U.S. Markets open in 10 mins

This Oil Stock Is Scorching Hot Right Now (Is It Still a Buy or Will It Burn Investors?)

Matthew DiLallo, The Motley Fool

Shares of W&T Offshore (NYSE: WTI) have enjoyed an impressive run lately. The stock was up another 10.5% this week, which pushed its year-to-date rebound to more than 45% (and we're only two weeks into the year). In fact, since last September, shares are up more than 150%.

That said, even with those gains, the stock is still down more than 70% over the past five years, suggesting it could have more room to run. However, while that upside potential might be tempting, this oil stock comes with a boatload of risk.

A natural gas flare from an offshore drilling rig.

Image source: Getty Images.

Drilling down into why this oil stock has been so hot

Two factors have driven W&T Offshore's rebound. First, crude oil has been on fire and was recently in the $60's, which is its best level in three years. In fact, oil has risen more than 40% since just last summer. Fueling that rebound has been a significant improvement in oil market fundamentals, thanks in part to OPEC's efforts to drain supplies. Those higher oil prices, if they hold up, would enable W&T Offshore to generate more cash flow from its production, which it could use to pay down debt or drill additional wells.

Meanwhile, more specific to W&T Offshore was its most recent operations update from late December. The offshore-focused oil driller noted that two of its three most recent exploration wells struck pay dirt. One well achieved an initial production rate of 1,100 barrels of oil equivalent per day, which outperformed the company's pre-drill expectations. Meanwhile, a second well also encountered oil and should start producing in the next 12 to 15 months. These wells hinted that the company still has the potential to uncover a substantial amount of oil.

An offshore oil platform with the sun rising in the background.

Image source: Getty Images.

Of risk and reward

W&T Offshore could unearth more of that oil in the coming year since the company has "number of high-quality, low-risk exploration opportunities under way or planned for the near future that offer substantial potential," according to comments by CEO Tracy Krohn in the third-quarter press release. Assuming success, these wells will come online over the next year, adding incremental production and cash flow. In addition to that, the company estimates that its drilling program could unlock as much as $2.2 billion of new oil reserves in the coming years, which is a substantial payday for the $1.5 billion company.

That said, what stands between W&T Offshore and those incremental supplies is its limited financial resources. The company said that it would need to invest about $317 million in drilling wells to unlock these underwater oil resources. That's a lot of money for a company that could only afford to spend $125 million on drilling last year because of lower oil prices and its tight financial situation. One of the things holding the company back is nearly $900 million of high-cost debt on its balance sheet, the bulk of which it took on to stay afloat during the oil market downturn. Because of that, it would make more sense for the company to divert any excess cash it pulls in from higher prices to paying down debt instead of drilling more wells.

Until the company shores up its balance sheet, it remains much too risky for the average investor, especially when compared to other oil stocks with stronger balance sheets and more visible growth prospects. For example, at $50 oil, Encana (NYSE: ECA) would have the money to grow cash flow at a 25% compound annual rate through 2022. Furthermore, Encana's plan would generate a whopping $1.5 billion in excess cash over that time frame, giving it money to pay down debt, increase its dividend, or buy back shares.

This oil stock is too hot to touch

W&T Offshore's stock has been scorching hot this year because investors are gambling that rising oil prices will give the company the cash it needs to repair its balance sheet and drill lucrative offshore wells. However, that's a high-risk bet because crude isn't back on solid ground just yet, with many analysts expecting oil to fall back into the $50's this year. Because of that, investors shouldn't touch this oil stock Instead, investors are better off considering a company like Encana, which can thrive even if crude takes a tumble.

More From The Motley Fool

Matthew DiLallo has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

  • Guggenheim's Minerd warns of a possible replay of 1987 stock market crash
    Business
    Reuters

    Guggenheim's Minerd warns of a possible replay of 1987 stock market crash

    Investors should brace for a possible replay of the 1987 stock market crash later this year, given this month's slump came against the backdrop of Federal Reserve interest rate hikes and rising inflation, Scott Minerd, Global Chief Investment Officer at Guggenheim Partners, said on Tuesday. “Eventually the Fed will acknowledge that three rate hikes will not be enough, but it is going to raise rates four times in 2018, and market speculation will increase that there may be a need for five or six rate hikes. On Monday Oct. 19, 1987, following large declines on Asian and European markets the previous week, the Dow Jones Industrial (.DJI) Average plunged 508 points, or 22.6 percent, for the biggest-ever single day decline in percentage terms by the blue-chip benchmark.

