U.S. markets closed
  • S&P 500

    4,266.49
    +24.65 (+0.58%)
     
  • Dow 30

    34,196.82
    +322.58 (+0.95%)
     
  • Nasdaq

    14,369.71
    +97.98 (+0.69%)
     
  • Russell 2000

    2,333.62
    +30.15 (+1.31%)
     
  • Crude Oil

    73.28
    -0.02 (-0.03%)
     
  • Gold

    1,776.30
    -0.40 (-0.02%)
     
  • Silver

    26.02
    -0.02 (-0.10%)
     
  • EUR/USD

    1.1936
    +0.0003 (+0.02%)
     
  • 10-Yr Bond

    1.4870
    0.0000 (0.00%)
     
  • GBP/USD

    1.3923
    -0.0041 (-0.29%)
     
  • USD/JPY

    110.8500
    -0.1120 (-0.10%)
     
  • BTC-USD

    34,708.57
    +1,225.38 (+3.66%)
     
  • CMC Crypto 200

    837.58
    +50.96 (+6.48%)
     
  • FTSE 100

    7,109.97
    +35.91 (+0.51%)
     
  • Nikkei 225

    28,875.23
    +0.34 (+0.00%)
     

Democrat Joe Manchin Says He’s Against a $15 Minimum Wage — Is It Good or Bad for American Workers?

·19 min read
Jim Watson/AP/Shutterstock / Jim Watson/AP/Shutterstock
Jim Watson/AP/Shutterstock / Jim Watson/AP/Shutterstock

The federal minimum wage — $7.25 per hour — hasn’t changed since 2009, even though the cost of living has risen rapidly. Labor activists long have been asking for a raise in the minimum wage but due to the partisan split between the House and Senate, it seems unlikely there will be a change in the foreseeable future — though President Joe Biden has promised to raise the federal minimum wage to $15.

See: 10 US Cities With Plenty of Jobs and Cheap Housing

Some individual states, cities, counties and companies already have implemented a $15 minimum wage or approved plans that eventually will make the minimum wage $15. But Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) is against a $15 federal minimum wage, which means it could be left out of the third pandemic relief bill.

Read: You Might Actually Be Able To Afford a Mansion in These 20 States

Here’s what a $15 minimum wage would mean for workers, employers, consumers and the economy, and how this higher minimum wage has impacted the places that already have it.

Last updated: March 3, 2021

Cheerful employees at supermarket doing checkout for customers  **DESIGN ON SCREEN WAS MADE FROM SCRATCH BY US**.
Cheerful employees at supermarket doing checkout for customers **DESIGN ON SCREEN WAS MADE FROM SCRATCH BY US**.

Federal vs. State Minimum Wage

The federal minimum wage is the base minimum wage any individual state can mandate. States can pass their own laws to implement a minimum wage that is greater than the federal minimum wage. Currently, 29 states plus Washington, D.C., Guam and the U.S. Virgin Islands have a minimum wage that exceeds the federal minimum wage.

Explore: Florida Votes To Raise Minimum Wage to $15

Woman hanging an open sign.
Woman hanging an open sign.

Why Raise the Minimum Wage?

A person working full time and earning the federal minimum wage of $7.25 an hour would make roughly $15,000 a year. That would put a family of two or more with no additional income below the federal poverty level of $16,910.

Related: The Cost of Living Is Quickly Rising in These 20 US Cities

mature man Working at a timber/lumber warehouse.
mature man Working at a timber/lumber warehouse.

Over 1 Million Americans Would Rise Above Poverty Level If the Federal Minimum Wage Increased

If the U.S. minimum wage were raised to $15 by 2025, the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office estimated that 17 million workers would see a boost in their wages, according to a CNBC report. In addition, another 10 million Americans who now earn slightly more than $15 an hour might also see a wage increase, according to the report.

The increase in pay for these workers would move 1.3 million Americans above the poverty level, the CBO projected.

