Given Exxon’s disappointing performance this year, shares of the largest U.S. oil company, are down almost 8%, investors in S&P 500 index funds might be pleased to see Exxon take a small step back in terms of weight in the benchmark U.S. index.
Investors in energy ETFs dominated by Exxon could use some relief as well.
“Given Exxon Mobil’s heavy weighting in these funds, the company’s performance can have a large effect on the performance of these ETFs,” writes Ingrid Pan for Market Realist.
XLE allocates almost 16% of its weight to Exxon. At the end of January, VDE’s Exxon allocation was 23% and those are not the only ETF with substantial weights to Exxon. The new Fidelity MSCI Energy Index ETF (FENY) does not skimp on Exxon with almost 22% weight to the oil giant while the iShares U.S. Energy ETF (IYE) devotes 22.2% to the stock. https://screener.fidelity.com/ftgw/etf/goto/snapshot/snapshot.jhtml?symbols=FENY
“Exxon’s stock performance highly correlates to the performance of these energy ETFs. This isn’t only because Exxon makes up a significant proportion of the total composition of the ETFs, but also because any of the other companies that the ETFs hold are exposed to the same factors as Exxon (for example, crude oil prices, natural gas prices, and oil service costs),” according to Market Realist.
Although the risks of a small number of stocks dominating an ETF have been documented in the past, most notably with Apple and more recently with Google, it bears noting that the Exxon-dominating-ETFs scenario does remind investors of the advantages of ETFs.
That being on the way down, ETFs can and do outperform holdings that occupy significant weights. As a matter of fact, FENY, IYE, VDE and XLE have all been noticeably less bad than Exxon this year. [Of Google and ETFs]
Tom Lydon’s clients own shares of Apple and Google.