U.S. Markets close in 3 hrs 38 mins

Exclusive: Apple, Google agree to pay over $300 million to settle conspiracy lawsuit

A Google logo is seen at the garage where the company was founded on Google's 15th anniversary in Menlo Park, California September 26, 2013. REUTERS/Stephen Lam

By Dan Levine

SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - Four major tech companies including Apple and Google have agreed to pay a total of $324 million to settle a lawsuit accusing them of conspiring to hold down salaries in Silicon Valley, sources familiar with the deal said, just weeks before a high profile trial had been scheduled to begin.

Tech workers filed a class action lawsuit against Apple Inc, Google Inc, Intel Inc and Adobe Systems Inc in 2011, alleging they conspired to refrain from soliciting one another's employees in order to avert a salary war. They planned to ask for $3 billion in damages at trial, according to court filings. That could have tripled to $9 billion under antitrust law.

The case has been closely watched due to the potentially high damages award and the opportunity to peek into the world of Silicon Valley's elite. The case was based largely on emails in which Apple's late co-founder Steve Jobs, former Google CEO Eric Schmidt and some of their Silicon Valley rivals hatched plans to avoid poaching each other's prized engineers.

In one email exchange after a Google recruiter solicited an Apple employee, Schmidt told Jobs that the recruiter would be fired, court documents show. Jobs then forwarded Schmidt's note to a top Apple human resources executive with a smiley face.

Another exchange shows Google's human resources director asking Schmidt about sharing its no-cold call agreements with competitors. Schmidt, now the company's executive chairman, advised discretion.

"Schmidt responded that he preferred it be shared 'verbally, since I don't want to create a paper trail over which we can be sued later?'" he said, according to a court filing. The HR director agreed.

The companies had acknowledged entering into some no-hire agreements but disputed the allegation that they had conspired to drive down wages. Moreover, they argued that the employees should not be allowed to sue as a group.

Rich Gray, a Silicon Valley antitrust expert in private practice, said the companies had an incentive to avoid trial because their executives' emails would make them look extremely unsympathetic to a jury. However, the plaintiff attorneys risked an appeals court saying the engineers could not sue as a group at all.

"An appellate court could say, 'Hey we just don't buy that,'" Gray said.

Trial had been scheduled to begin at the end of May on behalf of roughly 64,000 workers.

Spokespeople for Apple, Google and Intel declined to comment. An Adobe representative said that the company denies it engaged in any wrongdoing, but settled "in order to avoid the uncertainties, cost and distraction of litigation." An attorney for the plaintiffs, Kelly Dermody of Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein, in a statement called the deal "an excellent resolution."

Corporate defendants in antitrust cases often agree among themselves what portion each will contribute towards a settlement, said Daniel Crane, a professor at the University of Michigan Law School. One likely formula would be to divide the damages based on how many employees each company has in the class, he said.

Apple, Google, Adobe and Intel in 2010 settled a U.S. Department of Justice probe by agreeing not to enter into such no-hire deals in the future. The four companies had since been fighting the civil antitrust class action.

Walt Disney Co's Pixar and Lucasfilm units and Intuit Inc had already agreed to a settlement, with Disney paying about $9 million and Intuit paying $11 million.

Any settlement must be approved by U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh in San Jose, California. A hearing on final approval of the Intuit and Disney deals is scheduled for next week.

The plaintiffs and the companies will disclose principal terms of the settlement by May 27, according to the court filing on Thursday, though it is unclear whether that will spell out what each company will pay.

Some Silicon Valley companies refused to enter into no-hire agreements. Facebook Chief Operating Officer Sheryl Sandberg, for instance, rebuffed an entreaty from Google in 2008 that they refrain from poaching each other's employees.

Additionally, Apple's Jobs threatened Palm with a patent lawsuit if Palm didn't agree to stop soliciting Apple employees. However, then Palm Chief Executive Edward Colligan told Jobs that the plan was "likely illegal," and that Palm was not "intimidated" by the threat.

The case in U.S. District Court, Northern District of California is In Re: High-Tech Employee Antitrust Litigation, 11-cv-2509.

