U.S. Markets close in 5 hrs 41 mins

AP Exclusive: Manafort had plan to benefit Putin government

JEFF HORWITZ and CHAD DAY
1 / 2

Manafort of Republican presidential nominee Trump's staff listens during a round table discussion on security at Trump Tower in the Manhattan borough of New York

Paul Manafort of Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump's staff listens during a round table discussion on security at Trump Tower in the Manhattan borough of New York, U.S., August 17, 2016. Picture taken August 17, 2016. REUTERS/Carlo Allegri

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump's former campaign chairman, Paul Manafort, secretly worked for a Russian billionaire to advance the interests of Russian President Vladimir Putin a decade ago and proposed an ambitious political strategy to undermine anti-Russian opposition across former Soviet republics, The Associated Press has learned. The work appears to contradict assertions by the Trump administration and Manafort himself that he never worked for Russian interests.

Manafort proposed in a confidential strategy plan as early as June 2005 that he would influence politics, business dealings and news coverage inside the United States, Europe and the former Soviet republics to benefit the Putin government, even as U.S.-Russia relations under Republican President George W. Bush grew worse. Manafort pitched the plans to Russian aluminum magnate Oleg Deripaska, a close Putin ally with whom Manafort eventually signed a $10 million annual contract beginning in 2006, according to interviews with several people familiar with payments to Manafort and business records obtained by the AP. Manafort and Deripaska maintained a business relationship until at least 2009, according to one person familiar with the work.

"We are now of the belief that this model can greatly benefit the Putin Government if employed at the correct levels with the appropriate commitment to success," Manafort wrote in the 2005 memo to Deripaska. The effort, Manafort wrote, "will be offering a great service that can re-focus, both internally and externally, the policies of the Putin government."

For more news videos visit Yahoo View, available now on iOS and Android.

Manafort's plans were laid out in documents obtained by the AP that included strategy memoranda and records showing international wire transfers for millions of dollars. How much work Manafort performed under the contract was unclear.

The disclosure comes as Trump campaign advisers are the subject of an FBI probe and two congressional investigations. Investigators are reviewing whether the Trump campaign and its associates coordinated with Moscow to meddle in the 2016 campaign. Manafort has dismissed the investigations as politically motivated and misguided, and said he never worked for Russian interests. The documents obtained by AP show Manafort's ties to Russia were closer than previously revealed.

In a statement to the AP, Manafort confirmed that he worked for Deripaska in various countries but said the work was being unfairly cast as "inappropriate or nefarious" as part of a "smear campaign."

"I worked with Oleg Deripaska almost a decade ago representing him on business and personal matters in countries where he had investments," Manafort said. "My work for Mr. Deripaska did not involve representing Russia's political interests."

Deripaska became one of Russia's wealthiest men under Putin, buying assets abroad in ways widely perceived to benefit the Kremlin's interests. U.S. diplomatic cables from 2006 described Deripaska as "among the 2-3 oligarchs Putin turns to on a regular basis" and "a more-or-less permanent fixture on Putin's trips abroad." In response to questions about Manafort's consulting firm, a spokesman for Deripaska in 2008 — at least three years after they began working together — said Deripaska had never hired the firm. Another Deripaska spokesman in Moscow last week declined to answer AP's questions.

When asked Wednesday about Manafort's work for Deripaska, White House spokeswoman Sarah Huckabee Sanders said, "we do not feel it's appropriate to comment on someone who is not an employee at the White House."

Manafort worked as Trump's unpaid campaign chairman last year from March until August. Trump asked Manafort to resign after AP revealed that Manafort had orchestrated a covert Washington lobbying operation until 2014 on behalf of Ukraine's ruling pro-Russian political party.

The newly obtained business records link Manafort more directly to Putin's interests in the region. According to those records and people with direct knowledge of Manafort's work for Deripaska, Manafort made plans to open an office in Moscow, and at least some of Manafort's work in Ukraine was directed by Deripaska, not local political interests there. The Moscow office never opened.

