U.S. Markets close in 6 hrs 25 mins

Facebook still bristles with fake news

Rick Newman

If you search for “Breitbart” on Facebook, one of the listings likely to pop up is a group featuring the news organization’s red logo, with more than 20,000 members. When you click to join, you’re asked to answer three questions, including whether you consider the government your enemy. But the group has no affiliation with the Breitbart news organization, and if an administrator lets you in, you’ll see a news feed consisting of mainstream news, conservative commentary and outright fabrications. The sketchiest posts link to fringe websites few have ever heard of.

Facebook is under the most intense scrutiny in its 17-year history, amid revelations that it ran political ads paid for by Russian interests during last year’s presidential election. Congressional committees plan to release those ads in coming weeks. Meanwhile, special counsel Robert Mueller is investigating the social media giant as part of his inquiry into Russian meddling in American politics. Facebook executives will soon testify before Congress, which may impose new regulations on social-media platforms that have largely evaded government intervention up till now.

But Facebook faces another pernicious problem that has earned less attention of late: Fake news pockmarks the platform, especially in membership groups where people go to find like-minded users. Much of the bogus information has a political slant, as the Russian ads that ran on the platform last year apparently did. But much of the phony info may serve a more banal purpose than influencing elections — simply making money by coaxing gullible users into clicking on outrageous-sounding posts that lead them to third-party sites clogged with cheesy ads for things such as “Hot Girls Fishing” and “Better Than Adderall.”

This post in an unverified Breitbart group on Facebook promotes bogus conspiracy theories about the Oct. 1 mass shooting in Las Vegas.

Is this garden-variety snake oil or Russian subterfuge? Hard to say. “The line between politically motivated disinformation and inflammatory content meant to drive clicks to websites is a blurry one,” says Tim Chambers, who runs the digital arm of the consultancy Dewey Square Group and authored a recent paper on the malicious use of social media. “Fake sites are often based out of Eastern Europe and interrelate with state-sponsored actions.”

I spent several days exploring fake news on Facebook using my personal account, and it wasn’t hard to find. When I searched for “Breitbart,” for instance, I found four different Facebook accounts using the name. But only one bore the check mark indicating Facebook has verified it’s legitimate.

I asked to join one of the unverified Breitbart groups and was granted access by a Facebook user dubbed Joel Busick, who has 0 Facebook friends and lists no personal information, except the claim that he’s from Sister Lakes, Mich. His profile picture is a jar of red fruit. These are all hallmarks of a fake account, according to cybersecurity experts.

The “major sponsor” is a car dealership in New Jersey most NFL viewers have never heard of.

The unverified Breitbart stream includes links to news stories from legitimate media sites such as Fox News, National Review and the real Breitbart. But I also found plenty of exaggerated or distorted takes on real news, such as a post in the unverified Breitbart feed declaring the “NFL lost [a] second MAJOR sponsor to kneelers.” When I clicked on the link, the “major sponsor” turned out to be a car dealership in Flemington, N.J.

There were total lies mixed in with real and exaggerated news. Several related to the Oct. 1 massacre in Las Vegas, with links to stories claiming there were multiple shooters rather than one. Another post linked to a story insisting nobody fired from the Mandalay Bay Hotel where shooter Stephen Paddock did, in fact, fire from. A third post declared that Paddock had a direct link to Barack and Michelle Obama. All claims are demonstrably false. Another post claimed that rapper Eminem led an anti-Trump chant at a recent concert (true) and also wrote a check to Trump’s 2020 re-election campaign (false). Then there was a poll in the unverified Breitbart feed that asked, “Do you support the Second Amendment?” When I clicked on it, the link that popped up asked for my email address instead of allowing me to vote. I declined to provide it.

This unverified MSNBC page claims Trump published a tweet he never did.