(Reporting by Dan Levine, editing by Peter Henderson)

  • News

    Dow tumbles 425 points to start Thanksgiving week; Boeing, Apple deliver biggest intraday blows

    MARKET PULSE The Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) was sinking midday Monday, pressured by a decline in Boeing Co.'s stock (BA) and Apple Inc. to start the holiday-shortened week. Boeing shares were exacting a roughly 100-point toll

  • Business

    This is what Google learned after interviewing one job candidate 16 times, according to Eric Schmidt

    Eric Schmidt joined Google as CEO in 2001 and led the tech company for the next decade as the company grew from a start-up to a corporate behemoth, whose parent company, Alphabet, now has a market cap of over $740 billion . "They were super smart, somewhat disorganized kinds of people," Schmidt told Tyler Cowen on the " Conversations with Tyler " podcast. "The recruiting started off as informal, but it ultimately became very, very structured," Schmidt said.

  • Are Investors Undervaluing Target (TGT) Right Now?

    Are Investors Undervaluing Target (TGT) Right Now?

    Here at Zacks, we focus on our proven ranking system, which places an emphasis on earnings estimates and estimate revisions, to find winning stocks. Considering these trends, value investing is clearly one of the most preferred ways to find strong stocks in any type of market. Value investors rely on traditional forms of analysis on key valuation metrics to find stocks that they believe are undervalued, leaving room for profits.

  • Plug Power files to sell 21.2 million shares
    American City Business Journals

    Plug Power files to sell 21.2 million shares

    Plug Power, the Latham, New York fuel cell manufacturer, plans to sell up to 21.2 million shares of common stock owned by two major shareholders. The selling stockholders are Tech Opportunities LLC, which holds 12.93 million shares for about 5.5 percent of the company, and CVI Investments, which has 7.6 million shares for 3 percent of the company. If all 21.2 million shares are sold, CVI would hold no stock and Tech Opportunities would hold about 2.1 percent.

  • Canadian Solar (CSIQ) in Focus: Stock Moves 5.1% Higher

    Canadian Solar (CSIQ) in Focus: Stock Moves 5.1% Higher

    Canadian Solar Inc. CSIQ was a big mover last session, as the company saw its shares rise more than 5% on the day. The move came on solid volume too with far more shares changing hands than in a normal session. This breaks the recent trend of the company

  • Facebook faces growth trouble
    CNBC Videos

    Facebook faces growth trouble

    CNBC’s Julia Boorstin reports on the trouble at Facebook and new reports about CEO Mark Zuckerberg’s management style.

  • 3 Things Chesapeake Energy Corporation's CEO Wants You to Know About Its Surprising Addition
    Motley Fool

    3 Things Chesapeake Energy Corporation's CEO Wants You to Know About Its Surprising Addition

    Chesapeake Energy (NYSE: CHK) recently stunned investors by agreeing to acquire WildHorse Resource Development (NYSE: WRD) for nearly $4 billion in cash and stock. Lawler stated on the call that "the WildHorse acquisition strengthens and accelerates the delivery of our near-term strategic priorities of margin improvement, sustainable free cash flow, and a net debt-to-EBITDA ratio" of 2. First, the CEO noted that because higher-margin oil makes up the bulk of WildHorse's current production, the combined company's margins on a per-barrel of oil equivalent (BOE) basis will expand by 35% in the next year and more than 50% by 2020.

  • Amazon and other big tech stocks are being crushed: Here's the simple explanation
    Yahoo Finance

    Amazon and other big tech stocks are being crushed: Here's the simple explanation

    Reality continues to rain down on formerly high-flying big tech stocks. Sales growth in 2019 will probably be less explosive than 2018. Blame slowing user growth at the likes of Facebook or more competition for Amazon from the increasingly digitally savvy Target – the fact is the sales growth environment for big tech is taking a turn for the worse.

