U.S. Markets close in 1 hr 56 mins

An ugly economic lesson from the Nixon era proves why Trump's criticisms of the Fed are so worrying

Will Martin
donald trump

Leah Millis/Reuters


  • President Donald Trump has criticized the Federal Reserve's current path of interest-rate hikes twice in the past two days.
  • The criticism drew concerns about the Federal Reserve's political independence.
  • Presidents have pressured the Fed before, most notably Richard Nixon.
  • Nixon convinced then-Fed Chairman Arthur Burns to keep interest rates low, leading to nearly a decade of economic problems.

For two straight days, President Donald Trump has committed a major break in American political convention by commenting on the actions of the Federal Reserve and the criticism echoes one of the worst monetary-policy mistakes in US history.

On Thursday, Trump told CNBC he was "not thrilled" about the Federal Reserve's interest-rate hikes, breaking with the long-standing precedent of American presidents not commenting on Fed policy out of respect for the central bank's independence from political influence.

"Because we go up and every time you go up they want to raise rates again," Trump told CNBC in an interview that aired in full Friday. "I don't really — I am not happy about it. But at the same time I’m letting them do what they feel is best."

Trump followed up the CNBC comments with a tweet on Friday, in which the president said the Fed's interest-rate tightening "hurts all that we have done."

While the White House attempted to assuage concerns by reiterating the president's support for the Fed's independence, the comments still raised the spectre of a huge policy mistake from the 1970s.

Richard Nixon, the Fed, and stagflation

The Federal Reserve's structure is unique within the US bureaucratic system. It operates within government, but simultaneously remains relatively independent with some oversight from Congress.

The Fed's independence is couched in the belief that for the central bank to achieve its aims — ensuring financial stability and long-term growth — it should be free from the pressure that might be exerted by politicians seeking to alter policy for their own ends, rather than putting the country's prosperity first.

The most notable example of a president violating this edict independence of the Fed occurred under Richard Nixon in the 1970s.

In the run up to the 1972 election, Nixon wanted to present the country with a strong economy and low unemployment. To do so, Nixon swapped out Fed Chairman William McChesney Martin with his pick, Arthur Burns.

Nixon pressured the new Fed chairman to keep interest rates low to help maintain lower unemployment. The released Nixon tapes revealed numerous conversations between the president and Burns in which Nixon pressures the Fed chair to keep rates low. Nixon even told advisers "we'll take inflation if necessary, but we can't take unemployment."

Burns did in fact keep rates relatively low, but the move proved to be disastrous as it helped to usher in a period of stagflation — high inflation, high unemployment, and low economic growth.

Not until Paul Volcker took over the Fed nearly a decade later and ratcheted up interest rates in what is known as the "Volcker Shock" would the issue be truly corrected.

Other incidents, including President George H.W. Bush complaining about the policies of his Fed chair, Alan Greenspan, have also occurred, but the comments were far more muted than Nixon's extended pressure.

Nixon's attempts to influence provide a perfect example of why defenders of Fed independence are so fervent in their belief that politicians should not attempt to tamper with monetary policy, but there is also empirical evidence for independence as well.

Gregory Daco, chief US economist at Oxford Economics, pointed to research by Alberto Alesina and Lawrence Summers that showed in countries with a politically influenced central bank had higher inflation.

"While reviewing 16 OECD economies, they showed that countries with independent central banks generally had lower inflation without 'suffering any output or employment penalty'," Daco said. "As such, central banks acting outside of the political sphere of influence would be most desirable in any country."

The evidence further supports the independent mission of the Fed and makes it important for presidents to keep out of monetary policy. While Trump is far away from Nixon's level of interference, Daco said it is important to keep an eye on.

"While current conditions are very different from those of the 1970s, we must not forget that the premise of central bank independence rests on the advantage of insulating monetary policy from short-sighted political objectives," he said. "While inflation expectations are currently well anchored, history shows us that a pervasive lack of central bank independence can rapidly, and without warning, lead to rising inflation and economic instability."

