U.S. Markets closed

How to Haggle Right: 4 Tips for Negotiating the Best Salary

Arnie Fertig

"What are your salary expectations?"

This is commonly one of the first questions you're asked when interviewing for a new job. Employers want to get this question out in the open for a few reasons: 1) They want to get a general sense if you're willing to work at or below the top of their pay scale for a given job, and 2) they are in effect, asking you to negotiate against yourself, at the point in discussions when you have the least negotiating leverage. Job hunters are often at a loss (figuratively and literally) trying to both get the job and obtain the highest possible compensation. Here's how to do it:

1. Be responsive, but don't commit early on. Talk about your current and/or recent compensation level. Make certain to distinguish between "base" and "total" compensation. Then, pivot the focus away from salary to talk about the real purpose of the discussion at this stage, from your perspective: To determine if you and the employer make a great fit. Quickly close this part of the conversation by saying, "I'm sure that you agree that if I'm not the right fit for this position, it doesn't matter how much I want or how much you're likely to pay to whomever you hire. And, if it is a great fit, we will each work to treat each other fairly when it comes to determining a specific salary for this job, right?"

2. Find objective data to justify your request. Employers hire human resources professionals whose sole focus is dealing with employee compensation issues. They have access to a great deal of data, accumulated through industry research and other sources. You need to level the "information battleground" as best as you can. Research sites like Salary.com, Payscale.com, Jobstar.org, and a host of others to get as much knowledge as possible about how people with similar skills and education, years of experience, and levels of responsibility are compensated nationwide and in your particular geographic area.

3. Figure out your ZOPA. The first rule of negotiations is that sellers always have some level below which they will not sell--but no maximum on what they're willing to receive. For buyers, it is the opposite. As a buyer, you aren't likely to say, "I'm not willing to paying less than X" for whatever you're buying. But buyers do have at an upper limit of what they're willing to pay.

When you're negotiating for a position, you are the seller of your services, and the company is the buyer. Your ZOPA is the Zone Of Possible Agreement. Barring other factors, like other jobs you might accept or other candidates the employer might hire, there is a whole range of possible salary numbers that could be mutually acceptable. That zone is anything between the upper limit of what the company is willing to pay, and, at the same time, anything above the lowest amount you're willing to accept.

Chances are, you will never have perfect information to determine a ZOPA, but as you do your research you can approach it.

4. Talk about creating fairness and finding common ground. Remember that it is imperative to always keep a friendly tone, and base your arguments on objective facts, not your particular needs or desires. You can go far by asking probing questions with a smile on your face. In the course of your discussion you might use statements and questions like these:

"You know, I'm excited about doing this job, and I'd love to work here. But I'm curious if you could explain the basis of why you're offering X dollars?"

If they can't come up with anything compelling, this is when you bring your research to the fore:

"I know that you've had the opportunity to review many resumes and interview other candidates. I'm really flattered and thrilled that you think I'm a better fit than my competition. Given all that, I've been looking to figure out what a fair level of compensation would be. Salary survey 'such and such' suggests that there is a range of X to Y for this kind of work in this geographic area, with an average of Z. I'm sure you and I agree at this point that I'm far better than average at doing this work. Wouldn't it be fair to expect compensation that would reflect that shared judgment?

Of course, there can be counter arguments, and alternate facts will enter into the discussion. But when you negotiate based on facts and principles rather than whims and desires you show yourself to be reasonable and a solid professional. It is really hard at this point to argue against fairness, and you're well on your way to getting the highest possible compensation for the value you bring to your new job.

Happy hunting!

Arnie Fertig is the head coach of JOBHUNTERCOACH.COM, where he utilizes his extensive background in HR Staffing and as owner of a recruiting company to help mid-career job-hunters land their next job. Arnie provides one-to-one coaching services to individuals throughout the U.S. in all aspects of the job hunt, including: resume writing, personal branding, utilizing social media, enhancing networking skills, preparing for interviews, and negotiating compensation.