  • Trump Insults Key House Democrat Adam Schiff With Potty Humor Tweet

    Trump Insults Key House Democrat Adam Schiff With Potty Humor Tweet

    President Donald Trump insulted Democratic Representative Adam Schiff of California with a tweet that misspelled the Intelligence Committee member’s name in a way that suggests a scatological reference. “So funny to see little Adam Schitt (D-CA) talking about the fact that Acting Attorney General Matt Whitaker was not approved by the Senate, but not mentioning the fact that Bob Mueller (who is highly conflicted) was not approved by the Senate!” Trump tweeted on Sunday. Schiff, a frequent critic of Trump, said on ABC’s “This Week” earlier in the day that the appointment of Whitaker was “unconstitutional” because he wasn’t confirmed by the Senate — a claim that other Democratic lawmakers have made and the White House rejects.

  • Lockheed Martin Lands 255-Jet Fighter Order Worth $22.7 Billion
    Motley Fool

    Lockheed Martin Lands 255-Jet Fighter Order Worth $22.7 Billion

    Let the shareholders rejoice: Lockheed Martin's (NYSE: LMT) F-35 Lightning II fighter jet contracts are getting bigger -- and bigger. In September, Reuters  reported on a Pentagon deal to buy what it called at the time "the biggest batch yet" of Lockheed Martin's joint strike fighter -- 141 fighter jets valued at $11.5 billion. To win such a big order, Lockheed lowered its average F-35 cost to $81.6 million.

  • Best Big Marijuana Stock: Aurora Cannabis, Canopy Growth, or Tilray?
    Motley Fool

    Best Big Marijuana Stock: Aurora Cannabis, Canopy Growth, or Tilray?

    There are distinct categories for Canadian marijuana stocks when it comes to market cap. Most of these stocks have market caps of well under $1 billion. A few are between $1 billion and $5 billion. But only three claim market caps greater than $5 billion

  • Hedge-fund boss who predicted ‘87 crash says get ready for some ‘really scary moments’

    Hedge-fund boss who predicted ‘87 crash says get ready for some ‘really scary moments’

    ‘From a markets perspective, it’s going to be interesting. Paul Tudor Jones, a hedge-fund luminary, said he’s stress-testing his portfolio of corporate debt because he expects a tumultuous road ahead on the back of the Federal Reserve’s apparent commitment to normalizing interest rates and buttressed by corporate tax cuts from the Trump administration. Speaking at an economic forum in Greenwich, Conn., a hotbed for hedge funds, Jones said the Fed faces real challenges amid “the end of a 10-year run” of economic growth that many anticipate will soon come to a screeching, cyclical end.

  • New Strong Sell Stocks for November 19th

    New Strong Sell Stocks for November 19th

    Here are 5 stocks added to the Zacks Rank #5 (Strong Sell) List today:Astronics Corporation ATRO is a designer and manufacturer of products used in aerospace, defense, electronics, and semiconductor industries. The Zacks Consensus Estimate for its current

  • GE names leadership team for revamped power units
    CNBC Videos

    GE names leadership team for revamped power units

    CNBC's Joe Kernen and CNBC's Jim Cramer discuss General Electric's new leadership and Apple.

  • Business

    Cimarex to pay 15 pct premium for Resolute Energy in Permian push

    Oil and gas producer Cimarex Energy Co on Monday agreed to buy smaller rival Resolute Energy Corp for about $811 million, adding more assets in the shale-rich Permian Basin for a premium of roughly 15 percent. The region has seen several deals as bigger producers add more assets, allowing them to negotiate better with oilfield services, frac sand providers and pipeline operators as production costs rise. As part of the deal, Resolute shareholders have the option to receive 0.3943 shares of Cimarex common stock, $35 per share in cash, or a combination of $14 per share in cash and 0.2366 share of Cimarex common stock.

  • GE shakes up power unit leadership, taps retired executive to help

    GE shakes up power unit leadership, taps retired executive to help

    The changes mark another step in new GE Chief Executive Officer Larry Culp urgent effort to reduce heavy debt and restore profits at the 126-year-old, Boston-based conglomerate. "One of my top priorities is positioning our businesses to win, starting with GE Power," Culp said in a statement. GE stock was up 0.6 percent at $8.05 in morning trading.

