U.S. Markets close in 4 hrs 20 mins

Suit Against D.A. Who Used Fake Subpoenas To Put Victims In Jail Kicks Off Civil Rights Battle

Renata Singleton is a plaintiff in a lawsuit against the district attorney in New Orleans. 

WASHINGTON ― Renata Singleton is a black woman who spent five days in a New Orleans jail because she couldn’t afford her bail. Away from her three children, she lost eight pounds before her mother was finally able to purchase her release.

When Singleton got home, she had an 8 p.m. curfew and started wearing bell-bottom jeans to hide the electronic monitor on her ankle from her kids. Despite having a master’s degree in business administration, she’s worried she’ll have trouble finding a new job: Her mug shot and a record of her arrest are still floating around online.

None of those facts make Singleton’s story extraordinarily noteworthy: Legally innocent defendants unable purchase their freedom ahead of trial areregularly locked up. Here’s what does: Singleton wasn’t accused of a crime. She was the victim of one.

About three years ago, in November 2014, Singleton got into an argument with her boyfriend. He shattered her phone. Her daughter called the police. The boyfriend was arrested. 

Singleton’s ex-boyfriend was able to pay a $3,500 secured bond at his arraignment the next day, and he was released. He later pleaded guilty to two misdemeanors and was sentenced to probation without jail time.

Singleton, the victim in the case, didn’t have such an easy go of it. When a victim-witness advocate for the Orleans Parish District Attorney’s Office reached out to her, Singleton said she wasn’t interested in pursuing charges. She had a job that paid by the hour, and she didn’t want to miss out on work or time with her kids. She’d broken up with the man. She was ready to move on.

Prosecutors didn’t let her let it go. According to a lawsuit filed Tuesday against Orleans Parish District Attorney Leon Cannizzaro and others in his office, investigators drafted up “subpoenas” requiring Singleton to appear for a meeting at the district attorney’s office in April 2015, when the case against her ex-boyfriend was still pending.  

Those documents were not actually subpoenas ― but the district attorney’s office misleadingly labeled them as such to compel Singleton to show up to a meeting. Singleton didn’t know that at the time, but she didn’t go to the meeting because a friend in law enforcement told her that she hadn’t been validly served.

The day Singleton missed the meeting, an assistant district attorney applied for a material witness warrant, asking the court to jail Singleton. Believing the fake subpoenas were actual subpoenas, a judge issued the arrest warrant.

Singleton eventually met with prosecutors, but told them she wouldn’t talk to them without a lawyer present. Rather than granting her access to a lawyer, prosecutors had Singleton led out of their office in handcuffs, and she was arrested on the warrant.

It was the first time Singleton had ever been arrested. She was taken to jail and forced into an orange jumpsuit. Her bail was $100,000 ― more than 28 times the bail amount set for her alleged abuser. She spent five days in jail before she went before a judge, who reduced her bail to an amount her mother could afford.

Singleton is now the main named plaintiff in a lawsuit against Cannizzaro and his office that alleges that his prosecutors “routinely issue their own fabricated subpoenas directly from the District Attorney’s Office ― without any judicial approval or oversight ― in order to coerce victims and witnesses into submitting to interrogations by prosecutors outside of court.”

The suit, filed by Civil Rights Corps, the American Civil Liberties Union and the ACLU of Louisiana, opens a new front in the legal battle to change the criminal justice system ― by challenging the actions of prosecutors through civil rights litigation.

“Prosecutors are one of the biggest forces behind our society’s addiction to senseless mass human caging,” says Alec Karakatsanis, the Civil Rights Corps’ founder. “And for years, they have operated with virtually no transparency or accountability. Our hope is that cases like this one help tell people the story about what prosecutors have been doing in our legal system, away from view, and about why they have been doing it.”

Anna Arceneaux, an ACLU senior staff attorney on the case, said she hoped this lawsuit and others like it would help “change the landscape in holding prosecutors accountable, because so much of our crisis of over-incarceration in this country turns on the decision-making of prosecutors who are so used to not being held accountable and having very little oversight of their decisions.”

Orleans Parish District Attorney Leon Cannizzaro, pictured here on April 6, 2015, now faces a lawsuit from the ACLU and Civil Rights Corps.

Prosecutors are notoriously protected from being held accountable for misconduct. The high bar for suing prosecutors for the actions they take in the course of their jobs amounts to near immunity.