Find: $15 Minimum Wage Would Reduce Poverty, but at What Cost?

A mature warehouse manager discusses issues with a younger male warehouse worker.
A mature warehouse manager discusses issues with a younger male warehouse worker.

The Potential Downsides of an Increased Minimum Wage

A higher minimum wage could have negative repercussions for both workers and employers, according to the CBO analysis. The CBO estimated that 1.3 million Americans could lose their jobs if a wage hike were enacted, although some economists believe the actual number would be much lower.

The CBO also said that an increase in the minimum wage would “reduce business income and raise prices” as companies pass on the higher costs of labor to consumers. In addition, it could slightly reduce the U.S.’s total output.

Good To Know: 10 Sneaky Ways Your Employer Could Be Committing Wage Theft

Father teaching son to work on a truck.
Father teaching son to work on a truck.

Some Research Disputes the CBO Findings

Although the CBO predicts that raising the minimum wage would have negative effects on employment, some research contradicts these findings. A 2019 study by UC Berkeley’s Center on Wage and Employment Dynamics looked at sub-state wage variations that would echo what would happen if the minimum wage moved closer to the median wage across the U.S.

According to a press release, the study “did not detect adverse effects on employment, weeks worked or weekly hours among workers with a high school degree or less.”

“The results of our research show that we can raise pay to $15, even in low-cost states,” said Anna Godoey, one of the study authors, in the press release. “The data show that the minimum wage has positive effects, especially in areas where the highest proportion of workers received minimum wage increases. We also found reduced household and child poverty in such counties.”

Read: Notoriously Underpaid Jobs

Surfers couple running together with surfboards on the beach at sunset - Sporty friends having fun going to surf - Travel, vacation, sport lifestyle concept.
Surfers couple running together with surfboards on the beach at sunset - Sporty friends having fun going to surf - Travel, vacation, sport lifestyle concept.

States That Have Passed a $15 Minimum Wage

It remains to be seen if or when a federal minimum wage of $15 will pass, but several states have passed their own legislation in recent years to raise the minimum wage for employees, with seven states passing legislation to raise the minimum wage to $15 over the next few years:

  • California minimum wage: The state minimum wage will be $15 by January 2022.

  • Connecticut minimum wage: The state minimum wage will be $15 by June 2023.

  • Illinois minimum wage: The state minimum wage will be $15 by January 2025.

  • Maryland minimum wage: The state minimum wage will be $15 by January 2025.

  • Massachusetts minimum wage: The state minimum wage will be $15 by January 2023.

  • New Jersey minimum wage: The state minimum wage will be $15 by January 2024.

  • New York minimum wage: The state minimum wage will be adjusted annually to account for inflation beginning in 2021 until it reaches $15.

In addition, Washington, D.C. raised the minimum wage to $15 in July 2020.

See: (Almost) Half of All American States To Get a Minimum Wage Hike in 2021

Seattle, Washington, USA - July 6, 2018: Pike Place Market or Public Market Center in summer season, Seattle, Washington, USA.
Seattle, Washington, USA - July 6, 2018: Pike Place Market or Public Market Center in summer season, Seattle, Washington, USA.

Cities With a $15 Minimum Wage

Federal and statewide changes to the minimum wage will take longer to roll out, but some cities already have enacted a $15 minimum wage. The cities with a $15 minimum wage for some or all employees include:

  • New York City: A $15 minimum wage went into effect in 2018.

  • Seattle: As of 2020, the minimum wage for large employers (those with more than 500 employees) is $16.39; it is $15.75 for smaller employers that do not provide health insurance or tips and $13.50 for those that do.

  • San Francisco: A $15 minimum wage went into effect in July 2018; the minimum wage rose to $16.07 in July 2020.

  • Los Angeles: As of July 2020, the minimum wage is $15 for large businesses (those with 26 or more employees) and $14.25 for small businesses; it will rise to $15 for small businesses in July 2021.