More From US News & World Report

  • These Companies Are Sticking By The NRA
    Business
    HuffPost

    These Companies Are Sticking By The NRA

    NRA officials have gone on the attack to rail against the “politicization” of a tragedy, and going so far as to suggest that members of the media “love mass shootings” because of the ratings they supposedly bring. Enterprise Holdings, which operates the rental car brands Enterprise, National and Alamo, says it will end its discount program for NRA members next month, along with Avis and Budget.

  • Russian Olympian Who Wore an 'I Don't Do Doping' Slogan Shirt Just Failed Her Drug Test
    World
    Time

    Russian Olympian Who Wore an 'I Don't Do Doping' Slogan Shirt Just Failed Her Drug Test

    Nadezhda Sergeeva, pilot of the two-woman bobsled team representing the Olympic Athletes from Russia, proudly proclaimed her anti-doping stance when she appeared in a YouTube video wearing a sweatshirt with the slogan “I don’t do doping” stamped brightly across the front. The federation says that the bobsledder does not have a prescription for the drug.

  • President Trump Went Way Off Script and Turned His CPAC Speech into a Campaign Rally
    Politics
    Time

    President Trump Went Way Off Script and Turned His CPAC Speech into a Campaign Rally

    When President Donald Trump took the stage at the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) Friday morning, he clearly wanted to have some fun. For more than an hour, Trump held court, largely eschewing a teleprompter filled with prepared remarks on North Korea sanctions and remembrances for Billy Graham and the victims of the Parkland, Fla. shooting, instead choosing to ramble enthusiastically about familiar themes in his typical campaign style. Early in his CPAC speech, Trump caught a glimpse of himself in a TV monitor and joked, “I try like hell to hide the bald spot,” turning around to show the audience the back of his head.

  • Lisa Marie Presley Sues Manager for 'Reckless Mismanagement' of $100 Million Elvis Fortune
    Celebrity
    People

    Lisa Marie Presley Sues Manager for 'Reckless Mismanagement' of $100 Million Elvis Fortune

    Lisa Marie Presley and her financial manager Barry Siegel are in a legal battle after it was revealed that she’s $16.7 million in debt — Presley going after his “reckless and negligent mismanagement” of her inherited estate and Siegel claiming she “squandered” her own fortune due to her “excessive spending” habits. Much of that, she alleges, began in 2005 when Siegel sold 85 percent of her interest in Elvis Presley Enterprises in order to align himself with a famous investor tied to the holding company of American Idol. By 2016, Presley claims Siegel had liquidated almost all of the trust’s remaining principles — especially after the Idol holding company went bankrupt.

  • General Electric Cuts $2.4 Billion Off S&P-Worst Pension Deficit
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    General Electric Cuts $2.4 Billion Off S&P-Worst Pension Deficit

    General Electric Co. trimmed its pension deficit by $2.4 billion as the manufacturer tackles the worst shortfall in corporate America. The company closed 2017 with $100.3 billion in obligations across its pension plans and $71.6 billion in assets. Pension funding has become a central issue for GE stakeholders concerned about how the beleaguered company will meet its obligations while dealing with severe cash-flow and earnings challenges.

  • In 1961 a Plane Crash Killed the Entire U.S. Figure Skating Team. Here's How the Tragic Legacy Lives On
    News
    Time

    In 1961 a Plane Crash Killed the Entire U.S. Figure Skating Team. Here's How the Tragic Legacy Lives On

    Fifty-seven years ago this month, the U.S. figure skating team was devastated by a plane crash. The star-spangled athletes were on their way to compete at the 1961 World Figure Skating Championships in Prague, where they were expected to score medals and launch into preparations for the 1964 Olympics. The tragedy was mourned across the nation and shattered the figure skating world, which the U.S. had dominated for over a decade.

