U.S. Markets close in 3 hrs 6 mins

Notre Dame unhappy after losing NCAA appeal regarding vacated wins

(Getty Images)

Notre Dame says it strongly disagrees with the NCAA’s decision to vacate wins from the school’s football team in 2012 and 2013.

The NCAA said in November 2016 that the school had to vacate wins from the two seasons because a student trainer did coursework for two football players. Notre Dame appealed the decision, and the NCAA announced Tuesday that the school’s appeal had been denied.

Notre Dame went to the BCS Championship Game following the 2012 season and went 9-4 in 2013.

From the NCAA:

In its decision, the appeals committee highlighted that as a member of the NCAA, the university is subject to the Association’s rules, including those related to academic misconduct and the ability to impose penalties for academic misconduct violations. In this case, the university acknowledged the academic misconduct impacted the eligibility of student-athletes and resulted in student-athletes competing while ineligible. The appeals committee found the panel has the authority under NCAA rules to prescribe penalties for academic misconduct violations.

The university also argued that the penalty is excessive since there was no university involvement or knowledge of the academic conduct. The appeals committee confirmed that at the time of the violations, the athletic training student was considered a university employee under NCAA rules.

Notre Dame said it admitted that academic misconduct had taken place and that it took the necessary punishment steps at a school level regarding the cheating. It appealed the decision because it believed the NCAA “has never before vacated the records of an institution that had no involvement in the underlying academic misconduct.”

In a letter posted to the school’s website after the NCAA’s decision, Notre Dame expressed its displeasure with the decision. Hell hath no fury as a school forced to vacate wins.

Notre Dame president Rev. John Jenkins argued there was no precedent for the NCAA’s decision because the student trainer was not an employee of the school and noted the NCAA made that student/employee distinction in 2016. You’ll note that the NCAA’s statement above includes the phrase “at the time of the violations.”

There is no precedent in previous NCAA cases for the decision to add a discretionary penalty of vacation of team records in a case of student-to-student cheating involving a part-time student worker who had no role in academic advising.  In every other case in the record—meticulously detailed in the University’s arguments—the institutional representative of the university was employed as an administrator, coach, or person who served in an academic role.   The Committee simply failed to provide any rationale why it viewed the student-worker as an institutional representative in our case.  This is more disturbing given that, in 2016, the member institutions of the NCAA amended the academic misconduct rules to make clear that students who serve in roles identical to that of the student in our case would not be considered institutional representatives.  If the Committee members chose to depart both from precedent and the position adopted by the NCAA membership, it was incumbent on them to offer an explanation.  They did not.

Jenkins even referenced the NCAA’s decision regarding the North Carolina academic misconduct case in Notre Dame’s case against the NCAA. The sanctioning body said it couldn’t conclude that North Carolina violated NCAA rules with its sham classes. 

Notre Dame’s case stands in striking contrast with another recent high-profile academic misconduct case in which the NCAA Committee on Infractions chair explained that even though certain classes “more likely than not” were used to keep athletes eligible with fraudulent credits, the legitimacy of those classes was beyond the jurisdiction of the NCAA’s enforcement process precisely because that question must be left to the determination of the university in the exercise of its academic autonomy.  The notion that a university’s exercise of academic autonomy can under NCAA rules lead to exoneration—or to a severe penalty—without regard to the way in which it is used defies logic and any notion of fundamental fairness.

More on Yahoo Sports: 


– – – – – – –

Nick Bromberg is a writer for Yahoo Sports. Have a tip? Email him at nickbromberg@yahoo.com or follow him on Twitter!

  • Applied Industrial Technologies (AIT) is a Top Dividend Stock Right Now: Should You Buy?
    Finance
    Zacks

    Applied Industrial Technologies (AIT) is a Top Dividend Stock Right Now: Should You Buy?

    A dividend is that coveted distribution of a company's earnings paid out to shareholders, and investors often view it by its dividend yield, a metric that measures the dividend as a percent of the current stock price. Based in Cleveland, Applied Industrial Technologies (AIT) is in the Industrial Products sector, and so far this year, shares have seen a price change of -12.42%. The industrial products company is currently shelling out a dividend of $0.3 per share, with a dividend yield of 2.01%.

