U.S. Markets closed

Trump Administration Says Obamacare Ads Don't Work, But Federal Study Says They Do

Jonathan Cohn

When Trump administration officials slashed the advertising budget for healthcare.gov, the Affordable Care Act’s online marketplace, they said it was because of efficiency. Advertising, they said, was showing “diminishing returns” and was no longer an effective way to boost enrollment.

But research that the Department of Health and Human Services conducted and then distributed internally during President Barack Obama’s tenure pointed to a very different conclusion.

It found that the ads work.

The research, summarized by documents that a Senate Democratic office provided to HuffPost, focused on the two most recent years of open enrollment for the Affordable Care Act. Like all such studies, it is not definitive. But its findings are consistent with outside studies that have similarly found advertising to be effective.

It also suggests that the decision to cut healthcare.gov advertising, which experts have already warned will depress enrollment, is another example of the Trump administration undermining Obamacare through neglect or outright sabotage.

Of course, maybe that’s not surprising given that the Trump administration is simultaneously trying to wipe the 2010 health care law off the books.

Read the internal HHS research memo here.

The HHS research suggested that, combined, all advertising was responsible for about 37 percent of new enrollees signing up. That figure backs up prior assertions from Obama-era HHS officials, including Andy Slavitt, who was in charge of the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), and Lori Lodes, a who oversaw CMS outreach efforts and wrote about them for Vox.

(HHS Internal Memo, January 2017, obtained by HuffPost)

In addition, HHS found, advertising had driven a roughly equal proportion of existing enrollees to shop on healthcare.gov and re-enroll that way. The last part is important, because enrollees who shop around for new plans rather than simply enrolling in the same ones can frequently find better deals.

The HHS studies examined which forms of advertising were the most effective. Email, automated phone dialing, web search advertising and national television commercials were the most effective drivers, according to the report, while print, radio and display digital ads lagged.

The effective ads tended to work in tandem, the report said. For example, advertising through web searches seemed to be more effective if it targeted areas where people were also exposed to television ads.

The Trump administration has already said that, as part of the budget cuts, it is eliminating television advertising entirely.

“This isn’t like a grocery store, where you just get to pick one thing and do that,” Joshua Peck, who was chief marketing officer for healthcare.gov during the Obama administration, told HuffPost. “It’s all part of an ecosystem. If you remove parts of the ecosystem, you can undermine it.”

Peck, who also confirmed the authenticity of the research, said it was the product of fairly ordinary marketing research, involving both randomized control trials and more sophisticated mathematical modeling. In the simplest versions, researchers were able to compare new enrollments among two different groups: one that had received targeted forms of outreach and one that had not.

Advertising is not free, of course, and the Trump administration has cited the need to spend taxpayer dollars more efficiently ― and generally hold down federal spending ― as a reason to scrutinize all budgets, including the HHS budget for promoting the Affordable Care Act. Administration officials also pointed out that the new advertising levels were more in line with the expenses for promotion of Medicare Part D (the drug benefit for seniors) and Medicare Advantage (a private insurance alternative to traditional Medicare).

One other argument administration officials have made repeatedly is about the Affordable Care Act itself ― namely, that it makes no sense to prop up a “failing” program with federally financed advertising. They noted that enrollment in 2017 was slightly lower than in 2016, even though the Obama administration had doubled the advertising budget from $50 million to $100 million.

“A healthcare system that has caused premiums to double and left nearly half of our counties with only one coverage option is not working,” Caitlin Oakley, the HHS press secretary, said after the Trump administration announced the budget cut. “The Trump administration is determined to serve the American people instead of trying to sell them a bad deal.” (She provided the same statement to HuffPost in response to questions about the research.)

But the comparison to Medicare is of questionable relevance. Senior citizens are far more likely to search for coverage on their own because they expect to have more medical problems ― and because Medicare has been around, and available at retirement age, for half a century. Research from California and Kentucky, two states that have run their own state-based versions of healthcare.gov, showed that advertising in those places was effective, too.

In fact, Covered California, which operates California’s well-regarded insurance marketplace, recently issued a report suggesting that the federal government should be spending about four times more than it does already.