But there is one rarely used provision of the law: challenging patterns and practices of unconstitutional conduct. That’s what’s happening in the New Orleans case ― the plaintiffs are alleging that issuing fake subpoenas was the office’s adopted formal policy, not just the action of one rogue prosecutor. 

Cannizzaro had challenged members of the New Orleans City Council last month to show him one person who was ever arrested on one of the D.A. notices. It evidently wasn’t too hard: Civil rights investigators have already found at least 10 cases in the past three years in which prosecutors applied for arrest warrants by relying on the assertion that a witness didn’t obey one of the office’s fraudulent subpoenas. 

The lawsuit alleges that the Orleans Parish District Attorney’s Office engages in an unconstitutional policy of using “extrajudicial and unlawful means to coerce, arrest, and imprison crime victims and witnesses.” The lawsuit said that victims and witnesses “routinely wait weeks or even months in jail” before they appear before a judge.

According to the suit, a rape victim spent 12 days in jail before making a first court appearance, while a child sex trafficking victim spent 89 days behind bars before she was able to challenge her detention in court.

“Defendants’ policies are designed to create a culture of fear and intimidation that chills crime victims and witnesses from asserting their constitutional rights,” the lawsuit says. “As a result of these policies, crime victims and witnesses in Orleans Parish know that if they exercise their right not to speak with an investigating prosecutor, they will face harassment, threats, arrest, and jail.”

Prosecutors can typically request subpoenas through a formal process that requires witnesses or victims to appear at a court hearing or before a grand jury. They’re not allowed to use a subpoena to demand that a witness show up to a private meeting. 

So prosecutors in New Orleans forged and doctored the documents, according to the lawsuit. In one case, prosecutors gave a doctored subpoena to a 60-year-old homeless battery victim. The man was required to appear in court on March 6, 2017, but prosecutors altered the document to say he’d instead have to show up to the district attorney’s office on March 3. The forgery was apparent because the individual who altered it failed to change the appearance date in some cases, and forgot to remove some references to the court, the lawsuit said.

The Lens, a New Orleans news organization, first reportedon the fake subpoenas in April. Shortly afterward, Cannizzaro announced he would bring an end to what he admitted was an “improper” office policy.

“It was improper for us, it was incorrect for us to label those notices as a subpoena,” Cannizzzarotold a local news station. “That was incorrect. It was improper and I take responsibility for that.”

Instead, the office has begun sending out “notices” that do not include the word “subpoena.” Still, the lawsuit alleges, the documents “create the false impression that the witness is ‘required’ by law to meet privately with prosecutors.”

The lawsuit also alleges that Cannizzaro threatened Tamara Jackson, the executive director of the New Orleans victim rights organizationSilence Is Violence, another plaintiff in the suit. According to the suit, after Jackson filed a complaint to the National District Attorneys Association about what she saw as the local district attorney office’s inadequate protections for crime victims, Cannizzaro “called Ms. Jackson and told her to be careful: if it appeared that she was encouraging victims not to communicate with his office, he could prosecute her for witness coercion.”

Jackson told HuffPost that the district attorney’s office’s actions have made her organization’s work more difficult. She said she felt retaliated against for publicly criticizing the office for not offering supporting services. “What they tell people is that they will likely have this witness protection when we don’t have a witness protection program here in Orleans Parish, and they’re not being truthful. They give folks deceptive information to encourage them to share,” Jackson said. “I don’t trust them at all, and I do share the sentiments of our clients because I know what they’re capable of.” 

Tamara Jackson of the New Orleans organization Silence Is Violence.

Both Civil Rights Corps and the ACLU are placing a new focus on prosecutorial accountability. Civil Rights Corps, which prides itself on an “innovative and aggressive” approach to civil rights law, has brought several notable challenges to bail systems across the United States, including a noteworthy case currently pending before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit that bail supporters and opponents are watching closely. 

Civil Rights Corps hasreceived funding from Facebook co-founder Mark Zuckerberg and his wife, pediatrician Priscilla Chan. As part of its new project on prosecutors, the organization is planning to build a publicly accessible, centralized database of instances of prosecutorial misconduct. It will also pursue pattern and practice cases ― when an office is accused of using unconstitutional methods on a widespread basis ― and state bar complaints. A job description for the project states that there are “vast swaths of largely unexplored areas” of the law in regard to prosecutorial misconduct.

