U.S. Markets closed

U.S. court rules $24.9 billion Dell buyout underpriced by 22 percent

Michael Dell, chief executive of Dell Inc, delivers his keynote speech at the All Things Oracle OpenWorld Summit in San Francisco, California September 25, 2013. REUTERS/Jana Asenbrennerova/File Photo

By Tom Hals

WILMINGTON, Del (Reuters) - Michael Dell and Silver Lake Partners underpriced their 2013 $24.9 billion buyout of Dell Inc [DI.UL] by about 22 percent and may have to pay tens of millions to investors who opposed the deal for the computer maker, a Delaware judge ruled on Tuesday.

The ruling, which applies to about 5.5 million Dell shares, is a victory for the specialised hedge funds that have increasingly tried to squeeze more money from mergers using a type of lawsuit known as appraisal.

The lawsuits allow investors who oppose a deal, such as the bitterly contested Dell buyout, to sue and ask a Delaware judge to determine a fair deal price.

Activist investor Carl Icahn urged Dell shareholders to vote down the deal and take their case for fair value to court. Initially appraisal was sought for about 40 million shares, but the bulk was removed for procedural reasons.

In Tuesday's ruling, Vice Chancellor Travis Laster said fair value was $17.62 per share, not the $13.75 per share deal price.

With interest, investors who sought appraisal will collect about $20.84 per share.

The Dell investors presented evidence that fair value was $28.61 per share, which would have cost Michael Dell and Silver Lake hundreds of millions of dollars. The buyers contended that fair value was $12.68.

Dell and a lawyer for the stockholders, Stuart Grant, declined to comment. Tuesday's ruling can be appealed.

Laster said the Dell buyout took advantage of a dip in the company's stock price and its board never determined the intrinsic value before negotiating.

"The original merger consideration was dictated by what a financial sponsor could pay and still generate outsized returns," wrote Laster.

The judge dedicated much of the opinion to explaining why deal price was not a fair value indicator, particularly in a management-led buyout. Delaware judges had used deal price in appraisals involving the closely watched buyouts of Ancestry.com in 2012 and BMC Software Inc in 2013.

The added cost to the buyers from Tuesday's ruling is about $36 million.

About 3.9 million appraised shares were held by affiliates of Magnetar Capital.

A small number of hedge funds have built a strategy of swooping in just before a deal closes, when there is less risk a deal would collapse, and buying stock for the sole purpose of seeking appraisal.

Investors who seek appraisal do not get paid at the deal's closing, but they collect interest of 5 percentage points above the federal discount rate while the case is pending. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce has complained that encourages hedge funds to bring cases because they can earn a return even when a deal price is found to be fair.

One of the biggest losers from the Dell case may be T Rowe Price, one of the few mutual fund managers to test the appraisal strategy.

Dell was able to knock out T Rowe Price's stock, which comprised the bulk of the shares in the case, because the fund manager mistakenly voted in favour of the buyout.

T Rowe Price stood to collect around $190 million if its Dell stock had been appraised. Laster also ruled on Tuesday the fund manager was not entitled to interest on its shares.

"T Rowe Price runs mutual funds and allocates capital, but they may regret trying to do this themselves," said Minor Myers, a professor at Brooklyn Law School in New York. "This is just one of the pitfalls with appraisal, and it's not for novices."


(Reporting by Tom Hals in Wilmington, Delaware; Editing by Nick Zieminski and Richard Chang)

  • Russian Olympian Who Wore an 'I Don't Do Doping' Slogan Shirt Just Failed Her Drug Test
    World
    Time

    Russian Olympian Who Wore an 'I Don't Do Doping' Slogan Shirt Just Failed Her Drug Test

    Nadezhda Sergeeva, pilot of the two-woman bobsled team representing the Olympic Athletes from Russia, proudly proclaimed her anti-doping stance when she appeared in a YouTube video wearing a sweatshirt with the slogan “I don’t do doping” stamped brightly across the front. The federation says that the bobsledder does not have a prescription for the drug.

  • Buffett says Berkshire can handle $400 billion mega-catastrophe
    Finance
    Reuters

    Buffett says Berkshire can handle $400 billion mega-catastrophe

    Warren Buffett says: Bring it on. In his annual letter to shareholders of Berkshire Hathaway Inc , Buffett said "no company comes close" to his conglomerate in its ability to financially withstand even a mega-catastrophe that causes $400 billion of insurance losses. Buffett said the odds of such a catastrophe in any year is just 2 percent, but that Berkshire would lose only about $12 billion, a sum more than offset by annual profits from its non-insurance businesses.

