 2018 Tesla Model 3 electric vehicle is shown in Cardiff, California,

FILE PHOTO: A 2018 Tesla Model 3 electric vehicle is shown in this photo illustration taken in Cardiff, California, U.S., June 1, 2018. REUTERS/Mike Blake/File Photo

By Nick Carey

DETROIT (Reuters) - Consumer Reports on Thursday pulled a recommendation for Tesla Inc's Model 3, citing reliability problems, and the influential U.S. magazine turned up the pressure on other automakers to include crash-avoiding automatic braking as standard equipment.

The magazine's decision to withdraw its endorsement for the Tesla Model 3 less than nine months after recommending the electric sedan highlighted questions about quality that Tesla has faced since the vehicle's difficult launch. Tesla shares fell 3.4 percent to $292.19 in afternoon trading Thursday on the Nasdaq.

Low scores for the Model 3 hurt the brand's overall standing, knocking it down 11 spots to No. 19 out of 33 brands in Consumer Reports' 2019 annual rankings.

Millions of prospective auto buyers consult the magazine’s rankings, which are based on road testing, reliability, safety and owner satisfaction scores.

Despite reliability problems, Model 3 owners said they love their vehicles, said Jake Fisher, the magazine's senior director of automotive testing.

"We have already made significant improvements to correct any issues that Model 3 customers may have experienced that are referenced in this (Consumer Reports) report," a Tesla representative said in an email, "and our return policy allows any customer who is unhappy with their car to return it for a full refund."

Earlier this month, Tesla Chief Executive Elon Musk said during a call with investors that the company is focusing on improving customer service and quality.

Consumer Reports' refusal to endorse cars that lack technology that automatically applies brakes disqualified a wide swath of popular brands and models, including General Motors Co's Chevrolet.

"We've been pushing for this feature for a long time because it's very good at preventing crashes," Fisher said in a phone interview. "We have telegraphed for some time that this was coming."

A growing number of new vehicle models now include automatic emergency braking, often called AEB, as standard, including Subaru Corp's Ascent, Consumer Reports' 2019 top pick for the midsize SUV category.

Subaru was ranked as Consumer Reports' top car brand, followed by Hyundai Motor Co's luxury Genesis then Volkswagen AG units Porsche and Audi in third and fourth place, respectively. Toyota's luxury Lexus brand ranked fifth.

GM, which constantly stresses it is aiming for "zero crashes, zero emissions and zero congestion," did not respond to a request for comment.

This year's top picks included several wins for Toyota Motor Corp, including for its full-size Avalon hybrid electric sedan and the Toyota Prius hybrid. Subaru won for its compact Forester SUV and its midsize Ascent SUV.

GM's Chevrolet brand was ranked 23rd, while the Cadillac brand ranked 26th and GMC 27th.

Ford Motor Co's Ford brand ranked 20th and its Lincoln brand 8th, but its best-selling F-150 pickup truck was named best pickup.

Fiat Chrysler Automobiles NV's Chrysler brand ranked 22nd, with its Dodge brand 25th and Jeep brand in 29th place.

The automaker’s Fiat unit finished last among 33 brands rated.


(Reporting by Nick Carey; editing by Bernadette Baum and Jonathan Oatis)