U.S. Markets open in 9 hrs

Feds Sue California Farmer For Growing Wheat

Kevin Mooney


No one told Jack LaPant that he could be in violation of the Clean Water Act for farming his own land.

That’s mostly because the federal law includes a clear exemption for “normal” farming activities. But it’s also because the government officials LaPant consulted didn’t view overturned dirt that has been tilled and plowed as pollution.

In 2016, the Army Corps of Engineers, which administers the Clean Water Act with the Environmental Protection Agency, began legal action against LaPant for plowing he did in 2011 to plant wheat on a ranch property he owned in Northern California. 

But in March 2012, LaPant had sold the property, located in Tehama County about 4 miles south of the city of Red Bluff.

 

Before plowing his field to plant wheat, LaPant conferred in person with the Farm Service Agency in California, which is part of the U.S. Department of Agriculture. 

“All of these government officials I spoke with, and they have all been deposed, they never once suggested that I should go meet with the Army Corps of Engineers,” LaPant said in a phone interview with The Daily Signal. 

“I asked them if it was OK to take this piece of land and grow wheat and they all said it was OK,” he recalled. “Even today, you can go into these offices and they will not tell a farmer that he needs to go and see the Army Corps to farm on his own land. It makes no sense and the Department of Agriculture doesn’t understand any of it, and we are talking about the same federal government.”

LaPant recalls visiting “four different government folks” with expertise in soil conservation when he was researching the history of the farm.

“They all gave me the same answer,” LaPant said. “They told me, ‘Jack, if you’d like to go ahead and plant it the same way it’s been planted in the past, go ahead. But if you want to go in and plant a permanent crop, then maybe we’ll go back and study it.’ So, I went ahead and planted 900 acres of wheat.”

The legal complications for LaPant began after he sold the property to Duarte Nursery, a family-owned nursery operation based in Tehama County, California, which then encountered similar problems with the Army Corps of Engineers. 

Duarte Nursery entered into a settlement agreement with the federal government after suing the Army Corps of Engineers for denying due process. Pacific Legal Foundation, a nonprofit, public interest law firm based in Sacramento, California, and Washington, D.C., represented the nursery in the case and now represents LaPant.

Tony Francois, a lawyer with Pacific Legal Foundation who specializes in property rights, told The Daily Signal that the orchard-planting operations of another company, Goose Pond Ag, may be what led to the prosecution of LaPant. 

Goose Pond Ag, a Florida-based farmland management company, purchased a portion of the California property from Duarte Nursery in 2012. Six years later, in 2018, the company reached a settlement with the U.S. Justice Department in which it agreed to pay $5.3 million in civil penalties for Clean Water Act violations, according to media reports.

“It’s the orchard planting and the preparations for the orchard planting, which involves fairly substantial earthwork, that really got the Army’s attention and got this whole enforcement action going,” Francois said. “What’s odd about it is that they roped LaPant into it, and we think the Army may have initially thought LaPant was part of this plan to plant the orchard.”

This month, Pacific Legal Foundation plans to submit a motion for summary judgment to the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California that could resolve some or all of LaPant’s case based on “application of the law to the undisputed facts in the case,” Francois said.

If the case is not resolved,  it could move to a jury trial sometime in 2020.

The Daily Signal sought comment from the Army Corps of Engineers and the Environmental Protection Agency. Neither agency had responded by publication time. 

What’s particularly alarming to LaPant and other farmers familiar with his case is that in their view the Corps saw fit to modify the Clean Water Act without congressional approval, Francois said.

“There’s a pretty broad, clear statement in the Clean Water Act that you don’t need a permit for normal farming activities,” Francois said, adding:

This would include normal ranching, farming, forestry activities. But the Army has added multiple conditions that you have to meet for these protections [for such operations] to continue.

One of these conditions is that the property has to be tilled pretty regularly for this protection to continue. But there are many reasons why a farmer may suspend tilling. For example, cattle may have a higher price than wheat or corn, and so the land might be used for grazing for a period of time. 

The Army has definitely added hurdles and obstacles to a pretty clear and simple statement of the Clean Water Act that you don’t need a permit for normal farming activities. In our view, what they’ve done is to change the policy decision Congress made.

Kevin Mooney is an investigative reporter for The Daily Signal. This article first appeared in The Daily Signal on December 3, 2019.