There’s a separate “Breitbart News” group — also unverified — that appears linked to the unverified Breitbart group. When I asked to join that group, an administrator using the name “Izzy Wilshire” let me in. Like “Joel Busick,” Izzy Wilshire has no Facebook friends, and there’s no personal info at all. The profile picture is a mashup of a woman’s face and a wolf’s, which appears to be downloaded from Pinterest, according to a reverse image search I conducted on Google. Izzy Wilshire posts inflammatory messages in both unverified Breitbart groups. A typical one: “Go To Hell!” in response to Eminem’s anti-Trump chant. Another Breitbart News admin who posts similar items is “Carlos Hondo,” who has more than 600 Facebook friends, including many that appear to be real people. But Carlos Hondo lists no personal information, and his profile picture is an image of Beric Dondarrion, the nomadic warrior from “Game of Thrones,” wielding his familiar flaming sword.

Breitbart did not respond to several requests for comment regarding this story. A Facebook spokesperson issued this statement to Yahoo Finance: “Groups that use brands in their names don’t violate a specific policy on Facebook, as many groups don’t self-identify as ‘official’ groups and are intended to be fan groups or spinoff discussion groups. However, people want to see accurate information on Facebook, and so do we. We’re aggressively pursuing a multi-pronged approach to stop the spread of false news, and while we have much more work to do, just this week we announced that when a story has been fact-checked as false, it loses 80 percent of its future impressions on Facebook.”

Monitoring posts is a challenge

Bogus news inside member-only groups highlights a unique feature of Facebook: The site is highly compartmentalized, with members of the public only able to see what’s in their own news feed (assuming they’re on Facebook in the first place). That’s a huge selling point to advertisers, since Facebook can target ads to individual users based on everything it knows about their likes, dislikes, interests, and even personality traits detected via the quizzes and games that pop up from time to time on the site. But you have to be admitted to a group to see what’s shown there, a setup that makes public oversight impossible. Users can see content posted in other people’s news feeds, but only if they’re “friends.” Even then, one user wouldn’t necessarily see an ad served to another user. Twitter, by contrast, is generally open to anybody with an account, since a user can follow anybody and see what they post.

Michelle Obama said no such thing.

Since the unverified Breitbart groups I found were appropriating the name of a conservative news site, I searched to see if other groups did the same thing with different news organizations. I found an unverified CNN page, but it had few followers and no recent posts. An unverified MSNBC page — not requiring membership — had about 9,100 likes, and the newest post was from February. But that post claimed President Donald Trump had responded to kids writing letters to the White House by tweeting, “Don’t tell me how to do my job again or I’ll pass an executive order that says you have to be 21 years old to use the internet.” Trump never tweeted that.

Conservative causes seem to be more susceptible to fake news than liberal ones, and perhaps a more lucrative target for fake-news profiteers. But liberal causes aren’t immune. During last year’s campaign, there were 30 or more pro-Bernie Sanders accounts on Facebook that turned out to be operated by users based in Macedonia and Albania. Info from those accounts — much of it bashing Hillary Clinton, Sanders’s foe in the primary elections — “reached hundreds of thousands of Facebook users via hundreds of posts,” according to a recent report by NDN, a center-left think tank in Washington, DC. It’s not clear if those accounts had any connection with Russian interests, or were just an attempt to lure users to ad-heavy web sites.

Macedonia is home to a fake-news syndicate

In addition to bogus Facebook accounts borrowing brand names, I also spent some time looking into political groups on Facebook that don’t claim to be affiliated with a news organization or political candidate. There are several pro-Trump “deplorable” groups, for instance, and when I asked to join The American Deplorables, which has 41,000 members, a Facebook user named Димче Ѓуров —Macedonian that transliterates to Dime Djurov — gave me permission to join. Djurov appears to be a real Facebook user, whose page says he lives in Veles, Macedonia. If the recurrence of Macedonia sounds surprising, it’s not. There’s basically a fake-news syndicate in Macedonia, as several news organizations have revealed, mostly operated by young men who get paid by third-party operators for leading Facebook users to external websites clogged with ads. Facebook supposedly cracked down on the racket earlier this year, but evidently didn’t nail everybody.

