U.S. Markets open in 6 hrs 55 mins

Republicans Are So Tired Of Tax Experts Rudely Saying Their Plan Helps The Rich

Rep. Kevin Brady (R-Texas) unveils legislation to overhaul the tax code on Capitol Hill, Nov. 2, 2017. 

WASHINGTON ― The GOP tax overhaul overwhelmingly benefits the wealthiest people in America, according to several estimates. But Republicans say you can’t trust any ofthose.

Over 47 percent of the tax changes in the legislation would benefit the richest 1 percent of households over 10 years, areport released Wednesdayby the Tax Policy Center said. 

Wednesday’s report closely resemblesan analysis TPC issued on Monday, which the group quickly retracted because of an error ― which Republicans have said is all the more reason not to believe them.

Two controversies dominate the debate over how to analyze a tax bill: debt and distribution. Tax changes affect the amount of revenue the government collects, and Republicans disagree with most experts, who say their tax reform legislation would reduce revenue by more than $1 trillion over 10 years. GOP lawmakers would rather just take it on faith that tax cuts create growth andpay for themselves.

The other controversy Republicans take issue with is the question of whose taxes would go down and whose would go up. Republicans say their bill would reduce taxes for everybody, but TPC says 7 percent of households would face higher rates next year and 25percent would pay more in 10 years.

Rather than debate the merits of their tax proposal based on these facts, Republicans want to debate the facts themselves.

Rep. Kevin Brady (R-Texas), chairman of the tax-writing House Ways and Means Committee, blasted the “liberal Tax Policy Center” in a radio interview Tuesday morning, noting that the group withdrew its analysis after a mistake. Later that day, in an interview with HuffPost, he didn’t let up.

“You know, they’re the gang that can’t compute straight,” Brady said. “They had a tax analysis before there was a bill. Now they have one they had to abandon within hours. I don’t know how many strikes you get before you’re out.”

When HuffPost asked whether it said anything about the organization that it was upfront about its mistake ― that TPC withdrew its analysis entirely when it discovered an error ― Brady pointed to what he called the earlier “imaginary analysis” TPC did when Republicans released their tax framework in September.

“They didn’t even admit that there was no tax bill to score,” Brady said. “So, look, there’s a lot of credibility that’s gone there.” (In fact, TPC was very transparent abouthow it analyzed the tax frameworkRepublicans put forward. The center used similar Republican proposals from the past year to fill in gaps in the plan.)

In its Monday report, the center underestimated the amount that some households would benefit from an expanded child tax credit in the Republican bill. The updated report reduces the number of households that would face a tax increase a decade from now by about 3 percentage points. Also in the new report, the total tax benefit accruing to the richest 1 percent of households has declined from 48.4 percent to 47.2 percent.

Brady isn’t the only Republican criticizing TPC. President Donald Trump’s top economic adviser, Kevin Hassett, said in October that it was “scientifically indefensible” for TPC to downplay the positive economic feedback that tax cuts could create, despite a consensus among most economists that tax cuts don’t spur the kind of growth Republicans are hoping for. In response, Larry Summers, a former Treasury secretary under Bill Clinton and a top economic adviser to President Barack Obama, said heno longer took Hassett seriouslyafter his “absurd attacks on the Tax Policy Center.”

While Republicans like Brady criticize TPC for putting forth a score of the GOP bill when there wasn’t yet a bill, Republicans themselves were making wild claims about economic growth way before there was legislation.

Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin said the GOP tax proposal would generate so much growth and extra tax revenue that it wouldreduce the national debt by $1 trillion― an estimate seemingly based more on gut than math. A number of Republicans in Congress have also told HuffPost for weeks that theirtax cuts would pay for themselves ― although, again, there’sno evidencethat tax cuts replace lost revenue with economic growth.

The TPC isn’t out on a limb with its estimate of large budget deficits resulting from the proposal. The conservative Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, Fitch Ratings, and Congress’ own Joint Committee on Taxation and Congressional Budget Office agree.

Even the GOP-friendly Tax Foundation ― even when using the GOP’s preferred “dynamic scoring,” which accounts for macroeconomic effects in the cost of legislation ― said the Republican tax proposal wouldincrease the national debtby nearly $1 trillion over the next decade.

