U.S. Markets open in 7 hrs 37 mins

The impeachment rules fight is another blowup in the slow destruction of Congress

Edward Morrissey

If politics is just warfare by other means, both Mitch McConnell and Chuck Schumer have decided to drag out the heavy artillery in advance of the Senate impeachment trial of President Trump.

The Senate majority leader's rules proposal passed, thanks to the simple majority required, which itself is part of a pitted landscape in the upper chamber after nearly 20 years of partisan one-upmanship. That proposal will govern a process that might be more about settling scores with the House and with the Senate Democratic minority than it has to do with Trump or his handling of Ukraine aid.

One has to wonder just how much of this will have to do with the case against the president at all. It's just as questionable, after three years of impeachment demands from and to House Democrats, how much the push to impeach Trump has to do with a delay in aid to Ukraine. We have spent the last 20-plus years coming to an inevitable war between Republicans and Democrats in the Beltway, one that will determine whether the institutions matter more than party affiliation.

To grasp this, one needs to walk backward to 1999. Earlier this month, McConnell refused to sit down with House Speaker Nancy Pelosi or disclose his rules proposal to her before she sent over the articles of Trump's impeachment, claiming the House Democratic majority was trying to unduly influence Senate operations. During the three-week standoff, McConnell repeatedly said that he would use the rules package from Bill Clinton's 1999 impeachment trial, which put off any votes on witnesses until after the presentment of the case. That rules proposal got unanimously adopted, including a vote from then-newly elected Senator Chuck Schumer.

Pelosi finally gave up last week and transmitted the articles. By Monday, however, McConnell had adopted a new wrinkle in the Clinton-trial rules. It still used the same framework for voting on witnesses, but McConnell added a section that required a vote on admitting House-developed evidence. In previous trials, the House evidence was admitted automatically. That set Democrats off. They claimed that McConnell was cooking the trial, which might have pushed his grip on the majority just a little too far. By Tuesday afternoon, that rule had been replaced, subject to a hearsay objection and floor vote on specific House evidence.

But what prompted that rule change in the first place? Republicans had seethed while House chairs Adam Schiff and Jerrold Nadler had used their majoritarian authority to largely sideline them in the impeachment process. Rather than go to court to bid for testimony, Schiff and Nadler jammed through the articles of impeachment without any first-hand testimony or evidence of wrongdoing. Republicans saw this as a continuation of the Democrats' efforts to impeach Trump over the earlier Russia-collusion hypothesis, which fell apart after Robert Mueller's special counsel probe found no evidence for the theory.

Part of the animus driving Democrats was the way in which Republicans had muscled their way to Trump's first Supreme Court nomination. Barack Obama had nominated Merrick Garland after the death of Antonin Scalia in January 2016, a nomination McConnell had blocked with his Senate majority at the time. Democrats had at times threatened to do this in the past; Joe Biden in particular mentioned the possibility in 2007 and 1991, but the opportunity never arose for an election-year nomination. Chuck Schumer then attempted to filibuster the confirmation of Neil Gorsuch, which led McConnell to change the Senate rules to eliminate the filibuster on Supreme Court nominations.

And that resulted from Harry Reid's so-called "nuclear option" in 2013, in which he contradicted long-standing precedent to allow a simple Senate majority to change the rules in mid-session. Republicans at that time were using the filibuster to obstruct Obama's appointments to the D.C. Circuit appellate court. That was in payback for Senate Democrats' own obstructionism during the George W. Bush administration on federal judicial appointments, starting in 2002 and leading to a famous showdown and compromise in 2005.

It is this partisan escalation, in Capitol Hill in general and the Senate in particular, which has led the nation to this impasse. Both sides are trying mightily to claim the moral high ground in the impeachment fight and rules debate, but both sides have also done their best to cook the process for their own ends. Georgetown Law professor Jonathan Turley, who spoke in opposition to impeachment on institutional grounds (although no fan of Trump in other respects), concluded on Tuesday afternoon that both parties have run this into the ground. "The tide of hypocrisy washing over the Hill today," Turley quipped on CBS, "was enough to take the dome off its foundations."