NOW WATCH: What happens when you hold in your pee for too long

See Also:

SEE ALSO: Trump's stunning comments about the Federal Reserve could actually backfire

  • These are the bad things about early retirement that no one talks about
    News
    MarketWatch

    These are the bad things about early retirement that no one talks about

    For all the glamour of living an early retirement lifestyle, there are plenty of negatives I’ve come to discover since I permanently left my job in 2012. As a result, you’re repeatedly forced to will yourself into action.

  • Bank of America's lagging loan growth overshadows profit gains
    Business
    Reuters

    Bank of America's lagging loan growth overshadows profit gains

    The No. 2 U.S. bank's profit rose 35 percent, helped by cost controls, but investors focused on the underlying businesses. "It was definitely a surprise when some of the other banks had better-than-expected loan growth," said R.J. Grant, head of trading at Keefe, Bruyette & Woods. Bank of America's total loan book grew 0.3 percent to $930 billion during the third quarter compared with the year-ago period.

  • Sears bankruptcy could make these 5 big companies multi-million-dollar losers
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Sears bankruptcy could make these 5 big companies multi-million-dollar losers

    Being an unsecured creditor of Sears (SHLD) right now is not a good place to be. The 125-year old former retail icon filed for chapter 11 bankruptcy protection early on Monday, crippled from years of losses and mounting debt. Sears plans to close about

  • Brits Are All Making the Same Joke About the New Royal Baby
    News
    Time

    Brits Are All Making the Same Joke About the New Royal Baby

    Meghan Markle, the Duchess of Sussex, is expecting her first child with Prince Harry. The news, announced Monday morning by Kensington Palace, has already been greeted by hundreds of messages of congratulations for the royal couple on social media. The U.K. is set to leave the European Union on March 29, exactly two years after Prime Minister Theresa May started the formal process for doing so by invoking Article 50 of the Lisbon Treaty.

  • Finance
    Bloomberg

    Tesla Skeptic Surprised by How Much He Enjoyed the Model 3

    In a broader note about positive electric-car momentum, Jonas said he observed workers at Tesla’s lone auto plant in Fremont, California, who were “extremely busy cranking out Model 3s” for delivery in the U.S. He also drove the dual-motor performance version of the vehicle, which he sees as having better value-for-performance than the Model S sedan. “Frankly, our enjoyment of the high-spec version of the Model 3 took us by surprise,” Jonas said, adding that it’s “hard to say how much this matters.

  • Better Marijuana Stock: Aurora Cannabis vs. Auxly Cannabis Group
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Better Marijuana Stock: Aurora Cannabis vs. Auxly Cannabis Group

    One is market cap: Aurora's market cap is nearly 18 times bigger than Auxly's. Then there's stock performance. Here's how Aurora Cannabis and Auxly Cannabis Group stack up against each other in the areas that do matter.

  • Business
    Barrons.com

    Investors Don’t Like Activision’s ‘Call of Duty’ as Much as Players Do

    BARRONS NEXT HOT STOCKS It probably shouldn’t surprise anyone, but it looks like Call of Duty: Black Ops 4 landed with a boom. Perhaps a surprise: for investors, it landed with a bit of a thud. On Sunday, (ATVI) said the latest installment

  • This Sin-Stock ETF's Marijuana Moves Have Missed the Mark
    Business
    Motley Fool

    This Sin-Stock ETF's Marijuana Moves Have Missed the Mark

    Marijuana stocks have never been more popular, as investors seek to take advantage of the coming opening of the recreational marijuana market in Canada. Although those who want to invest in marijuana can choose from several individual companies with ties to cannabis, many of those who are more cautious about the sector would prefer to get more diversified exposure through an exchange-traded fund. There are some ETFs that specialize in marijuana stocks, giving concentrated exposure to the industry.

  • Ark Invest CEO: Tesla 'is a replay of Apple'
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Ark Invest CEO: Tesla 'is a replay of Apple'

    Tesla (TSLA) and Apple (APPL) have at least one thing in common – and it’s a big factor leading one analyst to project a price target of $4,000 for the electric vehicle manufacturer. It comes down to the chips, ARK Invest CEO and CIO Cathie Wood said in an interview with Yahoo Finance on Friday. Tesla CEO Elon Musk confirmed in August that the company would be making its own computer chips for automated driving, pivoting away from hardware produced by chipmaker Nvidia (NVDA).

