U.S. Markets open in 9 hrs 8 mins

Why Uber could be a better bet than Lyft

JP Mangalindan
Chief Tech Correspondent
In this Jan. 31, 2018, photo, a Lyft logo is installed on a Lyft driver's car in Pittsburgh. (AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar)

Lyft (LYFT) may have been the first major tech IPO of 2019, but five analysts Yahoo Finance spoke with indicate ride-hailing rival Uber may be a better investment when the company goes public later this year.

“Even if Lyft’s IPO had been a disaster, that wouldn't necessarily be telling for Uber just because they're pretty fundamentally different companies,” explains Alejandro Ortiz, a research analyst for SharesPost, a San Francisco private trading marketplace.

Lyft’s stock price, which has stabilized for now, closed on Friday at $74 — $2 higher than the value Lyft gave its stock for its IPO on March 29. But even if that weren’t the case, comparing Lyft to Uber may be a somewhat an apples-to-oranges-type comparison. While Lyft is available in hundreds of North American cities, for instance, Uber’s reach spans five continents, illustrating its more global ambitions at the moment.

A more diversified business

Uber, too, has also been more ambitious in its expansion beyond pure ride-hailing.

MOSCOW - APR 23: Worker with Uber Eats bicycle and a bag in a street of Moscow on April 23. 2018 in Russia

“There are a lot of other pieces there in the Uber business — it’s not a North American, ride-sharing pure play like Lyft is,” says D.A. Davidson senior research analyst Tom White.

Uber now considers its food delivery service, Uber Eats, part of its core business. And while Uber didn’t disclose how much Uber Eats raked in during the company’s fourth quarter, the segment accounted for 17% of Uber’s overall business in the third quarter. Uber Eats could generate $1 billion in revenues this year, according to Forbes, which performed back-of-the-envelope math by taking Uber’s internal revenues projections for Uber Eats of $10 billion and factoring in Uber’s typical 30% cut and delivery fees. If accurate, that would make Uber Eats the second-largest food delivery service in the U.S. behind Grubhub (GRUB).

In 2017, Uber also launched Uber Freight, an app-based service that matches truckers with companies that need cargo shipped across the U.S. Uber has not revealed exactly how Uber Freight is performing, but the company plans to go international with Uber Freight, launching first in the Netherlands next month.

Such efforts, analysts contend, will make Uber’s pitch to investors inherently different in April when the company is expected to embark upon its road show to meet with prospective investors.

“From a purely economic standpoint, diversification is typically associated with lower overall risk,” adds Ortiz, the research analyst for SharesPost Research. “That said, Uber’s history alone has shown that, especially with new technology, expanding aggressively means having to mitigate risks on multiple fronts. Come time for its roadshow, Uber will have to convince investors that the value of trying to be ‘all things to everyone in the world of mobility’ is worth the risk of potential pitfalls along the way.”

International hurdles

Ali Mogharabi, a senior equity analyst with Morningstar, agrees Uber still has its work cut out for it as it continues to grow internationally, addressing and solving potential regulatory and cultural issues along the way. Last month, for instance, Uber agreed to pay $2.6 million in the Netherlands for violating local taxi law and running an unlicensed taxi service between 2014 and 2015.

“The way I'm also looking at it, as Uber is utilizing its platform for additional services, possibly creating more economies of scale in the future,” explains Mogharabi. “I mean that Uber also utilizes that platform for Uber Eats. So in terms of economies of scale, you could see they have an advantage on that end, and that could that could be taken into consideration when it comes to the IPO pricing. That may actually increase confidence that the company may become profitable in the future.”

Still, if there’s anything Uber can learn from Lyft’s Wall Street debut, it’s that Wall Street clearly has an appetite for high-growth firms like Lyft and Uber, according to Wedbush Securities analyst Dan Ives. That’s regardless of the fact that they’re years away from profitability.

Morningstar estimates the earliest Uber and Lyft could become profitable is 2022, with Uber having the edge because it also has the fast-growing, revenue-generating Uber Eats.

For investors chomping at the idea of getting a chunk of Uber stock, Mogharabi advises waiting a beat.

“We're thinking that, when you basically see the stock trading at a 15-20% discount that might be the right time to get in,” adds Mogharabi. “That, of course, depends on the IPO pricing, which we probably won't see until about a month or so from now.”

With a private valuation exceeding $70 billion in 2018, Uber could be worth as much $120 billion once the company conducts its IPO — a valuation that could make Uber the largest tech IPO in U.S. history.

Investors, start your engines.

More from JP: