U.S. Markets closed

Google files to appeal $2.73BN EU antitrust fine

Natasha Lomas
Google has filed a legal appeal against a record-breaking fine handed down by the European Commission this summer for anti-competitive behavior relating to the operation of its product search comparison service, currently known as Google Shopping.

Google has filed a legal appeal against a record-breaking fine handed down by the European Commission this summer for anti-competitive behavior relating to the operation of its product search comparison service, currently known as Google Shopping. The news was reported earlier by Reuters and separately confirmed by us.

In June the EC judged that Google had given the service "an illegal advantage by abusing its dominance in general Internet search" -- accusing it of promoting Google Shopping in organic search results while simultaneously demoting rival services -- issuing a record-breaking €2.42 billion (~$2.73BN) fine for the antitrust violations.

It's that decision which Alphabet/Google will be hoping to overturn, buoyed by the fact that earlier this month Europe's top court, the ECJ, ruled that a lower court should review an earlier failed antitrust appeal by Intel, pertaining to a 2009 €1.06BN EC ruling.

In the Intel case ECJ judges said the lower court must re-examine their decision to uphold the antitrust judgement -- saying the court had failed to properly analyze economic aspects of the case.

And while the two cases are clearly different -- and the Intel verdict remains a partial one at this stage (the sanction has not been overturned as yet) -- it's certainly unusual for Europe's courts to rule against Commission verdicts, offering some hope to Google's lawyers they can successful argue against the regulator's rationale.

The Commission is reviewing its Google Shopping decision in light of the ECJ's Intel ruling, according to Reuters. (At the time of writing spokespeople for the EC's antitrust division had not responded to questions and requests for comment -- we'll update if we get a response.)

At the end of last month Google did take the first steps to comply with the Commission's antitrust order against Google Shopping, submitting details of how it intends to amend the price comparison service -- though these proposals have not been made public.

Not complying with the order would risk a regime of additional penalties that could be backdated to the date of any non-compliance. So it may be that Alphabet/Google is intending to seek to comply while still pursuing a legal challenge.

When reached by TechCrunch for comment a Google's spokesman declined to confirm whether it would be complying with the Commission's antitrust order while it pursues a legal challenge -- or to answer any questions. But a spokeswoman for the ECJ told us that Google has not lodged an application for interim measures.

She added: "On average, it takes between 18 months and 2 years from the day on which an appeal is lodged to final judgment being handed down."

So even if Google makes tweaks to the operation of Google Shopping in the short term, i.e. to avoid the risk of additional sanctions for non-compliance, years of uncertainty are being added to an antitrust investigation that has already clocked up more than six years of probes by EU regulators.

Meanwhile the Commission's antitrust arm has two ongoing formal investigations into Google's business practices -- specifically relating to the restrictions it places on OEMs encouraging them to bundle other Google services when using the Android mobile OS; and regarding its AdSense ad placement service. In both cases Google has denied the accusations, though the EC's competition commissioner said in June that the investigations were leaning towards further sanctions at that point.

She also said the EC is looking into other competition-related complaints against additional Google services -- including image search, maps and travel search, although as yet there are no formal investigations on those fronts.

  • This Is the Final Medal Count for Every Country at the 2018 Winter Olympics
    Sports
    Time

    This Is the Final Medal Count for Every Country at the 2018 Winter Olympics

    After 19 days of competition at the 2018 Winter Olympics in PyeongChang, South Korea, Norway came out on top of the final medal count. Norway’s dominance was apparent from the beginning of the Olympic Games, with 14 gold medal wins in sports like cross

  • Silicon Valley is so expensive that even Facebook and Apple employees can't afford to live near the office
    Business
    Business Insider

    Silicon Valley is so expensive that even Facebook and Apple employees can't afford to live near the office

    Silicon Valley's housing crisis is serious. A new report from Open Listings reveals that workers at five major tech companies, including Apple, Facebook, and Google, would have to spend over 28% of their salary to pay a monthly mortgage on a home near work. Software engineers at Apple have it worst.