  • Petaluma, California: As of January 2020, the minimum wage is $15 for large businesses (those with 26 or more employees) and $14 for small businesses.

  • Berkeley, California: The minimum wage surpassed $15 in 2019; as of July 2020, the minimum wage is $16.07.

  • Emeryville, California: The minimum wage for all employers rose to $15 or more in July 2018. The minimum wage is $16.84 as of July 2020.

  • Milpitas, California: As of July 2020, the minimum wage is $15.40.

  • Fremont, California: As of July 2020, the minimum wage is $15 for large businesses (those with 26 or more employees) and $13.50 for small businesses.

  • Malibu, California: As of July 2020, the minimum wage is $15.

  • Novato, California: As of July 2020, the minimum wage is $15 for “very large” businesses with 100 or more employees. It is $14 for large businesses (26 to 99 employees) and $13 for small businesses (25 employees or less).

  • Pasadena, California: As of July 2020, the minimum wage is $15 for large businesses (those with 26 or more employees) and $14.25 for small businesses. It will be $15 for all employees in July 2021.

  • Santa Monica, California: As of July 2020, the minimum wage is $15 for large businesses (those with 26 or more employees) and $14.25 for small businesses. It will be $15 for all employees in July 2021.

  • Santa Rosa, California: As of July 2020, the minimum wage is $15 for large businesses (those with 26 or more employees) and $14 for small businesses. It will be $15 for all employees in January 2021.

Explore: Here’s What the US Minimum Wage Was the Year You Were Born

Amazon Prime delivery truck
Amazon Prime delivery truck

Major Companies With a Minimum Wage of $15 or Higher

Several major companies also have raised — or made plans to raise — their minimum wage to $15 an hour or more:

  • Target: Raised its minimum wage to $15 in July 2020, ABC reported.

  • Bank of America: Announced in April 2019 that its minimum wage would rise to $17 in May 2019 and that it would continue to raise the minimum wage until it reached $20 in 2021.

  • JPMorgan Chase: Announced in January 2018 that its minimum wage would rise to at least $15 an hour and up to $18 an hour, depending on employee location, effective in February 2018.

  • Facebook: Raised its minimum wage for contractors to $15 an hour in 2015; raised the minimum wage for contractors again in May 2019 to $20 per hour in the San Francisco Bay Area, New York City and Washington, D.C., and $18 per hour in Seattle.

  • Amazon: Announced in October 2018 that it would increase its minimum wage to $15 an hour, effective November 2018.

  • Costco: Announced during its quarterly earnings call in March 2019 that it had raised the minimum wage to $15 an hour for its U.S. employees, Business Insider reported.

  • Charter Communications: Currently has a minimum wage of $15 an hour, and announced plans in April 2020 to raise the minimum wage to $20 in 2022.

  • Ben & Jerry’s: Raised its minimum wage to $16.92 in 2015; as of 2020, it is $18.13.

  • Disney: Under a 2018 settlement, Walt Disney World agreed to raise the minimum wage to $15 in October 2021, The New York Times reported.

  • Wells Fargo: In March 2020, Wells Fargo announced that it would be raising its minimum wage to $15 to $20, depending on location, by the end of 2020.

  • Google: Announced a $15 minimum wage for temporary workers in April 2019, The Verge reported.

  • Aetna: Raised its minimum wage to $16 in 2015, CNN reported.

  • Santander Bank: Raised its minimum wage to $15 in 2018.

  • Cigna: Raised its minimum wage to $16 in 2018.

Good To Know: These 30 Companies Are Giving Bonuses and Raises to Their Essential Workers

Couple sitting opposite each other in small restaurant, waiter standing and socialising, relaxed and friendly, customer service.
Couple sitting opposite each other in small restaurant, waiter standing and socialising, relaxed and friendly, customer service.