  • Broward Sheriff Deputy Resigns After Video Shows He Avoided School Shooting
    News
    Time

    Broward Sheriff Deputy Resigns After Video Shows He Avoided School Shooting

    The Broward sheriff deputy assigned to Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School resigned on Thursday, about a week after a school shooting there that left 17 people dead. Scot Peterson, a school resource officer from the Broward County Sheriff’s office, waited outside the school building without ever going inside, sheriff Scott Israel said during a news conference on Thursday. “What I saw was a deputy arrive at the west side of building 12, take up a position, and he never went in,” Israel said Thursday, referring to the school building where the shooter went on his rampage.

  • Girl injured by dog during boarding for Southwest flight
    Lifestyle
    Associated Press

    Girl injured by dog during boarding for Southwest flight

    Southwest Airlines said Thursday that a dog injured a child as passengers boarded a flight in Phoenix, an event likely to fuel the debate over the growing number of emotional-support animals on planes. A passenger on Wednesday's Phoenix-to-Portland, Oregon, flight tweeted that a dog bit a girl as she approached it, and that she screamed and cried. Southwest said the dog's teeth "scraped a child's forehead" and paramedics checked the girl, who appeared to be 6 or 7 years old.

  • Michael B. Jordan Had a Hilarious Response to an Internet Troll's Judgmental Opinion
    Celebrity
    Time

    Michael B. Jordan Had a Hilarious Response to an Internet Troll's Judgmental Opinion

    Michael B. Jordan’s charismatic turn as villain Erik Killmonger in Black Panther has commanded the collective attention of the Internet, some of who have taken it upon themselves to do extensive research into how Jordan lives his life off-camera, which has prompted a response from the actor himself. In an interview last year with Vogue, Jordan revealed that he shares a home with his parents and that he’d love to visit Tokyo, Japan because he loves anime, two facts that a Twitter user slyly pointed out might not be as endearing if they hadn’t come from the charming Fruitvale Station actor. As might be expected, the tweet went viral, catching the attention of Jordan himself, who had a pithy clap back to the tweet of his own.

  • Trump, Russia collusion disproved by Rick Gates plea: Corey Lewandowski
    Politics
    Fox Business Videos

    Trump, Russia collusion disproved by Rick Gates plea: Corey Lewandowski

    ‘Let Trump Be Trump’ co-author and former Trump campaign manager Corey Lewandowski says the Rick Gates plea proves there was no collusion between the campaign and Russia.

  • Top Dividend Stocks Warren Buffett Is Buying Now
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Top Dividend Stocks Warren Buffett Is Buying Now

    Warren Buffett's ability to pick winning stocks for long-term gains makes knowing what stocks he's buying for Berkshire Hathaway's (NYSE: BRK-A) (NYSE: BRK-B) portfolio worthwhile. Fortunately, Berkshire Hathaway -- like all big investors -- must file a 13F report with the Securities and Exchange Commission each quarter that shows what Warren Buffett's been up to. The latest report shows he's been picking up shares in dividend companies, including The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation (NYSE: BK), Apple Inc. (NASDAQ: AAPL), and Monsanto (NYSE: MON).

  • New Ferrari looks a big step up, says Vettel
    Sports
    Reuters

    New Ferrari looks a big step up, says Vettel

    Ferrari's new SF71H Formula One car already looks a big step up from last year's before it has turned a wheel in anger, four times world champion Sebastian Vettel said at Thursday's unveiling. Vettel won five races last season but finished runner-up to Mercedes' Lewis Hamilton, who is now also a four times world champion.

  • Why Nvidia (NVDA) Stock Is the Cheapest It's Been in Nearly a Year
    Finance
    Zacks

    Why Nvidia (NVDA) Stock Is the Cheapest It's Been in Nearly a Year

    It is no secret that Nvidia NVDA is one of Wall Street’s most popular stocks. The graphics chip maker is a dominant force in the global gaming industry, and its tireless investments in self-driving cars, machine learning, and artificial intelligence all but guarantee the company a spot among the tech industry’s leaders for years to come. Nvidia’s leadership and innovation have also led to a massive surge in the company’s stock.