Manafort has been a leading focus of the U.S. intelligence investigation of Trump's associates and Russia, according to a U.S. official. The person spoke on condition of anonymity because details of the investigation were confidential. Meanwhile, federal criminal prosecutors became interested in Manafort's activities years ago as part of a broad investigation to recover stolen Ukraine assets after the ouster of pro-Russian President Viktor Yanukovych there in early 2014. No U.S. criminal charges have ever been filed in the case.

FBI Director James Comey, in confirming to Congress the federal intelligence investigation this week, declined to say whether Manafort was a target. Manafort's name was mentioned 28 times during the hearing of the House Intelligence Committee, mostly about his work in Ukraine. No one mentioned Deripaska.

On Monday, White House press secretary Sean Spicer had singled out Manafort when asked about possible campaign contacts with Russia. He said Manafort "played a very limited role for a very limited amount of time" in the campaign, even though as Trump's presidential campaign chairman he led it during the crucial run-up to the Republican National Convention.

Manafort and his associates remain in Trump's orbit. Manafort told a colleague this year that he continues to speak with Trump by telephone. Manafort's former business partner in eastern Europe, Rick Gates, has been seen inside the White House on a number of occasions. Gates has since helped plan Trump's inauguration and now runs a nonprofit organization, America First Policies, to back the White House agenda.

Gates, whose name does not appear in the documents, told the AP that he joined Manafort's firm in 2006 and was aware Manafort had a relationship with Deripaska, but he was not aware of the work described in the memos. Gates said his work was focused on domestic U.S. lobbying and political consulting in Ukraine at the time. He said he stopped working for Manafort's firm in March 2016 when he joined Trump's presidential campaign.

Manafort told Deripaska in 2005 that he was pushing policies as part of his work in Ukraine "at the highest levels of the U.S. government — the White House, Capitol Hill and the State Department," according to the documents. He also said he had hired a "leading international law firm with close ties to President Bush to support our client's interests," but he did not identify the firm. Manafort also said he was employing unidentified legal experts for the effort at leading universities and think tanks, including Duke University, New York University and the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

Manafort did not disclose details about the lobbying work to the Justice Department during the period the contract was in place.

Under the Foreign Agents Registration Act, people who lobby in the U.S. on behalf of foreign political leaders or political parties must provide detailed reports about their actions to the department. Willfully failing to register is a felony and can result in up to five years in prison and a fine of up to $250,000, though the government rarely files criminal charges.

Deripaska owns Basic Element Co., which employs 200,000 people worldwide in the agriculture, aviation, construction, energy, financial services, insurance and manufacturing industries, and he runs one of the world's largest aluminum companies. Forbes estimated his net worth at $5.2 billion. How much Deripaska paid Manafort in total is not clear, but people familiar with the relationship said money transfers to Manafort amounted to tens of millions of dollars and continued through at least 2009. They spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss the secret payments publicly.

In strategy memos, Manafort proposed that Deripaska and Putin would benefit from lobbying Western governments, especially the U.S., to allow oligarchs to keep possession of formerly state-owned assets in Ukraine. He proposed building "long term relationships" with Western journalists and a variety of measures to improve recruitment, communications and financial planning by pro-Russian parties in the region.

Manafort proposed extending his existing work in eastern Europe to Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and Georgia, where he pledged to bolster the legitimacy of governments friendly to Putin and undercut anti-Russian figures through political campaigns, nonprofit front groups and media operations.

For the $10 million contract, Manafort did not use his public-facing consulting firm, Davis Manafort. Instead, he used a company, LOAV Ltd., that he had registered in Delaware in 1992. He listed LOAV as having the same address of his lobbying and consulting firms in Alexandria, Virginia. In other records, LOAV's address was listed as Manafort's home, also in Alexandria. Manafort sold the home in July 2015 for $1.4 million. He now owns an apartment in Trump Tower in New York, as well as other properties in Florida and New York.

