U.S. Markets closed

How to evaluate target-date mutual funds

Constance Gustke

Target-date mutual funds sound like no-brainer investments.

They have set target dates, usually matched to an investor's target retirement year. As the target date nears, say 2020, investment allocations are slowly switched from equities to bonds and cash for capital preservation.

In reality, the 40 target-date mutual fund families vary widely, having different fees, structures and even holdings. Here's how to evaluate them.

"Not all funds work the same, despite having similar target dates," says Eric Schaefer, chief of investment products at money-management firm American Independence Financial Services in New York. "That's one gotcha that trips people up."

'To' versus 'through' funds

The way target-date funds are structured can be confusing to investors. Some have a glide path "to" the fund's target date. Others have a glide path "through" the fund's target date.

"To" funds pare down equity holdings as the retirement date nears, shifting into more cash and bonds. When the target date is reached, some funds are converted to retirement-income funds or an annuity, while others keep assets in the same fund, according to Morningstar.

"Through" target-date funds, which are more prevalent, manage asset allocation past the target date and through the investor's retirement. They usually hold many more equities than target-date funds that run to the retirement date, according to Morningstar.

The target date is a person's projected date of retirement, but "through" funds assume that investors will stay invested after the target date is reached.

"'Through' funds assume that you'll invest until you die," says Roger Wohlner, a Certified Financial Planner professional with Asset Strategy Consultants in Arlington Heights, Ill.

For example, T. Rowe Price's target-date funds have "through" investing dates. "These funds are designed for people with retirement goals," says Jerome Clark, portfolio manager of the T. Rowe Price Retirement Funds. So, the equity allocation is about 55 percent near the target date, according to T. Rowe Price.

Nearly all target-fund assets are stashed in retirement funds such as 401(k)s. The reason: They're a cheap way to broadly diversify a portfolio, Schaefer says. But that doesn't mean that target-date funds can't be harnessed to meet set individual investment goals, such as saving money for a child's college or for making large purchases, he says.

Target-date fund factors

Even so, target-date funds are not one-size-fits-all investments. Here's why.

You may not really understand the workings of a particular target-date fund. According to a survey by the Securities and Exchange Commission released earlier this year, many investors don't fully understand how target-date funds operate.

And fund prospectuses don't always help. Target-date funds' disclosure "still falls short in several key areas," according to the Morningstar report.

That's why Schaefer recommends spending two hours checking out a target-date fund before deciding to invest. "Look at the fund's philosophy and risks, and then match them against your own," he says.

Equity allocations vary widely among funds. For shorter-duration funds, investment allocations vary widely, according to Morningstar. Though funds with 2015 target dates held 52 percent of their holdings in equities on average, one 2015 fund's equity allocation was 20 percent while another's was 78 percent, according to the report.

"Two or three target-date funds could have vastly different profiles," Wohlner says. "So look at their overall percent of asset allocations."

Big fund companies issue most funds. The top three fund companies -- Vanguard, Fidelity Investments and T. Rowe Price -- command 75 percent of target-date assets, according to Morningstar. "So there are some good funds that may not be getting as much exposure," says Josh Charlson, senior mutual fund analyst for Morningstar.

Also, these big funds usually offer a fund of funds, where various existing mutual fund offerings are bundled together into one target year. These may be existing funds that already have been sold to the firm's regular mutual fund customers. "So target-fund quality depends on the quality of the underlying funds," Wohlner says.

Lately, though, investors can opt for more index-based funds. Eleven all-index funds are now being offered by companies such as Vanguard and BlackRock, which are lower-cost funds. Annual expenses for index target-date funds are less than 20 basis points compared to 0.72 percent for average target-date funds, according to financial information firm BrightScope in San Diego.

"Target-date fund expenses are always important because they can make a big difference in your return," Charlson says.

Funds may underperform. Think that target-date funds -- even a fund of funds -- perform well in good and bad markets because they're highly diversified? Think again. The target-date fund category trailed the Standard & Poor's 500 index in 2011, according to Morningstar. For example, the 2016-2020 funds had a negative 0.22 percent loss versus a 2.1 percent gain for the S&P 500 in 2011.

And when the market nose-dived in 2008, some 2010 target-date funds dropped 41 percent that year, losing more ground than the S&P 500.

"If you expect a low risk of losing money in target-date funds, you'll be disappointed," Charlson says.

Your investment may be underfunded. People aren't saving enough money for retirement, Wohlner says. So, they may be underfunding their target-date funds, too. "Look at the fund and determine if your investment is appropriate," he says.

In any case, don't just count on target-date funds as your total retirement investment. "They're not a silver bullet," Charlson says.