The ACLU also wants to draw attention to the role of prosecutors, both through litigation and through educational efforts. Arceneaux said the ACLU wants to challenge the contours of prosecutorial immunity and take cases that others aren’t always willing to take.

“The district attorneys hold a lot of power, and it’s not an easy lawsuit to bring for people in the local community,” Arceneaux said. “Prosecutors have enormous power, and they routinely operate without oversight.”

This story has been updated with a quote from Tamara Jackson.

Read the full lawsuit below.

Ryan Reilly is HuffPost’s senior justice reporter, covering criminal justice, federal law enforcement and legal affairs. Have a tip? Reach him at ryan.reilly@huffingtonpost.com or on Signal at 202-527-9261.

This article originally appeared on HuffPost.

  • The ‘smart money’ says it’s time to buy the Chinese internet giants and the U.S. FAANGs

    The ‘smart money’ says it’s time to buy the Chinese internet giants and the U.S. FAANGs

    When the media and investors turn negative on stocks but the “smart money” is bullish, it’s a good time to think about buying. After all, exactly what is the smart money, and how do you know? Lately, several fund managers who pass this test have been pounding the table on Chinese internet names.

  • Business

    Goldman Sachs sees a correction coming for chipmakers but still likes Nvidia

    "We foresee a cyclical correction approaching and recommend investors to stay selective in Semis," Goldman Sachs said in a note Thursday. Nvidia is Goldman's top choice in the industry. Goldman Sachs warned clients about a downturn coming for the semiconductor sector, but still recommends some chip stocks.

  • Kinder Morgan Beats Q3 Earnings Estimates, Improves Leverage
    Market Realist

    Kinder Morgan Beats Q3 Earnings Estimates, Improves Leverage

    Kinder Morgan Beats Q3 Earnings Estimates, Improves Leverage Kinder Morgan’s third-quarter results Kinder Morgan (KMI) announced its third-quarter results on October 17 after the markets closed. The company announced an adjusted EPS of $0.21—up ~40%

  • How Analysts View Honeywell ahead of Third-Quarter Earnings
    Market Realist

    How Analysts View Honeywell ahead of Third-Quarter Earnings

    Currently, 24 analysts are tracking Honeywell (HON), which is more than during the second quarter. The latest analyst consensus target price on Honeywell is ~$178.0, which implies a potential return of 11.6% over the closing price of $159.56. In the past three months, analysts have moved the target price from $173.65 to the current target price, which indicates analysts are bullish on the stock.

  • Car Wars: Steel Getting Stronger, Lighter to Curb Aluminum Rise

    Car Wars: Steel Getting Stronger, Lighter to Curb Aluminum Rise

    Lightweight aluminum has chipped away at steel’s use in vehicles as fuel efficiency standards have risen. The fuel standards are under attack, a trade war threatens to hike costs, and the auto industry is racing toward a future with electric cars that consumers insist go further and further on a single charge. For automakers, “the biggest bang for their buck is going to be in the power train and battery supply,” Petersen said.

  • Aurora Cannabis Gets License for Aurora Sky Facility
    Market Realist

    Aurora Cannabis Gets License for Aurora Sky Facility

    Key Updates from the Cannabis Sector after Legalization in Canada (Continued from Prior Part) Aurora Sky license On October 17, Aurora Cannabis (ACB) (ACBFF) announced that it received sales licenses from Health Canada. Aurora Cannabis stated that with

  • Seritage Growth Properties Can Thrive in a Post-Sears World
    Motley Fool

    Seritage Growth Properties Can Thrive in a Post-Sears World

    A little more than three years ago, Sears Holdings (NASDAQ: SHLD) spun off real estate investment trust Seritage Growth Properties (NYSE: SRG) and sold more than 250 real estate assets to Seritage. The idea was that Sears would receive some much-needed cash to pay down debt, while Seritage would be able to gradually recapture space from Sears and Kmart and redevelop some of its real estate for higher-paying tenants. Now that Sears Holdings filed for bankruptcy earlier this week, the REIT may have to move even faster to find new tenants.

