U.S. Markets close in 6 hrs 2 mins

How Indians cleaned up one of their dirtiest cities—and have kept it that way

Raghuram Rajan

We do know that enhanced trade and technological change transmitted through markets have led to the loss of middle-income jobs and weakened the economic basis for the community in many parts of the developed world. It may be this, coupled with the flight of those who can leave, that is more responsible for the social disintegration of the community.

How do we revive the proximate community?

There is no magic solution to creating local jobs, but as one examines case studies of what has worked, some key factors emerge. Once again, we will see the importance of technology as part of the solution. Let us start with two case studies. First, let’s look at a project that revived community spirit, and in the process made the community more attractive and livable. It took place in Indore in India.

Cleaning up Indore

 How do we revive the proximate community? Indian cities are colorful, vibrant, noisy, and… dirty. The commercial hub of the state of Madhya Pradesh, Indore, was no exception. People treated it as a vast public garbage dump. After eating food on paper plates bought from stalls at the famous Sarafa food market, customers simply threw their plates and any residue on the ground.

People were no more careful with their domestic garbage, dumping it anywhere in the proximity of overflowing dumpsters, which were rarely emptied. Stray animals—dogs, cows, goats, and pigs–roamed freely, eating the garbage and adding their excrement to the mix. Some poor people, who did not have access to toilets, defecated in the open, in vacant fields or near public drains. All in all, it was a perfect breeding place for flies, mosquitoes, and, therefore, disease.

Into this mix were thrown two abnormal individuals, Malini Gaud, who had been elected mayor of Indore on a plank of cleanliness, and Manish Singh, the municipal commissioner. There was also one dedicated NGO, Basix, which had experience in effective waste management. Basix wanted more waste for poor rag pickers, who make a living separating out metals, paper, plastic, and glass from waste, and recycling it.

The reformers realised that part of the solution was to make it easier for people to dispose of their garbage. That meant placing public garbage cans at every needed place throughout the city with its location geo-tagged for easy collection, collecting domestic garbage directly from every home, and constructing over ten thousand toilets in places where people used open spaces.

The municipal cleaning staff now had to collect the garbage. The 5,500-person staff was used to collecting pay and not much more. Attendance was a miserable 30 to 40%. The municipal commissioner decided to apply both carrot and stick. Staff were given smart uniforms, and their cycle rickshaws replaced with motorized GPS-fitted trucks. Each vehicle was given about one thousand households or bins to collect from every day, and its location and performance was monitored.

Most employees actually were unhappy with their poor image. They did want to do a good job once they realised the mayor and commissioner were serious about change and apathy would no longer be the order of the day. Some did not want to change, and the stick was applied to them. Biometric attendance was introduced, and after discussion with the union and due notice, 300 still-recalcitrant employees were suspended, and 600 were terminated.

The householder was happy that garbage was collected regularly at her doorstep, and soon agreed to pay a regular monthly fee for collection, offsetting the municipality’s additional costs. Shops and eateries installed garbage cans outside, incentivised by a stiff fine if they lacked one. One knotty problem was that some people still preferred answering the call of nature in the open rather than in an enclosed toilet.

 Cleaning up a city offers a very visible sign of community effort and engagement. The municipality adopted the innovative idea of drum squads—these would search stealthily for open defecators and then flush them out by drumming loudly when they were found. Open defecation ceased, and disease seems to have fallen significantly since.

Cleaning up a city seems small in the larger scheme of community revival, but it is an essential component of change, especially in a world where the ability to attract talented people with improved livability is an important source of competitive advantage. Moreover, it offers a very visible sign of community effort and engagement.

According to Indian magazine Business Today, there is something strange about the Sarafa market today: “There is no leftover food, no dirty plates, no garbage to be seen—anywhere.”

Indore was ranked the cleanest city in India in 2017 (after coming in at 149th in 2014). Its citizens take pride in its ranking and, according to Vijay Mahajan, the chairman of Basix, are working hard to maintain it.

Excerpted from Raghuram Rajan’s The Third Pillar with permission from HarperCollins India.

We welcome your comments at ideas.india@qz.com.

 

Sign up for the Quartz Daily Brief, our free daily newsletter with the world’s most important and interesting news.

More stories from Quartz:

  • Should You Buy Barrett Business Services, Inc. (NASDAQ:BBSI) For Its Upcoming Dividend In 3 Days?
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    Should You Buy Barrett Business Services, Inc. (NASDAQ:BBSI) For Its Upcoming Dividend In 3 Days?