More From Bankrate.com

  • Sprint and T-Mobile just dropped a big hint that the merger is coming
    Business
    BGR News

    Sprint and T-Mobile just dropped a big hint that the merger is coming

    Rumors about a Sprint T-Mobile merger have been swirling for months. T-Mobile’s earnings for Q3 2017 were released early this morning, alongside a video blog from CEO John Legere. Neither company wants to publicly address questions about a potential merger, because saying the wrong thing could jeopardize ongoing negotiations or adversely affect the stock price. “We wanted to make sure you all saw and focused on our Q3 results and not just on the rumors and speculation that seem to fill the news every day,” CEO John Legere said in the video.

  • The Internet Is Loving That George W. Bush Made Barack Obama Laugh During Bill Clinton's Speech
    Politics
    Time

    The Internet Is Loving That George W. Bush Made Barack Obama Laugh During Bill Clinton's Speech

    The Internet is all about the moment George W. Bush cracked Barack Obama up during Bill Clinton’s speech at a hurricane relief concert attended by all five living former U.S. presidents. While Clinton spoke at Saturday night’s “Deep From the Heart:

  • Read Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s short story on Instagram about Melania Trump
    Celebrity
    Quartz

    Read Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s short story on Instagram about Melania Trump

    In Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s world, Melania Trump is listless, and a bit racist. In a new short story by the author of the 2013 novel Americanah, Adichie imagines an exchange between “Mrs. T” and her black Pilates instructor, Janelle. The story extends the world she created (paywall) last June, in a story told from the perspective of the first lady. The Nigerian-born writer published “Janelle Asked to the Bedroom” on T Magazine’s site (paywall) and in a series on Instagram Friday. In the story, told from Janelle’s perspective, the pilates instructor meets a despondent Mrs. T in her apartment bedroom. The two have a brief, uncomfortable exchange in which Mrs. T reveals, among other things, that

  • Police May Have Found the Body of a 3-Year-Old Who Disappeared After Being Sent Outside as Punishment
    News
    Time

    Police May Have Found the Body of a 3-Year-Old Who Disappeared After Being Sent Outside as Punishment

    Texas police say they have found the body of a young child during the search for Sherin Mathews, a 3-year-old girl who went missing from a Dallas suburb two weeks ago after being sent out of her home in the middle of the night as punishment. A child’s body was found on Oct. 22 in a culvert beneath a road in the suburb of Richardson, Texas. Sherin, who was adopted by Wesley Mathews and his wife Sini from an orphanage in India, was reported missing on Oct. 7 after her father made her stand outside their home at 3 a.m. as punishment for not drinking her milk, the Washington Post reports.

  • 4 Tax Breaks That Are Slated to Disappear (So Grab Them Now!)
    Business
    Motley Fool

    4 Tax Breaks That Are Slated to Disappear (So Grab Them Now!)

    With Republicans' tax reform plan finally starting to take shape, it's a good idea to look into how your favorite tax breaks could change. While there are likely to be substantial changes to the tax reform plan before it potentially becomes law, it seems clear that many of today's itemized deductions will no longer exist. Unfortunately, it's not on the (very short) list of itemized deductions that the GOP plans to retain in tax reform.

  • Prince Alwaleed Bin Talal: President Trump has his own w...
    Politics
    CNBC Videos

    Prince Alwaleed Bin Talal: President Trump has his own w...

    Prince Alwaleed Bin Talal, Kingdom Holding Company chairman, talks about comments President Trump's comments on Islam, and Saudi Arabia's relationship with the United States.

  • Amazon says it received 238 proposals for 2nd headquarters
    Finance
    Associated Press

    Amazon says it received 238 proposals for 2nd headquarters

    Amazon said Monday that it received 238 proposals from cities and regions in the United States, Canada and Mexico hoping to be the home of the company's second headquarters. Proposals were due last week, and Amazon made clear that tax breaks and grants would be a big deciding factor on where it chooses to land. Amazon.com Inc. did not list which cities or metro areas applied, but said the proposals came from 43 U.S. states, as well as Washington, D.C. and Puerto Rico, three Mexican states and six Canadian provinces.

  • The US oil phenomenon that could help spark the 'tale of two markets'
    Business
    CNBC.com

    The US oil phenomenon that could help spark the 'tale of two markets'

    Get ready for a 'tale of two markets,' says oil expect Tom Kloza    5:57 PM ET Thu, 19 Oct 2017 | 01:31 The United States has started doing something unprecedented when it comes to oil, and the impact is expected to grow into next year. Tom Kloza of the Oil Price Information Service is alluding to the U.S. ramping up exports. It follows the 40-year ban that was lifted two years ago. "The highlight you need to watch for the next few months is going to be more record breaking exports of crude oil. Our view is that it's going to soften the price for Brent," the firm's global head of energy analysis said recently on CNBC's "Futures Now." According to Kloza, it's possible the U.S. will export 15 million

  • Here's How Much the Average 50-Something American Has Saved for Retirement
    Lifestyle
    Motley Fool

    Here's How Much the Average 50-Something American Has Saved for Retirement

    Your 50s are a pivotal time not just in your career, but on the road to retirement. By the time your 50s roll around, you'll have conceivably been working for a good 30 years, which means your earnings will likely have peaked.