One strategy memo to Deripaska was written by Manafort and Rick Davis, his business partner at the time. In written responses to the AP, Davis said he did not know that his firm had proposed a plan to covertly promote the interests of the Russian government.

Davis said he believes Manafort used his name without his permission on the strategy memo. "My name was on every piece of stationery used by the company and in every memo prior to 2006. It does not mean I had anything to do with the memo described," Davis said. He took a leave of absence from the firm in late 2006 to work on John McCain's 2008 presidential campaign.

Manafort's work with Deripaska continued for years, though they had a falling out laid bare in 2014 in a Cayman Islands bankruptcy court. The billionaire gave Manafort nearly $19 million to invest in a Ukrainian TV company called Black Sea Cable, according to legal filings by Deripaska's representatives. It said that after taking the money, Manafort and his associates stopped responding to Deripaska's queries about how the funds had been used.

Early in the 2016 presidential campaign, Deripaska's representatives openly accused Manafort of fraud and pledged to recover the money from him. After Trump earned the nomination, Deripaska's representatives said they would no longer discuss the case.

___

Associated Press writers Jack Gillum, Eric Tucker, Julie Pace, Ted Bridis, Stephen Braun and Julie Bykowicz contributed to this report in Washington; Nataliya Vasilyeva contributed from Moscow and Kiev, Ukraine; and Jake Pearson contributed from New York.

___

Submit reporting tips to The Associated Press: https://www.ap.org/tips

  • Coronavirus fears spook stocks: Here's how to keep a cool head and protect your 401(k)
    Business
    USA TODAY

    Coronavirus fears spook stocks: Here's how to keep a cool head and protect your 401(k)

    Sign up here Here are four moves experts say could help protect your investments during volatile periods, such as the bumpy stretch caused by the coronavirus: 401(k): Coronavirus fears shouldn't stop you from investing in stocks Monitoring markets: Dow jumps 300 points as investors assess economic fallout from virus 1. Review your investments Pay attention to where you're invested and which companies are most likely to be affected, portfolio managers say. Daniel Milan, managing partner at Southfield, Michigan-based Cornerstone Financial Services, says the effects from the virus outbreak on the stock market will be short-lived and has cautioned his clients to not let fear drive their investme...

  • Wait for these signals to buy coronavirus-battered stocks, says BNY Mellon strategist
    Business
    MarketWatch

    Wait for these signals to buy coronavirus-battered stocks, says BNY Mellon strategist

    Some believe the next big fall in equities will come when we see a cluster of U.S. cases, which may partly explain why that popular past time of buying stocks on any dip seems less popular lately. Citigroup strategists are advising against buying equities right now, on the view that if a Federal Reserve lifeline is coming, it may not happen right away. Gov. Warsh argues for immediate, globally coordinated rate cut Our call of the day comes from BNY Mellon's chief strategist Alicia Levine, who has advice for those wanting to know when to buy beaten-down (and down) stocks.

  • Something 'dangerous' is happening beneath the surface of the market selloff
    Business
    Yahoo Finance

    Something 'dangerous' is happening beneath the surface of the market selloff

    So every time stocks went up, bonds tailed off and vice-versa,” Academy Securities' Peter Tchir said on Yahoo Finance's The Final Round. All of a sudden, that behavior changed a little bit into the close yesterday. And making it even more dangerous to me, you saw oil fall off into the close.

  • 3M's making protective masks on three continents, but it's not enough
    News
    American City Business Journals

    3M's making protective masks on three continents, but it's not enough

    The Star Tribune has an update on 3M's mask-making efforts; the Maplewood-based company has boosted production in China — the epicenter of the Covid-19 outbreak, where tens of thousands of people have gotten sick — as well as at factories elsewhere in Asia, Europe, Latin America and the United States. That's been the case now for nearly a month; 3M (NYSE: MMM) CEO Mike Roman said in January that the company was "going 24/7" in producing the masks in factories across the globe. But the spread of the virus — and the worries that it could get even worse — have meant that the company, along with other mask producers, is still playing catch-up.