  • General Electric to restate two years of earnings
    Business
    Reuters

    General Electric to restate two years of earnings

    The updated accounting standard, which will take into account revenue from long-term contracts, will result in a 13 cent cut in reported earnings per share for 2016 and a cut of 16 cents per share for 2017, according to the company's 10-K filing. GE is adopting the new accounting standards as the Securities and Exchange Commission investigates the company over its accounting for long-term service contracts. The changes also come as the company struggles to reverse steep declines in some of its businesses and is looking to sell off $20 billion of assets.

  • 3 Cryptocurrencies That Could Still Double
    Business
    Motley Fool

    3 Cryptocurrencies That Could Still Double

    What we as investors witnessed from cryptocurrencies last year is something that may not be duplicated again. A single asset class gained more than 3,300% in market cap (almost $600 billion) over a span of just 12 months. After beginning January on a high note, cryptocurrencies fell off a cliff, losing 67% of their market cap, from peak to trough, between Jan. 7 and Feb. 6.

  • Boeing to have 51 percent stake in venture with Embraer - paper
    Business
    Reuters

    Boeing to have 51 percent stake in venture with Embraer - paper

    Boeing Co (BA.N) will have a 51 percent stake in a joint company currently being negotiated with Brazilian aircraft maker Embraer (EMBR3.SA), O Globo newspaper columnist Lauro Jardim reported on Sunday. Boeing has agreed to a Brazilian government demand that the U.S. company have no more than a 51 percent controlling share, Jardim said, without citing sources. Embraer said it would not comment on the matter.

  • Warren Buffet Says Berkshire Hathaway Has a Unique Problem: Too Much Cash
    Business
    Newsweek

    Warren Buffet Says Berkshire Hathaway Has a Unique Problem: Too Much Cash

    Warren Buffett on Saturday lamented his inability to find big companies to buy, and said his goal is to make "one or more huge acquisitions" of non-insurance businesses to bolster results at his conglomerate Berkshire Hathaway Inc. In his annual letter to Berkshire shareholders, Buffett admitted that finding things to buy at a "sensible purchase price" has become a challenge, and is a major reason Berkshire is awash with $116 billion of low-yielding cash and government bonds. Buffett said a "purchasing frenzy" binge by deal-hungry chief executives employing cheap debt has made that task difficult. Berkshire typically pays all cash for acquisitions.

  • Bitcoin Cash, Litecoin and Ripple Daily Analysis – 25/02/18
    Business
    FX Empire

    Bitcoin Cash, Litecoin and Ripple Daily Analysis – 25/02/18

    A promising start to Saturday’s session ended in yet another tumble for Bitcoin Cash, which has had a dire start to the year. Last weekend, the Bitcoin Cash rally kicked in late Saturday and came to an end in just a few hours, with Bitcoin Cash hitting a weekend high $1,630, an intraday gain of 7.77%, before tumbling to $1,392.3 just a few hours later. This Saturday’s moves were certainly shallower, Bitcoin Cash moving to a Saturday high $1,298.9, an intraday gain of 3.75%, before falling to a low $1,129.4.

  • New tax scam can cause entire refund to vanish
    World
    KGO – San Francisco

    New tax scam can cause entire refund to vanish

    The IRS told the I-Team that people are being targeted by scams from all directions. Not only are there fake IRS calls, but there are new tax scams gaining popularity, including one where your entire tax return can vanish.

  • 4 Social Security Tips You Need to Know
    Lifestyle
    Motley Fool

    4 Social Security Tips You Need to Know

    Millions of seniors depend on Social Security to pay the bills in retirement, and the more you know about the program, the better positioned you'll be to make the most of your benefits. In fact, workers are often advised to wait until full retirement age to claim benefits because that's the point at which they'll be eligible to collect those payments in full. This means that if you were born in 1961, you'll need to hold off on filing for Social Security until age 67 to avoid a reduction in benefits.

  • Trump officials fight eviction from Panama hotel they manage
    Finance
    Associated Press

    Trump officials fight eviction from Panama hotel they manage

    One of President Donald Trump's family businesses is battling an effort to physically evict its team of executives from a luxury hotel in Panama where they manage operations, and police have been called to keep the peace, The Associated Press has learned. Witnesses told the AP they saw Trump's executives carrying files to a room for shredding. Representatives of the hotel owners' association formally sought to fire Trump's management team Thursday by hand-delivering termination notices to them at the Trump International Hotel and Tower, according to a Panamanian legal complaint filed by Orestes Fintiklis, who controls 202 of the property's 369 hotel units.