  • Nine Energy and Magnum Oil Tools Sign $493M Takeover Deal

    Nine Energy and Magnum Oil Tools Sign $493M Takeover Deal

    Nine Energy Service, Inc. NINE announced that it has agreed to acquire Magnum Oil Tools International, LTD, for roughly $493 million. The transaction comprises cash consideration of approximately $334 million along with stock consideration of 5 million

  • Cramer: Buy FAANG now
    CNBC Videos

    Cramer: Buy FAANG now

    CNBC's 'Squawk on the Street' team discusses why Jim Cramer is bullish on FAANG stocks.

  • Jamal Khashoggi's death may end an era of Bay Area tech investment
    American City Business Journals

    Jamal Khashoggi's death may end an era of Bay Area tech investment

    New details have emerged about the killing of journalist Jamal Khashoggi by Saudi agents — involving his beheading and dismemberment upon entering the Saudi consulate in Istanbul, Turkey — thanks to audio files described by Turkish officials. As evidence mounts of the Washington Post columnist’s gruesome death tied to Saudi Arabia, Bay Area tech companies, which have gobbled up billions in funding from the kingdom in recent years, could see that money river dry up as Saudi investment becomes increasingly toxic. A week after Khashoggi’s disappearance, Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman still vehemently denies any involvement from Saudi Arabia, as does President Donald Trump.

  • Nokia in Q3 2018: Why Analysts Are Estimating Lower
    Market Realist

    Nokia in Q3 2018: Why Analysts Are Estimating Lower

    Nokia (NOK) is expected to announce its third-quarter earnings on October 25. Analysts expect revenue of $6.4 billion compared to $6.46 billion in Q3 2017, indicating a year-over-year decline of 1%. Revenues for Ericsson (ERIC) and Juniper Networks (JNPR) are expected to fall 4.2% and 6.5%, respectively, in their current quarters.

  • How Has Microsoft’s Recent Performance Shaped Up?
    Market Realist

    How Has Microsoft’s Recent Performance Shaped Up?

    Microsoft’s (MSFT) revenue rose at a four-year CAGR (compound annual growth rate) of 6% to $110.4 billion in fiscal 2018, which ended on June 30, 2018. Its net income rose at a four-year CAGR of 8% to $30.3 billion. Microsoft’s revenue forecasts for fiscal 2019, fiscal 2020, and fiscal 2021 are $122.9 billion, $135.9 billion, and $151.2 billion, respectively.

  • Pricing boost helps Philip Morris quarterly results to beat estimates

    Pricing boost helps Philip Morris quarterly results to beat estimates

    Philip Morris International (PM.N), maker of Marlboro cigarettes, maintained its full-year guidance on Thursday after higher pricing helped it to report better than expected quarterly sales and profit. Philip Morris is pinning its hopes for the future on its IQOS device, which heats tobacco instead of burning it, thereby producing a vapour instead of smoke. Shares in Philip Morris also fell this week after rival British American Tobacco (BATS.L) cut its full-year revenue target for cigarette alternatives such as vaping pens and tobacco heating devices, citing a flat market in Japan and a product recall in the United States.

  • How the Recent Sell-Off Impacted AT&T’s Technical Indicators
    Market Realist

    How the Recent Sell-Off Impacted AT&T’s Technical Indicators

    What Investors Should Know about AT&T’s Growth Prospects (Continued from Prior Part) AT&T’s moving averages Now let’s look at AT&T’s (T) technical indicators and compare them to its peers in the telecom space. The sell-off of AT&T stock in October saw

  • Bears in for a Tough Ride after Alcoa’s Third-Quarter Earnings
    Market Realist

    Bears in for a Tough Ride after Alcoa’s Third-Quarter Earnings

    Alcoa (AA), the leading US-based aluminum producer, released its Q3 2018 earnings yesterday, October 17, after the close of markets (XME). Alcoa’s Q3 earnings were better-than-expected, and the stock was trading sharply higher in after-market trading yesterday. Alcoa reported revenues of $3.39 billion in the third quarter.

  • 'It's Not a Republican Problem.' Mitch McConnell Blames Entitlements for Rising U.S. Deficits

    'It's Not a Republican Problem.' Mitch McConnell Blames Entitlements for Rising U.S. Deficits

    Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell on Tuesday blamed rising federal deficits and debt on a bipartisan unwillingness to contain spending on Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security, and said he sees little chance of a major deficit reduction deal while Republicans control Congress and the White House. “It’s disappointing but it’s not a Republican problem,” McConnell said in an interview with Bloomberg News when asked about the rising deficits and debt.

