U.S. Markets open in 8 hrs 35 mins

I’m not buying Apple’s HomePod for two main reasons

Ben Gilbert
Apple HomePod

AP


  • Apple's latest major product is available now. It's called the HomePod, and it costs $350.
  • The HomePod is a Siri-powered smart speaker, similar to Amazon Echo and Google Home, but it touts sound quality comparable to premium speakers.
  • There are some huge problems with Apple's proposition that limit HomePod's potential appeal.


Apple's HomePod is finally here — you can buy one for $350 right now, online or in Apple stores.

But should you? For me, the answer is an easy no. 

It's not just the high price, or the Sonos Play:3 speaker I own that I'm quite happy with. The problem with Apple's new HomePod for me boils down to two main threads:

  1. The HomePod is only intended for people who use Apple Music, Apple Mail, Apple Maps, and Apple everything else.
  2. Siri, as we all know, is not good. And Siri is the way you interact with HomePod.
HomePod

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

Like most people, I use a menagerie of electronic devices and services from various companies.

My phone is a Google Pixel, my laptop is a MacBook Air, and my TV is a TCL — it's got a Roku built into it. I have a PC for gaming, which runs Windows 10, and game consoles from Microsoft, Sony, and Nintendo. (Yes, I own too many electronics. I know.)

I use a variety of Google services for mail, and calendar, and maps. I pay for Amazon Prime, and Spotify, and Netflix. I'm kinda all over the place. And that makes Apple's HomePod more or less useless to me. 

Don't use Apple Music? Don't maintain your calendar, mail, maps, and everything else through Apple's version of that service? The HomePod probably isn't very useful to you either.

That's because Apple's intentionally limiting the way the HomePod works with so-called "third-party" apps. If you're, say, a Spotify user, you can use Spotify on the HomePod through AirPlay2. What that means is you go to the app on your phone and manually push it to the HomePod — you can't say, "Hey Siri, play the Black Panther soundtrack." There's no way to set HomePod to default to Spotify, or Tidal, or whatever other service you'd like to use with voice control. The only way to use them — if they're supported, that is — is through manual input.

And doesn't that kind of defeat the purpose of having a voice-controlled smart speaker?

Apple HomePod

Apple

Perhaps more worrying is the fact that Siri, in general, is pretty terrible at its intended function: hearing human speech and translating it into actions. 

In fairness to Apple, no one really has voice recognition figured out completely. Amazon's Echo (with its voice assistant "Alexa") and Google's Home (with "Google Assistant") have many similar faults, whether we're talking about mishearing commands, not understanding them, or not being able to do what you want them to do. And none of these so-called "digital assistants" functions like an actual assistant — proactively adding structure and organization to your life — so much as they're executing commands by voice. 

All that said, based on my experience with Apple's Siri across several iPhones, I don't have much faith in the HomePod version of Siri to accurately recognize my voice every time. It doesn't always work when I'm carefully holding an iPhone next to my face — why should it work any better across a large room, potentially filled with other noises?

siri

Suzanne Plunkett/Reuters

Maybe Apple will add support for more third-party services, like Spotify and Uber. Maybe Apple will add the ability to set Google services as your default mail, calendar, map, and weather service. Maybe.

My guess is that stuff isn't changing any time soon, but I'd love to be wrong about that.

What's more likely is that Siri will get better over time. The HomePod will assuredly help Apple improve Siri's functionality as users spend more and more time speaking to their new smart speakers. 

But without support for a wider range of services — one that recognizes the reality we live in where most people use a variety of different services and devices from many different companies — the HomePod makes no sense for me. 

NOW WATCH: The NFL is using this football helmet that morphs on impact to reduce head injuries

See Also:

SEE ALSO: Early reviews are in for Apple's new $350 Echo competitor, the HomePod — and it's getting destroyed

DON'T MISS: 7 reasons you shouldn't buy Apple's HomePod right now

  • AT&T and Comcast earnings: What to watch for this week
    News
    MarketWatch

    AT&T and Comcast earnings: What to watch for this week

    Telecommunications companies like AT&T Inc. (T) and Comcast Corp. (CMCSA) are grappling with an ever-growing challenge from streaming giant Netflix Inc. AT&T, which announces third-quarter earnings on Wednesday morning, completed an $81 billion acquisition of Time Warner, now known as WarnerMedia, in June. In September, Comcast secured a majority stake in Sky PLC (UK:SKY) after bidding $39 billion in a blind auction, besting 21st Century Fox Inc. (FOXA) The company, which announces third-quarter earnings Thursday morning, also agreed to buy Fox's 39.1% stake in Sky for $15.1 billion.