  • Hedge Funds Are Betting On CA, Inc. (CA)
    Finance
    Insider Monkey

    Hedge Funds Are Betting On CA, Inc. (CA)

    Investing in hedge funds can bring large profits, but it’s not for everybody, since hedge funds are available only for high-net-worth individuals. They generate significant returns for investors to justify their large fees and they allocate a lot of time

  • Why Celldex Therapeutics Is Jumping Today
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Why Celldex Therapeutics Is Jumping Today

    Shares of Celldex Therapeutics (NASDAQ: CLDX) jumped 12.1% higher as of 11:22 a.m. EST on Monday. What we're probably seeing is typical volatility in a small clinical-stage biotech stock. There have been several other double-digit-percentage daily increases for the biotech stock over the last four months.

  • See what the IHS Markit Score report has to say about IDEX Corp.
    Business
    Markit

    See what the IHS Markit Score report has to say about IDEX Corp.

    To the fullest extent permitted by law, IHS Markit disclaims any responsibility or liability, whether in contract, tort (including, without limitation, negligence), equity or otherwise, for any loss or damage arising from any reliance on or the use of this material in any way. Please view the full legal disclaimer and methodology information on pages 2-3 of the full report.

  • With pressure on power division, GE accelerates board turnover
    Finance
    American City Business Journals

    With pressure on power division, GE accelerates board turnover

    General Electric Co. said Monday that former Vanguard chairman and CEO John Brennan has stepped down from the Boston conglomerate's board of directors. GE (NYSE GE) had previously said that Brennan, who was the company's lead independent director until this summer, would not stand for reelection in 2019, but had not given a timeline for his exit. Brennan has been replaced by Paula Rosput Reynolds, a former CEO of several energy companies and a director on the boards of firms like BP and TransCanada Corporation.

  • Generic drug stocks slammed by report of expanded price-fixing probe
    News
    MarketWatch

    Generic drug stocks slammed by report of expanded price-fixing probe

    Shares of generic drug makers fell sharply Monday, after a Washington Post report that an antitrust lawsuit brought by states over two drugs in 2016 has expanded into a major probe of alleged price-fixing across the industry. The case now involves at least 16 companies and 300 drugs, the report said, citing Joseph Nielsen, an assistant attorney general and antitrust investigator in Connecticut, who has been a leader in the probe. Executives at more than a dozen companies allegedly conducted business over steak dinners, cocktail receptions and on golf courses, using an insider shorthand, the paper reported.

  • ‘Investor sentiment’ driving the markets
    Business
    Yahoo Finance Video

    ‘Investor sentiment’ driving the markets

    Emotion, not fundamentals, are driving the markets and that makes it tough to predict where stocks will go next. Yahoo Finance’s Alexis Christoforous speaks with Ryan Nauman of Informa Financial Intelligence.

  • Hedge Funds Are Buying Barrick Gold Corporation (ABX)
    Finance
    Insider Monkey

    Hedge Funds Are Buying Barrick Gold Corporation (ABX)

    Is Barrick Gold Corporation (NYSE:ABX) a good equity to bet on right now? We like to check what the smart money thinks first before doing extensive research. Although there have been several high profile failed hedge fund picks, the consensus picks among

  • Aurora Cannabis stock gains after company unveils plan to buy Mexican partner
    News
    MarketWatch

    Aurora Cannabis stock gains after company unveils plan to buy Mexican partner

    Just days after Aurora Cannabis Inc. announced a supply deal with Mexico’s Farmacias Magistrales SA, the Canadian cannabis company said it has entered a letter of intent to buy all of the company’s outstanding shares in an all-stock deal. Farmacias is Mexico’s first and, for now, only federally licensed importer of raw materials containing THC, the psychoactive ingredient in cannabis, Aurora (ACB)(CA:ACB) said in a statement. The company has the licenses and facilities to store and distribute medical products with more than 1% THC.