Since the Macedonian-style accounts make money when Facebook users click off to a third-party site and see an ad, there’s an incentive to make Facebook posts linking to those sites as provocative as possible. In the feed running inside The American Deplorables group, I found a mix of real, distorted and fake news, similar to what I found in the counterfeit Breitbart group. Examples of fakery: Michelle Obama said that if Trump deports Muslims, her family will leave America, too; a “sad announcement about Nancy Pelosi” linked to a nonexistent third-party page; and President Obama was behind a 2015 terrorist attack in Texas. That last item was posted by Филип Крстевски, who appears to be a Serbian otherwise known as Filip Krstevski.

Facebook’s credibility

My fake-news survey of Facebook is obviously anecdotal. But it’s virtually impossible to do a thorough analysis to determine how prevalent fake news is on Facebook. Twitter releases some user data publicly, which has allowed researchers to estimate that as many as 15% of Twitter’s 300 million accounts might be fake. Facebook guards its data much more closely, making outside analysis difficult. In its latest quarterly filing with the SEC, Facebook estimated that 1.5% of its 2.01 billion monthly users were “undesirable.” Facebook also said, however, that its estimate “may not accurately represent the actual number of such accounts” because it’s based on a “limited sample.”

Facebook has been losing credibility with the public, meanwhile, and with Washington as well. Last November, CEO Mark Zuckerberg said it was a “pretty crazy idea” that fake news on Facebook might have influenced the U.S. presidential election. That was before Facebook itself discovered that Russian interests had purchased political ads meant to sway the election in Trump’s favor. Facebook’s Chief Operating Officer, Sheryl Sandberg, acknowledged recently that “things happened on our platform in this election that should not have happened.”

Facebook says it is hiring 1,000 new staffers to help monitor ads and content for problems, but it has made similar promises before to crack down on problematic content. Members of Congress may decide that new legislation is necessary to police political content on Facebook and other social media sites, much as political ads are regulated in the traditional media. One suspects fake news will persist anyway.

Confidential tip line: rickjnewman@yahoo.com. Encrypted communication available.

Read more:

Rick Newman is the author of four books, including Rebounders: How Winners Pivot from Setback to Success. Follow him on Twitter: @rickjnewman

  • Prince William Might Have Just Hinted at the New Royal Baby's Name

    Prince William Might Have Just Hinted at the New Royal Baby's Name

    Speculation about the name of the new royal baby has run rampant — and it’s possible that Arthur might be the winning guess. According to some Twitter accounts, the Duke of Cambridge said, “There’s Arthur, there he is,” while pointing to a photographer who works for The Sun, a popular British tabloid. The photographer in question, Arthur Edwards, is referred to as a “veteran” in his field, so would be known by sight to the royals.

  • How Nick Saban Keeps Alabama Football Rolling

    How Nick Saban Keeps Alabama Football Rolling

    Nick Saban knows what he’s doing isn’t normal. The University of Alabama football coach is well aware that it’s anything but typical for one school to thoroughly dominate a major sport the way his Crimson Tide has ruled college football over the past decade. “To me it takes a completely different mindset to stay successful as opposed to what you have to do to build something to be successful,” says Saban.