  • Mega Millions $1.6 Billion Jackpot Also Comes With a Mega Millions Tax Bill
    Finance
    Fortune

    Mega Millions $1.6 Billion Jackpot Also Comes With a Mega Millions Tax Bill

    With a jackpot of $1.6 billion, tonight’s Mega Millions lottery drawing is the biggest in history. The Mega Millions drawing will be held Tuesday night at 11 p.m. ET—and the odds are categorically against you. The Mega Millions tax bite, though, is pretty solid.

  • 4 Things Aurora Cannabis Did Right Before Its NYSE Debut
    Business
    Motley Fool

    4 Things Aurora Cannabis Did Right Before Its NYSE Debut

    Aurora Cannabis (NASDAQOTH: ACBFF) (TSX: ACB) has sought to make it even easier for U.S. investors to buy its shares by arranging to have its shares listed on the New York Stock Exchange. Beginning tomorrow, Oct. 23, Aurora will join the elite group of cannabis companies whose shares trade on major U.S. exchanges. Getting ready for the increased exposure that a NYSE listing brings takes time and effort, and Aurora Cannabis hasn't wasted any time.

  • Companies Say They're Ready to Move Supply Chains From China
    News
    Bloomberg

    Companies Say They're Ready to Move Supply Chains From China

    A common theme is that they are ready to relocate supply chains if the cost of importing Chinese goods becomes prohibitive. "If there was a broad-based tariff on apparel, I think you could see a bit more of an acceleration of the migration out of China into other regions for apparel sourcing," Mitch Butier, chief executive officer of the California label producer, said during an Oct. 23 earnings call. A number of them have already moved out of China," Jean-Jacques Ruest, CEO of the Canadian railway company, said during an Oct. 23 earnings call.

  • The stock market's 'dead cat bounce' is over and the rolling bear market is making a comeback, Morgan Stanley says
    Business
    Business Insider

    The stock market's 'dead cat bounce' is over and the rolling bear market is making a comeback, Morgan Stanley says

    The stock market may have bounced back from its sharp sell-off at the beginning of October, but Morgan Stanley says the selling will pick back up soon. The firm expects the S&P 500 to slide back below the 200-day moving average, a key technical level. Tread carefully in tech and consumer discretionary, Morgan Stanley warns.

  • Twitter locks Elon Musk's account after bizarre posts
    Business
    The Telegraph

    Twitter locks Elon Musk's account after bizarre posts

    Elon Musk claims Twitter temporarily locked his account after fearing his bizarre posts were the work of hackers. Hours earlier, the Tesla and SpaceX chief declared his love for anime. Another post, written by Musk just minutes later said he owned a wolverine that he described as “chibi”, which is Japanese slang for short. It is not known exactly which tweets caused Twitter to temporarily block Musk, however the social network has been stepping up its crackdown on what it believes to be “spam accounts” in recent months.

  • Why Investors Are Paying a Premium for These 3 Biotech Stocks
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Why Investors Are Paying a Premium for These 3 Biotech Stocks

    Amarin stock exploded in September because it looks like Vascepa will become the next go-to drug for this enormous population. During the 8,179-patient Reduce-It trial, patients given Vascepa in addition to their normal statin treatments were 25% less likely to suffer a major cardiovascular event such as a heart attack. Over the past year, Amarin Corporation actually lost $92 million because sales of Vascepa just haven't kept pace with operating expenses.

  • Suze Orman missed the point of retirement, and that’s why she went back to work
    News
    MarketWatch

    Suze Orman missed the point of retirement, and that’s why she went back to work

    Suze Orman did a smackdown of the FIRE (Financial Independence/Retire Early) movement on Paula Pant’s podcast. Coach Carson posted a balanced, informative response, appreciating Suze’s admonition to be sure you have enough for a risk-free retirement. Suze enumerated a string “what can go wrong” scenarios as evidence that early retirement (on less than $10 million) leaves you vulnerable when life hands you lemons — a whole tree of lemons.