And while it’s true enrollment through healthcare.gov declined slightly this year over 2016, it’s also true that the Trump administration cut outreach activities right after taking office in January ― during the final weeks of open enrollment, when interest had traditionally surged. Analysts later concluded that cut probably depressed enrollment.

Peck noted that, according to the HHS studies, advertising was actually more effective in the second year, with the added spending. “We did a lot of research to figure out what was working and what wasn’t. That research gave us really clear guidelines on what to do, we acted on it and we saw the return on that investment.”

  • This article originally appeared on HuffPost.
  • MGM Resorts Suffers Backlash After Suing Shooting Victims

    MGM Resorts Suffers Backlash After Suing Shooting Victims

    It took just minutes for the hashtag #BoycottMGMResorts to appear on Twitter, and for people to declare they would no longer patronize the largest casino owner on the Las Vegas Strip. “Was going to stay in November already changed my reservations,” a man named Brandon Tur wrote on Twitter. The reaction to MGM Resorts International’s lawsuits against victims of the worst mass shooting in U.S. history was harsh, and probably not surprising.

  • These MLPs Are on Fire Today
    Motley Fool

    These MLPs Are on Fire Today

    What happened Shares of several master limited partnerships (MLPs) took off on Thursday after the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC)  finalized a new policy relating to the tax code overhaul passed at the end of 2017. Leading the way higher were

  • A Russian Warship Was Discovered with an Estimated $130 Billion in Gold on Board

    A Russian Warship Was Discovered with an Estimated $130 Billion in Gold on Board

    A sunken Russian warship estimated to contain 200 tons of gold bullion and coins was discovered about one mile off the coast of the South Korean island of Ulleungdo. Shinil Group, the South Korean treasure-hunting company that led the search, announced their discovery on Sunday. According to The Telegraph, a joint team with experts from South Korea, Britain, and Canada used two manned submersibles to film the wreck at a depth of more than 1,400 feet.

  • When is the best time to convert my traditional IRA to a Roth?

    When is the best time to convert my traditional IRA to a Roth?

    Q.: I have about $57,000 in my traditional IRA and about $6,800 in a Roth IRA. The idea of converting while in low bracket year is sound but fear of the required minimum distributions (RMD) may not need to be a strong motivator. Yes, when RMDs begin they can kick you into a higher tax bracket, but not necessarily.

  • Even the Americans sitting on piles of cash aren't using it correctly to build wealth
    Business Insider

    Even the Americans sitting on piles of cash aren't using it correctly to build wealth

    The average American is holding too much cash in savings, and it's keeping them from building wealth. You should instead invest your excess savings in the stock market for the best returns, NerdWallet's retirement and investing specialist Arielle O'Shea recommends. The easiest way to put your savings to work is through a 401(k), which invests your money in stocks through low-cost index funds or exchange-traded funds.

  • Microsoft crushes earnings and reports $110 billion in annual revenue, stock jumps 4% on strong guidance (MSFT)
    Business Insider

    Microsoft crushes earnings and reports $110 billion in annual revenue, stock jumps 4% on strong guidance (MSFT)

    After initially moving not much at all, Microsoft stock jumped over 4% in after-hours trading. Notably, this marks the end of Microsoft's 2018 fiscal year. For the quarter, Microsoft showed strong growth in all three of its major reporting areas — especially in cloud computing, where Wall Street most wants to see growth.

  • Better Buy: Novavax, Inc. vs. Pfizer
    Motley Fool

    Better Buy: Novavax, Inc. vs. Pfizer

    The biopharmaceutical industry has been extremely generous toward investors over the last eight years. Not every biopharma stock has been a gushing success for investors, though. Pharma titan Pfizer (NYSE: PFE) and clinical-stage vaccine developer Novavax (NASDAQ: NVAX), for instance, have both drastically under-performed their pharma peers during this period.

  • Trump Wants to Redesign Air Force One. Here's Why the Presidential Plane Looks the Way It Does

    Trump Wants to Redesign Air Force One. Here's Why the Presidential Plane Looks the Way It Does

    When President Trump confirmed that he wants to redesign Air Force One during his term in office, in an interview with CBS that aired on Tuesday, he told reporter Jeff Glor that he planned to repaint the iconic aircraft red, white and blue. “Air Force One is going to be incredible,” Trump told Glor. “It’s going to be the top of the line, the top in the world, and it’s going to be red, white and blue.