Given the partisan warfare around the impeachment, the trial outcome is all but certain. Of more concern, however, should be the damage done to the legislative branch over the last two decades. This poisonous atmosphere of majoritarian flexing has transformed Congress from a co-equal branch to either the wingman or the executioner of the president. With this partisan war as context, succeeding House majorities will feel freer to impeach any president of the opposing party on any pretext, especially by launching constant investigations that encroach on the executive's co-equal status and automatically considering any objection to be obstructive. We will either have parliamentary systems with the executive under the thumb of the House, or presidencies entirely unencumbered by an independent legislature.

At some point, we need leadership on Capitol Hill that restores its own prerogatives while respecting the prerogatives of the executive. This would benefit both parties in the long run, and it would return the federal government to actual representative democracy. Unfortunately, after two decades in the trenches of the Democrat-Republican war, there doesn't seem to be any leaders emerging of that quality — nor a lot of demand from anyone else to produce them.

Want more essential commentary and analysis like this delivered straight to your inbox? Sign up for The Week's "Today's best articles" newsletter here.

More stories from theweek.com
Stephen Colbert and Samantha Bee advise GOP senators to save themselves, subpoena Trump's secrets
Several senators left the chamber in the middle of Adam Schiff's impeachment remarks
With her proud students watching, Florida teacher becomes a U.S. citizen

  • Dow Jones Futures Dive As Stock Market Faces Coronavirus Pandemic Fears; Apple Eyes Buy Point
    Investor's Business Daily

    Dow Jones Futures Dive As Stock Market Faces Coronavirus Pandemic Fears; Apple Eyes Buy Point

    Dow Jones futures dived Sunday night, along with S&P 500 futures and Nasdaq futures, on fears that a global coronavirus pandemic is possible. The stock market rally took a step back last week on coronavirus fears, with Apple warning that'll miss revenue targets due to the Covid-19 virus. Coronavirus cases are picking up outside of China, notably in South Korea and Italy.

  • Morgan Stanley is paying $2,500 per customer for E-Trade. You can earn a $3,500 sign-up bonus for signing with a new broker — with one major catch

    Morgan Stanley is paying $2,500 per customer for E-Trade. You can earn a $3,500 sign-up bonus for signing with a new broker — with one major catch

    If the latest Wall Street mega-deal doesn't make you want to switch online brokerage accounts for a lucrative sign-up bonus, maybe it should. Wall Street giant Morgan Stanley announced an agreement Thursday to pay $13 billion to acquire the online brokerage E-Trade which has 5.2 million customer accounts. “The combination will significantly increase the scale and breadth of Morgan Stanley's Wealth Management franchise, and positions Morgan Stanley to be an industry leader in Wealth Management across all channels and wealth segments,” Morgan Stanley said in a statement.

  • Here's what smart investors do with their 401(k)s when the stock market is hitting highs

    Here's what smart investors do with their 401(k)s when the stock market is hitting highs

    Rarely do investors consider defensive moves in their 401(k)s when stocks are  rallying, but that is precisely when you should begin thinking about diversifying your investments. When stocks get squirrely, I recall a comment from my old colleague, Noel, who used to declare, 'Well, it's either the warning bell or the dinner bell.' More often than not, as we have discussed in previous columns, it's the dinner bell. From the time I began investing in 1987 through last year, stocks, as measured by the Dow Jones industrial average, have generated positive returns in 27 of 33 years, or 82% of the annual periods over that time span.

