U.S. Markets close in 3 hrs 43 mins

Social Security: Why Stock Investors Should Claim at 62

Dan Caplinger, The Motley Fool

Social Security provides a key source of retirement income for tens of millions of Americans, and one of the biggest financial decisions that older Americans have to make is when to start taking their Social Security benefits. Faced with a choice between larger benefits later in life and smaller benefits immediately, many choose to take their Social Security retirement benefits right at age 62, the earliest claiming age.

The Social Security Administration (SSA) has said that its intent in offering larger payments to those who delay taking benefits is to make the choices actuarially equivalent -- meaning that for the average person, when you claim shouldn't have an impact on how much you receive in benefits. But that's an overly simplistic summary of what's actually a complex mathematical question.

Fortunately, analyst Brian Alleva, with the Office of Retirement Policy and the Office of Retirement and Disability Policy at the SSA, did a much more thorough research project a couple of years ago that took a much closer look at the claiming decision. The study's conclusions make it clear that the ideal claiming decision varies depending on the investment strategy that a retiree follows. For stock market investors, that generally favors claiming as early as possible.

Social Security card with two dice on top.

Image source: Getty Images.

Discount rates and Social Security benefits

Most analyses of Social Security claiming ages focuses on looking at how much money you'll get from Social Security over the course of your lifetime. Claim early, and you'll get smaller payments but for a longer period of time. Wait, and your payments will be larger, but you'll get fewer of them. Guess how long you expect to live, and you'll be able to compare outcomes and decide which choice is likely to pay you more in the long run.

Strangely, though, most analyses of Social Security benefits ignores the time value of money. In order to keep the math as simple as possible, you'll typically find comparisons based on current-value benefit payments. In the language of the SSA study, this analysis assumes a real discount rate of zero, incorporating only the rate of inflation in valuing earlier payments more highly than ones further into the future.

Some analysts have argued that using the real discount rate for bonds is the better way to analyze the claiming decision. Because Social Security payments resemble what investors can get by purchasing an immediate annuity from a private insurance company and because Social Security is a financial obligation of the U.S. government, the argument goes, using the inflation-adjusted long-term bond rate makes the most sense.

However, the Alleva study sought to look at how different assumptions about the discount rate can lead to different optimal choices for when to claim Social Security. For investors, the results are eye-opening because they shed light on how aggressive and conservative investors can come to different conclusions about which decision is smartest.

Aggressive investors should claim earlier

The most important part of the SSA study's analysis looks at how choosing a discount rate affects the claiming age at which you can maximize your benefits. For an ultra-conservative investor who uses a real discount rate of zero, claiming at 62 pays the most until your life expectancy reaches around age 77. Then, the ideal claiming age rises to 66 by age 80 and hits 70 at around age 86. Those figures are almost identical to what traditional breakeven analysis typically gives.

However, the more aggressive an investor is, the higher those ideal claiming ages go. When you use a 2.4% real discount rate -- roughly equivalent to the typical return on long-term bonds -- the entire decision curve is shifted up about two to four years. In other words, in order to justify waiting beyond age 62 using the higher discount rate, you'd have to be confident in living until nearly age 80 rather than age 77.

For those who invest primarily in stocks, the real discount rate of 6.7% produces a scenario in which it never makes sense to wait until age 70 to claim Social Security. Indeed, unless you expect to live beyond age 95, waiting even until full retirement age is inferior to claiming as soon as possible. Once you hit a real discount rate of 7.5%, it's always smartest to claim at 62.

What the SSA study means for you

Few people use this sort of analysis in justifying taking their Social Security benefits early. That's appropriate, because despite the initial intent of Social Security not to be a primary income source, most people don't have substantial retirement nest eggs that they invest.

But for those who do have outside investments, the SSA analysis provides useful information in gauging this key claiming decision. Wait to claim, and you'll have to tap into your other financial resources earlier, forcing you to sell off investments that would likely have produced positive returns. Claim earlier, and you can let those investments grow longer. The more they grow, the smarter it will have been to allow them to do so by using Social Security to cover your living expenses instead.