  • French Olympic Ice Dancer Suffers Serious Wardrobe Malfunction
    Sports
    Time

    French Olympic Ice Dancer Suffers Serious Wardrobe Malfunction

    French ice dancers Guillaume Cizeron and Gabriella Papadakis took second place in Monday’s short program despite a wardrobe malfunction. During the duo’s performance, Papadakis’ costume appeared to unhook from around her neck, exposing her left breast for part of the routine. The malfunction did seem to impair their final score of 81.93, but not enough to stop them from finishing second behind Scott Moir and Tessa Virtue of Canada, who scored 83.67.

  • Airbus sees no demand for bigger A350 for now
    Business
    Reuters

    Airbus sees no demand for bigger A350 for now

    By Alexander Cornwell TOULOUSE, France (Reuters) - Airbus is not planning a larger A350 jet and will focus on developing existing versions of the widebody aircraft, an executive said on Tuesday. Last summer, the European planemaker shelved tentative plans for a bigger A350 that would compete more directly with Boeing's new 777X plane currently under development. Lucas-Ugena earlier told reporters that Airbus remained focused on its existing A350-900 and A350-1000 jets.

  • Ethereum Founder Vitalik Buterin Warns That Cryptocurrencies Could Drop to 'Near-Zero'
    Business
    Fortune

    Ethereum Founder Vitalik Buterin Warns That Cryptocurrencies Could Drop to 'Near-Zero'

    Vitalik Buterin, the co-founder of the Ethereum blockchain and its associated cryptocurrency, does not want people throwing their life savings into virtual coins just yet. “Reminder: cryptocurrencies are still a new and hyper-volatile asset class, and could drop to near-zero at any time,” he tweeted this weekend. Reminder: cryptocurrencies are still a new and hyper-volatile asset class, and could drop to near-zero at any time.

  • 'Despacito' Is the Clear Winner of the 2018 Olympic Ice Dancing Competition
    Entertainment
    Time

    'Despacito' Is the Clear Winner of the 2018 Olympic Ice Dancing Competition

    If you watched the short program portion of the ice dancing competition at the 2018 Winter Olympics, there’s a good chance you came away with “Despacito” stuck in your head. Three pairs opened their program during Sunday’s figure skating event in PyeongChang with versions of the smash hit by Luis Fonsi and Daddy Yankee, which became the most streamed song ever over the summer with more than 4.6 billion YouTube views. Korea’s Alexander Gamelin and Yura Min were next to break it down to the popular Latin jam, with Polish skaters Maksym Spodyriev and Natalia Kaliszek — whose 66.06 was the highest score of the three teams — following shortly afterward.

  • New CEO denies prior knowledge of sex claims against founder
    News
    Associated Press

    New CEO denies prior knowledge of sex claims against founder

    The new CEO of Las Vegas-based Wynn Resorts said he was not aware of any of the sexual misconduct accusations against casino mogul Steve Wynn before they surfaced last month. Wynn Resorts is facing scrutiny by gambling regulators in Nevada and Massachusetts, where the company is building a roughly $2.4 billion casino just outside Boston. Steve Wynn has vehemently denied the misconduct accusations and attributed them to a campaign led by his ex-wife.

  • The Only 3 Energy Stocks That Matter to Billionaire Carl Icahn
    Business
    Insider Monkey

    The Only 3 Energy Stocks That Matter to Billionaire Carl Icahn

    Billionaire investing legend Carl Icahn of Icahn Capital has gained a reputation as a savvy investor and fearsome corporate raider, one who has tangled with the likes of Blockbuster Video and Time Warner in an effort to improve the value of his investments. If his wealth is anything to go by, he’s been rather successful in that regard. The 82-year-old is currently ranked 79th on Forbes’ real-time list of the world’s billionaires, with a personal fortune estimated at $17 billion. Icahn came to greater attention among the American public following the Presidential elections in 2016, when he was named a special advisor on regulatory reform by fellow billionaire Donald Trump. Icahn was quickly caught

  • California city to test universal basic income
    U.S.
    Fox Business Videos

    California city to test universal basic income

    Stockton, California, is set to experiment with a universal basic income plan in which select individuals will be given $500 a month, no strings attached.

  • 6 Reasons Buffett Bought Into Teva Pharmaceutical, as Told by a Teva Shareholder
    Business
    Motley Fool

    6 Reasons Buffett Bought Into Teva Pharmaceutical, as Told by a Teva Shareholder

    The past couple of years have been rough on Teva Pharmaceutical Industries (NYSE: TEVA) and its shareholders. The largest maker of generic drugs and developer of a handful of brand-name medicines lost practically half of its value in 2017, and it tumbled by well over 80% from its all-time highs in less than three years. The list of reason why Teva ran into a brick wall last year is a mile long.

