Amid all the Sturm und Drang surrounding the U.S. Department of Labor's proposed fiduciary rule--and President Trump's order to review it--I'm concerned that some of the practical implications for investors have been overlooked. So this month we're going to bring them into focus.
See Also: The Best Online Brokers for Investors
To review briefly, the rule requires that brokers and other financial professionals who offer investors advice on retirement accounts--401(k)s, IRAs and rollover IRAs--act as fiduciaries, putting clients' best interests ahead of their own financial gain. Specifically, the rule would target high-fee investments in rollover IRAs, such as variable annuities. I think that goal, though laudable, raises two important questions: Should you roll over retirement funds into an IRA when you leave your job or retire (a strategy that Kiplinger's often recommends)? And if so, where should you invest the money?
In her story on rollovers, senior associate editor Sandra Block points out that rollovers make sense if your 401(k) has high fees, or if you want to gain access to more investment options or have more control over your account. But sometimes you should just stay put--especially if you like your plan's investment choices and have access to lower-cost institutional-class mutual funds not available to retail customers.
As to where you should put your money if you do choose a rollover, you won't go wrong following our advice to stick with top-performing mutual funds such as those in the Kiplinger 25, or solid individual stocks or low-cost exchange-traded funds (see Earn Up to 6% From Our Fund Portfolios). Aside from their high fees, variable annuities are complex investments that should be approached with caution under any circumstances (see Income Guarantees, With a Catch).
Pricing changes. Regardless of what happens to the fiduciary rule, many brokers and other financial-services firms have already changed their practices and pricing policies. There has been a move away from sales commissions and toward managed accounts, in which you pay a flat fee--1% per year is common--for the company to handle your retirement assets. Merrill Lynch has announced that it will stop offering commission-based IRAs and switch to fee-based accounts.
So you need to know which arrangement suits you best. You may like the convenience of an annual fee. But if you are a buy-and-hold investor who trades infrequently, or a do-it-yourselfer who makes your own decisions and just needs someone to execute trades, it may prove less expensive to pay trading commissions (especially with commissions dropping; Fidelity recently cut its fee to $4.95 for stock and ETF trades).
See Also: The Biggest Mistakes Investors Make
If your account is too small to justify a 1% fee, you may decide to get computerized recommendations from an online robo adviser. Or if you're in the market for a particular service, such as retirement planning, you might look for an adviser who charges an hourly rate or a flat fee per project (check out the Garrett Planning Network).
It's also important to remember what the fiduciary standard doesn't do: It doesn't guarantee that you'll get better advice or that you won't lose money. The best way to protect yourself is to be your own fiduciary: Feel comfortable with what you're investing in. Match your investments with your appetite for risk. No matter what ultimately happens with the fiduciary rule, ask if potential advisers follow a fiduciary standard, how they are compensated and how they resolve potential conflicts. If you don't get satisfactory answers, take your business elsewhere. In the end, nobody has a bigger stake in your money than you do.
Copyright 2017 The Kiplinger Washington Editors