  • The only reasons to stay with the iPhone right now have nothing to do with the iPhone

    The only reasons to stay with the iPhone right now have nothing to do with the iPhone

    My iPhone X is fine. I picked up the $1,000 rectangle of glass and aluminum on launch day. I’ve been on Apple’s upgrade program since it launched in 2015, which means I pay a monthly fee, currently $56, and get each new iPhone as it’s released every year. I switched my main phone from Android to iPhone in 2014, with the launch of the iPhone 6. I’ve been there through the iterative years of the designs with the iPhone 6, 6s, 7, and 8. I’ve continued to pay for these phones, because, as my colleague Akshat recently put it, “Apple was producing the best damn phones in the market.” But Apple no longer has a monopoly on quality. Samsung’s most recent phones were my favorites of last year, and for

  • Finance
    Associated Press

    Corning: 1Q Earnings Snapshot

    CORNING, N.Y. (AP) _ Corning Inc. (GLW) on Tuesday reported a first-quarter loss of $589 million, after reporting a profit in the same period a year earlier. The Corning, New York-based company said it had a loss

  • 3 Bargain Stocks You Can Buy Right Now
    Motley Fool

    3 Bargain Stocks You Can Buy Right Now

    Gilead Sciences (NASDAQ: GILD), Micron Technology (NASDAQ: MU), and Walker & Dunlop (NYSE: WD) actually have relatively low valuations. Gilead's revenue and earnings have declined over the last couple of years on sinking sales of its hepatitis C virus (HCV) franchise. Stabilization in the HCV market should set Gilead up for a return to growth.

  • 2020 Democratic presidential candidate calls for universal basic income
    Fox Business Videos

    2020 Democratic presidential candidate calls for universal basic income

    2020 Democratic presidential candidate Andrew Yang on his plan to offer universal basic income to all Americans between the ages of 18 to 64.

  • US brands suffer collateral damage in Chinese corporate war
    Associated Press

    US brands suffer collateral damage in Chinese corporate war

    It was looking like a banner year for business in China. The U.S. clothing company was expecting a 20 percent jump in online sales on Alibaba's Tmall, thanks to the e-commerce giant's massive reach. The company refused to sign an exclusive contract with Alibaba, and instead participated in a big sale promotion with its archrival, JD.com Inc. Tmall punished them by taking steps to cut traffic to their storefront, two executives told The Associated Press.

  • Better Buy: Amgen Inc. vs. Celgene
    Motley Fool

    Better Buy: Amgen Inc. vs. Celgene

    Amgen (NASDAQ: AMGN) has been the hands-down winner over Celgene (NASDAQ: CELG) in terms of stock performance over the last year. Celgene beat Amgen in earnings, but only because of a technicality: Amgen incurred a big one-time tax hit in 2017. Wall Street analysts think Celgene will grow earnings by nearly 20% annually over the next five years, with Amgen's earnings increasing by less than 5% annually during the period.

  • Koch network success in Trump era draws Democratic pushback
    Associated Press

    Koch network success in Trump era draws Democratic pushback

    The sprawling network funded by the billionaire Koch brothers is having a very good run with President Donald Trump in the White House and Republicans in control of Congress. A conservative judge is seated on the Supreme Court. Democrats are increasingly questioning how far the network's influence extends into the White House, casting the groups' backing by industrialists Charles and David Koch as puppeteers behind Trump's agenda and hoping to rouse their own donors to fight back.

  • Tax bill will slash by half the number of homeowners claiming the mortgage deduction

    Tax bill will slash by half the number of homeowners claiming the mortgage deduction

    Tax returns using mortgage interest deduction Already, the deduction was not used by most taxpayers. Of the 150 million or so tax returns the IRS has received annually in recent years, just 20 percent claimed the deduction, according to research from the Urban Brookings Tax Policy Center. The anticipated drop is largely due to the near-doubling of the standard deduction that took effect Jan. 1 under the new tax law. Fewer taxpayers are expected to itemize their deductions, which is the only way to take advantage of the tax break for interest paid on mortgages. The new report estimates that 18 million households will itemize deductions this year, down from 46.5 million last year. Taxpayers would

  • Bitcoin Cash has risen 80% over the last week
    Business Insider

    Bitcoin Cash has risen 80% over the last week

    Bitcoin Cash is up 17% against the dollar on Monday. The cryptocurrency has risen 80% over the last seven days. An upcoming 'fork' of the currency — a change to its underlying code — appears to be supporting the price rally. Follow the live Bitcoin Cash