  • Why eBay, Inc. Stock Plunged Today
    Motley Fool

    Why eBay, Inc. Stock Plunged Today

    Shares of eBay Inc. (NASDAQ: EBAY) were down 9.1% as of 2:45 p.m. EDT Thursday after the online marketplace announced mixed quarterly results and reduced its full-year revenue guidance. More specifically on the former, eBay's second-quarter revenue climbed 9.1% year over year to $2.64 billion, or near the low end of last quarter's guidance for a range of $2.64 billion to $2.68 billion. The underlying drivers of eBay's results were mostly positive.

  • 3 Stocks I'm Never Selling
    Motley Fool

    3 Stocks I'm Never Selling

    Warren Buffett once said that when its comes to stocks, his "favorite holding period is forever." Investors shouldn't blindly apply that idea to all stocks, but holding the best stocks "forever" can mean the difference between a 10% gain and multi-bagger returns. Amazon generates most of its revenue from its online marketplaces in over a dozen countries. Amazon locks in those customers with Prime, its premium plan, which offers discounts, free shipping, streaming media, and other perks.

  • 3 Top Dividend Stocks With Yields Over 3%
    Motley Fool

    3 Top Dividend Stocks With Yields Over 3%

    To get started on the path to wealth-building through dividend stocks, we asked three Motley Fool investors to each highlight a top-quality dividend stock. For a little bit of an additional challenge, we wanted to see companies with a dividend yield of more than 3%, better than the S&P 500's aggregate yield of 1.8% today. A 3% dividend yield is actually pretty measly.

  • Kinder Morgan Inc. Takes Another Big Step Forward
    Motley Fool

    Kinder Morgan Inc. Takes Another Big Step Forward

    Kinder Morgan (NYSE: KMI) continued its forward progress in the second quarter. The natural gas pipeline giant reported $1.1 billion ($0.50 per share) in distributable cash flow (DCF), which was 9% ahead of the year-ago quarter. Natural gas pipelines led the charge.

  • Walmart acquiring Shopify is no longer a laughable idea

    Walmart acquiring Shopify is no longer a laughable idea

    As competition between Walmart and Amazon intensifies, the acquisition of Shopify's merchant marketplace may be the boost that the Walton family's juggernaut needs to move ahead. At 100,000 sellers a month over the next 5 years, there could be an estimated 11 Million sellers on Amazon’s marketplace by 2023. E-commerce intelligence firm Marketplace Pulse estimates Amazon's Gross Merchandise Volume or GMV for 2018 at $280B, set to triple over a 5-year period, concluding that the marketplace contribution to Amazon's GMV would surpass 70% by 2023.

  • Chicago Could Soon Become the Largest American City to Give Universal Basic Income a Try

    Chicago Could Soon Become the Largest American City to Give Universal Basic Income a Try

    If one local politician gets his way, Chicago could become the largest city in the U.S. to trial a universal basic income program. Chicago lawmaker Ameya Pawar has thus far received support from 36 co-sponsors on a bill to introduce the pilot program. If the bill receives adequate support, it will be voted on by City Council.

  • Amazon.com Inc. Earnings Next Week: What to Expect
    Motley Fool

    Amazon.com Inc. Earnings Next Week: What to Expect

    The e-commerce giant will deliver its second-quarter results after the close on July 26, and with shares up an incredible 82% over the past 12 months -- 22% in the past three months alone -- investors have high expectations. In its first quarter, sales and operating income increased 43% and 92% year over year, respectively -- results that blew past both analysts' consensus estimates and management's own forecast. Next week, investors will be looking for similarly impressive growth, as well as strong guidance.

  • Business
    Motley Fool

    Is Arconic Headed for a Private Equity Acquisition?

    In this segment from MarketFoolery, host Mac Greer is joined by Motley Fool analysts Jason Moser and Taylor Muckerman to dig into the current situation at Arconic (NYSE: ARNC), which until late 2016 was the parts manufacturing division of aluminum giant Alcoa. In the year and a half since it was spun off, the company has been underperforming expectations somewhat, but its real problems began when President Trump started heating up his trade wars.