How Minimum Wage Increases Have Affected Major Cities

Most of the places that currently have a $15 minimum wage haven’t had it implemented for long enough to see the true effects of the increase, but a 2018 study by UC Berkeley’s Center on Wage and Employment Dynamics examined what happened in six major cities that increased their minimum wage to more than $10 by the end of 2016: Chicago, Oakland, San Francisco, San Jose, Seattle and Washington, D.C. The study focused specifically on the food services industry, which is a major employer of low-wage earners.

The study concluded that the cities had stronger private sector growth than the average comparable county. It also found that raising the minimum wage by 10% increased earnings among food services workers by 1.3% to 2.5%. And, significantly, the study found that the increase in the minimum wage in these cities did not lead to job loss.

“We cannot detect significant negative employment effects,” the study concluded.

Compare: This Is the Living Wage You Need in All 50 States

people in New York walking home from work
people in New York walking home from work

New York City's Minimum Wage Increase

In 2016, New York passed a law that would raise the minimum wage in New York City to $15 per hour by the end of 2018. The bill mandated that large employers (of 11 or more workers) raise the minimum wage to $11 and small employers (of 10 or fewer) raise the minimum wage to $10.50 by Dec. 31, 2016. The minimum wage rose to $13 for large employers and $12 for small employers on Dec. 31, 2017; $15 for large employers and $13.50 for small employers on Dec. 31, 2018; and $15 for all NYC employers by Dec. 31, 2019.

See: 30 Places in America That Are Getting Poorer

restaurant rooftop bar
restaurant rooftop bar

1. What Happened: Restaurants Reportedly Reduced Employee Hours, Eliminated Jobs

In response to New York City’s December 2018 minimum wage increase, some restaurant owners said they had to cut employee hours and raise prices, CBS News reported. Jon Bloostein, who operates six New York City restaurants that employ between 50 and 110 people each, said he no longer uses hosts and hostesses during less busy times and began staggering employee start times. He also increased menu prices.

“As a result (of the minimum wage hike), it will cost more to dine out,” he told CBS News. “It’s not great for labor, it’s not great for the people who invest in or own restaurants, and it’s not great for the public.”

Bloostein’s views aren’t unfounded. A 2019 survey conducted by the NYC Hospitality Alliance found that in response to rising labor costs, 76.5% of full-service restaurant owners reduced employee hours and 36.3% eliminated jobs.

Explore: Notoriously Underpaid Jobs

Professional female barista with dark skin standing at bar on working place and preparing tasty beverage on order.
Professional female barista with dark skin standing at bar on working place and preparing tasty beverage on order.

2. What Happened: Restaurant Workers Saw Major Wage Increases

Despite the NYC Hospitality Alliance report, The New School’s Center for New York City Affairs said it did not see massive job loss in the restaurant industry, which has the highest proportion of workers affected by the minimum wage of any major industry.

The New York State minimum wage rose in phases from $7.25 an hour at the end of 2013 to $13.50 during 2018. During this period, New York City has seen a strong economic expansion of the restaurant industry, outpacing national growth in employment, annual wages and the number of both limited- and full-service restaurant establishments,” the report stated. “Compared to 12 large cities around the country that did not have any minimum wage increases from 2013-18, New York City’s restaurants generally have seen stronger job growth.”

It also concluded that there were no negative employment effects and “sizable” average wage gains for restaurant employees, “with 2013-18 real wage increases averaging 15-23% for full-service and 26-30% for limited-service restaurant workers.”

Find Out: 10 Sneaky Ways Your Employer Could Be Committing Wage Theft

New York job seekers
New York job seekers

3. What Happened: The Unemployment Rate Rose

The unemployment rate in New York City was 4.0% in December 2018 and increased to 4.1% in January 2019, 4.2% in February 2019 and 4.3% in March 2019.

It’s unclear whether this is a direct effect of the wage increase, or whether there are confounding factors.

Important: The Salary You Need To Afford Rent in Every State

Seattle, USA - October 5, 2013: A family and a man jogging with his dog just before sunset in Myrtle Edwards Park with a view of Mount Rainier.
Seattle, USA - October 5, 2013: A family and a man jogging with his dog just before sunset in Myrtle Edwards Park with a view of Mount Rainier.