  • Millions of Chinese Firms Face Collapse If Banks Don’t Act

    Millions of Chinese Firms Face Collapse If Banks Don’t Act

    “If we can't pay back the bonds, it will be very, very bad,” said Brigita, whose company has 10,000 employees and sells mid- to high-end car brands such as BMWs. With much of China's economy still idled as authorities try to contain an epidemic that has infected more than 75,000 people, millions of companies across the country are in a race against the clock to stay afloat. While China's government has cut interest rates, ordered banks to boost lending and loosened criteria for companies to restart operations, many of the nation's private businesses say they've been unable to access the funding they need to meet upcoming deadlines for debt and salary payments.

  • Business

    Stock Futures Are Getting Hammered Because Coronavirus Is Still Spreading

    After dropping 228 points on Friday, the Dow Jones Industrial Average is looking set for another drop of more than 300 points as coronavirus fears grow. Dow futures have dropped 356 points, or 1.2%, while S&P 500 futures have fallen 1.2%, and Nasdaq Composite futures have slumped 1.6%. For JonesTrading's Michael O'Rourke, last Friday's drop was due to the market finally realizing that coronavirus would hit the global economy.

  • Here are Warren Buffett's top 15 stock holdings
    Yahoo Finance

    Here are Warren Buffett's top 15 stock holdings

    Some of the top holdings include American Express (AXP), Apple (AAPL), Bank of America (BAC), and Delta Airlines DAL , according to Buffett's widely-read annual letter. Buffett wrote that he doesn't view these investments as "stock market wagers — dalliances to be terminated because of downgrades by 'the Street,' an earnings' miss,' expected Federal Reserve actions, possible political developments, forecasts by economists or whatever else might be the subject du jour." Rather than stock holdings, Buffett views these as companies Berkshire Hathaway "partly owns."

  • Stocks Slide as Virus Case Rise Heightens Concern: Markets Wrap

    Stocks Slide as Virus Case Rise Heightens Concern: Markets Wrap

    U.S. equity futures sank with Asian shares and gold surged after the number of coronavirus cases outside of China increased and concern grew that global economic growth could take a more sustained hit. Seoul saw the brunt of losses, down more than 3%, with declines also in Hong Kong, Sydney and Shanghai. Weakness in S&P 500 Index and Euro Stoxx 50 futures also reflected the caution from traders to news over the weekend that finance chiefs and central bankers from the world's largest economies see downside risks to the global economy persisting.

  • Virus Outbreak Exposes $46 Billion Rift in China’s Tech Industry

    Virus Outbreak Exposes $46 Billion Rift in China’s Tech Industry

    Chinese businesses like Alibaba and Meituan with outsized footprints in the material world are rushing to contain the fallout while virtual denizens ByteDance Inc. and Tencent Holdings Ltd. ride a surge in social media and entertainment. Alibaba Group Holding Ltd. and Meituan Dianping have shed $28 billion of market value since Covid-19 erupted in central China in January because they depend on millions of people and trucks to ferry packages and meals through an increasingly tangled nationwide transport network. WeChat operator Tencent, which flogs virtual goods like costumes and armor in mobile games or sprinkles advertising online, has gained about $18 billion.

  • The ugly side to the booming U.S. economy, in one telling chart

    The ugly side to the booming U.S. economy, in one telling chart

    They have jobs but are living paycheck to paycheck, and not because they're splurging but because, at their level of the economy, prices of basic goods and services have run away from them. Richter said this group of people is getting hit by nosebleed costs in health care, education, and housing to the point where they're getting “strung out. They're just not benefiting from bigger paydays and the fact that stocks are soaring.

  • 'Flat earther' dies in rocket crash
    Associated Press Videos

    'Flat earther' dies in rocket crash

    A California man who said he wanted to fly to the edge of outer space to see if the world is round has died after his home-built rocket blasted off into the desert sky and plunged back to earth. Feb.

  • Business

    Barron's Picks And Pans: AT&T, Kroger, Virgin Galactic And More

    Cover story "Wall Street Takes Over Main Street" by Daren Fonda and Andrew Bary shares why the Morgan Stanley (NYSE: MS) deal for E*TRADE Financial Corp (NASDAQ: ETFC) heats up big banks' race to land more retail investors. Jack Hough's "It's Time to Build a Stake In Caterpillar" suggests that earnings could be bottoming out at construction, mining and energy and transportation machine maker Caterpillar Inc. NYSE: CAT).