  • Citigroup to refund $335 million of credit card interest charges
    Business
    Reuters

    Citigroup to refund $335 million of credit card interest charges

    Citigroup Inc (C.N) said on Friday that it had failed to properly reduce interest charges on some 1.75 million credit card accounts since 2011, prompting a $335 million (239.65 million pounds) refund to customers later this year. The refund, which will average $190 per account, stems from the bank's discovery that it had not used a proper method for reducing interest charges for cardholders who resumed timely payments after having had to pay penalty rates for lapses. The errors amounted to about 10 percent of the interest reductions cardholders were due, the bank said.

  • Hyundai Overtakes Its German Luxury Car Rivals
    Business
    Bloomberg Video

    Hyundai Overtakes Its German Luxury Car Rivals

    Feb.22 -- In its debut year, Hyundai’s luxury line bumped Volkswagen AG’s Audi from top billing to the No. 2 spot, with premium mainstays BMW, Toyota Motor Corp.’s Lexus and VW’s Porsche rounding out the top five. Bloomberg's Dave McCombs reports on "Bloomberg Daybreak: Asia."

  • This Las Vegas Airport Is Letting People Dump Their Marijuana Before Flying
    News
    Time

    This Las Vegas Airport Is Letting People Dump Their Marijuana Before Flying

    Tourists catching a flight out of Sin City can now dump their leftover legal marijuana in metal containers set up at the airport. The 10 green bins dubbed “amnesty boxes” prevent federal transportation agents from finding pot on passengers during security screenings. The containers were installed last week following a county ban on marijuana possession and advertising at McCarran International Airport, aiming to keep it in compliance with federal law.

  • U.S. Companies Abandon the NRA as Boycott Call Grows
    Business
    Bloomberg

    U.S. Companies Abandon the NRA as Boycott Call Grows

    A call to boycott the National Rifle Association became the top trend on Twitter as users of the global social media platform demanded that a variety of companies sever ties with the lobbying group. The online furor comes a day after the NRA’s leaders attacked the media and Democrats, claiming the fallout from last week’s Florida high school massacre was being politicized. One user, with almost a quarter of a million followers, tagged a slew of brands in his post, including NRA partners Hertz Corp. and LifeLock Inc. “There are only 5 million NRA members but over 300 million of us! Businesses have a choice whose business they prefer,” tweeted another.

  • President Trump Still Hasn't Forgiven John McCain for Killing Obamacare Repeal
    Politics
    Time

    President Trump Still Hasn't Forgiven John McCain for Killing Obamacare Repeal

    President Donald Trump has again blasted Sen. John McCain for voting against the repeal and replacement of the Affordable Care Act last summer — but did not once call him by name. “We’re having tremendous plans coming out now, healthcare plans, at a fraction of the cost, that are much better than Obamacare,” Trump said Friday at the Conservative Political Action Conference. “Remember — one person walked into a room when he was supposed to go this way,” Trump added, giving a thumbs up sign, “and he walked in and went this way [thumbs down] and everyone said, ‘What happened?

  • GE says it may face U.S. action over subprime mortgage operations
    Business
    Reuters

    GE says it may face U.S. action over subprime mortgage operations

    General Electric Co (GE.N) faces potential action by the U.S. Justice Department over allegations that its GE Capital unit and now defunct WMC Mortgage Corp unit violated U.S. law in connection with subprime mortgages, according to a regulatory filing on Friday. GE said the department "is likely to assert" violation of the Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act of 1989 (FIRREA) "in connection with WMC's origination and sale of subprime mortgage loans in 2006 and 2007," the filing said. "WMC and GE Capital will explore whether an acceptable settlement of this matter can be reached.