    Barrett Business Services's next dividend payment will be US$0.30 per share, on the back of last year when the company paid a total of US$1.20 to shareholders. Based on the last year's worth of payments, Barrett Business Services has a trailing yield of 1.4% on the current stock price of $88.19. Dividends are a major contributor to investment returns for long term holders, but only if the dividend continues to be paid.

  • These Factors Make Public Joint-Stock Company Lenenergo (MCX:LSNG) An Interesting Investment
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    These Factors Make Public Joint-Stock Company Lenenergo (MCX:LSNG) An Interesting Investment

    I've been keeping an eye on Public Joint-Stock Company Lenenergo (MCX:LSNG) because I'm attracted to its fundamentals. Looking at the company as a whole, as a potential stock investment, I believe LSNG has a lot to offer. Basically, it is a financially-sound company with an impressive history of performance, trading at a great value.

  • How the Fed ‘could trigger carnage in the bond and equity markets’ this week
    Business
    Yahoo Finance

    How the Fed ‘could trigger carnage in the bond and equity markets’ this week

    Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell holds a news conference following the Federal Reserve's two-day Federal Open Market Committee Meeting in Washington, U.S., July 31, 2019. The one bright spot in the economy, the strength of the U.S. consumer, could throw a wrench in the Fed's messaging this week, as central bankers gear up for an annual policy conference in Jackson Hole, Wyoming. “There is a risk [Fed Chair Jerome] Powell and his colleagues end up disappointing the bond market next week – by not signaling clearly enough that additional rate cuts are coming in mid-September and beyond,” Ashworth wrote in a note to clients.

  • Trump Administration Asks Supreme Court to Permit Employment Discrimination Against Transgender Workers
    Politics
    Meredith Videos

    Trump Administration Asks Supreme Court to Permit Employment Discrimination Against Transgender Workers

    The Trump administration's Department of Justice is asking the Supreme Court to set a legal precedent that would enable employers to fire employees because they are transgender.

  • Business
    Thomson Reuters StreetEvents

    Edited Transcript of SMCI earnings conference call or presentation 15-Aug-19 9:00pm GMT

    Q4 2019 Super Micro Computer Inc Earnings Call

  • 3 Marijuana Stocks You Should Buy, According to This 124-Year-Old Wall Street Firm
    Business
    Motley Fool

    3 Marijuana Stocks You Should Buy, According to This 124-Year-Old Wall Street Firm

    CV Sciences: price target $5, representing 62% upside Considering Piper Jaffray's excitement concerning CBD growth in the United States – an industry that Lavery believes could reach $8 billion to $15 billion in annual sales in five years – it's no surprise that CV Sciences (OTC: CVSI) is Piper's second overweight pot stock. CV Sciences and its line of PlusCBD Oil products have had a number of big wins this year, with the creme-de-la-creme being its distribution partnership with Kroger (NYSE: KR), the nation's largest grocer.

  • What To Know Before Buying UnitedHealth Group Incorporated (NYSE:UNH) For Its Dividend
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    What To Know Before Buying UnitedHealth Group Incorporated (NYSE:UNH) For Its Dividend

    Dividend paying stocks like UnitedHealth Group Incorporated (NYSE:UNH) tend to be popular with investors, and for good reason - some research suggests a significant amount of all stock market returns come from reinvested dividends. If you are hoping to live on your dividends, it's important to be more stringent with your investments than the average punter. Regular readers know we like to apply the same approach to each dividend stock, and we hope you'll find our analysis useful.

  • Virgin plastic pellets are the biggest pollution disaster you’ve never heard of
    Finance
    Quartz

    Virgin plastic pellets are the biggest pollution disaster you’ve never heard of

    Some 30 miles north of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, in a township adjacent to a state forest, oil and gas giant Royal Dutch Shell is building a sprawling new plant to support what it sees as the future of its business: making millions of tons of new, virgin plastic. Shell, along with other major oil and gas companies like Exxon, sees plastic as one avenue for growth as natural gas prices plummet—and, longer-term, as a way to weather the world's slow rejection of fossil fuels as an energy source. For now, if Shell can't make money selling its plentiful natural gas, it can certainly make plastic with it.