  • Albertsons to buy Rite Aid in cash-and-stock deal
    Finance
    Reuters

    Albertsons to buy Rite Aid in cash-and-stock deal

    The deal is a potential lifeline for a slimmed-down Rite Aid that saw its negotiating power for generic drugs weaken when it sold nearly half of its stores to larger rival Walgreens. Rite Aid shares rose were up about 25 percent at $2.66 in premarket trading. Depending on whether Rite Aid shareholders chose to be paid in cash and Albertsons stock or only stock, the deal values Rite Aid at between $1.30 and $2.65 per share, Evercore ISI analyst Ross Muken said.

  • There Will Be 3 National Protests Over the Florida Mass Shooting. Here's What You Need to Know
    Finance
    Fortune

    There Will Be 3 National Protests Over the Florida Mass Shooting. Here's What You Need to Know

    On Feb. 14, a gunman walked into Marjory Stoneman Douglas High in Parkland, Fla. and shot and killed 17 people, including 14 students. The aftermath of the tragic shooting followed similar patterns: politicians sent their thoughts and prayers to the victims and discussed “the difficult issue of mental health“, and the price of shares in gun manufacturers went up. A group of students of Marjory Stoneman Douglas High who survived the shooting have started an organization called “March for Our Lives.” Their mission statement emphasizes the need to make the lives of students and teachers the nation’s “top priority” and calls on students across the country to join their cause.

  • The Internet Is Thrilled About Tessa Virtue and Scott Moir's Ice Dancing Gold Medal
    Sports
    Time

    The Internet Is Thrilled About Tessa Virtue and Scott Moir's Ice Dancing Gold Medal

    Come what may, ice dancing virtuosos Tessa Virtue and Scott Moir of Canada were determined to finish on top at the 2018 Winter Olympics in PyeongChang, South Korea. To the dramatic refrains of their Moulin Rouge medley, the popular pair of Virtue and Moir gave a picture-perfect performance of twizzles, surprising lifts and synchronized steps. This is the Moir-Virtue team’s third Olympic gold in ice dancing, after winning in 2010 in Vancouver and helping Canada snag a team gold this year in PyeongChang.

  • Where Will Skyworks Solutions, Inc. Be in 5 Years?
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Where Will Skyworks Solutions, Inc. Be in 5 Years?

    In the past six months, Skyworks shares have advanced a measly 1%, and over the past year shares are up less than 12%. Skyworks Solutions is poised to capitalize on the growth of the Internet of Things. The share price continues to amble, even as the company excels, because Skyworks has been given the dreaded label of being an Apple, Inc. (NASDAQ: AAPL) supplier.

  • Anonymous trader buys $400 million in bitcoin
    Business
    MarketWatch

    Anonymous trader buys $400 million in bitcoin

    Go big or go home. That’s the motto of one mysterious investor who put his chips on the table, buying close to $400 million of the No.1 digital currency, bitcoin. The purchase comes as cryptocurrencies are making a comeback after a dreadful start to 2018. Major digital currencies lost as much as 50% to start the year as growing regulation and security fears crippled the market, seeing traders bail on their positions. However, the tide has turned. The price of bitcoin BTCUSD, +1.61%  has increased more than 60% since trading under $6,000 on February 6, pushing back above $10,000, helped by signs of growing recognition of digital currencies from officials in Washington. “Not sure who that big buyer

  • China, US skirmish over nuclear codes: Report
    Business
    Fox Business Videos

    China, US skirmish over nuclear codes: Report

    China reportedly came close to getting its hands on the U.S. nuclear codes. Fox News military analyst Gen. Jack Keane (Ret.) weighs in.

  • 3 Ways to Make Sure You Don't Run Out of Money in Retirement
    Business
    Motley Fool

    3 Ways to Make Sure You Don't Run Out of Money in Retirement

    One of the biggest fears among workers aged 55 and older is running out of money in retirement. Considering about half of those workers don't have much in the way of retirement savings, they absolutely should be concerned their meager nest eggs won't last. It's hard to live off a retirement account with only a couple years' worth of living expenses.

  • Venezuela is about to pre-sell its ‘petro’ cryptocurrency, and it could be an ‘excellent pilot for Putin’
    Business
    CNBC.com

    Venezuela is about to pre-sell its ‘petro’ cryptocurrency, and it could be an ‘excellent pilot for Putin’

    Venezuela will launch a pre-sale of its commodity-backed "petro" cryptocurrency on Tuesday. President Nicolas Maduro hopes the country's own digital currency will help it to make financial transactions and get around Western sanctions. Both the United States and the European Union have imposed economic sanctions on Venezuela over their opposition to its autocratic government. Last year, the Economist Intelligence Unit's Democracy Index downgraded Venezuela from a "hybrid regime" to an "authoritarian regime" due to its "continued slide towards dictatorship." Venezuela's petro token will be backed by its oil, gas, gold and diamond reserves, according to the government. The country's cryptocurrency

  • Trump Slams 'Insecure' Oprah and Says He Hopes She Runs for President
    Politics
    Fortune

    Trump Slams 'Insecure' Oprah and Says He Hopes She Runs for President

    Donald Trump has insulted Oprah Winfrey and challenged the TV star to challenge him in the 2020 presidential election. The president tweeted about Winfrey late Sunday night after watching her host a “60 Minutes” panel discussion in which she addressed the problems with the national discourse. “One year into Donald Trump’s presidency, Americans remain divided, often unwilling to listen to what the other side has to say,” she said as she introduced partisan panelists from Grand Rapids, Michigan.