  • Tesla Sinks on Weak China Registrations Before Brunt of Virus
    Business
    Bloomberg

    Tesla Sinks on Weak China Registrations Before Brunt of Virus

    Tesla Inc. shares fell after China registration data indicated a significant sequential slowdown in demand before the electric-car maker started feeling the brunt of any impact from the coronavirus. Registrations of new Tesla cars plunged 46% to 3,563 in January from December, according to state-backed China Automotive Information Net, which gathers industry data based on insurance purchases. Of the January registrations, 2,605 were for cars built in China.

  • Business
    Barrons.com

    Fear Has Overtaken This Market. How to Use It to Turn a Profit.

    In anticipation, the stock market has experienced some of its most dramatic losses in two years. The profound rotation away from risk assets into Treasury bonds earlier this week into government debt and away from stocks should be considered as a warning shot across the equity market's bow. Early next week, the Institute for Supply Management will release its February report on U.S. economic activity, and similar reports will be released that measure economic activity all over the world.

  • Virgin Galactic misses expectations in the fourth quarter
    Business
    Yahoo Finance Video

    Virgin Galactic misses expectations in the fourth quarter

    Virgin Galactic CEO George T. Whitesides joins the On The Move panel to discuss why the space company missed analyst expectations during the fourth quarter and what investors should look for moving forward.

  • 'Stuck in no man’s land': A working mom details being stuck with her sick child's student loan bill
    Business
    Yahoo Finance

    'Stuck in no man’s land': A working mom details being stuck with her sick child's student loan bill

    Unforeseen medical expenses piled up for a son diagnosed with leukemia, and her family is stuck without any of the repayment options offered to regular student loan borrowers. Consequently, she said she was feeling “stuck in no man's land,” and the financial pain was intensifying. The Trump administration reportedly considered ways to help people like Natalie with their student debt, specifically with their Parent PLUS loans, given the relative age of the borrowing group.

  • Business
    TheStreet.com

    Jim Cramer on Coronavirus: What It Means for Markets, Federal Reserve and Microsoft

    Jim Cramer has some thoughts on the markets, the Federal Reserve and Microsoft as coronavirus fears shake Wall Street. Stock futures declined sharply Thursday, putting Wall Street on pace for its worst week since the global financial crisis in 2008, as coronavirus infections accelerated and health officials confirmed that a California man contracted the disease despite having no travel links or contacts with those afflicted by the virus. The company warned investors that it will fall short of previously issued fiscal third-quarter sales guidance of between $10.75 billion and $11.15 billion for its "more personal computing" segment, which includes Windows OEM and Surface.

  • Trump talks about the stock market, and gets 1 out of 3 points right
    Business
    MarketWatch

    Trump talks about the stock market, and gets 1 out of 3 points right

    Stock markets do this all the time. Since Trump was elected president in November 2016, the Dow has risen from around 18,000 to around 27,000. Trump went on an extended riff blaming the market's fall on Tuesday's Democratic presidential debate.

  • 3 Stocks Warren Buffett and Leon Cooperman Agree On
    Business
    GuruFocus.com

    3 Stocks Warren Buffett and Leon Cooperman Agree On

    According to the Aggregated Portfolio, a Premium feature of GuruFocus, three stocks billionaire investors Warren Buffett (Trades, Portfolio) and Leon Cooperman (Trades, Portfolio) both own in their investment vehicles, Berkshire Hathaway Inc. NYSE:BRK.A)(NYSE:BRK.B) and the Omega Advisors family office, are Wells Fargo & Co. (NYSE:WFC), United Airlines Holdings Inc. NASDAQ:UAL) and Amazon.com Inc.