  • Ford Escape sales are down — here’s how it compares with other small SUVs
    Business
    American City Business Journals

    Ford Escape sales are down — here’s how it compares with other small SUVs

    Sales of the Ford Escape aren't what they used to be. The Escape, made at the Louisville Assembly Plant, saw sales decline by 20 percent in September 2018, compared with the same month last year. Ford and its Lincoln Motor Co. subsidiary have been successful in increasing sales of larger SUVs, such as the Navigator and Expedition this year.

  • 2 Pharmaceutical Stocks to Buy With Dividends of 3% or Better
    Business
    Motley Fool

    2 Pharmaceutical Stocks to Buy With Dividends of 3% or Better

    During a tough week for the overall market, pharmaceutical stocks across the board fell a few notches despite a lack of significant news for the industry itself. Over the past five years, Pfizer has been able to raise its dividend 42% despite declining sales for aging blockbusters that lost patent protection and a sterile injectibles business that suffered major product shortages after it was acquired. Now that the worst is over, a strong product lineup and bulging pipeline could allow America's largest pharmaceutical company to direct a ton of cash toward its shareholders.

  • Sears' bankruptcy: Stanley Black & Decker, Apex Tool among largest unsecured creditors
    Business
    American City Business Journals

    Sears' bankruptcy: Stanley Black & Decker, Apex Tool among largest unsecured creditors

    A couple of tool manufacturers with big presences could lose millions of dollars as a result of Sears filing for bankruptcy protection. Sears Holding Corp., which owns Sears and Kmart, filed for Chapter 11 protection on Monday in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in White Plains, New York. Apex Tool Group, the privately held Sparks-based company, has a $6.6 million unsecured claim against Sears, according to the bankruptcy filings.

  • The Sears Bankruptcy Is Likely to Inflict Pain on Mall Owners for Years
    Finance
    Bloomberg

    The Sears Bankruptcy Is Likely to Inflict Pain on Mall Owners for Years

    Mall owner Macerich Co. struck a agreement that year with the struggling department-store operator to redevelop a 300,000 square-foot store at Kings Plaza Shopping Center, a high-traffic mall in Brooklyn, New York. After Sears filed for Chapter 11 protection early Monday, Macerich’s lengthy -- and expensive -- process is worth keeping in mind. Other mall owners, who have been grappling with the retailer’s store closings and diminished ability to attract shoppers for years, must now contend with the possibility of a full liquidation, which would mean a glut of retail real estate in an already oversupplied market.

  • This Is the Average American's Salary. How Does Yours Compare?
    Business
    Motley Fool

    This Is the Average American's Salary. How Does Yours Compare?

    In an age of oversharing, many of us are remarkably tight-lipped when it comes to talking salary. But in reality, knowing where you stand can help you determine whether you're in a good place or whether you should be taking steps to boost your earnings

  • Business
    American City Business Journals

    Best Buy, Target could win in Sears bankruptcy — unless they're right next door

    Sears Holdings Corp., which filed for bankruptcy early Monday morning, wasn't a big competitive threat to either Best Buy Co. or Target Corp. But the Minnesota retailers could be among the biggest beneficiaries if Sears goes away. Bloomberg has an early take on the possible winners and losers in a Sears bankruptcy, and counts Richfield-based Best Buy (NYSE: BBY) firmly in the "win" camp. Sears, even as its sales dwindled, remained a pretty popular place for consumers to shop for things like washing machines and stoves, and Best Buy is among the chains with a chance of capturing that business.

  • Warren Buffett predicted the fall of Eddie Lampert and Sears over 10 years ago (SHLD, BRK.A, BRK.B)
    Finance
    Business Insider

    Warren Buffett predicted the fall of Eddie Lampert and Sears over 10 years ago (SHLD, BRK.A, BRK.B)

    Sears filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy early Monday, the culmination of a downward spiral. CEO Eddie Lampert, once called the "next Warren Buffett," will also step down. Incidentally, Buffett predicted the retailer's and Lampert's downfall in 2005.