  • Bearish Bets: 2 Stocks You Should Consider Shorting This Week

    Bearish Bets: 2 Stocks You Should Consider Shorting This Week

    Using recent actions and grades from TheStreet's Quant Ratings and layering on technical analysis of the charts of those stocks, Trifecta Stocks identifies five names each week that look bearish. While we will not be weighing in with fundamental analysis we hope this piece will give investors interested in stocks on the way down a good starting point to do further homework on the names. Dillard's Inc. recently was downgraded to Hold with a C+ rating by TheStreet's Quant Ratings.

  • Coronavirus, consumer sentiment, GDP, retail earnings: What to know in the week ahead
    Yahoo Finance

    Coronavirus, consumer sentiment, GDP, retail earnings: What to know in the week ahead

    The Conference Board's consumer sentiment index has risen for three straight months between November and January. The Conference Board's consumer confidence index should remain elevated in February. Jobless claims remain low and wages are slowly by steadily rising,” Wells Fargo Securities economists wrote in a note Friday.

  • Is Tesla Really The Emerging ‘Energy King’?

    Is Tesla Really The Emerging ‘Energy King’?

    About 22 months ago, Tesla Inc. (NASDAQ:TSLA) CEO Elon Musk fired an ominous warning that the shorts were about to experience 'the short burn of the century.' The heads-up came at a time of intense short interest in the company, with the CEO even threatening to take Tesla private. The foreboding [for the bears] came after Tesla posted a surprise second quarter profit that pushed the shares to an eight-month high. The second wave came after Beijing gave Tesla the go-ahead to build a $5bn gigafactory in Shanghai, the first facility outside the U.S.

  • How Strategists and Investors See Coronavirus Playing Out

    How Strategists and Investors See Coronavirus Playing Out

    Italy's government imposed a lockdown on an area of 50,000 people near Milan and took other measures as infections exceeded 130. Here's what strategists and investors are saying about the developments. “With cases of COVID-19 still rising, it is hard to tell when manufacturing will bottom, potentially setting the stage for prolonged weakness,” said Vishnu Varathan, head of economics and strategy at Mizuho Bank Ltd. in Singapore.

  • Warren Buffett says Berkshire is '100% prepared' for his death, details what will happen to his stock
    Yahoo Finance

    Warren Buffett says Berkshire is '100% prepared' for his death, details what will happen to his stock

    Investing icon Warren Buffett says Berkshire Hathaway (BRK-A, BRK-B) is "100% prepared" for his death, and detailed what will happen to his shares in that event. In his widely-read annual letter, Buffett told the story of how his friend received "an irritating letter" from a local newspaper seeking biographical data for an obituary. Buffett, whose net worth is estimated by Forbes to be $90.2 billion, has 99% of his net worth in Berkshire shares.

  • Dozens take part in underpants run
    Associated Press Videos

    Dozens take part in underpants run

    Dozens of running enthusiasts wearing nothing but underwear and jogging shoes took part in a race along the Danube river in Belgrade on Saturday. Feb.

  • Asian markets slump as new coronavirus cases jump outside China

    Asian markets slump as new coronavirus cases jump outside China

    The decline followed a sell-off Friday on Wall Street. South Korea's Kospi (KR:180721)  dropped 3%, while the S&P ASX/200 (AU:XJO)  in Sydney lost 2.3%. Another large jump in new cases was reported in South Korea on Monday, a day after the the president called for “unprecedented, powerful” steps to combat the outbreak that is increasingly confounding attempts to stop the spread.