Image: Reuters.



Read the original article.

  • Asian Stocks Drop in Risk-Off Turn; Yen Rises: Markets Wrap
    Business
    Bloomberg

    Asian Stocks Drop in Risk-Off Turn; Yen Rises: Markets Wrap

    Seven straight weekly advances in the MSCI Asia Pacific Index might also have left some investors looking for a short-term exit point from equities. “As Chinese citizens travel home for the Lunar New Year, more cases of the new virus have been reported and it seems it is spreading,” said Zhou Hao, a senior emerging markets economist at Commerzbank AG. “There is a risk of an exponential outbreak” along the lines of the 2003 SARS virus, Zhou said.

  • Business
    Bloomberg

    Peter Schiff Says He’s Lost His Bitcoin After Wallet Freeze-Out

    Cryptocurrency skeptic Peter Schiff said he can't access his Bitcoin holdings after his digital wallet stopped accepting his password. I just lost all the Bitcoin I have ever owned,” Schiff, chief global strategist at Alliance Global Partners, said in a series of posts on his unverified Twitter account. My wallet got corrupted somehow and my password is no longer valid.

  • 3 Top-Notch “Strong Buy” Stocks Under $3
    Business
    TipRanks

    3 Top-Notch “Strong Buy” Stocks Under $3

    If you're on a budget, yet in a risk-tolerant mood, it's worth taking a look at penny stocks – companies whose shares sell for less than $5 apiece. Here you get a lot more for your money; For example, buying a single share of Amazon will set you back $1,865, but if you wanted to spend the equivalent amount on a stock worth $3, you could load up on 621 shares of company x. Is it worth it though?

  • Man who made a killing during financial crisis says that, at some point, the stock market will slow down — but, till then, ‘I love riding a horse that’s running’
    Business
    MarketWatch

    Man who made a killing during financial crisis says that, at some point, the stock market will slow down — but, till then, ‘I love riding a horse that’s running’

    The U.S. stock market has enjoyed a nearly uninterrupted assault on records, highlighted by the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) closing at a milestone above 29,000 for the first time and the S&P 500 (SPX) achieving its own landmark close above the psychological round-number at 3,300, while investors in the Nasdaq Composite Index (COMP) may have their sights trained on 10,000.

  • Bearish Bets: 2 Well-Known Stocks You Should Consider Shorting This Week
    Business
    TheStreet.com

    Bearish Bets: 2 Well-Known Stocks You Should Consider Shorting This Week

    Using recent actions and grades from TheStreet's Quant Ratings and layering on technical analysis of the charts of those stocks, Trifecta Stocks identifies five names each week that look bearish. While we will not be weighing in with fundamental analysis we hope this piece will give investors interested in stocks on the way down a good starting point to do further homework on the names. Nektar Therapeutics Inc. recently was downgraded to Sell with a D rating by TheStreet's Quant Ratings.

  • News
    TheStreet.com

    Is the Stock Market Open on Martin Luther King Jr. Day?

    Martin Luther King Jr. Day was first signed into law in 1983, and first officially observed as a holiday in 1986. Generally observed on the third Monday of January (close to or on King's actual birthday, January 15), MLK Day celebrates the life and legacy of one of America's most well-known and influential activists, who fought for racial and economic justice across the country. Martin Luther King Jr. Day, falling on January 20 this year, is a federal holiday, and not every worker in the country necessarily gets a day off of work for it (45% of employers gave workers the day off in 2019).

  • These 3 Software Stocks Can Climb Higher in 2020, Says Top Investing Firm
    Business
    TipRanks

    These 3 Software Stocks Can Climb Higher in 2020, Says Top Investing Firm

    Yes, the economy still runs on oil and coal, but digital technology has impacted all of us, whether we work in factories or offices or watch the kids at home. All of these factors make software companies a natural place for investors to look when they seek stocks with high return potential. Software companies create the code and programs that let us maneuver in the digital world, from messenger apps to word processing and facial recognition.

  • `Substantial' Market Correction Is Unlikely, Fidelity's Richards Says
    Business
    Bloomberg

    `Substantial' Market Correction Is Unlikely, Fidelity's Richards Says

    Anne Richards, chief executive officer of Fidelity International, discusses the outlook for the global economy, financial markets and active management in 2020. She speaks with Francine Lacqua on "Bloomberg Markets" at the World Economic Forum's annual meeting in Davos, Switzerland.