  • Business
    Market Exclusive

    Cannabis Stock News Daily Roundup August 19

    Dixie Brands (CSE: DIXI.U) (OTCQX: DXBRF) (Frankfurt: 0QV) announced that its pet wellness subsidiary Therabis launched its new new Mobility soft chew for dogs. The new soft is designed to promote joint health and a healthy inflammatory system in dogs. Industries (CSE: TGIF) (OTCQX: TGIFF) announced the grant of 6,800,000 incentive stock options to its directors, officers, consultants, and employees pursuant to the company's stock option plan.

  • Pfizer (NYSE:PFE) Shareholders Have Enjoyed A 20% Share Price Gain
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    Pfizer (NYSE:PFE) Shareholders Have Enjoyed A 20% Share Price Gain

    One imperfect but simple way to consider how the market perception of a company has shifted is to compare the change in the earnings per share (EPS) with the share price movement. During five years of share price growth, Pfizer achieved compound earnings per share (EPS) growth of 6.6% per year. This EPS growth is higher than the 3.7% average annual increase in the share price.

  • A gun law case before the US Supreme Court has Americans up in arms
    Finance
    Quartz

    A gun law case before the US Supreme Court has Americans up in arms

    The US Supreme Court will soon consider the right to bear arms, something it hasn't done for nearly a decade. The case in question has pitted New York City against the New York State Pistol and Rifle Association over a law on transporting guns. The twist here is that New York City, and its many legal allies, say the case is actually moot.

  • Earnings Preview: Is Kohl's Getting Back on Track?
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Earnings Preview: Is Kohl's Getting Back on Track?

    After a multiyear run of mediocre performance, Kohl's (NYSE: KSS) finally seemed to get its house in order about two years ago. Back in May, Kohl's executives warned investors not to expect an immediate rebound in sales and earnings for Q2. Kohl's upcoming second-quarter earnings report and conference call will give investors more insight into whether business trends are turning around as expected.

  • Investors Who Bought Novavax (NASDAQ:NVAX) Shares Three Years Ago Are Now Down 94%
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    Investors Who Bought Novavax (NASDAQ:NVAX) Shares Three Years Ago Are Now Down 94%

    Because Novavax is loss-making, we think the market is probably more focussed on revenue and revenue growth, at least for now. Shareholders of unprofitable companies usually expect strong revenue growth. Some companies are willing to postpone profitability to grow revenue faster, but in that case one does expect good top-line growth.

  • Houston-based cabaret owner gets another delisting warning, increases dividend
    Business
    American City Business Journals

    Houston-based cabaret owner gets another delisting warning, increases dividend

    Houston-based RCI Hospitality Holdings Inc. (Nasdaq: RICK), owner of Bombshells Restaurant & Bar, Rick's Cabaret and other cabaret brands, has received its second delisting warning from the Nasdaq Stock Market, according to an Aug. 14 press release. RCI said it had expected to receive the warning, which the Nasdaq issued because RCI has yet to file its most recent financial report — for the quarter ended June 30 — with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. This is the second such warning the company has received this year — it also has yet to file its report for the quarter ended March 31 and received a separate warning in May. On July 16, RCI sent the Nasdaq its plan to regain compliance for the first warning.

  • A Short-Seller Goes Too Far to Beat the ‘Bullies’
    Business
    Bloomberg

    A Short-Seller Goes Too Far to Beat the ‘Bullies’

    You won't find a better example of this than Cohodes's efforts over the last year to destroy — yes, destroy — MiMedx Group Inc., a biomedical company that makes products that heal wounds and treat serious inflammation. From 1985 to 2006, he partnered with another prominent short, David Rocker. Together, they uncovered wrongdoing at companies like AremisSoft Corp. and Conseco Inc. When Rocker retired in early 2007, Cohodes took over the firm, and renamed it Copper River Management LLC.

  • Business
    Barrons.com

    GE Just Responded to Fraud Claims. Here’s What Investors Need to Know.

    (GE) in a statement emailed to investors Monday morning, disputed many of the allegations raised by forensic accountant Harry Markopolos. Markopolos, known for correctly identifying the Bernie Madoff Ponzi scheme, alleged last Thursday that the company is engaged in accounting fraud in its long-term care insurance business—a claim GE has denied. GE (ticker: GE) continues to stand by its accounting for the troubled long-term care insurance business.

  • 13 Arrested as Far-Right Rally Clashes With Counter-Demonstrators in Downtown Portland
    U.S.
    Meredith Videos

    13 Arrested as Far-Right Rally Clashes With Counter-Demonstrators in Downtown Portland

    Hundreds of far-right protesters and anti-fascist counter-demonstrators swarmed downtown Portland, Oregon, on Saturday for a long-hyped rally that attracted President Donald Trump's attention and resulted in at least 13 arrests.

