Tracking inflows to and outflows from exchange traded funds, for those truly passionate about ETFs, can be interesting and there is no doubt that flows data make for some compelling articles about ETFs.
However, and this cannot be understated in the case of equity-based ETFs, flows data are not predictors of future performance. It cannot be described more accurately than by Josh Brown on the Reformed Broker with this article title “Flows Don’t Follow Value, They Follow Performance.” Emphasis (our own) on “follow.”
Here is the skinny on MOO. The ETF was once home to over $5 billion in assets and the largest equity ETF in the Market Vectors stable. Investors have pulled almost $1.3 billion from MOO this year, making it one of the 10 worst ETFs in terms of 2014 outflows. MOO is now home to $3.3 billion in assets under management, not even half the amount held by the Market Vectors Gold Miners ETF (GDX) .
Outflows from MOO are understandable. To a certain extent. Over the past three years while the Materials Select Sector SPDR (XLB) is up nearly 29% and the S&P 500 is higher by more than 51%, MOO is up 2.2%. Investors frustrated with MOO’s laggard ways could be the cause of the 2014 redemptions. [Potash Recovery Could Lift Agribusiness ETF]
Those departing MOO in recent weeks may have done so at the wrong time. The ETF is up 3% in the past month, but even as MOO has traded modestly higher over the past week, investors have pulled $224.4 million from the fund. That despite the fact that MOO is closing in on $55, a price It has not closed above in 11 months.
Departures from MOO belie positive price action is some of the ETF’s marquee holdings. Over the past month, Monsanto (MON) is up more than 5%. Deere (DE) is higher by nearly 6% while Potash (POT) has gained 3.1%. Those stocks combine for almost 22% of MOO’s weight.
But judging by the flows, investors might think MOO is destined to fall while price action in some of the ETF’s largest holdings are telling a different story. And that is the story really worth paying attention to.
Market Vectors Agribusiness ETF