  • Why American Airlines Group Stock Jumped 6% -- Then Gave Most of It Back
    Motley Fool

    Why American Airlines Group Stock Jumped 6% -- Then Gave Most of It Back

    Shares of American Airlines Group (NASDAQ: AAL) popped 6.4% in early trading Wednesday before retracting to close the day up less than 1% -- just 0.9%, to be precise. An upgrade assigned to the stock by Deutsche Bank appears to be the primary reason for the move. A Deutsche Bank analyst upgraded American Airlines stock from "hold" to "buy" on Wednesday, as we're told by our friends at StreetInsider.com.

  • Employee Accused of Urinating on Production Line at Food Processing Facility
    WTKR - Norfolk

    Employee Accused of Urinating on Production Line at Food Processing Facility

    Smithfield Foods, Inc. said in a statement Tuesday that it disposed of more than 50,000 pounds of product after reports of an employee urinating at his station at the company’s processing facility in Virginia.

  • Intel restructures manufacturing organization
    American City Business Journals

    Intel restructures manufacturing organization

    Chip giant Intel is restructuring its technology and manufacturing business group as it chases more connected device markets and grapples with delays on its next chip generation. In a memo to employees, reviewed by the Business Journal, Group President and Chief Engineering Officer Murthy Renduchintala described splitting the technology and manufacturing business into three groups. The three new groups are technology development, manufacturing and operations and global supply chain.

  • Blackstone third-quarter profit beats estimates amid market rise

    Blackstone third-quarter profit beats estimates amid market rise

    By Joshua Franklin NEW YORK (Reuters) - Blackstone Group LP (BX.N), the world's largest manager of alternative assets, modestly exceeded analyst expectations with an 11 percent jump in third-quarter earnings on Thursday, as climbing equity

  • Why MannKind Corp. Soared 16.4% Tuesday
    Motley Fool

    Why MannKind Corp. Soared 16.4% Tuesday

    After MannKind Corp. (NASDAQ: MNKD) announced that it closed on its planned collaboration agreement with United Therapeutics (NASDAQ: UTHR), its shares rallied 16.4% on Tuesday. MannKind only has one Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved drug to its name, Afrezza, an inhalable insulin. Afrezza was launched in 2015 and sales have been far shy of optimistic pre-launch forecasts.

  • Don't Fall Into These 2 Yield Traps: This Stock Is a Better Buy
    Motley Fool

    Don't Fall Into These 2 Yield Traps: This Stock Is a Better Buy

    For example, USA Compression Partners LP (NYSE: USAC) and CSI Compressco LP (NASDAQ: CCLP) offer investors yields of 12% and 13%, respectively, but they provide a niche service, and results can be volatile. Leverage can be great when things are going well, but can cause problems when times are tough.

  • Why Winnebago Stock Surged 17% -- Then Gave Most of It Back
    Motley Fool

    Why Winnebago Stock Surged 17% -- Then Gave Most of It Back

    Shares of RV-maker Winnebago Industries (NYSE: WGO) leapt 17.6% in early trading after the company reported earnings Wednesday, before retreating to a more recent price up just 5% from yesterday's close. For its fiscal fourth quarter of 2018, Winnebago reported $0.94 per share in earnings, exceeding expectations for $0.86, on sales of $536.2 million. Motorhome sales slowed, but towables were a bright spot for Winnebago in Q4.

  • Business

    The Black Hole Inside General Electric

    RBC Capital Markets, Wolfe Research, and (BCS) all upgraded the shares this month after Larry Culp was named to replace John Flannery at the helm. Today, the Financial Times reported that GE Power was going to win a contract in Iraq over rival (SIE) (SIEGY). Wolfe analyst Nigel Coe wrote that could help turn investor sentiment on GE, noting that the struggles in GE Power are what drives most of the negative feelings toward the stock.

  • A former GE exec who trained new managers found that almost all of them were making the same mistake
    Business Insider

    A former GE exec who trained new managers found that almost all of them were making the same mistake

    Beth Comstock is the former vice chair of General Electric. Comstock would hand out "permission slips" authorizing employees to take risks — but she also said it's important for people to stop hiding behind their excuses. Beth Comstock doesn't tolerate excuses.