  • Warren Buffett Flashes ‘Urgent’

    Warren Buffett Flashes ‘Urgent’

    It's evolved over time into what reads like a love letter to shareholders, to insurance float — the lucrative gift that keeps on giving at Berkshire — and to America as a whole, while taking the occasional jab at Wall Street's fee-giddy bankers and anyone who thinks Ebitda is an honest profit gauge. Berkshire had $128 billion of cash as of December, about the same level as the previous quarter and many billions more than Buffett would like to see sitting in a bank. The letter, one of two major yearly events for Berkshire investors and Buffett groupies (the other is the shareholder meeting each May) has become more condensed in recent years.

  • ‘Overprotected’ investors could get stung in the next recession, warns top Barclays strategist

    ‘Overprotected’ investors could get stung in the next recession, warns top Barclays strategist

    Rattled by rising non-China coronavirus cases — notably in South Korea — investors appear unwilling to load up on stocks heading into the new week. Welcome to the world of helicopter investing and our call of the day from Barclays Wealth Management's chief investment officer William Hobbs, who finds overly anxious investors living in the “long shadow” caused by the financial crisis. “The most common narrative in markets is what to do when the next recession comes along — own Treasurys, own gold, own quality to such an extent that my concern would almost be that if the next recession is of a more normal variety, such as a stock retracement of 10% to 15% and moderate declines in unemployment, you'll find that you have overprotected yourself and the underperformance could actually be in the areas which you thought were giving you safety,” Hobbs told MarketWatch.

  • 3 Monster Growth Stocks Primed for Further Gains

    3 Monster Growth Stocks Primed for Further Gains

    As Wall Street observers gauge the strength of a particular investment opportunity, often, they will filter out the noise and instead, concentrate their attention on its long-term growth prospects. Setting out on our own search, we used TipRanks' Stock Screener tool to pinpoint 3 stocks that have earned “Strong Buy” consensus ratings from the analysts and boast substantial upside potential from current levels. Selecta Biosciences believes that its ImmTOR immune tolerance platform can help patients fight rare diseases.

  • Business

    Stocks That Fell to 3-Year Lows in the Week of Feb. 21

    Carnival Corp. (NYSE:CCL), Exxon Mobil Corp. (NYSE:XOM), 3M Co. (NYSE:MMM) and HSBC Holdings PLC (NYSE:HSBC) have reached their three-year lows. The price of Carnival shares declined to $41.69 on Feb. 21, which is only 4.2% above the three-year low of $39.92. Carnival is a British-American cruise operator and currently the world's largest travel leisure company.

  • Business

    Virgin Galactic Stock Is on a Tear. This Other Asset Is Doing Even Better.

    Instead of buying stock from another holder when exercising a call option, a warrant holder will buy shares from the company, in this case Virgin Galactic. The company will take the cash from the warrant holder and issue new shares. It's one way for a company to raise capital.

  • Boeing finds debris in fuel tanks of many undelivered 737 MAX jets

    Boeing finds debris in fuel tanks of many undelivered 737 MAX jets

    Boeing Co has found debris in the fuel tanks of dozens of undelivered 737 MAX jets amid ongoing inspections as the Chicago-based planemaker struggles to restore the trust of airlines and the wider public in the grounded fleet. Boeing found debris in the fuel tanks of about 35 aircraft, a company spokesman confirmed on Friday. A person familiar with the matter told Reuters that more than 50% of the undelivered 737 MAX jets inspected thus far have had debris found in them.

  • Sellers Tighten Grip on S&P 500, Nasdaq as Virus Spread Quickens

    Sellers Tighten Grip on S&P 500, Nasdaq as Virus Spread Quickens

    Investors are reprising a pattern that has prevailed in U.S. markets for almost a year, in which periods of near-euphoric gains are intermittently broken by sharp reactions to outside threats. Futures are pointing to declines that would leave equities down almost 3% since Wednesday as the deadly virus spread in countries including Italy and Iran. The S&P 500 started last week trading at more than 22 times earnings while the Nasdaq 100 Index's multiple was nearly 30, both among the highest in decades.