  • AT&T Defends Time Warner Deal's Cost Savings From U.S. Assault

    AT&T Defends Time Warner Deal's Cost Savings From U.S. Assault

    AT&T Inc. attacked the U.S. government expert who disputes the company’s claim that its takeover of Time Warner Inc. would lead to $2.5 billion in cost savings. Rob Walters, a lawyer for AT&T, tried Monday to undermine the Justice Department’s expert, Ronald Quintero, saying he ignored AT&T’s history of successfully integrating companies and achieving projected savings. Walters also said that in a separate case in which he testified as an expert, Quintero’s testimony was "utterly discredited" by a judge.

  • Korean Air heiresses to resign as smuggle probe widens
    Associated Press

    Korean Air heiresses to resign as smuggle probe widens

    Korean Air Lines said Monday that two daughters of its chairman will resign from their executive positions amid mounting public criticism over the women's behavior and allegations that the family engaged in smuggling. An official at the Korea Customs Service, meanwhile, confirmed that authorities raided the airline's headquarters in Seoul seeking evidence on alleged smuggling and tariff evasion. Chairman Cho Yang-ho announced the resignation of his daughter Hyun-ah, who returned to leadership last month after a four-year hiatus following a "nut rage" scandal, and her younger sister Hyun-min, who is under investigation for allegedly hurling a cup of water at a business meeting.

  • Trump's revenge: U.S. oil floods Europe, hurting OPEC and Russia

    Trump's revenge: U.S. oil floods Europe, hurting OPEC and Russia

    MOSCOW/LONDON (Reuters) - As OPEC's efforts to balance the oil market bear fruit, U.S. producers are reaping the benefits - and flooding Europe with a record amount of crude. Russia paired with the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries last year in cutting oil output jointly by 1.8 million barrels per day (bpd), a deal they say has largely rebalanced the market and one that has helped elevate benchmark Brent prices close to four-year highs. Now, the relatively high prices brought about by that pact, coupled with surging U.S. output, are making it harder to sell Russian, Nigerian and other oil grades in Europe, traders said.

  • What We Know About Sean Hannity's Shell Companies and Why It Matters

    What We Know About Sean Hannity's Shell Companies and Why It Matters

    Fox News anchor Sean Hannity had a bad week. Last Monday, a lawyer representing Donald Trump’s personal attorney, Michael Cohen, said that Hannity was one of Cohen’s three clients. Cohen is under investigation in relation to a payment he reportedly made to adult film star Stormy Daniels on behalf of then-candidate Trump.

  • A Smarter Nvidia Corporation Play for a Potential 500% Return

    A Smarter Nvidia Corporation Play for a Potential 500% Return

    According to some market pundits, issues like Apple Inc.’s (NASDAQ:AAPL) woes, China trade war concerns and today’s much more volatile and erratic cryptocurrency market can all be fingered as reasons why investors should stay away from Nvidia stock. If you’re a buyer of those markets, Nvidia — whose chips are leaders in all those areas — should sound attractive. This appears to be the case for Nvidia stock right now–and that’s good news for bulls.

  • Reddit co-founder: My wife Serena Williams and I want our...
    CNBC Videos

    Reddit co-founder: My wife Serena Williams and I want our...

    Reddit co-founder Alexis Ohanian joins a growing list of tech luminaries who believe that limiting screen time fosters better psychological and social development.

  • Investors Are Dumping Altria Group Inc Stock Without Looking at the Facts

    Investors Are Dumping Altria Group Inc Stock Without Looking at the Facts

    The usually reliable Altria Group Inc (NYSE:MO) is off to a horrific start this year, with MO stock shedding 18%. For technical analysts, the recent break below $60 was highly discouraging. In short, MO stock must regain its footing quickly due to the significant technical damage.

