U.S. markets close in 4 hours 45 minutes
  • S&P 500

    +18.43 (+0.43%)
  • Dow 30

    +14.56 (+0.04%)
  • Nasdaq

    +117.75 (+0.89%)
  • Russell 2000

    +6.11 (+0.34%)
  • Crude Oil

    -1.04 (-1.13%)
  • Gold

    -4.70 (-0.25%)
  • Silver

    +0.09 (+0.39%)

    +0.0018 (+0.17%)
  • 10-Yr Bond

    -0.0710 (-1.54%)

    +0.0002 (+0.02%)

    0.0000 (0.00%)
  • Bitcoin USD

    +40.49 (+0.15%)
  • CMC Crypto 200

    +1.40 (+0.24%)
  • FTSE 100

    +32.47 (+0.43%)
  • Nikkei 225

    -14.90 (-0.05%)

Pandemic 'stay at home stocks' like Peloton, Zoom, Roku tank on Pfizer vaccine news—is it an overreaction?

Pfizer on Monday morning announced that its experimental COVID-19 vaccine, developed in partnership with BioNTech, was more than 90% effective in studies and that it could distribute 50 million doses before the end of this year, and 1.3 billion doses in 2021.

The good news immediately sent U.S. markets broadly higher—especially airline stocks, energy names, bank stocks, in-person entertainment like theme parks, and real estate—except for a slew of key names that have seen huge gains during the pandemic, boosted by prolonged work-from-home trends.

Those “stay-at-home stocks” were hit hard.

Peloton (PTON) fell by as much as 25%; Logitech (LOGI) fell 19%; Zoom Video (ZM) dropped 17%; CrowdStrike (CRWD) fell 11%; Chewy (CHWY) fell 10%; Roku (ROKU) sunk 7%; Netflix (NFLX) fell 6%; Slack (WORK) was down 4%.

The market thinking appears to be: a widely available vaccine will prompt a return to normalcy, which will mean the end of the hockey-stick run for products and services you use in your home.

But that reductive logic doesn’t apply equally well to every stay-at-home name. Rather, the post-pandemic prospects for each business have to be examined on a case-by-case basis.

Remote work won’t abruptly end with a vaccine

Since early on in the pandemic, analysts and experts have predicted that some form of remote work is here to stay—after all, it was a trend already growing before the pandemic. If that’s the case, then many companies are going to continue to use enterprise tools like Zoom and Slack, even once offices reopen. Whether workers are in their office or at home, teams that use Slack aren’t going to just stop using it.

In Zoom’s case, the stock has also become extremely expensive. It trades at more than 800 times earnings, so it was arguably due for a big correction. The vaccine news provided an excuse for firms to take some profit and move into other names, like the battered stocks set to take off now that a vaccine is imminent. (As for Slack, increased competitive threat from Microsoft Teams is also contributing to its slide.)

The same “here to stay” thinking with the enterprise names can apply broadly to streaming services like Netflix and Roku: just because people might return to their offices doesn’t mean they will stop streaming at home.

In Roku’s case, the dip makes a little more sense, since Roku relies on ad revenue from ads on its home screen, and advertisers might indeed shuffle their budgets away from Roku if they think time spent on streaming will drop significantly. For Netflix, which makes its revenue from subscriptions (it doesn’t sell ad space or sell user data), the stock dive would only make sense if you think a significant number of subscribers will cancel Netflix after the pandemic.

A Peloton indoor exercise bicycle is delivered to a customer during the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) lockdown in San Francisco, California, U.S. April 9, 2020. REUTERS/Greg Mitchell
A Peloton indoor exercise bicycle is delivered to a customer during the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) lockdown in San Francisco, California, U.S. April 9, 2020. REUTERS/Greg Mitchell

Peloton is its own case: the exercise-bike company took off early in the pandemic amid staggering demand for its bikes, creating wait times of 5-10 weeks on orders. As the stock surged, some analysts warned of a “pull-forward in demand,” the idea that Peloton cannot sustain this level of sales and would be punished later on because shareholder expectations would get too high. But in its fourth-quarter earnings report in September, Peloton had its first profit and showed massive continued demand for its bikes, making the bear case look wrong. (Meanwhile, Netflix, in contrast, actually did see in Q3, and explicitly identified, a pull-forward in demand from the first half of 2020 that hurt its subscription adds.) Once gyms fully reopen across the country, will Peloton bike sales really dry up?