More From The Motley Fool

The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

  • Now is a ‘once-in-a-lifetime’ chance to invest in US pot companies, investor says
    Yahoo Finance

    Now is a ‘once-in-a-lifetime’ chance to invest in US pot companies, investor says

    With some Canadian pot stocks posting triple-digit return rates this year, many retail investors have looked north to pour cash into cannabis. U.S. cannabis companies are worth a lot more than their current valuations suggest since federal illegality has put undue pressure on the industry, said David Wenger, a New York attorney and senior editor of the Cannabis Law Digest.

  • Tesla slips after Elon Musk announced lower-cost Model 3 (TSLA)
    Business Insider

    Tesla slips after Elon Musk announced lower-cost Model 3 (TSLA)

    Tesla CEO Elon Musk announced on Twitter on Thursday that a lower-cost Model 3 was immediately available for order on the company's website. The electric car will have a base price of $45,000 and is eligible for federal and state tax rebates. Tesla shares were down about 1% early Friday — they were up as much as 2.2% earlier in the session.

  • Business

    Proctor & Gamble Earnings Sent the Stock Flying

    (PG) (PG) stock is lifting the consumer staples sector Friday, thanks to strong earnings. Where we were: Staples have been sluggish all year, and the sector is trailing the market, even as the group has picked up some steam lately. Where we’re headed: Proctor & Gamble is rallying on its earnings report, and could keep climbing.

  • Here’s why you shouldn’t retire super early — even if you can

    Here’s why you shouldn’t retire super early — even if you can

    Despite the many perks of early retirement — waking up whenever you want, for example — it wasn’t the easiest decision. Earnings tend to peak around 48 for men and about 39 for women, according to an analysis by PayScale.

  • Why ServiceSource International Is Imploding Today
    Motley Fool

    Why ServiceSource International Is Imploding Today

    Shares of ServiceSource (NASDAQ: SREV), a provider of outsourced inside sales and customer service solutions, are being obliterated today. The stock is down 46% as of 11:07 a.m. EDT on Friday after the company shared preliminary third-quarter results and revised its full-year guidance.

  • What happens if you win Mega Millions' $970M jackpot?
    Associated Press

    What happens if you win Mega Millions' $970M jackpot?

    Despite the terrible odds — one in 302.5 million for those keeping score at home — someone will eventually match all six numbers and win the Mega Millions jackpot, which now stands at $970 million. Here are some answers for someone holding that prized lottery ticket for what would be the second-largest lottery jackpot in U.S. history. Lottery officials recommend winners take a deep breath, put their winning ticket in a safe spot and consult with a reputable financial planner before popping over to the lottery headquarters.

  • Business

    Jim Cramer Shares His Thoughts On Amarin, AT&T, McDonald's And More

    On CNBC's "Mad Money Lightning Round", Jim Cramer said Arrowhead Pharmaceuticals Inc (NASDAQ: ARWR) is a great speculative stock. Cramer is willing to endorse AT&T Inc. (NYSE: T), but he thinks Verizon Communications Inc. (NYSE: VZ) offers more safety

  • The only positive in autos is Tesla, says Jim Cramer
    CNBC Videos

    The only positive in autos is Tesla, says Jim Cramer

    CNBC's 'Squawk on the Street' discusses Tesla after Tesla CEO Elon Musk announced the low-cost Model 3 vehicle.

  • Suddenly Toxic, Saudi Prince Is Shunned by Investors He Courted

    Suddenly Toxic, Saudi Prince Is Shunned by Investors He Courted

    Now Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman could become the biggest risk to his own project. Everything changed when Jamal Khashoggi walked into the Saudi consulate in Istanbul on Oct. 2 and didn’t come out. Prince Mohammed, who’s denied any knowledge of Khashoggi’s fate, still has his defenders -– notably Donald Trump.

