U.S. Markets open in 31 mins

Investors are behaving like ‘rats on a sinking ship,’ strategist says

Heidi Chung
Reporter

The stock market kicked off 2018 by rallying to a record high in January, then plunging in February and March. By the end of the summer, markets recovered their losses. And then they tumbled again in the fall.

“This is the final round, and trading this year has round-tripped to nowhere, and so you just are spinning and spinning. You see a little bit of a rally,” Quad Group’s Chief Strategist Peter Borish told Yahoo Finance. “I feel like we’re rats on a sinking ship. They all run to one side thinking something good is going to happen and it doesn’t, and then the wind shifts and so we all run to the other side.”

The S&P 500 (^GSPC) has tumbled 8%, the Dow (^DJI) nearly 6% and the Nasdaq (^IXIC) sunk a whopping 11% since September 13. The S&P is now flat on the year, while the Dow holds on to a 1% gain, and the Nasdaq is up 2% so far in 2018.

To add to investors’ pain, small caps have also been largely underperforming their larger counterparts. Earlier in the year, investors were piling into the Russell 2000 to find safety amid an escalating trade war; however, rising interest rates and fears of an economic slowdown have taken down the once hot group. The ETF tracking the small caps, IWM, has fallen 16% from its high on August 31.

“Let’s look at things we look at particularly. We look at the Russell. We look at IWM — that’s near its lows, and we’re looking at the transports,” Borish explained.

Much like the small caps, the transports have also been feeling the pain. The Dow Jones Transportation Average (^DTX) is down 15% from its September 14 high. According the Dow Theory, one of the oldest stock market indicators, the performance of the transports is a critical indicator of how the rest of the market will perform.

“Things were improving in terms of trade. You would have to get the stuff somewhere, whether it’s more soybeans from the Midwest, or you’d have to get a train, a boat, or a plane or somewhere to get to China, and the transports are dramatically underperforming; they maintain very close to their yearly lows,” Borish said.

Borish explained that unless there is concrete evidence that the market is headed higher, he will remain cautious. “Until there are some more definitive answers, either some price action or through some policy action — We personally don’t think it’s going to happen, so we’re leaning toward the capsizing approach that rallies are to be faded, and to be honest, this isn’t that much of a rally.”

Heidi Chung is a reporter at Yahoo Finance. Follow her on Twitter: @heidi_chung.

Follow Yahoo Finance on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Flipboard, LinkedIn, and reddit.

More from Heidi:

Amazon could surge 37% in 2019, Cowen says

Dave & Buster's blames weak sales on poorly executed all-you-can-eat wings special

Why the Fed could surprise the world next week with no rate hike

Tobacco giant Altria makes massive bet on cannabis