  • Here's How Much Bitcoin Elon Musk Owns
    Business
    Fortune

    Here's How Much Bitcoin Elon Musk Owns

    Musk revealed this week on Twitter how much Bitcoin he owns—and it’s not much. Musk shed light on his bitcoin ownership in response to a question from a Twitter follower asking why there were so many bots impersonating him to push cryptocurrency scams. “What’s with all the ETH spam?” the Twitter user asked, referring to the cryptocurrency Ethereum.

  • Retiring at 62 vs. 70: Pros and Cons
    Lifestyle
    Motley Fool

    Retiring at 62 vs. 70: Pros and Cons

    When most people think of retirement planning, they think about how much money they need to save. Social Security benefits play a major role in deciding your retirement age, though it's important to remember that claiming benefits and actually retiring don't always go hand in hand. The earliest you can claim Social Security benefits is age 62, but you'll receive a cut in benefits for every month you claim before your full retirement age (FRA), which is between 65 and 67, depending on the year you were born.

  • Flu Killed 13 Children Last Week But May Be Winding Down, CDC Says
    Health
    Time

    Flu Killed 13 Children Last Week But May Be Winding Down, CDC Says

    This year’s sweeping flu season may be starting to wind down, but activity is still high throughout the country, according to the CDC’s latest update. With weeks of flu season potentially still to go, that number is likely to climb higher. Illness and hospitalization rates also remain high, with most of the continental U.S. reporting widespread flu activity.

  • These 3 Dividend Stocks Offer Shares at a Discount
    Business
    Motley Fool

    These 3 Dividend Stocks Offer Shares at a Discount

    Dividend stocks can help investors benefit from the power of compounding. By reinvesting dividend payments to purchase additional shares of stock, you'll see the amount of income you receive grow over time, building on itself and creating a positive-feedback loop that can eventually produce huge amounts of income. In particular, Aqua America (NYSE: WTR), Franco-Nevada (NYSE: FNV), and Student Transportation (NASDAQ: STB) are three stocks that you can buy more cheaply through dividend reinvestment than you'll get on the open market.

  • New tax scam can cause entire refund to vanish
    World
    KGO – San Francisco

    New tax scam can cause entire refund to vanish

    The IRS told the I-Team that people are being targeted by scams from all directions. Not only are there fake IRS calls, but there are new tax scams gaining popularity, including one where your entire tax return can vanish.

  • Latest Mueller indictment spells trouble for bankers, too
    Finance
    Associated Press

    Latest Mueller indictment spells trouble for bankers, too

    Recently filed federal charges against President Donald Trump's ex-campaign chairman Paul Manafort could also pose legal and regulatory risks for the banks that loaned him millions of dollars against his New York real estate in recent years. The most serious exposure may be for a Rhode Island-based bank that employed a "conspirator" in Manafort's scheme to obtain a loan he couldn't afford, according to the 32-count new indictment unsealed this week. Dubbed "Lender B" in court papers, Citizens Bank not only lent Manafort $3.4 million based off of fraudulent documents but, in another case, appeared to help Manafort avoid being caught by sending back a crudely falsified financial statement that had been sent to them from a Manafort associate, according to federal prosecutors.

  • Trump Said to Weigh 'Red Flag' Orders to Take Guns Away Quickly
    Politics
    Time

    Trump Said to Weigh 'Red Flag' Orders to Take Guns Away Quickly

    The White House is considering the idea of using restraining orders to take firearms away from people considered dangerous as part of its response to last week’s massacre at a Florida high school, two people familiar with the matter said. Under extreme risk protection orders, which are also known as red flag laws or gun violence restraining orders, firearms can be confiscated from people found to be at risk. The White House is studying an Indiana version of the law, and is considering other measures as well, according to the people, who requested anonymity to discuss policy deliberations.

  • US asks judge to approve seizure of Pharma Bro's assets
    Finance
    Associated Press

    US asks judge to approve seizure of Pharma Bro's assets

    NEW YORK (AP) — "Pharma Bro" Martin Shkreli appeared in court Friday for the first time since a judge locked him up for his online antics, and the brash former pharmaceutical CEO had a new look since his bail was revoked in September: a scruffy beard that made his appearance less boyish. "Under the circumstances, I think he's doing remarkably well," his attorney, Ben Brafman, told reporters when asked about his client's stint in a fortress-like federal jail in Brooklyn. U.S. District Judge Kiyo Matsumoto didn't immediately rule on the government's demand that Shkreli should have to forfeit $7.3 million in assets, including a one-of-a-kind Wu-Tang Clan "Once Upon a Time in Shaolin" album that he has boasted he bought for $2 million.