  • Home Depot vs. Lowe’s: Both Stocks Are Slumping, So Which One Should You Buy?

    Home Depot vs. Lowe’s: Both Stocks Are Slumping, So Which One Should You Buy?

    An analyst downgrade based on housing market outlooks has sent stocks from Lowe’s and Home Depot down over the last two days. Both Home Depot and Lowe’s are in downtrends dating back to September. On Wednesday, shares in Lowe’s and The Home Depot were slumping after disappointing housing market data led a key analyst to downgrade his ratings and slash price targets, and both stocks continued the slump into a second day on Thursday.

  • Ford CEO seeks to rally dealers as shares sink to new low

    Ford CEO seeks to rally dealers as shares sink to new low

    With Ford Motor Co's stock at nearly a nine-year low and the company squeezed by tariffs and trade tensions, Chief Executive Jim Hackett sought to restore confidence among dealers gathered in Las Vegas this week, days ahead of announcing the automaker's third-quarter results. In closed-door meetings with members of Ford's national dealer network, Hackett and other top Ford executives showed off future versions of the popular Explorer and Escape SUVs, as well as new the Ranger mid-sized pickup truck and an unnamed smaller off-road utility vehicle, attendees said. Ford has said it will refresh 75 percent of its North American lineup over the next two years.

  • Business

    Gambling Stocks Aren’t So Lucky, According to Goldman Sachs

    (GS) removed (LVS) from its Conviction Buy list amid a dimmer outlook for Macau, although the firm still thinks it’s the best bet among casinos. Where we were: Casino stocks have suffered this year, hurt in large part by weak gambling data from Macau. Where we’re headed: A less robust reality is ahead, although Las Vegas Sands does have some hedges that should help it through a sluggish period.

  • Business
    Motley Fool

    Why IBM’s Brief Growth Streak Just Stalled

    Unfortunately for its shareholders, there was a speed bump on the road to rebound last quarter: The company reported this week that revenue shrank, and growth in its vital "strategic imperatives" businesses slowed. Seriously, when IBM's legacy mainframe business is the strongest performer in a given quarter, one has to see that as a problem.

  • Is CenturyLink, Inc. a Buy?
    Motley Fool

    Is CenturyLink, Inc. a Buy?

    Legacy landline telecom CenturyLink, Inc. (NYSE: CTL) gets plenty of grief. And understandably so, considering that its legacy business, copper wire landline and internet connections is a steadily declining business while fiber and wireless technologies

  • Why Yandex N.V. Stock Plunged Today
    Motley Fool

    Why Yandex N.V. Stock Plunged Today

    What happened Shares of Yandex N.V. (NASDAQ: YNDX) dropped 17.8% on Thursday following reports that Russia's state-owned Sberbank may take a controlling stake in the country's leading internet search company. More specifically, according to sources speaking

  • Love Dividends? 3 Stocks You Might Want to Buy
    Motley Fool

    Love Dividends? 3 Stocks You Might Want to Buy

    It's even better when you know that the dividend is a big one! You'll get more of those good feelings if you add high-yielding Magellan Midstream Partners, L.P. (NYSE: MMP), General Mills, Inc. (NYSE: GIS), and Tanger Factory Outlet Centers, Inc. (NYSE: SKT) to your income portfolio. It has also been reworking older brands, notably with new yogurt and ice cream products.

  • Goldman Sachs Adds Nvidia To 'Conviction Buy' List
    Yahoo Finance Video

    Goldman Sachs Adds Nvidia To 'Conviction Buy' List

    Goldman Sachs analyst Toshiya Hari reiterated his 'Buy' rating for Nvidia and added the chip-maker to Goldman’s 'Conviction Buy' list.