  • 3 “Strong Buy” Stocks Holding Steady Amid Coronavirus Concerns
    Business
    TipRanks

    3 “Strong Buy” Stocks Holding Steady Amid Coronavirus Concerns

    Coronavirus fears have weighed heavily on the market, and investors are seeking refuge. While the situation in China is reportedly improving, health officials warn the spike in new cases throughout the rest of the world underscores the risk of a global pandemic. Against this backdrop, Wall Street pros remind investors not to panic and rush to a sell-off, pointing out that a select group of tickers still represent compelling opportunities.

  • Dow Jones Tumbles On U.S. Virus First, Microsoft Coronavirus Warning
    Business
    Investor's Business Daily

    Dow Jones Tumbles On U.S. Virus First, Microsoft Coronavirus Warning

    Earlier, Wednesday's stock market rally attempt fizzled as the Covid-19 virus continued to spread around the globe. Meanwhile, Carvana, Square, Teladoc Health, Anaplan and Etsy offered notable earnings reports overnight. Gilead Sciences announced trials for its antiviral Remdesivir to treat the coronavirus.

  • Suze Orman: The 60-40 portfolio 'is dead'
    Business
    Yahoo Money

    Suze Orman: The 60-40 portfolio 'is dead'

    Financial advisors have long stood by the golden rule of having a portfolio of 60% stocks and 40% bonds, but Suze Orman says the rule no longer applies. Actually, 60-40 is dead,” Orman, founder of the Suze Orman Financial Group, said on Yahoo Finance's On the Move. It should probably be 75-25 stocks, believe it or not, stocks, if you also have enough cash to get you by.

  • There is not a 'better time,' for Disney to name Bob Chapek as CEO: Analyst
    Business
    Yahoo Finance Video

    There is not a 'better time,' for Disney to name Bob Chapek as CEO: Analyst

    Shares of Disney are under pressure Wednesday as Bob Chapek begins his first day as the CEO of Disney. Tuna Amobi, CFRA Analyst, discusses with Yahoo Finance's On The Move.

  • Business
    TheStreet.com

    Nvidia, AMD, Intel Tumble After Microsoft's Virus-Related Sales Warning

    Shares of chipmakers that make processors for personal computers and other devices that run on Microsoft software plunged on Thursday after the world's most valuable tech company warned the coronavirus will have a negative impact on sales and earnings. Shares of Intel , Nvidia , Advanced Micro Devices and Micron Technology were all trading lower on Thursday in the wake of Microsoft's warning that its supply chain in China is coming back online at a slower-than-expected pace in the wake of the Chinese Lunar New Year production halt and coronavirus outbreak. Microsoft's China supply chain "is returning to normal operations at a slower pace than anticipated," the company said.

  • Chesapeake Energy’s ‘very low’ stock price prompts reverse split plans
    Business
    MarketWatch

    Chesapeake Energy’s ‘very low’ stock price prompts reverse split plans

    Shares of Chesapeake Energy Corp. tumbled to another record low Wednesday, after the oil and natural gas production company said it was planning for a reverse stock split and that the commodities pricing environment has “further deteriorated” in recent weeks. The company also reported before the market opened a fourth-quarter loss that was narrower than expected, but revenue that fell more than forecast, as production increased while average prices for oil, natural gas and natural gas liquids (NGL) production all fell. Chief Executive Doug Lawler tried to assuage investors by saying on the post-earnings conference call with analysts that given improvements to margins and moves made to strengthen the balance sheet, “the previous going concern language will not be present” in the 2019 annual report, but the stock continued to sell off.

  • Ford COO Sees 2009 Crisis Flashback on Faces of Colleagues
    Business
    Bloomberg

    Ford COO Sees 2009 Crisis Flashback on Faces of Colleagues

    “Everyone at Ford knows the situation we're in,” Jim Farley, who becomes COO on March 1, said Wednesday at a Wolfe Research conference in New York. Ford lost $14.8 billion in 2008, the most in its then 105-year history, but was the only automaker in Detroit to avoid the bailouts and bankruptcies that befell General Motors and Chrysler a year later. The tables have turned recently as Ford let its product lineup lapse, posted a string of dismal earnings results and botched the launch of its redesigned Explorer sport utility vehicle.