  • These companies are cutting ties with the NRA
    Business
    Yahoo Finance

    These companies are cutting ties with the NRA

    In the wake of the mass shooting in a Florida high school last week, companies are dropping their partnerships with the National Rifle Association (NRA), which touts 5 million members. According to a list compiled by ThinkProgress, an advocacy organization, there are at least 22 corporations, including car-rental companies and financial institutions that have been offering discounts to NRA members. –First National Bank of Omaha: The largest privately held bank announced it will stop issuing the NRA Visa Card due to “customer feedback” on Thursday.

  • Michael B. Jordan Had a Hilarious Response to an Internet Troll's Judgmental Opinion
    Celebrity
    Time

    Michael B. Jordan Had a Hilarious Response to an Internet Troll's Judgmental Opinion

    Michael B. Jordan’s charismatic turn as villain Erik Killmonger in Black Panther has commanded the collective attention of the Internet, some of who have taken it upon themselves to do extensive research into how Jordan lives his life off-camera, which has prompted a response from the actor himself. In an interview last year with Vogue, Jordan revealed that he shares a home with his parents and that he’d love to visit Tokyo, Japan because he loves anime, two facts that a Twitter user slyly pointed out might not be as endearing if they hadn’t come from the charming Fruitvale Station actor. As might be expected, the tweet went viral, catching the attention of Jordan himself, who had a pithy clap back to the tweet of his own.

  • Democrats distance themselves from Nancy Pelosi
    Politics
    Fox Business Videos

    Democrats distance themselves from Nancy Pelosi

    Former President George W. Bush Deputy Assistant Brad Blakeman discusses why Democrats are starting to disengage from Senate Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi.

  • In Your 60s? 3 Stocks You Should Consider Buying
    Business
    Motley Fool

    In Your 60s? 3 Stocks You Should Consider Buying

    OK, those of us in our 60s know this already, but I'm going to say it anyway: We are not old. The Pew Research Center conducted a study of aging and found that the definition of old age depends on who you ask. Well, I admit that how we feel about aging might not matter much in investing, but what does matter is longevity.

  • President Trump Still Hasn't Forgiven John McCain for Killing Obamacare Repeal
    Politics
    Time

    President Trump Still Hasn't Forgiven John McCain for Killing Obamacare Repeal

    President Donald Trump has again blasted Sen. John McCain for voting against the repeal and replacement of the Affordable Care Act last summer — but did not once call him by name. “We’re having tremendous plans coming out now, healthcare plans, at a fraction of the cost, that are much better than Obamacare,” Trump said Friday at the Conservative Political Action Conference. “Remember — one person walked into a room when he was supposed to go this way,” Trump added, giving a thumbs up sign, “and he walked in and went this way [thumbs down] and everyone said, ‘What happened?

  • Adam Schiff's Memo Has Been Released. Here's What It Says
    Politics
    Time

    Adam Schiff's Memo Has Been Released. Here's What It Says

    Democrats on the the House Intelligence Committee on Saturday released a memo prepared as a counter to the one overseen by the committee’s chairman Devin Nunes that was publicized earlier this month. Overseen by Rep. Adam Schiff, the ranking Democrat on the committee, the memo from the Democrats attempts to contextualize the Nunes memo, which argued that the FBI displayed bias in obtaining a FISA warrant for former Trump campaign adviser Carter Page. That memo alleges that the FBI failed to disclose Christopher Steele, who compiled the notorious Steele dossier, was working for Fusion GPS or the firm’s founder Glenn Simpson, and that Deputy FBI Director Andrew McCabe — who is stepping down —said the FBI would not have sought a warrant without the dossier.

  • 3 Cheap Dividend Stocks That Helped Warren Buffett Earn $3.7 Billion in Dividends in 2017
    Business
    Insider Monkey

    3 Cheap Dividend Stocks That Helped Warren Buffett Earn $3.7 Billion in Dividends in 2017

    Warren Buffett, the revered billionaire investor and Chairman and CEO of $500 billion holding company Berkshire Hathaway, just released his annual shareholder letter in which he discussed a number of intriguing topics. Perhaps the most noteworthy one was the revelation that Republican tax cuts contributed $29 billion to Berkshire Hathaway Inc. (NYSE:BRK.A)‘s bottom-line last year. That clearly proved irksome to Buffett, who supported Hillary Clinton during the 2016 Presidential Elections and was not fond of the idea of tax cuts for the wealthy. As Buffett made clear in the letter, the windfall “did not come from anything we accomplished at Berkshire.” The letter also revealed that Berkshire earned