  • Nokia CEO sees big 5G rollouts nearly a year ahead of schedule
    Tech
    Reuters

    Nokia CEO sees big 5G rollouts nearly a year ahead of schedule

    BARCELONA/HELSINKI (Reuters) - Telecom operators are accelerating their timelines for the roll-out of next-generation 5G networks, lifting Nokia's confidence of an uplift for its business this year, Chief Executive Rajeev Suri said on Sunday. The telecom network industry, dominated by China's Huawei, Finland's Nokia and Sweden's Ericsson, is weathering the toughest part of a decade-long cycle as demand for 4G gear falls. "The confidence about where that 5G uplift comes from is understanding the accelerated timelines operators now have," Suri told Reuters in an interview ahead of the Mobile World Congress taking place in Barcelona this week.

  • America's Nightmare Flu Season Is Finally Coming to an End
    Business
    Fortune

    America's Nightmare Flu Season Is Finally Coming to an End

    The flu is on its way out. While still at epidemic levels, the historically bad 2017-2018 season has finally started to subside. Deaths caused by pneumonia and influenza fell to 9.5 percent of all fatalities across the country during the week ended Feb. 3, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s most recent data.

  • These 3 Dividend Stocks Offer Shares at a Discount
    Business
    Motley Fool

    These 3 Dividend Stocks Offer Shares at a Discount

    Dividend stocks can help investors benefit from the power of compounding. By reinvesting dividend payments to purchase additional shares of stock, you'll see the amount of income you receive grow over time, building on itself and creating a positive-feedback loop that can eventually produce huge amounts of income. In particular, Aqua America (NYSE: WTR), Franco-Nevada (NYSE: FNV), and Student Transportation (NASDAQ: STB) are three stocks that you can buy more cheaply through dividend reinvestment than you'll get on the open market.

  • American in Custody After Severed Head Is Found in Japan
    News
    Time

    American in Custody After Severed Head Is Found in Japan

    An American man is in custody in Japan after authorities found a severed head in a suitcase left in a lodging facility. Japanese investigators said the 26-year-old American was seen on security footage with a 27-year-old woman who went missing, The Japan Times reported. Police were investigating the woman’s disappearance when they came upon what appears to be her missing head, still inside a suitcase in an Osaka lodging facility, they said.

  • Latest Mueller indictment spells trouble for bankers, too
    Finance
    Associated Press

    Latest Mueller indictment spells trouble for bankers, too

    Recently filed federal charges against President Donald Trump's ex-campaign chairman Paul Manafort could also pose legal and regulatory risks for the banks that loaned him millions of dollars against his New York real estate in recent years. The most serious exposure may be for a Rhode Island-based bank that employed a "conspirator" in Manafort's scheme to obtain a loan he couldn't afford, according to the 32-count new indictment unsealed this week. Dubbed "Lender B" in court papers, Citizens Bank not only lent Manafort $3.4 million based off of fraudulent documents but, in another case, appeared to help Manafort avoid being caught by sending back a crudely falsified financial statement that had been sent to them from a Manafort associate, according to federal prosecutors.

  • 3 Reasons Traditional IRAs Are Better Than Roth IRAs
    Business
    Motley Fool

    3 Reasons Traditional IRAs Are Better Than Roth IRAs

    Saving for retirement is important, and someone making the most of the savings they're able to set aside will make a huge difference in how comfortable their retirement is. The federal government offers many tax-favored retirement savings vehicles, and one of the most popular is the IRA. One question millions of people face every year is whether to use a traditional or Roth IRA.

  • Why one major bank is refunding more than $330 million to customers
    Business
    KGO – San Francisco

    Why one major bank is refunding more than $330 million to customers

    Citi will soon refund more than $330 million to nearly 2 million credit card accounts.

  • This Growth Stock Looks Like an Incredible Bargain After Getting Pummeled This Week
    Business
    Motley Fool

    This Growth Stock Looks Like an Incredible Bargain After Getting Pummeled This Week

    This week was a rough one for U.S. oil and gas giant Devon Energy (NYSE: DVN). Devon Energy's stock might be down now, but the recovery looks to be just ahead. Two related factors drove Devon Energy's sell-off this week.