  • Sears files for bankruptcy
    Business
    Yahoo Finance Video

    Sears files for bankruptcy

    Sears has officially for bankruptcy as CEO Eddie Lampert tries to turn the struggling retailer around. Yahoo Finance’s Alexis Christoforous, Brian Sozzi, Melody Hahm and Ethan Wolff-Mann discuss.

  • Microsoft Earnings: Mark Your Calendar
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Microsoft Earnings: Mark Your Calendar

    Software giant Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT) has continued to impress investors in 2018 amid its ongoing progress becoming a more cloud-centric company. Microsoft reports its first-quarter earnings for fiscal 2019 on October 24. Ahead of Microsoft's earnings release, here's an overview of some of the key areas investors will want to watch. Core to Microsoft's momentum recently is the company's rapidly growing commercial-cloud revenue.

  • Here’s How Prince Harry and Meghan Markle’s Baby Will Change the Line Of Succession
    News
    Time

    Here’s How Prince Harry and Meghan Markle’s Baby Will Change the Line Of Succession

    Prince Harry and Meghan Markle are expecting a baby in spring 2019, Kensington Palace announced Monday morning. Harry and Meghan married in May, becoming the Duke and Duchess of Sussex. Now, the question is where the new arrival will fit into the line of succession of the British royal family.

  • 2 Hot Marijuana Stocks Listing Soon on U.S. Exchanges -- Are They Buys?
    Business
    Motley Fool

    2 Hot Marijuana Stocks Listing Soon on U.S. Exchanges -- Are They Buys?

    Two marijuana stocks that are currently listed on Canadian stock exchanges soon plan also to list on U.S. stock exchanges. Aurora Cannabis (NASDAQOTH: ACBFF) (TSX: ACB) expects to trade on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) by the end of October and Aleafia Health (NASDAQOTH: ALEAF) should soon trade on the Nasdaq stock exchange. Are these hot marijuana stocks that are coming soon to U.S. stock exchanges smart picks to buy now?

  • Bank of America Earnings: Better Margins, Strong Asset Quality, and an All-Around Good Quarter
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Bank of America Earnings: Better Margins, Strong Asset Quality, and an All-Around Good Quarter

    Bank of America (NYSE: BAC) is the last of the "big four" U.S. banks to report its third-quarter earnings. Not only did Bank of America beat expectations on both the top and bottom lines, but the business looks pretty solid all around. First, looking at the top and bottom lines, Bank of America did quite well in the third quarter.

  • 3 Reasons 62-Year-Olds Should Take Social Security Now
    Business
    Motley Fool

    3 Reasons 62-Year-Olds Should Take Social Security Now

    As people approach retirement, it's natural to want to claim Social Security as soon as possible. Even though waiting beyond the earliest claiming age of 62 for retirement benefits can give you larger monthly checks, you still have to make it through

  • What Investors Should Know about AT&T’s Growth Prospects
    Business
    Market Realist

    What Investors Should Know about AT&T’s Growth Prospects

    What Investors Should Know about AT&T’s Growth Prospects AT&T’s earnings in Q3 2018 AT&T (T), the second-largest wireless service provider in the United States, is looking to showcase its strength as it nears its third-quarter earnings release. The company

  • It’s Official -- These 5 Social Security Changes Are Coming for 2019
    Business
    Motley Fool

    It’s Official -- These 5 Social Security Changes Are Coming for 2019

    For workers, Social Security's maximum taxable earnings are increasing, and more income will be required to earn a Social Security "credit." Beneficiaries who claimed Social Security early and still work will be happy to learn they'll be able to earn more without a benefit reduction in 2019, and for high earners, the maximum possible Social Security benefit is also on the rise. With all of that in mind, here are the recently released details of these five 2019 Social Security changes. As I mentioned, Social Security beneficiaries are getting a 2.8% COLA starting with their January 2019 benefit payment.