On the other hand, Peloton stock, like Zoom, got extremely expensive (trading at a 15x P/E ratio), so it was due for a correction as soon as there was any indication that the end of the pandemic is in sight.

Buy online, pick up in store

One good example of a trend accelerated by the pandemic that is generally expected not to reverse is e-commerce and the rise of BOPIS (buy online, pick up in store) for brick-and-mortar retail.

Walmart, Target, Best Buy, Urban Outfitters, Restoration Hardware, and Dick’s Sporting Goods are just some of the physical retail names seeing enormous e-commerce gains, so much so that the share of U.S. retail spending attributed to e-commerce has surged to 16.1%, up from 10.8% one year ago.

Those chains have also seen huge customer adoption of curbside pickup. Dick’s Sporting Goods president Lauren Hobart said in August that Dick’s “anticipated originally that we would see a large drop-off [in curbside] when the stores reopened, but that is not the case.” Many retail analysts predict that even after the pandemic, consumers will stick with their new behavior and shop online, for home delivery or curbside pickup.

Whole Foods CEO John Mackey disagrees—he thinks some people will stick to online ordering, but that it won’t remain the norm for most. Even if he’s right, what that creates is a hybrid landscape for physical retail and physical grocery.

The same applies to remote work: even if a large number of workers return to the office, many more workers than before the pandemic are going to keep working from home, which should be good for enterprise names like Zoom, Slack, and CrowdStrike.

In this photo taken of a computer screen Wednesday, April 15, 2020, shows the Michigan Supreme Court who broke new ground by hearing two cases via Zoom video conferencing. Justice David Viviano was the only judge in his regular seat in court. At one point more than 180 people were watching live on YouTube. Justice Richard Bernstein, perhaps the most loquacious member, had questions for the lawyers as time was winding down. "Even on Zoom he finds a way" to run out the clock, Chief Justice Bridget McCormack joked. (AP Photo/Ed White)
In this photo taken of a computer screen Wednesday, April 15, 2020, shows the Michigan Supreme Court who broke new ground by hearing two cases via Zoom video conferencing. (AP Photo/Ed White)

Wharton professor Mauro Guillen writes in his new book, “2030: How Today’s Biggest Trends Will Collide and Reshape the Future of Everything,” that beyond the pandemic we should expect a “hybrid model” of working that allows for remote-work a few days a week, and continued automation of service warehouses.

“Most of what I hear from companies right now is that we're going to go to a hybrid model,” Guillen told Yahoo Finance in August. “So, a majority of American employees who are working from home now, they're saying, ‘Yes, I would like to have a remote component in my work week, but I would like to also go to the office.’”

Logitech CEO Bracken Darrell sounds a similar tune. He insists that the recent sales boom for Logitech’s computer accessories can’t be totally chalked up the pandemic, but to four “secular” shifts: “One is video going everywhere, whether it’s offices or webcams. The second one is the rise of gaming as a professional sport, and as a bigger and bigger spectator sport; it’ll be the biggest collection of sports in the world one day. The third one is working from anywhere. The fourth is everybody creating their own content and streaming it, which lends itself well to our microphones. All four of those are long-term secular trends.”

But of course, Darrell has to hope so for his business. The other companies labeled “stay at home names” during the pandemic are all hoping their momentum continues, even once we get a vaccine.

Daniel Roberts is an editor-at-large at Yahoo Finance and closely covers tech. Follow him on Twitter at @readDanwrite.

Read more:

AMC’s outlook is extremely dire as pandemic drags on

Netflix's Q3 demonstrates the dreaded 'pandemic pull-forward in demand'

Curbside pickup is ‘extremely sticky’ and will continue post-pandemic: McKinsey retail analyst

Walmart and Target huge e-commerce gains are a blaring siren to brick-and-mortar retail

2 key numbers show how quickly Nike is bouncing back from the pandemic

Why Restoration Hardware stock is up 270% during the pandemic

Why Wayfair stock is up 250% this year

Why Dick’s Sporting Goods is wildly outperforming amid the pandemic