  • 3 Dividend Stocks That Should Pay You the Rest of Your Life
    Business
    Motley Fool

    3 Dividend Stocks That Should Pay You the Rest of Your Life

    There's a balance in the dividend space between high yields and dividend sustainability. In the end, it's generally more important to find stocks that can keep paying -- and hopefully increasing -- their dividends than to stretch for high yields that are ephemeral because they are backed by dividends that are likely to get cut. If you want to add a few good dividend names to your portfolio, these three Motley Fool contributors think you'll want to look at biotech Gilead Sciences (NASDAQ: GILD), telecom giant Verizon (NYSE: VZ), and consumer products specialist Procter & Gamble (NYSE: PG).

  • How Much Are HC2 Holdings, Inc. (NYSE:HCHC) Insiders Spending On Buying Shares?
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    How Much Are HC2 Holdings, Inc. (NYSE:HCHC) Insiders Spending On Buying Shares?

    So shareholders might well want to know whether insiders have been buying or selling shares in HC2 Holdings, Inc. NYSE:HCHC). What Is Insider Selling?

  • Tilray, Inc. (NASDAQ:TLRY): Are Analysts Optimistic?
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    Tilray, Inc. (NASDAQ:TLRY): Are Analysts Optimistic?

    Tilray, Inc.'s (NASDAQ:TLRY): Tilray, Inc. engages in the research, cultivation, processing, and distribution of medical cannabis. The US$3.1b market-cap posted a loss in its most recent financial year of -US$67.7m and a latest trailing-twelve-month loss of -US$115.1m leading to an even wider gap between loss and breakeven. Many investors are wondering the rate at which TLRY will turn a profit, with the big question being “when will the company breakeven?” Below I will provide a high-level summary of the industry analysts' expectations for TLRY.

  • Is Sabre (NASDAQ:SABR) A Risky Investment?
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    Is Sabre (NASDAQ:SABR) A Risky Investment?

    The external fund manager backed by Berkshire Hathaway's Charlie Munger, Li Lu, makes no bones about it when he says 'The biggest investment risk is not the volatility of prices, but whether you will suffer a permanent loss of capital.' So it might be obvious that you need to consider debt, when you think about how risky any given stock is, because too much debt can sink a company. Generally speaking, debt only becomes a real problem when a company can't easily pay it off, either by raising capital or with its own cash flow. What Is Sabre's Net Debt?

  • Carnival Corporation (NYSE:CCL) Goes Ex-Dividend In 3 Days
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    Carnival Corporation (NYSE:CCL) Goes Ex-Dividend In 3 Days

    Yet cash flows are even more important than profits for assessing a dividend, so we need to see if the company generated enough cash to pay its distribution. Over the past year it paid out 132% of its free cash flow as dividends, which is uncomfortably high. We're curious about why the company paid out more cash than it generated last year, since this can be one of the early signs that a dividend may be unsustainable.

  • Better Buy: Eli Lilly vs. GlaxoSmithKline
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Better Buy: Eli Lilly vs. GlaxoSmithKline

    Eli Lilly (NYSE: LLY) and GlaxoSmithKline (NYSE: GSK) are undergoing transformations. Both big drugmakers have launched multiple new products to drive future growth while simultaneously dealing with sagging sales of older drugs. The companies' executions of these transformation efforts differ, though.

  • Three 5G Stocks Poised to Soar Over the Next Decade
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Three 5G Stocks Poised to Soar Over the Next Decade

    That means next year could mark the beginning of a big Apple refresh cycle, leading to iPhone growth once again. Given Apple's very reasonable valuation, rising dividend, and share repurchases, its shareholders seem poised to win big from the 5G revolution. Taiwan Semiconductor and 5G Speaking of Apple, the smartphone giant is designing more and more of its own custom chips in-house these days, such as its A-series processors.

  • What Does Fortinet, Inc.'s (NASDAQ:FTNT) Share Price Indicate?
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    What Does Fortinet, Inc.'s (NASDAQ:FTNT) Share Price Indicate?

    The company's shares saw a decent share price growth in the teens level on the NASDAQGS over the last few months. As a large-cap stock with high coverage by analysts, you could assume any recent changes in the company's outlook is already priced into the stock. Let's take a look at Fortinet's outlook and value based on the most recent financial data to see if the opportunity still exists.