U.S. markets close in 4 hours 9 minutes
  • S&P 500

    +22.32 (+0.49%)
  • Dow 30

    +118.33 (+0.33%)
  • Nasdaq

    +81.94 (+0.54%)
  • Russell 2000

    +0.08 (+0.00%)
  • Crude Oil

    +0.79 (+0.94%)
  • Gold

    -17.20 (-0.95%)
  • Silver

    -0.55 (-2.24%)

    -0.0026 (-0.22%)
  • 10-Yr Bond

    -0.0010 (-0.06%)

    +0.0001 (+0.00%)

    +0.5470 (+0.48%)

    -881.81 (-1.39%)
  • CMC Crypto 200

    -0.53 (-0.04%)
  • FTSE 100

    +54.80 (+0.76%)
  • Nikkei 225

    +505.60 (+1.77%)

How pay-as-you-go auto insurance can be a smart choice in the COVID era

·5 min read
How pay-as-you-go auto insurance can be a smart choice in the COVID era
How pay-as-you-go auto insurance can be a smart choice in the COVID era

Last spring, millions of Americans suddenly saw their commute transform from an hour crawling on the freeway to less than a minute staggering over to the dining room table.

And with everyone spending far less time in their cars, the pandemic has started to change the car insurance industry, too.

Since the beginning of the pandemic, auto insurers have noticed increased demand for pay-as-you-go plans, which allow drivers to pay only for the miles they clock each month instead of a typical flat premium.

In fact, Allstate reported that the number of cars insured through its pay-per-mile program has increased six-fold in the past year, according to Bloomberg.

Here’s more on how this type of program works and which providers offer it, so that you'll know what to look for you when you compare car insurance quotes, which you should be doing at least once every six months.

How does pay-as-you-go work?

Closeup dashboard of mileage car
Song Pin / Shutterstock

Pay-per-mile insurance is a type of auto insurance policy that offers drivers who aren’t often out on the road an opportunity to save on their premiums.

You’ll still get all the same coverage you would with a traditional insurance policy, just instead of your usual monthly premiums, you’ll be charged a small base rate and for the miles you put on your car each month.

Your base rate will reflect some of the same underwriting factors for standard car insurance policies, like age, driving record, vehicle, your location and credit score. If you haven't seen your score in a while, you can easily check your credit score for free.

Generally, your base charge comes in around $20 a month and up, according to an analysis by LendingTree's ValuePenguin site. And then the typical per-mile charge is a few cents.

How do they measure my miles?

For the pay-per-mile structure to work, insurance companies need an accurate report of the miles you drive.

Most insurance companies that offer these programs generally provide a small device you can plug into a port near your steering wheel.

Depending on your insurer, the device could also track a few other factors, like your location, speed, time of day or whether you accelerate or brake quickly, which can contribute to further discounts on your premium.

Which providers offer it?

Man holds pen and clipboard while other man holds it steady
Freedomz / Shutterstock

While many companies offer discounts for low-mileage drivers, not all insurers offer a true pay-per-mile insurance policy.

Here are the pay-per-mile programs you can find while comparing rates online.


The Milewise program from Allstate is offered in 19 states across the country.

With Milewise, you’ll install a small device in your car to track your miles. You’ll be charged a daily rate as well as a per-mile rate for the miles you clock each month.

If you don’t plan to drive too much, you can pay as little as $20 a month with Milewise, based on multiple reviews of the program.

There’s also an Allstate Milewise mobile app you can download to monitor your usage more closely.


Nationwide’s SmartMiles program is open to residents of 41 states, making it the most widely accessible of the pay-per-mile programs.

Nationwide says most cars made after 1996 are compatible with its tracking device, but it warns some hybrids or diesel-powered cars may not be.

The per-mile rate at Nationwide is usually between 4 to 10 cents, which you’ll pay in addition to a daily base rate.

While a traditional policy with unlimited mileage will generally cost about $133 a month, Nationwide estimates the same drive logging about 500 miles a month would pay $95 a month with SmartMiles.

SmartMiles also offers its drivers a 10% discount for safe driving.


Automotive Electronic Diagnostic port OBD II under car dashboard
Gargantiopa / Shutterstock

Metromile is available in eight states: Arizona, California, Illinois, New Jersey, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Virginia and Washington.

When you sign up, the company will send you a small, wireless device you can plug into your vehicle’s diagnostic port to track your miles. Your monthly bill won’t factor in driving habits — just your base rate and mileage charge.

It’s a great fit for those who drive infrequently (about 12,000 miles a year or less), according to ValuePenguin. But the site also notes, based on customer feedback, that Metromile puts more emphasis on price than customer service and a smooth claims process.

In response to that, the company is now working on improving the claims experience by automating it.

Mile Auto

Mile Auto is currently only offered in four states: Arizona, Georgia, Illinois and Oregon. But it’s also the only pay-per-mile program that doesn’t involve installing a device in your car.

With Mile, you’ll send the company a photo of your odometer at the end of the month to keep track of the miles you’ve driven. Those miles (at your per-mile rate) will then be added to your base rate and that’s how the insurer calculates your monthly bill.

The company estimates that its customers save about 30% to 40% off their standard car insurance rates.

Other ways to keep the savings rolling

Young Couple Sitting On Sofa Using Digital Tablet
Monkey Business Images / Shutterstock

While you’re shopping for a new auto insurance policy, why not trim a few hundred more dollars from your monthly budget?

With homeowners insurance, simply comparing rates to find the best deal could cut your annual bill by up to $1,000.

Don’t forget about your life insurance either. Providing financial security for your family doesn’t have to cost an arm and a leg and your sanity — and involve a medical exam.

Now, signing up for an affordable life insurance policy takes only minutes, a medical exam is often not required, and policies start at just $16 a month.

Finally, if pay-as-you-go auto insurance doesn’t make sense for you or if it’s not offered in your state, you may want to ask your insurance company to give you a COVID “stimulus” discount.

If your insurer is holding out on you, it may be time to shop around for a better rate.

With all these savings squared away, once things return to normal, you’ll have a pile of cash saved up and a road of possibilities ahead of you.