  • These stocks may be sacrificed in a cold war with China
    COL
    CNBC Videos

    These stocks may be sacrificed in a cold war with China

    Jim Cramer says the escalation in the United States' trade war with China could end in an outright cold war that debilitates parts of the stock market.

  • News
    CNBC

    Here's how much money you should have saved by 50

    Fidelity, the nation's largest retirement-plan provider, recommends having the equivalent of six times your annual salary saved. To get to that number, Fidelity recommends saving 15 percent of your annual income. Make sure to invest these funds instead of leaving them in a traditional low-interest savings account.

  • Finance
    InvestorPlace

    Advanced Micro Devices Stock Is Finally Ready for a Strong Comeback

    During that stretch, I was bullish on AMD stock from $20 all the way to $30. Does that mean it’s time to buy back into AMD stock? Advanced Micro Devices stock has dropped a bunch over the past several weeks because Intel (NASDAQ:INTC) is reportedly gaining traction when it comes to volume production of next-gen chips.

  • 5 Deeply Discounted Value Stocks That Haven't Been This Cheap in at Least a Decade
    Business
    Motley Fool

    5 Deeply Discounted Value Stocks That Haven't Been This Cheap in at Least a Decade

    October has been a wake-up call for investors that the stock market won't go up in a straight line, even if we'd like it to. Sure, Bank of America (NYSE: BAC) has seen its stock catapult higher from its Great Recession lows, but its forward P/E of 9.8 would represent a more-than-decade low for the stock.

  • Apple Might Ditch Intel in the Macs in 2020
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Apple Might Ditch Intel in the Macs in 2020

    Earlier this year, Bloomberg reported that Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL), which has a strong internal chip development organization, "is planning to use its own chips in Mac computers beginning as early as 2020, replacing processors from Intel (NASDAQ: INTC) Corp

  • Banks vs. Big Tech: 4 to Buy, 4 to Sell
    Finance
    InvestorPlace

    Banks vs. Big Tech: 4 to Buy, 4 to Sell

    Investors on Wall Street continue to contend with a choppy and uncertain trading environment, even among popular sectors like tech stocks. A growing chorus on Wall Street is sounding the alarm, with analysts at Morgan Stanley warning that the large-cap stocks in the S&P 500 are the only holdout from a “rolling bear market’ that has already savaged pretty much every other asset class, including small-cap stocks, high-yield bonds, and emerging market assets. The fact that the S&P 500 is once again below its 200-day moving average supports this thesis, weighed down by bank stocks.

  • The $1.6B Lottery Jackpot Is Still Up for Grabs — but the Tax Bill for the Winner Will Be Massive
    Finance
    GoBankingRates

    The $1.6B Lottery Jackpot Is Still Up for Grabs — but the Tax Bill for the Winner Will Be Massive

    Whoever wins the Mega Millions lottery could face over 40 percent in taxes. Lines are growing at convenience stores and gas stations as the Mega Millions lottery grows to its biggest prize ever. The cash option is $904 million, which gives you a lot of options of how to spend it until you take taxes into consideration.

  • Tesla Skeptic Andrew Left Is Now Long on ‘Proven Hit’ Model 3
    Business
    Bloomberg

    Tesla Skeptic Andrew Left Is Now Long on ‘Proven Hit’ Model 3

    Citron Research’s Andrew Left, a vocal and long-term Tesla short, said in a report Tuesday that the electric-car maker is snatching customers from BMW, Mercedes, Toyota and Honda. In a Bloomberg Television interview, he said Chief Executive Officer Elon Musk has distracted investors from a company that’s turning a corner. “Elon Musk has made such a sideshow of himself that people started to forget about -- including myself -- the underlying business,” Left said on Bloomberg TV.

  • MARKETS: Here's why stocks are selling off right now and what a bottom would look like
    Business
    Yahoo Finance Video

    MARKETS: Here's why stocks are selling off right now and what a bottom would look like

    Live from the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, Yahoo Finance's Jared Blikre joins Seana Smith to discuss the latest market moves.

  • Trump’s Tax Push to Help Middle Class Could Help Top Earners Too
    Politics
    Bloomberg

    Trump’s Tax Push to Help Middle Class Could Help Top Earners Too

    It’s still unclear how Trump will propose to reduce the tax burden on middle-class Americans, but one of the most straightforward ways would be to lower rates by 10 percent for single filers making up to $82,500. U.S. income tax rates are graduated and income dollars get taxed in chunks as they move up through the brackets -- which means wealthy Americans would also get to apply the reduced rate on their first dollars of income. “A millionaire gets the same size tax cut,” said Kyle Pomerleau, an economist at the conservative Tax Foundation.