  • Is Quanta Services Inc (PWR) A Good Stock To Buy?
    Finance
    Insider Monkey

    Is Quanta Services Inc (PWR) A Good Stock To Buy?

    Hedge fund managers like David Einhorn, Dan Loeb, or Carl Icahn became billionaires through reaping large profits for their investors, which is why piggybacking their stock picks may provide us with significant returns as well. Many hedge funds, like Paul Singer’s Elliott Management, are pretty secretive, but we can still get some insights by analyzing their quarterly 13F filings. One of the most fertile grounds for large abnormal returns is hedge funds’ most popular small-cap picks, which are not so widely followed and often trade at a discount to their intrinsic value.

  • Why Morgan Stanley Lowered Its Price Target for AMD
    Finance
    Market Realist

    Why Morgan Stanley Lowered Its Price Target for AMD

    Mixed Server, PC, and Graphics Growth Makes AMD’s Stock Volatile (Continued from Prior Part) Analysts’ price target for AMD Wall Street analysts have lowered their price target for Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) due to near-term GPU (graphics processing

  • Exxon’s Power Play Points to Texas’ Future
    Business
    Bloomberg

    Exxon’s Power Play Points to Texas’ Future

    Despite lots of sunshine and power demand, the state hasn’t embraced solar power in a Texas-sized way. Last year, it ranked sixth in the U.S. in terms of solar generation, just behind Utah. As of the end of November, the state’s solar pipeline was at almost 37 gigawatts, up from less than 25 GW at the beginning of the year, according to the latest monthly report from the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT).

  • Why Etsy Stock Climbed 27.1% in November
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Why Etsy Stock Climbed 27.1% in November

    What happened Shares of Etsy (NASDAQ: ETSY) gained 27.1% in November, according to data provided by S&P Global Market Intelligence. The company recorded another quarter of strong sales and earnings growth, helping to send its stock to a new lifetime high

  • Implied Volatility Surging for Tandem Diabetes (TNDM) Stock Options
    Finance
    Zacks

    Implied Volatility Surging for Tandem Diabetes (TNDM) Stock Options

    Investors in Tandem Diabetes Care, Inc. TNDM need to pay close attention to the stock based on moves in the options market lately. What is Implied Volatility? Options with high levels of implied volatility suggest that investors in the underlying stocks are expecting a big move in one direction or the other.

  • Musk: ‘I do not respect the SEC’
    Business
    Yahoo Finance Video

    Musk: ‘I do not respect the SEC’

    Elon Musk is making waves with his latest interview, admitting no one is checking his tweets and saying he has no respect for the SEC. Yahoo Finance’s Alexis Christoforous and Rick Newman discuss.

  • Here's Why Hi-Crush Partners Fell 22.2% in November
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Here's Why Hi-Crush Partners Fell 22.2% in November

    Shares of Hi-Crush Partners (NYSE: HCLP) fell over 22% last month, according to data from S&P Global Market Intelligence. Investors went on a pretty wild ride to get there, though. Well, Hi-Crush announced third-quarter 2018 earnings at the end of October, rose on upbeat earnings from peer Covia Holdings, and then continued to trek lower as investors worried over falling crude oil prices.

  • Huawei CFO bail hearing to resume in Canada as Beijing steps up pressure
    World
    Reuters

    Huawei CFO bail hearing to resume in Canada as Beijing steps up pressure

    TORONTO/BEIJING (Reuters) - A top executive of Chinese tech giant Huawei Technologies is due back in a Canadian court on Monday where she will fight for her freedom with the help of pressure from Beijing against prosecutors' claims she cannot be trusted. Huawei [HWT.UL] Chief Financial Officer Meng Wanzhou, 46, was arrested by Canadian authorities on Dec. 1 at the request of the United States. U.S. officials allege Huawei was trying to use the banks to move money out of Iran.