  • Better Buy: Cisco Systems, Inc. vs. Oracle Corporation
    Motley Fool

    Better Buy: Cisco Systems, Inc. vs. Oracle Corporation

    Cisco (NASDAQ: CSCO) and Oracle (NYSE: ORCL) are often considered "mature" tech stocks that generate stable but unremarkable returns. In a comparison of these two stocks back in March, I concluded that Cisco's higher dividend and cash repatriation plans made it a better buy. Cisco is the world's largest manufacturer of network routers and ethernet switches.

  • Better Buy: AT&T, Inc. vs. T-Mobile
    Motley Fool

    Better Buy: AT&T, Inc. vs. T-Mobile

    T-Mobile (NASDAQ: TMUS) has led the United States wireless industry in subscriber growth over the last four years. Offering customers things like separate equipment billing and reintroducing unlimited plans destroyed some of the favorable economics enjoyed by much larger carriers like AT&T (NYSE: T), but it's allowed T-Mobile to quickly scale the size of its business. Meanwhile, AT&T has expanded its operations by acquiring DirecTV and WarnerMedia (formerly Time Warner).

  • Business

    Broadcom Gets Another Downgrade From Goldman Sachs

    Nearly a week after Broadcom Inc (NASDAQ: AVGO) stock crashed following the announcement of a puzzling .9 billion buyout of CA, Inc. (NASDAQ: CA), Broadcom is still getting hate from Wall Street. The Analyst Goldman Sachs analyst Toshiya Hari downgraded

  • The most costly mistakes investors of every size make, according to Bank of America’s $2 trillion wealth-management chief
    Business Insider

    The most costly mistakes investors of every size make, according to Bank of America’s $2 trillion wealth-management chief

    Getty Images / Eduardo Munoz Alvarez Irregular investing, waiting for an all-clear sign, and overconfidence are three of the biggest mistakes investors make.  That's according to Chris Hyzy, the chief investment officer of Bank of America Global Wealth

  • Business

    BNY Mellon says client losses to hit results over next few quarters

    Bank of New York Mellon Corp's said its second-quarter results were hurt by the loss of two clients, which will continue to have an impact over the next few quarters. Shares of the world's largest custodian bank fell about 2 percent to $54.56 in premarket trading. The bank did not disclose the identity of the clients, but said it was working to add new clients.

  • 3 Top Energy Stocks to Buy in July
    Motley Fool

    3 Top Energy Stocks to Buy in July

    Gas prices are higher this July, thanks to a rise in oil prices. But while summer vacationers may not be happy about it, the energy industry -- and its investors -- are ecstatic. Even companies that aren't directly involved in the sale of gasoline are

  • Business

    Don’t Let Debt Scare You From the AT&T Dividend Yield

    Colloquially known as the dividend king, AT&T (NYSE:T) has more than earned that title thanks to 34 years of annual dividend raises. Through multiple boom-bust cycles, an unprecedented global banking crisis, and several military conflicts, the AT&T dividend yield has stayed true. With the telecom giant’s much-covered acquisition of Time Warner, several investors have questioned the viability of the AT&T dividend yield.

  • Could Kinder Morgan, Inc. Be a Millionaire-Maker Stock?
    Motley Fool

    Could Kinder Morgan, Inc. Be a Millionaire-Maker Stock?

    Kinder Morgan's stock may be undervalued, but can it outperform to the tune of $1 million? Investors were justifiably angry with Kinder Morgan in 2016, when management cut its dividend by more than 75% to free up cash. It hasn't helped that, in general, pipeline stocks have been having a rough couple of years.

  • Business

    Traders bet Microsoft’s big run is about to hit a speed bump

    Microsoft MSFT has been on a tear this year, but some traders are betting the hot stock is showing signs of a slowdown. Shares of Microsoft are expected to move around 4 percent in either direction when it releases second-quarter earnings after the bell on Thursday. This is a bet that shares of Microsoft will rally nearly 5 percent in the next month but find a ceiling around the $110 level.