  • China Plans to Launch an 'Artificial Moon' to Light Up the Night Skies

    China Plans to Launch an 'Artificial Moon' to Light Up the Night Skies

    The night skies might soon have company: Chinese scientists are planning to launch an artificial moon into orbit by 2020 to illuminate city streets after dark. Scientists are hoping to hang the man-made moon above the city of Chengdu, the capital of China’s southwestern Sichuan province, according to a report in Chinese state media. The imitation celestial body — essentially an illuminated satellite — will bear a reflective coating to cast sunlight back to Earth, where it will supplement streetlights at night.

  • It’s a ‘Hold’ for Nokia: A Look at Analyst Recommendations
    Market Realist

    It’s a ‘Hold’ for Nokia: A Look at Analyst Recommendations

    Nokia in Q3 2018: Why Analysts Are Estimating Lower (Continued from Prior Part) Stock up 23% in 2018 Nokia (NOK) stock fell 32% in 2016 and traded flat in 2017. Since the start of 2018, however, it has risen ~23%. It has fallen 5% in the last 12 months

  • Palo Alto Networks Stock Upgraded: What You Need to Know
    Motley Fool

    Palo Alto Networks Stock Upgraded: What You Need to Know

    Cybersecurity company Palo Alto Networks (NYSE: PANW) won a big upgrade today when analysts at R.W. Baird announced they're assuming coverage of the stock and raising their price target to $250 a share. If they're right about that, Palo Alto Networks is worth more than 23% more than it currently costs. Many companies offer cybersecurity services, but which one is the best to invest in?

  • State Street (STT) Misses on Q3 Earnings & Revenue Estimates

    State Street (STT) Misses on Q3 Earnings & Revenue Estimates

    Have you been eager to see how State Street STT performed in Q3 in comparison with the market expectations? State Street came out with earnings of $1.87 per share, which missed the Zacks Consensus Estimate of $1.88. You should note that the earnings estimate revisions for State Street depicted a bearish stance prior to the earnings release.

  • Marijuana investors may lose 90% of their money in Canada, so consider the really big prize elsewhere

    Marijuana investors may lose 90% of their money in Canada, so consider the really big prize elsewhere

    Marijuana presents a tremendous opportunity for investors over the next few years. Naïve investors are excited. The reality is that professionals will pick their pockets, and many naïve investors who are excited now will end up losing 90% of their investment.

  • Provocateur Stormy Daniels Takes an Unexpected Turn in the National Spotlight

    Provocateur Stormy Daniels Takes an Unexpected Turn in the National Spotlight

    To understand what it means to be famous like Stormy Daniels, for the reasons she is famous, spend time with her in a public space. On Oct. 15, a California judge threw out the defamation case she filed against Donald Trump. Over the past year, Daniels, 39, has become the Zelig of White House scandals.

  • Kinder Morgan Inc.’s CEO Outlines a 4-Step Plan for a Brighter Tomorrow
    Motley Fool

    Kinder Morgan Inc.’s CEO Outlines a 4-Step Plan for a Brighter Tomorrow

    Kinder Morgan (NYSE: KMI) recently completed a "momentous" quarter according to CEO Steve Kean. Not only did the pipeline giant's financial results beat its expectations, but it was a pivotal quarter on a strategic front, because the company closed the sale of the Trans Mountain Pipeline and locked up another new growth project. Complete the distribution of the Trans Mountain proceeds and continue our discussions on turning the positive indications that we now have from all three rating agencies into positive ratings actions.

  • Better Buy: GlaxoSmithKline plc vs. Eli Lilly
    Motley Fool

    Better Buy: GlaxoSmithKline plc vs. Eli Lilly

    People get sick regardless of the economic cycle, so companies that cater to healing them often outperform during downturns, and their stocks are considered "defensive." Healthy and dependable dividends can also contribute to stabilizing portfolio returns in good times and bad. Two successful blue-chip stocks in the healthcare industry are British GlaxoSmithKline plc (NYSE: GSK) and Eli Lilly (NYSE: LLY). Investors like both stocks for their dividends and consistent performance, but the companies are really quite different, with GlaxoSmithKline diversified into vaccines and consumer products, and Eli Lilly focused on pharmaceuticals.