  • Geron Corporation: The Clock Is Ticking
    Motley Fool

    Geron Corporation: The Clock Is Ticking

    Geron Corporation (NASDAQ: GERN) reached an unfortunate milestone last month. Namely, the company's short interest hit an all-time high at the end of March, with over 44 million shares now being sold short.  Why is Wall Street so deeply pessimistic about

  • GE's Q1 Performance Proves the Doubters Wrong
    Motley Fool

    GE's Q1 Performance Proves the Doubters Wrong

    Shares of industrial giant General Electric (NYSE: GE) have plunged over the past year due to deteriorating performance in the company's power business -- historically its largest segment by revenue -- and investor fears about hidden liabilities in the GE Capital financing business. Last Friday, General Electric silenced many of its critics with solid first-quarter results. While the company still faces earnings pressure from the power and GE Capital segments, the valuable aviation and healthcare segments are performing very well.

  • IBM Plunges: 5 Reasons to Buy, 5 Reasons to Sell
    Motley Fool

    IBM Plunges: 5 Reasons to Buy, 5 Reasons to Sell

    Shares of IBM (NYSE: IBM) plunged nearly 8% on April 18, after the tech giant reported its first-quarter earnings. Big Blue's numbers initially looked solid, topping analyst estimates on both the top and bottom lines. But upon digging deeper into the 

  • Finance

    Kinder Morgan Inc Finally Gives Investors What They Want

    Pipelines were supposed to be safe tollways that produced plenty of cash flows. Kinder Morgan stock has pretty much languished since that fateful day. Moves to right the ship at Kinder Morgan have begun to work and KMI has finally given long-suffering shareholders what they wanted all the time — a big return to dividend growth.

  • Flight Records Shed New Light on President Trump's Infamous 2013 Moscow Trip

    Flight Records Shed New Light on President Trump's Infamous 2013 Moscow Trip

    President Donald Trump twice gave James Comey an alibi for why a salacious report about the 2013 Miss Universe pageant in Moscow couldn’t be true: He never even spent the night in Russia during that trip, Trump told the former FBI director, according to Comey’s memos about the conversations. Now, flight records obtained by Bloomberg provide to-the-minute details, from wheels down to departure. Combined with existing accounts and Trump’s own social-media posts, they capture a mere 45 hours and 43 minutes that, nearly five years later, loom large in the controversy engulfing the White House and at the heart of the Comey memos, which the Justice Department turned over last week to Congress.

  • Ford Motor Company Earnings: Will Cost Cuts Help Boost Margins?
    Motley Fool

    Ford Motor Company Earnings: Will Cost Cuts Help Boost Margins?

    Ford Motor Company (NYSE: F) will present its first-quarter 2018 earnings results after the bell on Wednesday, April 25. Wall Street analysts polled by Thomson Reuters expect Ford to report earnings of $0.41 per share, on average, up from $0.39 per share in the first quarter of 2017. Back in January, CFO Bob Shanks said that while he expects Ford's full-year 2018 revenue to be about the same as 2017's, or a little higher, its adjusted earnings per share will likely fall to between $1.45 and $1.70 from $1.78 in 2017.

  • Princess Charlotte and Prince George Have Very On-Brand Reactions to Their New Baby Brother

    Princess Charlotte and Prince George Have Very On-Brand Reactions to Their New Baby Brother

    When it was revealed that Kate Middleton gave birth to the newest member of the royal family on Monday, April 23, there were plenty of people filled with excitement at the news, but no reaction was as precious as the ones that siblings Prince George and Princess Charlotte had about their new baby brother. The little prince and princess, who were spotted on their way to visit their mother and the new baby in the Lindo Wing at St. Mary’s Hospital in London, gave two very on-brand reactions to the birth. George, however, adopted a cool and casual air as he made the walk into the Lindo Wing, no doubt because as the oldest child who had already welcomed a younger sibling, he felt like a seasoned pro.