  • Hedge Funds Are Dumping General Dynamics Corporation (GD)
    Finance
    Insider Monkey

    Hedge Funds Are Dumping General Dynamics Corporation (GD)

    Hedge funds run by legendary names like Nelson Peltz and David Tepper make billions of dollars a year for themselves and their super-rich accredited investors (you’ve got to have a minimum of $1 million liquid to invest in a hedge fund) by spending enormous resources on analyzing and uncovering data about small-cap stocks that the big brokerage houses don’t follow. Is General Dynamics Corporation (NYSE:GD) a healthy stock for your portfolio? The number of bullish hedge fund positions were trimmed by 6 recently.

  • Is IHS Markit Ltd. (INFO) A Good Stock To Buy?
    Finance
    Insider Monkey

    Is IHS Markit Ltd. (INFO) A Good Stock To Buy?

    Hedge funds and other institutional investors usually invest large amounts of capital and have to conduct due diligence while choosing their next pick. With this in mind, let’s take a look at the recent hedge fund activity surrounding IHS Markit Ltd. (NASDAQ:INFO). The number of bullish hedge fund positions moved up by 4 in recent months.

  • Is Micron Technology, Inc. (MU) A Good Stock To Buy?
    Finance
    Insider Monkey

    Is Micron Technology, Inc. (MU) A Good Stock To Buy?

    Hedge funds and other investment firms that we track manage billions of dollars of their wealthy clients' money, and needless to say, they are painstakingly thorough when analyzing where to invest this money, as their own wealth depends on it. Micron Technology, Inc. (NASDAQ:MU) investors should be aware of a decrease in support from the world's most elite money managers of late. MU was in 59 hedge funds' portfolios at the end of the third quarter of 2018.

  • See what the IHS Markit Score report has to say about Lions Gate Entertainment Corp.
    Business
    Markit

    See what the IHS Markit Score report has to say about Lions Gate Entertainment Corp.

    Lions Gate Entertainment Corp NYSE:LGF.B Score: Positive (75) 19 days at current score. Upgraded from Neutral on November 22nd 2018 View full report here! Summary This company ranked positively in all 3 IHS Markit categories and the Consumer

  • Is General Electric Company (GE) A Good Stock To Buy?
    Finance
    Insider Monkey

    Is General Electric Company (GE) A Good Stock To Buy?

    Hedge funds run by legendary names like Nelson Peltz and David Tepper make billions of dollars a year for themselves and their super-rich accredited investors (you’ve got to have a minimum of $1 million liquid to invest in a hedge fund) by spending enormous resources on analyzing and uncovering data about small-cap stocks that the big brokerage houses don’t follow. General Electric Company (NYSE:GE) has experienced an increase in activity from the world's largest hedge funds of late. GE was in 46 hedge funds' portfolios at the end of the third quarter of 2018.

  • See what the IHS Markit Score report has to say about Hyster-Yale Materials Handling Inc.
    Business
    Markit

    See what the IHS Markit Score report has to say about Hyster-Yale Materials Handling Inc.

    Hyster-Yale Materials Handling Inc NYSE:HY Score: Positive (76) 7 days at current score. Upgraded from Neutral on December 4th 2018 View full report here! Summary This company ranked positively compared to the Industrials sector despite only

  • Here's Why Pattern Energy Group Rose 15.5% in November
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Here's Why Pattern Energy Group Rose 15.5% in November

    Shares of Pattern Energy Group (NASDAQ: PEGI) rose over 15% last month, according to data from S&P Global Market Intelligence. The renewable energy asset manager reported third-quarter 2018 earnings and two portfolio-altering transactions. First, it sold a 90-megawatt wind farm at a selling price equivalent to 15 times the expected 10-year CAFD.

  • Say What? A Marijuana Stock Buying Back Its Shares
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Say What? A Marijuana Stock Buying Back Its Shares

    At seemingly every turn this year, the marijuana industry has made history. In Canada, nine decades of recreational marijuana prohibition was tossed aside in favor of legalization via the Cannabis Act. In the United States, two more states approved medical cannabis (Utah and Missouri), bringing the total number of states with legalized medical weed to 32.