  • GE says it may face U.S. action over subprime mortgage operations
    Business
    Reuters

    GE says it may face U.S. action over subprime mortgage operations

    General Electric Co (GE.N) faces potential action by the U.S. Justice Department over allegations that its GE Capital unit and now defunct WMC Mortgage Corp unit violated U.S. law in connection with subprime mortgages, according to a regulatory filing on Friday. GE said the department "is likely to assert" violation of the Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act of 1989 (FIRREA) "in connection with WMC's origination and sale of subprime mortgage loans in 2006 and 2007," the filing said. "WMC and GE Capital will explore whether an acceptable settlement of this matter can be reached.

  • NYSE Top Dividend Paying Stocks
    Business
    Simply Wall St.

    NYSE Top Dividend Paying Stocks

    Williams Companies is one of our top dividend-paying companies that can help boost the investment income in your portfolio. These stocks are a safe way to create wealth as their stable and constant yields generally hedge against economic uncertainty and

  • Why Nvidia (NVDA) Stock Is the Cheapest It's Been in Nearly a Year
    Finance
    Zacks

    Why Nvidia (NVDA) Stock Is the Cheapest It's Been in Nearly a Year

    It is no secret that Nvidia NVDA is one of Wall Street’s most popular stocks. The graphics chip maker is a dominant force in the global gaming industry, and its tireless investments in self-driving cars, machine learning, and artificial intelligence all but guarantee the company a spot among the tech industry’s leaders for years to come. Nvidia’s leadership and innovation have also led to a massive surge in the company’s stock.

  • Like Dividends? I Bet You'll Love These 4 Stocks
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Like Dividends? I Bet You'll Love These 4 Stocks

    Crestwood Equity Partners is a master limited partnership (MLP) that operates oil and natural gas pipelines, processing plants, and storage facilities across most of America's fastest-growing shale regions. The company uses that cash to support its generous distribution, which at the moment yields 8.8%, and which Crestwood covered with cash flow by a comfortable 1.4 times in 2017.

  • President Trump Went Way Off Script and Turned His CPAC Speech into a Campaign Rally
    Politics
    Time

    President Trump Went Way Off Script and Turned His CPAC Speech into a Campaign Rally

    When President Donald Trump took the stage at the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) Friday morning, he clearly wanted to have some fun. For more than an hour, Trump held court, largely eschewing a teleprompter filled with prepared remarks on North Korea sanctions and remembrances for Billy Graham and the victims of the Parkland, Fla. shooting, instead choosing to ramble enthusiastically about familiar themes in his typical campaign style. Early in his CPAC speech, Trump caught a glimpse of himself in a TV monitor and joked, “I try like hell to hide the bald spot,” turning around to show the audience the back of his head.

  • Venezuelan President Asks Banks to Mine the National Cryptocurrency. Unions are Aghast.
    Business
    Fortune

    Venezuelan President Asks Banks to Mine the National Cryptocurrency. Unions are Aghast.

    Venezuelan president Nicolas Maduro is doubling down on his support for the Petro, encouraging the country’s banks to mine and use the recently-launched national cryptocurrency. Maduro has also reportedly ordered several state-owned companies, including an oil and natural gas company and aluminium and gold producers, to use the Petro for a percentage of their sales and purchases moving forward.

  • 8 memorable quotes from Warren Buffett's newest shareholder letter
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    8 memorable quotes from Warren Buffett's newest shareholder letter

    In his annual letter to Berkshire Hathaway (BRK-A, BRK-B) shareholders, legendary investor Warren Buffett muses on the M&A environment, his aversion to leverage, opportunities to buy during downturns, and his disregard for fees charged by active managers.

  • Buffett says 'terrible mistake' for long-term investors to be in bonds
    Business
    Reuters

    Buffett says 'terrible mistake' for long-term investors to be in bonds

    Billionaire Warren Buffett prodded ordinary investors on Saturday to stay invested in U.S. stocks, ignoring price swings, guidance from people with fancy credentials and the temptation to load up on bonds. Buffett said it is a "terrible mistake" for investors with long-term horizons - among them, pension funds, college and endowments and savings-minded individuals - to measure their investment "risk" by their portfolio's ratio of bonds to stocks. The long-time bull on U.S. companies and the economy issued his latest letter to Berkshire Hathaway Inc shareholders on Saturday.