  • Apple cuts production orders for all three new iPhone models - WSJ

    Apple cuts production orders for all three new iPhone models - WSJ

    (Reuters) - Apple Inc (AAPL.O) has cut production orders in recent weeks for all three iPhone models launched in September, the Wall Street Journal reported on Monday, citing sources. A lower-than-expected demand for the new iPhones and

  • NVIDIA (NVDA) Shares Decline to Touch a New 52-Week Low

    NVIDIA (NVDA) Shares Decline to Touch a New 52-Week Low

    Shares of NVIDIA Corporation NVDA declined 18.78% to close at $164.43 on Nov 16. Moreover, during the trading session, shares slipped to a 52-week low of $161.61.The chip-making giant’s disappointing outlook for the fiscal fourth quarter and an unimpressive

  • Business

    Micron Falls After FT Report Indicates Deepening China Probe

    (Bloomberg) -- Shares of Micron Technology are down 2 percent pre-market, after the Financial Times reported that Chinese authorities would deepen an antitrust probe into Micron and two other chipmakers, claiming ”massive evidence” of violations.Western

  • Best Amazon Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals so far
    The Telegraph

    Best Amazon Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals so far

    As supreme ruler of the online retail landscape, Amazon has built quite the reputation for extraordinary Black Friday deals. Last year alone the selection was so generous and diverse that the website went on to handle 54.9% of all online Black Friday transactions, according to Hitwise data cited in Dealerscope. The weekend was so successful for the company, in fact, that Cyber Monday went on to become the biggest shopping day in the company’s history.

  • Why Verizon Is Up 12% So Far in 2018
    Motley Fool

    Why Verizon Is Up 12% So Far in 2018

    Shares of Verizon (NYSE: VZ) are up 12% so far this year, handily beating the S&P 500's paltry 2% gain as the end of 2018 nears. The main reason for Verizon's 2018 advance has to do with modest gains in its subscriber base. In the third quarter of 2018, Verizon reported 515,000 net additions to its postpaid wireless-subscriber base.

  • Warren Buffett Is Betting $86 Billion on This Industry
    Motley Fool

    Warren Buffett Is Betting $86 Billion on This Industry

    Berkshire Hathaway (NYSE: BRK-A) (NYSE: BRK-B) recently revealed the contents of its closely watched stock portfolio as of the third quarter, and to the surprise of many investors, the company spent an 11-figure sum on bank stocks. In all, Berkshire Hathaway's bank stocks, much of which were selected by CEO Warren Buffett himself, are worth more than $86 billion as of this writing.

  • Business
    Motley Fool

    Why Procter & Gamble Is Now All the Rage on Wall Street

    On the Motley Fool Industry Focus podcast, we're taking a break from manic market action to highlight stocks which investors can buy to play defense -- without having to check a quote screen every five minutes. In particular, we hone in on consumer staples stocks, which have led the entire market over the last three extremely volatile months. To understand why sleepy consumer conglomerate Procter & Gamble (NYSE: PG) has found new fans and is a worthy choice to shore up a tech or healthcare-heavy portfolio, simply watch the video below.

  • Business

    Insider Buys Of The Week: Hain Celestial, Newell Brands, Wynn Resorts

    Conventional wisdom says that insiders and 10-percent owners really only buy shares of a company for one reason: they believe the stock price will rise and they want to profit. Newell Brands Inc (NYSE: NWL) saw a director add to his stake last week. Note that this director is the son of Carl Icahn, and his stake was last seen at more than 400,000 shares.

  • Top Stocks Warren Buffett Just Sold
    Motley Fool

    Top Stocks Warren Buffett Just Sold

    Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway (NYSE: BRK-A) (NYSE: BRK-B) has been busy. In addition to swooping in and buying bundles of bank stocks, Buffett sold some of Berkshire's longtime holdings in the third quarter. Since Berkshire Hathaway manages a portfolio worth more than $200 billion, and it tends to be among the biggest owners of the stocks it purchases, knowing what stocks it's selling is important.