  • Value stocks are making a comeback, and here’s how to get in early
    Business
    MarketWatch

    Value stocks are making a comeback, and here’s how to get in early

    I believe that is unlikely to continue,” says Joel Greenblatt, the co-chief investment officer at Gotham Funds. was the worst year since 1999 for the strategy of buying cheap stocks and shorting expensive stocks (the top quintile for each), Greenblatt says. The last time this strategy experienced such extremely poor results, value put in three great years of performance, from 2000-2002.

  • The ‘best job in America’ pays $105,000 — and you’ve probably never heard of it
    Business
    MarketWatch

    The ‘best job in America’ pays $105,000 — and you’ve probably never heard of it

    Front-end engineers had an average overall job satisfaction score of 3.9 out of 5 on Glassdoor, making theirs the No. 1 profession for 2020 in terms of job satisfaction, salary and job openings, according to a new ranking, knocking data scientists off the No 1 spot. Front-end engineers develop the code that enhances a customer's or user's experience, and essentially create, install and test the user interface elements of a website. Amanda Stansell, senior economic research analyst at Glassdoor, said there's more competition between tech and non-tech companies for these roles.

  • 3 “Strong Buy” Biotech Stocks That Can Inject a Healthy Dose of Upside
    Business
    TipRanks

    3 “Strong Buy” Biotech Stocks That Can Inject a Healthy Dose of Upside

    To watch Selvaraju's track record, click here) The Street appears equally confident in IMMU's future potential; 4 Buy ratings add up to a Strong Buy consensus rating. With an average price target of $28, the analysts believe Immunomedics can add 47% to its share price over the coming year. See Immunomedics stock analysis on TipRanks) Revance Therapeutics (RVNC) After a disappointing 2019, which saw Revance's share price drop by more than 18%, the neuromodulator-focused biotech has started 2020 with a bang; Revance stock is up by 38% year-to-date.

  • What interest rates dating back to 1311 tell us about today’s global economy
    Business
    Quartz

    What interest rates dating back to 1311 tell us about today’s global economy

    Interest rates sure are weird these days. Five central banks currently hold policy rates negative; several are dabbling with unconventional bond-buying. The one bank that tried to raise them, the Federal Reserve, found itself back cutting rates within a year.

  • Dow Jones Futures: Stock Market Rally Faces Next Test; Netflix, Texas Instruments Earnings Due
    Business
    Investor's Business Daily

    Dow Jones Futures: Stock Market Rally Faces Next Test; Netflix, Texas Instruments Earnings Due

    Dow Jones futures fell Monday night, along with S&P 500 futures and Nasdaq futures, with Asian markets selling off amidgrowing evidence that China's coronavirus can spread from human to human. The coronavirus is unexpected news. Earnings season is expected, but the outcome unclear.

  • U.S. Stock Index Futures Decline Amid China Virus Fears
    World
    Bloomberg

    U.S. Stock Index Futures Decline Amid China Virus Fears

    U.S. stock index futures slid as concerns over the spread of a SARS-like virus from central China damped demand for equities. S&P 500 Index futures contracts expiring in March fell as much as 0.5% after multiple medical workers were reported to have been infected. Dow Jones Industrial Average contracts were down 0.3% while those on the Nasdaq 100 retreated 0.5%.

  • Head of Canada Pension Fund Warns on Rush to Iliquid Assets
    Business
    Bloomberg

    Head of Canada Pension Fund Warns on Rush to Iliquid Assets

    The biggest global funds should all be monitoring their investments in illiquid assets, according to the head of Canada's largest pension fund. I do ring the alarm bell on not to be too invested in illiquid assets,” Mark Machin, chief executive officer of the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board, said in a Bloomberg Television interview Monday at the World Economic Forum in Davos. We are very comfortable with our risk models and what we would do in various lurches down markets, but I do worry about the expansion of a lot of funds like us around the world into private illiquid assets.

  • Prince Harry Says He and Meghan Markle Hoped to Continue Royal Duties, but 'That Wasn’t Possible'
    News
    Meredith Videos

    Prince Harry Says He and Meghan Markle Hoped to Continue Royal Duties, but 'That Wasn’t Possible'

    Prince Harry said Sunday that he felt “great sadness” but found “no other option” to cutting almost all of his and his wife Meghan's royal ties in the hopes of achieving a more peaceful life.