  • John McCain Takes a Veiled Swipe at Donald Trump's Medical Exemption From the Vietnam War
    Politics
    Time

    John McCain Takes a Veiled Swipe at Donald Trump's Medical Exemption From the Vietnam War

    Senator John McCain (R-AZ) appeared to take aim at President Donald Trump’s draft deferrals during the Vietnam War this week, following a series of public rebukes of the Trump administration. In an interview about the Vietnam War on C-SPAN3, American History TV, on Oct. 22, McCain criticized “high income” draftees who avoided military service while apparently alluding to the president’s own draft exemption — but he did not mention Trump by name. “One aspect of the [Vietnam] conflict by the way that I will never, ever countenance is that we drafted the lowest income level of America and the highest income level found a doctor that would say that they had a bone spur,” he said, naming the ailment under which Trump received medical deferrals.

  • Technology
    Fortune

    Latest Microsoft Windows 10 Update Makes Some Apps Disappear

    Last week, the company released the latest Windows 10 Creators Update, which includes new security features and support for new augmented reality perks that will work with “mixed reality” headsets and other hardware gear from Dell, , and other hardware partners. The software update was announced October 17, the same day the company previewed its new Surface Book 2 laptop/tablet combo platter. Soon after that, users who had upgraded their operating system on their own machines started posting about missing apps on the Microsoft support page.

  • Prince Alwaleed says bitcoin will implode: 'Enron in the making'
    Business
    CNBC

    Prince Alwaleed says bitcoin will implode: 'Enron in the making'

    Saudi billionaire investor Prince Alwaleed bin Talal said Monday that bitcoin will "implode" one day. The billionaire investor was referring to the massive accounting fraud that took Enron, a U.S. energy-trading and utilities giant, into bankruptcy in late 2001. The company is based in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.

  • Retailer Meijer Pulls Packaged Vegetables in Six U.S. States Amid Listeria Scare
    Health
    Fortune

    Retailer Meijer Pulls Packaged Vegetables in Six U.S. States Amid Listeria Scare

    Retailer Meijer said it was recalling packaged vegetables in six U.S. states because of possible contamination from Listeria monocytogenes bacteria, which can cause fatal food poisoning in young children, pregnant women and elderly or frail people. Meijer, based in Grand Rapids, Michigan, said there were no illnesses reported as of Sunday. The recall affects 35 products and includes vegetables such as broccoli, cauliflower and asparagus as well as party trays sold in Meijer-branded plastic or foam packaging in Michigan, Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Kentucky and Wisconsin between Sept. 27 and Oct. 20, the company said on Saturday.

  • Why Atlanta Is the Early Favorite to Land Amazon’s Second Headquarters
    Business
    Fortune

    Why Atlanta Is the Early Favorite to Land Amazon’s Second Headquarters

    More than 100 cities submitted bids to become Amazon’s second corporate home--a prize that could bring 50,000 new high-paying jobs and a big boost of civic prestige. The bidding ended last week and, though is not expected to announce the winner until 2018, one city has emerged as the early favorite according to popular betting website Paddy Power. As you can see from the screenshot below, Atlanta is the frontrunner at two-to-one odds with Austin and Boston as the initial runners-up.Also notable in the Paddy Power odds is that a Canadian city, Toronto, is currently number four to win the Amazon prize.

  • Halliburton warns of slower growth as U.S. rig count drops
    Finance
    Reuters

    Halliburton warns of slower growth as U.S. rig count drops

    The outlook suggests Halliburton's current-quarter might not be as strong as its latest quarter, echoing warnings on Friday from its two bigger rivals, Schlumberger NV and Baker Hughes . Halliburton's shares fell about 1.5 percent. Schlumberger was down 1.5 percent, while Baker Hughes fell 4 percent.

  • Gretchen Carlson: It’s ‘Horrifying’ Fox News Renewed Bill O’Reilly’s Contract Amid Sexual Harassment Claims
    Finance
    Fortune

    Gretchen Carlson: It’s ‘Horrifying’ Fox News Renewed Bill O’Reilly’s Contract Amid Sexual Harassment Claims

    Gretchen Carlson has come out swinging against her former network after a report that Fox News offered its former anchor Bill O’Reilly a contract renewal despite knowledge of sexual harassment allegations against him. “It’s horrifying to think that any company would dismiss an employee following multiple allegations of sexual harassment and then allow him back on the air a few months later,” Carlson said in a statement Saturday. The New York Times reported Saturday that in January, O’Reilly had reached a $32 million settlement with a network analyst who had alleged sexual harassment claims against the host, which reportedly included claims of a non-consensual sexual relationship.