  • Canada's Trudeau spurs criticism, raises eyebrows on India trip
    World
    Reuters

    Canada's Trudeau spurs criticism, raises eyebrows on India trip

    By Andrea Hopkins and Nidhi Verma OTTAWA/NEW DELHI (Reuters) - Canadian and Indian officials scrambled on Thursday to explain how a convicted Sikh extremist was invited to a New Delhi reception for Justin Trudeau, the latest misstep in the Canadian prime minister's bumpy eight-day trip to India. The tour has been overshadowed by suggestions of a lukewarm reception by the government and a series of photo ops featuring the Trudeau family in coordinated Indian attire that have raised eyebrows in both countries. The latest flashpoint, a swiftly cancelled invitation by the Canadian delegation to Jaspal Atwal -- convicted in 1986 of the attempted murder of an Indian politician visiting Canada -- came just days after Trudeau had assured his hosts he would not support anyone trying to revive a separatist movement in India.

  • 3 Stocks That Feel Like Microsoft in 1986
    Business
    Motley Fool

    3 Stocks That Feel Like Microsoft in 1986

    Investors who bought into Microsoft's (NASDAQ: MSFT) growth story early and held on for the long term minted themselves an absolute fortune. Dan Caplinger (Match Group): There's nothing new about trying to find romance, but there's been a revolutionary change in the way that people seek out potential partners. Match Group has tapped into the needs of the mobile generation by extending its traditional online dating service to the app world, with its popular Tinder platform seeing its membership rolls nearly double in 2017 to 3.1 million members.

  • MGM Resorts Struggles on the Las Vegas Strip
    Business
    Motley Fool

    MGM Resorts Struggles on the Las Vegas Strip

    Revenue was up 5.5% for MGM Resorts to $2.6 billion and net income jumped from $24.7 million a year ago to $1.4 billion, or $2.42 per share. Digging into the numbers, you get a picture of why MGM Resorts had an underwhelming quarter in what seemed to be a favorable operating environment. Revenue per available room was down 4.9% on the Las Vegas Strip, driven by high-end resorts like Bellagio, MGM Grand Las Vegas, and Mandalay Bay all having both lower average daily room rates and lower occupancy versus a year ago.

  • In One Tweet, Kylie Jenner Wiped Out $1.3 Billion of Snap’s Market Value
    Business
    Bloomberg

    In One Tweet, Kylie Jenner Wiped Out $1.3 Billion of Snap’s Market Value

    Snap Inc.’s flagship platform has lost some luster, at least according to one social-media influencer in the Kardashian-Jenner clan. Shares of the Snapchat parent company sank 6.1 percent on Thursday, wiping out $1.3 billion in market value, on the heels of a tweet on Wednesday from Kylie Jenner, who said she doesn’t open the app anymore. Whether it’s the demands of her newfound motherhood, or the recent app redesign, the testament drew similar replies from her 24.5 million followers. Wall Street analysts too have begun to notice, citing recent user engagement trends noticed since the platform’s redesign.  Jenner’s tweet was followed late Thursday by one from Maybelline New York, asking its followers

  • 3 Top AI Stocks in China to Buy Now
    Business
    Motley Fool

    3 Top AI Stocks in China to Buy Now

    While it's widely regarded as the leader in the field of artificial intelligence (AI), the United States isn't the only country producing advanced AI technology. China currently lags the U.S. in AI research, but the Middle Kingdom has announced to the world that it's no longer content to remain in the shadow of the West. Last July, the government of China announced an ambitious policy regarding AI: close the gap with the U.S. in terms of AI research within three years and become the world leader in the field by 2030.

  • Dear America, here's how other countries stop mass shootings
    News
    Quartz

    Dear America, here's how other countries stop mass shootings

    Yesterday, Donald Trump met with a group of students, teachers, and parents to discuss last week’s school shooting massacre in Parkland, Florida and the uniquely American epidemic of school shootings. Referring to the shootings, Trump asked his guests, “Does anyone have any ideas for how to stop it?” The White House’s selected guests suggested a variety of areas to troubleshoot: Mental illness, bullying, FBI negligence, gun-free zones (which the president has publicly blamed for attracting “maniacs”), censorship, partisanship, lack of relatedness, obsession with identity, lack of expert “consultants,” lack of safety training for students, and even the absence of armed, undercover police in schools.