  • In Your 60s? 3 Stocks You Should Consider Buying
    Business
    Motley Fool

    In Your 60s? 3 Stocks You Should Consider Buying

    OK, those of us in our 60s know this already, but I'm going to say it anyway: We are not old. The Pew Research Center conducted a study of aging and found that the definition of old age depends on who you ask. Well, I admit that how we feel about aging might not matter much in investing, but what does matter is longevity.

  • Best Dividend Stocks This Month
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    Best Dividend Stocks This Month

    Valero Energy is one of the top dividend stocks I think are worth considering today. A large part of investment returns can be generated by dividend-paying stock given their role in compounding returns over time. If you’re a long term investor, these high-performing top dividend stocks can boost your monthly portfolio income.

  • Trump Said to Weigh 'Red Flag' Orders to Take Guns Away Quickly
    Politics
    Time

    Trump Said to Weigh 'Red Flag' Orders to Take Guns Away Quickly

    The White House is considering the idea of using restraining orders to take firearms away from people considered dangerous as part of its response to last week’s massacre at a Florida high school, two people familiar with the matter said. Under extreme risk protection orders, which are also known as red flag laws or gun violence restraining orders, firearms can be confiscated from people found to be at risk. The White House is studying an Indiana version of the law, and is considering other measures as well, according to the people, who requested anonymity to discuss policy deliberations.

  • Adam Schiff's Memo Has Been Released. Here's What It Says
    Politics
    Time

    Adam Schiff's Memo Has Been Released. Here's What It Says

    Democrats on the the House Intelligence Committee on Saturday released a memo prepared as a counter to the one overseen by the committee’s chairman Devin Nunes that was publicized earlier this month. Overseen by Rep. Adam Schiff, the ranking Democrat on the committee, the memo from the Democrats attempts to contextualize the Nunes memo, which argued that the FBI displayed bias in obtaining a FISA warrant for former Trump campaign adviser Carter Page. That memo alleges that the FBI failed to disclose Christopher Steele, who compiled the notorious Steele dossier, was working for Fusion GPS or the firm’s founder Glenn Simpson, and that Deputy FBI Director Andrew McCabe — who is stepping down —said the FBI would not have sought a warrant without the dossier.

  • 3 Cheap Dividend Stocks That Helped Warren Buffett Earn $3.7 Billion in Dividends in 2017
    Business
    Insider Monkey

    3 Cheap Dividend Stocks That Helped Warren Buffett Earn $3.7 Billion in Dividends in 2017

    Warren Buffett, the revered billionaire investor and Chairman and CEO of $500 billion holding company Berkshire Hathaway, just released his annual shareholder letter in which he discussed a number of intriguing topics. Perhaps the most noteworthy one was the revelation that Republican tax cuts contributed $29 billion to Berkshire Hathaway Inc. (NYSE:BRK.A)‘s bottom-line last year. That clearly proved irksome to Buffett, who supported Hillary Clinton during the 2016 Presidential Elections and was not fond of the idea of tax cuts for the wealthy. As Buffett made clear in the letter, the windfall “did not come from anything we accomplished at Berkshire.” The letter also revealed that Berkshire earned

  • 8 memorable quotes from Warren Buffett's newest shareholder letter
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    8 memorable quotes from Warren Buffett's newest shareholder letter

    In his annual letter to Berkshire Hathaway (BRK-A, BRK-B) shareholders, legendary investor Warren Buffett muses on the M&A environment, his aversion to leverage, opportunities to buy during downturns, and his disregard for fees charged by active managers.

  • Warren Buffett: Investors handicapped by debt miss 'extraordinary opportunities'
    Business
    Yahoo Finance

    Warren Buffett: Investors handicapped by debt miss 'extraordinary opportunities'

    It’s impossible to accurately know when the next market decline will be, according to legendary investor Warren Buffett. It’s important to remember that even Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway (BRK-A, BRK-B) hasn’t been immune to significant swings in its stock price either. “This table offers the strongest argument I can muster against ever using borrowed money to own stocks.