U.S. Markets open in 8 hrs 56 mins

We Tested 5 Electric Bikes. Here's What We Found.

Lauren F. Friedman

Consumer Reports has no financial relationship with advertisers on this site.

When you shop through retailer links on our site, we may earn affiliate commissions. 100% of the fees we collect are used to support our nonprofit mission. Learn more.

You’re cycling along a smooth, flat road, and suddenly a large hill appears before you.

If you’re on a regular bicycle, you take a deep breath, downshift, and start pedaling hard. But if you’re on an electric bike, you can just relax: Either the pedal assist will kick in automatically, helping you to glide uphill, or you’ll activate the throttle for a quick boost. Either way, you can reach the top of the hill without breaking a sweat.

For many people, “there are certain barriers to cycling: The distances are too far, it takes too long, it can be hard going up hills,” says John MacArthur, principal investigator for electric bicycle research initiatives at the Transportation Research and Education Center at Portland State University in Oregon. “Once you put a battery onto a bike, it breaks down a lot of those barriers.”

It’s little wonder then, that the popularity of electric bikes has soared.  

Sales of e-bikes in the U.S. grew more than eightfold between 2014 and 2017, according to NPD Group, a market research firm. But the number of people in the U.S. who use e-bikes is still quite small—especially compared with the product’s massive popularity in China and parts of Europe.

Think an electric bike might be right for you? CR put five very different models to the test. (Skip to the results below.)

Here’s what you need to know if you’re thinking about buying an e-bike—including the safety considerations—along with details about our testing program and our findings.  

Electric Bikes: The Basics

Before you buy an e-bike, the first thing you should figure out is whether it’s legal to ride one where you live. Until recently, the laws governing the use of e-bikes were different in almost every state, says Morgan Lommele, the director of state and local policy at People for Bikes, a bicycling industry group.

People for Bikes has been lobbying state legislators across the country to enact uniform regulations governing the use of e-bikes. For now, your best bet is to look up the laws that apply to where you live in the group’s state-by-state guide.

Next, think about what you want to use an e-bike for, and how far you’ll need it to go on a charge, says Bernie Deitrick, who leads CR’s electric bike testing. On our hilly course, the bikes we tested went between 15 and 30 miles before running out of juice—though that range is even wider when you look at the whole e-bike market, and also varies depending on how and where you ride.

You should also keep in mind how a bike rides when it’s not charged—especially if you need to cover long distances, or if you won’t always be able to charge it fully between rides. “The electric assist is important, but the bicycle itself is important, too,” Deitrick says.

Compared with nonelectric bikes, e-bikes tend to be heavy. Some of the bikes we tested were almost unrideable without the charged assist function, while others made for a pleasant ride with or without a boost. “You can have an e-bike that’s a great electric vehicle but a terrible bike,” Deitrick says.

You might have to try some e-bikes in person to figure out whether you’d prefer riding one with pedal assist (where the electric boost kicks in automatically as you pedal) or with a throttle (where you can get a boost by twisting or pushing a mechanism on the handlebars, even if you’re not pedaling). Some e-bikes come with both pedal assist and a throttle.

If your local bike shop sells e-bikes—as many now do—give a few a test ride before you buy one, Deitrick recommends. A shop can also help make sure a bike is properly fitted to your height and riding style. Some cities also have e-bike rentals or e-bike shares, so you can see how you like e-bikes in general before deciding whether you might want to buy one.

One more thing to keep in mind: While a serious cyclist on a nonelectric racing bike can speed past a person on an e-bike, on average, people riding e-bikes go about 3 mph faster than someone on a traditional bike, MacArthur says. That difference tends to be greater on uphills.

If you’re buying or even renting an electric bike, make sure you also get (and wear) a bike helmet that fits properly.

Finally, think about whether it is safe to ride where you live. “The safety issues we see with bicycles we also see with e-bikes,” Lommele says. “We’re still vulnerable users.”

“Cities are starting to get serious about building good infrastructure that’s safe and comfortable for [cyclists] to use,” says Christopher Cherry, Ph.D., a professor of civil and environmental engineering at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville. But many cities and towns still have a long way to go, and for some journeys in the U.S., there’s simply not a safe cycling route.

How We Tested

For our tests, all riders used each bike equally to average out any differences in performance due to weight, riding level, and style. We did not evaluate the built-in computer that comes with many e-bikes—generally to track speed and distance—but we do mention which models have one.

Here’s how to understand each of the features we rated.

Range
We fully charged the bikes’ batteries, and then rode a hilly loop course on our test grounds at CR’s headquarters. We maximized the assistance provided by the motors, and the loop included stops and starts, full-speed stretches, U-turns, a long uphill, and a sharp downhill. The score for this test is based on the number of miles each bike covered before the battery was depleted.

Acceleration
We timed the bikes on a set course, starting from a standstill and accelerating to the highest speed.

Braking
We measured the distance required to come to a stop from the highest attainable speed under assistance or throttle.

Hill Climb
We timed each bike as it climbed a short, steep hill.

Control Response
We judged how quickly each bike disengaged assistance when the rider stopped pedaling—an important safety feature.

Unassisted Hill Climb
A judgment of how easy it was to climb hills without pedal assistance or throttle, based on the lowest gear ratio available.

Unassisted Cruising
A judgment of how easy it was to cruise at the highest speed without the pedal assistance or throttle, based on the highest gear ratio available.

The Results of CR's Electric Bike Tests

We tested five models that included a variety of features, at prices ranging from $600 to $2,600.

These are all regulated as either Class 1 (where the assist is activated by your pedaling and gets you up to 20 mph) or Class 2 (where the assist is activated by a throttle and gets you up to a maximum of 20 mph). We did not test any Class 3 bikes, which have top speeds of 28 mph. 

These five models can’t be seen as representative of the entire electric bike market, but they do provide a snapshot of the wide variety of e-bikes at the lower end of the market.

The e-bikes are presented in alphabetical order. Each is rated on several features, but there is no Overall Score.  

The full article is available to ConsumerReports.org subscribers. Sign in or subscribe to read this article.

More from Consumer Reports:
Top pick tires for 2016
Best used cars for $25,000 and less
7 best mattresses for couples

Consumer Reports is an independent, nonprofit organization that works side by side with consumers to create a fairer, safer, and healthier world. CR does not endorse products or services, and does not accept advertising. Copyright © 2019, Consumer Reports, Inc.