Seattle's Minimum Wage Increase

Seattle was the first major city to pass a bill that would increase the minimum wage to $15 an hour. The bill, which went into effect in 2015, made the minimum wage for employers who don’t offer medical benefits to their employees $11 as of April 2015; $12 for small employers (500 employees or fewer) and $13 for large employers as of 2016; $13 for small employers and $15 for large employers as of 2017; $14 for small employers and $15.45 for large employers as of 2018; and $15 for small employers and $16 for large employers as of 2019.

Find: How Much You Need To Live Comfortably in 50 Major US Cities

shaker.
shaker.

1. What Happened: The Number of Jobs in Restaurants and Bars Increased

Although some business owners, particularly in the food industry, threatened to leave Seattle amid growing wage requirements, it doesn’t seem that many have followed through. According to data from the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis and the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the number of jobs in restaurants and bars had been on the upswing since Seattle’s minimum wage laws went into effect in 2015 (though the coronavirus pandemic has obviously changed this trajectory in 2020).

University of Washington research published in 2018 found that “fewer than one in four employers reported reducing their workforces through cuts in hours or headcount” as a result of the wage hikes.

Learn: Here’s What the US Minimum Wage Was the Year You Were Born

Mid adult couple talking to female receptionist.
Mid adult couple talking to female receptionist.

2. What Happened: Employers Raised Wages — and Prices

The University of Washington researchers found that “many firms (almost half) raised wages of employees above the newly set minimum wage rates.” However, it also found that to compensate, “about half of all employers reported raising prices to offset increased labor costs.” These price increases were “more likely to occur in the food and accommodation sector than other types of industry sectors,” the study found.

Compare: From Alabama to Wyoming: The Cost of Living Across America

Group of coworkers going down the stairs and talking.
Group of coworkers going down the stairs and talking.

3. What Happened: Low-Wage Workers With Above-Median Experience Saw an Increase in Earnings

A National Bureau of Economic Research working paper published in 2018 found that “on net, the minimum wage increase from $9.47 to as much as $13 per hour raised earnings by an average of $8-$12 per week. The entirety of these gains accrued to workers with above-median experience at baseline; less-experienced workers saw no significant change to weekly pay.”

The pay bump for more skilled workers can be attributed to the fact that these are the employees that businesses want to retain if they have to make job cuts due to higher wages.

“Business owners are willing to pay higher wages, but one of the things they’re looking for is workers who can be productive from their first day on the job,” Jacob Vigdor, one of the study’s lead researchers, told the Seattle Times.

Check Out: What You Can Rent on a Minimum Wage Salary in Every State

Man bicycling on Twin Peaks in San Francisco with downtown in background.
Man bicycling on Twin Peaks in San Francisco with downtown in background.

San Francisco's Minimum Wage Increase

San Francisco passed a proposition in November 2014 that would continue to raise the minimum wage every year. Under this proposition, the minimum wage was raised to $12.25 in May 2015, to $13 in July 2016, to $14 in July 2017 and to $15 in July 2018. The minimum wage was raised to $16.07 in July 2020 based on the annual increase in the Consumer Price Index from the previous year.

See: The Cost of Living Is Quickly Rising in These 20 US Cities

Midsection of barista hanging closed sign on window.
Midsection of barista hanging closed sign on window.

1. What Happened: Low-Rated Restaurants Were More Likely To Flee the City

A Harvard Business School research paper found that restaurants with low- and mid-level Yelp ratings were more likely to be affected by a change in the minimum wage.

“We find that the impact of the minimum wage depends on whether a restaurant was already close to the margin of exit,” the study stated. “Restaurants with lower ratings are closer to the margin of exit at all observed minimum-wage levels and are disproportionately driven out of business by increases to the minimum wage. Our point estimates suggest that a $1 increase in the minimum wage leads to a 14% increase in the likelihood of exit for a 3.5-star restaurant (which is the median rating on Yelp) but has no discernible impact for a 5-star restaurant (on a 1 to 5-star scale).”