  • Business
    Bloomberg

    A Bailout Won’t Help China’s Tesla Wannabe, NIO

    New York-listed NIO Inc., a self-described pioneer in China's premium electric vehicle market and rival to Elon Musk's company, said Tuesday that it has made a tentative agreement with the municipal government of Hefei in Anhui province for funding support. The company will move its China headquarters there from Shanghai and says it plans to raise more than 10 billion yuan ($1.43 billion) in light of the partnership.

  • Warren Buffett Bets on These 3 High-Yield Dividend Stocks
    Business
    TipRanks

    Warren Buffett Bets on These 3 High-Yield Dividend Stocks

    It hasn't escaped notice, however, that the sudden hit to the market has occurred just as Senator Bernie Sanders, an avowed socialist with a vigorous anti-Wall Street policy platform, has taken a commanding lead in the race for the Democratic Party Presidential election nomination. Any strong defensive investing strategy will include dividends. Warren Buffett, certainly no stranger to smart investing, is long-term fan of dividend investing, as a look at Berkshire Hathaway's holdings shows.

  • This is the No. 1 mistake investors are making now — here’s how to avoid it
    Business
    MarketWatch

    This is the No. 1 mistake investors are making now — here’s how to avoid it

    The stock market is under pressure. Investors are reacting — badly. The No. 1 mistake investors are making now in the wake of coronavirus has to do with their artificial construct of the true nature of the stock market.

  • Coronavirus fears prompt action for Louisville businesses
    Business
    American City Business Journals

    Coronavirus fears prompt action for Louisville businesses

    Several Louisville businesses and organizations are considering their responses as fears of a COVID-19 coronavirus outbreak in the U.S. grow. "Out of an abundance of caution, UPS has put in place health and hygiene measures that are in line with suggested World Health Organization measures," Mike Mangeot, public relations manager for United Parcel Service Inc., said in a statement to Business First. "However, given the scale and ongoing challenges with China resuming normal business activities, there will be some impact in our International segment this quarter." He also noted that people receiving packages are not at risk of contracting the virus.

  • Bristol-Myers Squibb Company Just Reported Yearly Earnings: Have Analysts Changed Their Mind On The Stock?
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    Bristol-Myers Squibb Company Just Reported Yearly Earnings: Have Analysts Changed Their Mind On The Stock?

    Bristol-Myers Squibb Company (NYSE:BMY) shares fell 4.8% to US$62.04 in the week since its latest yearly results. It was an okay result overall, with revenues coming in at US$26b, roughly what analysts had been expecting. This is an important time for investors, as they can track a company's performance in its report, look at what top analysts are forecasting for next year, and see if there has been any change to expectations for the business.

  • Is Now The Time To Look At Buying Southwest Airlines Co. (NYSE:LUV)?
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    Is Now The Time To Look At Buying Southwest Airlines Co. (NYSE:LUV)?

    Today we're going to take a look at the well-established Southwest Airlines Co. (NYSE:LUV). The company's stock saw significant share price movement during recent months on the NYSE, rising to highs of US$58.54 and falling to the lows of US$48.90. Some share price movements can give investors a better opportunity to enter into the stock, and potentially buy at a lower price.

  • Business
    Barrons.com

    3M Stock Is Upgraded Amid a Sea of Difficulties. It’s a Bold Call.

    Stock in industrial-chemical giant (MMM) is deeply out of favor, but that represents an opportunity to one analyst on Wall Street. Melius Research analyst Scott Davis upgraded 3M shares to the equivalent of Buy from Hold on Wednesday evening. It's a bit of good news for 3M (ticker: MMM) investors, who have endured a rough ride lately.