  • Finance
    CNBC

    The fear gauge and strong earnings tell Jim Cramer this bottom in the stock market may be real

    The Cboe Volatility Index and strong earnings reports from key companies helped stocks recover intraday on Tuesday, CNBC's Jim Cramer says. The Cboe Volatility Index , also known as the stock market's fear gauge or the VIX, flashed a signal that could mean the market bottomed during Tuesday's turbulent trading session , CNBC's Jim Cramer said. Last week, the "Mad Money" host called on technician Mark Sebastian, who specializes in volatility, to get a read on the VIX , which measures expectations of near-term volatility by tracking S&P 500 option prices.

  • Why Nektar Therapeutics Crashed 17.2% Today
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Why Nektar Therapeutics Crashed 17.2% Today

    After delivering a disappointing update on NKTR-214 in cancer patients this summer, Nektar Therapeutics' (NASDAQ: NKTR) shares have been struggling. The company didn't report any news today, so a negative report issued by Plainview LLC this month may be to blamed for its 17.2% tumble today. In February, Bristol-Myers Squibb (NYSE: BMY) inked a blockbuster deal to license rights to NKTR-214 following positive data last year for NKTR-214's use alongside Bristol-Myers' Opdivo.

  • S&P 500 closes down for fifth day as stocks retreat in wake of China selloff
    News
    MarketWatch

    S&P 500 closes down for fifth day as stocks retreat in wake of China selloff

    U.S. stocks bounced off intraday lows and major indexes trimmed early losses Tuesday, but the S&P 500 still finished lower for a fifth session as a big drop in the Chinese market revived fresh questions about the global economy. The Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) fell 125.98, or 0.5%, to 25,191.43 after being down more than 500 points earlier. (DJIA)On Monday, Dow industrials and the S&P 500 closed lower while the Nasdaq bucked the trend to edge higher.

  • 2 More Marijuana Stocks Are Moving to the NYSE
    Business
    Motley Fool

    2 More Marijuana Stocks Are Moving to the NYSE

    This year, we've witnessed GW Pharmaceuticals gain approval in the U.S. for the first cannabis-derived drug, and we watched as Vermont legalized recreational marijuana use entirely through the legislative process. This began with Cronos Group at the end of February, when it chose to list its shares on the Nasdaq. It was followed just a few months later by Canopy Growth Corp., which became the first marijuana stock to list on the NYSE.

  • Finance
    CNBC

    Here's the tax bite on $1.6 billion Mega Millions and $620 million Powerball jackpots

    Strategies can be employed to reduce the amount of your win that is taxed, although they are best explored with the help of an experienced tax advisor. While it's anyone's guess who will end up winning the Mega Millions and Powerball jackpots, there's at least one guaranteed recipient of a chunk of the loot — the IRS. With the Mega Millions jackpot at $1.6 billion and Powerball's top prize at $620 million, that tax bill will be hefty even if the winner employs strategies to reduce their taxable income.

  • Watch out for ‘dead cat bounce’ in stocks because there’s more pain ahead: Morgan Stanley’s Wilson
    News
    MarketWatch

    Watch out for ‘dead cat bounce’ in stocks because there’s more pain ahead: Morgan Stanley’s Wilson

    October is living up to its infamous reputation as a volatile month for stocks with major indexes down sharply and there is likely more pain ahead for investors, according to one prominent Wall Street analyst. The recent rebound “was a dead cat bounce,” said Michael Wilson, an equity strategist at Morgan Stanley, in a report. After eking out gains last week, the S&P 500 (SPX) is trading below the 200 DMA of 2,768 thus far this week as stocks remain under pressure with third-quarter earnings cycle picking up pace.

  • Why Tesla Stock Jumped Tuesday
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Why Tesla Stock Jumped Tuesday

    Shares of electric-car company Tesla (NASDAQ: TSLA) popped on Tuesday, rising as much as 7.5%. The stock's rise comes after the electric-car company scheduled its earnings report about a week earlier than usual with just two days' notice, leading to some speculation that the automaker may have achieved its goal to become profitable during the quarter. Citron Research, which had previously encouraged investors to short Tesla stock, is now reversing its stance on the stock.