  • Airbus turmoil overshadows bid to rescue CSeries
    Business
    Reuters

    Airbus turmoil overshadows bid to rescue CSeries

    Airbus's coup in buying a $6 billion Canadian jetliner project for a dollar stunned investors and took the spotlight off a growing ethics row last week, but internal disarray has raised questions over how smoothly it can implement the deal. The European planemaker secured the deal for Bombardier's CSeries programme by pledging to throw its marketing might behind the loss-making jets, just as the Airbus sales machine reels from falling sales and internal and external corruption investigations. Chief Executive Tom Enders has urged staff to keep calm in the face of French reports describing payments to intermediaries and growing concern over fallout from the investigations.

  • Western Digital Corp Is Pulling the Right Strings
    Business
    InvestorPlace

    Western Digital Corp Is Pulling the Right Strings

    It’s been a rough road for old-school hard disk drive (HDD) manufacturers ever since solid state drives (SSDs) emerged as a credible replacement for their clunkier and slower predecessors. If you love a good comeback story, WDC stock, now the leading HDD maker, fits the bill to a tee. When WDC purchased flash memory maker, SanDisk, in a $19 billion deal in 2016, not everybody was sure it was a very smart move.

  • Buy Intel Corporation Now, Before It Gets to $50
    Business
    InvestorPlace

    Buy Intel Corporation Now, Before It Gets to $50

    Intel Corporation (NASDAQ:INTC) is on a hot streak. INTC stock has already hit fresh 16-year highs. The stock appears set for a massive technical breakout, as shares are on the verge of topping the key $40 technical level. With the market as a whole moving

  • Bank of America Is Back on Offense
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Bank of America Is Back on Offense

    After spending years retreating and retrenching in the wake of the financial crisis, it seems clear that Bank of America (NYSE: BAC) is changing gears. On the bank's latest earnings call, Chairman and CEO Brian Moynihan rattled off a list of things the bank is doing to go on offense. Through the first nine months of 2017, Bank of America has spent $2.25 billion in technology-related investments.

  • Boeing, Mitsubishi Heavy in deal to cut costs of 787 wing production
    Business
    Reuters

    Boeing, Mitsubishi Heavy in deal to cut costs of 787 wing production

    Under the new agreement announced in a joint statement on Monday, MHI will pursue increased efficiency in its production system and supply-chain through lean production methods, automation and other activities. MHI said last year Boeing was seeking a new round of lower prices and changes in payment terms as the U.S. manufacturer stepped up efforts to conserve cash. Delays in the 787 development and delivery, due in part to difficulties of managing a global supply chain, prompted Boeing to produce more of the upcoming 777X widebody, including the wings, at home despite MHI's attempts to keep the work in Japan.

  • 'It's Been a Rollercoaster.' Shawn Johnson East Reveals Miscarriage in Emotional Video
    Celebrity
    Time

    'It's Been a Rollercoaster.' Shawn Johnson East Reveals Miscarriage in Emotional Video

    Shawn Johnson East and her husband Andrew East announced in an emotional YouTube video posted on Saturday that Johnson East had a miscarriage just two days after the couple found out they were pregnant. “Today’s video is a little bit sensitive,” Johnson East, 25, said at the beginning of the video. The video — titled “pregnancy + heartbreak” — documented the couple’s whirlwind 48-hours pregnancy experience: from the moment when Johnson East showed herself crying joyful tears after taking two pregnancy tests which came back positive, to the moment the couple learned they had a miscarriage.

  • GE's Got a New CEO
    Business
    The Street

    GE's Got a New CEO

    General Electric Co. (GE) shares posted a swing back into the green Friday, Oct. 20, after tumbling as much as 6% in early trading following disappointing third-quarter results. But if history is any indicator, shares could continue to decline in price under the tenure of a new CEO. Friday's report was the first under new chairman and CEO, John Flannery. He took over for Jeff Immelt, who had been head of the company since 2001. Following Immelt's first quarterly report Oct. 11, 2001, GE stock rose 2.7% on the day earnings were released, according to Bloomberg data. But after that 2.7% increase that day, GE stock tumbled as much as 45% during the next 16 months, according to the data. From his

  • Why This REIT Stock Is a Dividend Investor's Dream
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Why This REIT Stock Is a Dividend Investor's Dream

    If you're a dividend investor, you'd probably consider an ideal dividend stock to be one that pays a higher-than-average yield, with the dividend likely to steadily grow over time, right? One such company worth your investment consideration is Realty Income (NYSE: O), which is organized as a real estate investment trust. REITs tend to have generous dividend yields -- Realty Income's yield is currently 4.6% -- because they're required to pay out at least 90% of their income as dividends in return for preferential tax treatment.