  • Are 401(k) Withdrawals Considered Income?
    Business
    Investopedia

    Are 401(k) Withdrawals Considered Income?

    Starting at age 59½, retirement savers can start accessing their accounts without penalty. Moreover, at age 72, retirees are mandated to start taking required minimum distributions (RMDs). Here we look at what happens when you make those 401(k) withdrawals.

  • Avoid Paying Taxes on Social Security Income
    Business
    Investopedia

    Avoid Paying Taxes on Social Security Income

    With no inflation adjustment having been made to these benchmarks since 1983, they're now exceeded by most taxpayers who receive Social Security benefits and have other sources of income, too. A number of strategies, both before and after you retire, can limit the amount of tax you pay on Social Security benefits. Reducing your taxable income during the years in which you're drawing Social Security can have other benefits, too, such as lowering your Medicare premiums, which vary by income.

  • Business
    MoneyShow

    Top Picks 2020- Cisco Systems CSCO

    See also: Top Picks 2020: Bristol-Myers Squibb (BMY) Over the last few years, CSCO has set out to reinvent IT architectures to help customers simplify the ever-changing technology landscape. In doing so, they are focusing on six core elements: applications, data, security, cloud, infrastructure, and teams. These six core elements add value as more and more business migrate from an internal network structure to private, hybrid, and even multi-cloud environments.

  • Business
    GuruFocus.com

    Marathon Petroleum and Auto Nation Are on the Casualty List

    Buying the stocks of good companies on bad news is my favorite investing method. The trick is to find bad news that is real but probably temporary. Each quarter in this column I compile my Casualty List.

  • Tesla Slams Acceleration Petition Brought by ‘Short Seller’
    Business
    Bloomberg

    Tesla Slams Acceleration Petition Brought by ‘Short Seller’

    The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration is evaluating allegations that Tesla Inc. vehicles contain a defect that can cause sudden unintended acceleration, according to a notice posted on the agency's website last week. The review was prompted by a petition asking the agency to open a defect investigation of some 500,000 Tesla vehicles over the alleged flaw. The petition cited 127 consumer complaints to the agency and claims of 110 crashes.

  • Business
    Barrons.com

    A Contrarian Value Investor Bought Up AT&T Stock, Sold Apple, Microsoft and Amazon

    Contrarian value investor Tocqueville Asset Management in aggregate made some big changes to its overall investments in well-known large-cap stocks. Tocqueville bought substantially more (T) stock (ticker: T) in the fourth quarter, while slashing positions in (AAPL)(AAPL), (MSFT)(MSFT), and (AMZN) stock (AMZN). The firm disclosed the stock trades, among others, in a form it filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission.

  • Stock market is “eerily reminiscent of January 2018” when stocks suffered rapid correction, technical analyst says
    Business
    MarketWatch

    Stock market is “eerily reminiscent of January 2018” when stocks suffered rapid correction, technical analyst says

    Stock market investors could be setting themselves up for a nasty fall. “52-week highs, the percentage of issues above their 200-day moving average, and sector high all are suggesting bullish long-term momentum, but the crescendo nature of this strength without meaningful single day breadth figures and elevated complacency leaves us tactically cold,” he wrote in a Friday note.

  • The Benefits of Starting an IRA for Your Child
    Business
    Investopedia

    The Benefits of Starting an IRA for Your Child

    The primary difference between traditional and Roth IRAs is when you pay taxes on the money that you contribute to the plan. With a traditional IRA, you pay taxes when you withdraw the money during retirement (at your then-applicable tax rate). All the funds, both your contributions and any earnings they've accrued, are considered pre-tax in a traditional IRA.

  • We Think NVIDIA (NASDAQ:NVDA) Can Stay On Top Of Its Debt
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    We Think NVIDIA (NASDAQ:NVDA) Can Stay On Top Of Its Debt

    Debt assists a business until the business has trouble paying it off, either with new capital or with free cash flow. What Is NVIDIA's Debt? You can click the graphic below for the historical numbers, but it shows that as of October 2019 NVIDIA had US$1.99b of debt, an increase on US$2.0k, over one year.