The study also found that “lower-rated restaurants also increase prices in response to minimum-wage increases.”

Notable: 10 US Cities With Plenty of Jobs and Cheap Housing

San Jose courthouse
San Jose courthouse

2. What Happened: Nearly One-Third of San Jose's Workforce Would See an Increase in Earnings

Because San Francisco’s minimum wage increase to $15 happened so recently, there is not much data available on the actual changes that have taken place as a result. However, a 2016 policy brief by UC Berkeley’s Center on Wage and Employment Dynamics examined what the effects of a $15 minimum wage in nearby San Jose by 2019 were projected to be. (Minimum wage increases applied to the San Francisco-Oakland-San Jose, California, metropolitan area.) The paper determined that an increase in the minimum wage would lead to an increase in earnings for 115,000 workers in San Jose — 31.1% of the city’s workforce. For those who would get a raise under the increase, their pay would go up by 17.8%.

Explore: These Cities Have the Most People Moving In During the Pandemic

Young woman shopping in clothing store, checking price tag.
Young woman shopping in clothing store, checking price tag.

3. What Happened: Average Consumer Prices Would Rise 0.3%

The policy brief projected that businesses would make up for the increase in payroll costs by increasing consumer prices by 0.3% by 2019. However, the paper noted that the increase in restaurant prices would be greater — an estimated 3.1%.

Compare: This Is the Living Wage You Need in All 50 States

An architect is working in the office.
An architect is working in the office.

4. What Happened: Employment Growth Would Slow

The UC Berkeley Center on Wage and Employment Dynamics policy brief projected that employment growth would slow as the minimum wage grew. The paper estimated that there would be 960 fewer jobs in San Jose by the end of 2019. This prediction didn’t come to pass, however. According to BLS data, the number of employees in San Jose increased from January to December 2019.

See: 5 Things To Negotiate at Your Job Other Than Salary

Barman pouring alcohol pouring cocktail for attractive girl.
Barman pouring alcohol pouring cocktail for attractive girl.

Should the US Raise the Federal Minimum Wage to $15 an Hour?

The cities that have a $15 minimum wage — and the companies affected by it — haven’t had this minimum wage for long, so it’s hard to say definitively what the effects of raising the minimum wage across the country would be. Here’s a summary of what’s happened so far:

  • Although a survey of New York City restaurant owners found that the majority said they would be reducing restaurant worker hours and that nearly one-third would be eliminating jobs, a study of the effect of NYC wage increases from 2013 to 2018 on the restaurant businesses and its employees found that there were no negative employment effects and sizable average wage gains for restaurant employees.

  • NYC unemployment rose 0.3% from the time the latest wage increase went into effect (Dec. 31, 2018) through July 2019, although this could be attributable to other factors.

  • Fewer than a quarter of Seattle business owners reduced their employee hours or cut jobs because of the rise in minimum wage requirements, and the number of restaurant and bar jobs actually grew since the new laws went into effect in 2015.

  • Experienced low-wage workers in Seattle saw increases in their weekly pay; low-skilled, low-wage workers saw little to no difference in their pay.

  • NYC and Seattle businesses that employ low-wage workers — who fall heavily into the food and accommodations sectors — increased prices for consumers as a result of the higher cost of labor.

  • Low- and medium-rated San Francisco restaurants were more likely to exit as minimum wage requirements increased; minimum wage increases did not affect highly rated restaurants.

Based on these findings, it’s clear that there are pros and cons to raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour. Only the passage of time will let us see how a higher minimum wage will affect workers, employers and consumers over time.

More From GOBankingRates

This article originally appeared on GOBankingRates.com: Democrat Joe Manchin Says He’s Against a $15 Minimum Wage — Is It Good or Bad for American Workers?