  • 3 Under-the-Radar Stocks Snatched Up By Billionaire David Tepper in Q4
    Business
    Insider Monkey

    3 Under-the-Radar Stocks Snatched Up By Billionaire David Tepper in Q4

    David Tepper of Appaloosa Management expressed confidence in the market at the beginning of this year, telling CNBC that the market looked almost as cheap at the beginning of this year as it did at the beginning of last year, buoyed by corporate tax cuts. That confidence was reflected in the fourth-quarter growth spurt that Appaloosa undertook, as the billionaire investor poured money into the market, hiking the value of his hedge fund’s 13F portfolio by 50% to $10.7 billion according to the 13F that Appaloosa filed with the SEC last week. Among the major stocks that Tepper poured money into during the previous quarter were Facebook Inc (NASDAQ:FB), Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL), T-Mobile US Inc (NYSE:TMUS),

  • General Electric: Barron's Shouts 'Beware!' That Settles It
    Business
    Forbes

    General Electric: Barron's Shouts 'Beware!' That Settles It

    Barron’s colorless black and white cover shows a broken General Electric logo with this dramatic advice: Value investors, beware. GE faces big risks, and its shares are no bargain. The problem is that Barron’s dire graphics and categorical warning are unsupported by the article, itself. Worse, for investors who heed the warning, it comes just when GE becomes an excellent contrarian buy/hold opportunity. Disclosure: Author recently established a position in General Electric So, what’s wrong with the Barron’s article? Barron’s simply explains why the stock is down 50% from the last time Barron’s wrote about GE: “General Electric Shares Could Return 15%” (June 17, 2017). Everything Barron’s says has

  • Cheasapeake (CHK) Q4 Earnings: A Disappointment in Store?
    Business
    Zacks

    Cheasapeake (CHK) Q4 Earnings: A Disappointment in Store?

    Chesapeake Energy Corporation CHK is slated to report fourth-quarter 2017 results on Feb 22, before the opening bell.In the trailing three months, the company reported a positive earnings surprise of 20.00%. Chesapeake beat the Zacks Consensus Estimate

  • Ice Hockey: Canada crush OAR to set up U.S. showdown
    Sports
    Reuters

    Ice Hockey: Canada crush OAR to set up U.S. showdown

    By Steve Keating GANGNEUNG, South Korea (Reuters) - Canada thumped the Olympic Athletes from Russia 5-0 on Monday to book their spot in the Olympic women's ice hockey final and renew one of the Winter Games's greatest rivalries. Canada have played for gold at every Winter Games since women's hockey became part of the Olympic program in 1998 and for the fifth time in six Winter Games will face off against the United States. "We have something special here and we're ready our coaching staff has prepared us as best they can and we just need to go out and just play," Canada forward Meghan Agosta told reporters.

  • Munger: You won't get the returns Buffett and I got by doing what we did
    Business
    Yahoo Finance

    Munger: You won't get the returns Buffett and I got by doing what we did

    Buffett and Munger have been critics of fees charged to investors by fund managers. Warren Buffett’s right-hand man, Charlie Munger, the vice chairman of Berkshire Hathaway (BRK-A, BRK-B), said they had an “easier world” than the young investors of today face. “I don’t think you’re going to get the kind of results we got by just doing what we did,” Munger, 94, said at the Daily Journal’s (DJCO) annual meeting in Los Angeles last week.

  • Alaska Air Group's January Load Factor Declines, Stock Falls
    Finance
    Zacks

    Alaska Air Group's January Load Factor Declines, Stock Falls

    Shares of Alaska Air Group, Inc. ALK have declined more than 2% ever since it released its traffic results for January 2018, last week. In the first month of 2018, the company’s consolidated traffic (measured in revenue passenger miles or RPMS) increased

  • 3 Beaten-Up Oil Stocks: Are They Bargains?
    Business
    Motley Fool

    3 Beaten-Up Oil Stocks: Are They Bargains?

    As an investor, you should be getting excited about the recent bump in oil prices. This is the best oil price environment we've seen in a long, slow, and painful three years. If you're not an oil investor yet, though, the early February market correction has beaten down the prices of some promising companies.