But Republicans refuse to believe it. When HuffPost asked Rep. Lynn Jenkins (R-Kan.) about the tax proposal and her vote against the budget setting up tax reform, Jenkins explained that she voted no on the budget because “it didn’t balance.” (The budget allows Republicans to increase debt by $1.5 trillion in the name of tax cuts.)

But Jenkins told HuffPost she supports the tax proposal now because revenue won’t decrease in a dynamic score. When we noted that the Tax Foundation’s dynamic score said debt would still increase by $1 trillion, Jenkins said, “You’ll have to wait until the accurate one is out.”

When the Tax Foundation found in aseparate studythat temporary expensing of assets ― which allows businesses to write off the cost of new investments ― would have a limited effect on economic growth, House Speaker Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) refused to believe that was a Tax Foundation finding.

“I haven’t read that study, but I’d be kind of shocked if the Tax Foundation said that,” Ryan said. He suggested that a reporter had confused the Tax Foundation with TPC.

“I think TPC has shown their ideological and partisan colors with the fact that they put out an estimate on a mythical tax plan that hasn’t been written,” Ryan said in early October.

A few weeks later, Bloomberg reporter Jonathan Nicholson, who wrote his own story onRepublicans attacking TPC,asked Ryanabout his office describing the Tax Foundation as “nonpartisan” when the board is stacked with Republicans.

Ryan cited disagreements with TPC’s economic modeling, but he also praised the Tax Foundation for having a number of Republicans on staff.

The Tax Policy Center also has plenty of prominent Republicans in its ranks. Two of TPC’s fellows are former Congressional Budget Office directors who served under Republican presidents ― Donald Marron (under George W. Bush) and Rudy Penner (under Ronald Reagan). And N. Gregory Mankiw, a Harvard economics professor who is on the TPC board, served as the chairman of George W. Bush’s Council of Economic Advisers.

The Tax Policy Center may get its left-leaning reputation because it’s a joint venture of the Brookings Institution and the Urban Institute, two respected think tanks that are also (perhaps unfairly) seen as left-leaning. But neither think tank is a bastion of ideology, and both are known for their policy-minded analysis ― as well as for having well-known Republicans serving in major positions.

As Ryan said, part of the problem may just be that TPC uses a distributional analysis, which divvies up the percentage benefit of tax changes among income groups. The percentages seem politically unfavorable to Republicans because the wealthiest Americans currently pay the most taxes by far, so when a piece of legislation lowers taxes across the board, the rich benefit the most.

But Democrats think this goes to a more fundamental problem with the Republican Party ― one that isn’t based on some intellectual argument over economic models.

“A very nasty, bad habit of Donald Trump has now infected the Republicans, which is, anyone who disagrees with you, attack ad hominem,” Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) told HuffPost on Tuesday when asked about Republicans deriding TPC. “It’s not what America is about, it’s not what the Founding Fathers wanted us to do. It’s become an overwhelming tendency in their party.”

Like TPC, the Joint Committee on Taxation has found that not everybody would benefit from Republicans’ proposed changes to the tax code. The committee has reported that, under the legislation, nearly 20 percent of households would face higher taxes a decade from now.

But Republicans say nearly everyone will benefit from their plan ― you just need to trust them. That’s what Rep. Dave Brat (R-Va.), a former economist, told HuffPost, even though he wasn’t sure what he was supposed to think of TPC.

“I get them all confused,” Brat said, in an extremely relatable moment. “Too many acronyms.”

Amanda Terkel contributed reporting.

This article has been updated to include Schumer’s comments.

This article originally appeared on HuffPost.

  • What happens if you win Mega Millions' $970M jackpot?
    News
    Associated Press

    What happens if you win Mega Millions' $970M jackpot?

    Despite the terrible odds — one in 302.5 million for those keeping score at home — someone will eventually match all six numbers and win the Mega Millions jackpot, which now stands at $970 million. Here are some answers for someone holding that prized lottery ticket for what would be the second-largest lottery jackpot in U.S. history. Lottery officials recommend winners take a deep breath, put their winning ticket in a safe spot and consult with a reputable financial planner before popping over to the lottery headquarters.

  • The ‘smart money’ says it’s time to buy the Chinese internet giants and the U.S. FAANGs
    News
    MarketWatch

    The ‘smart money’ says it’s time to buy the Chinese internet giants and the U.S. FAANGs

    When the media and investors turn negative on stocks but the “smart money” is bullish, it’s a good time to think about buying. After all, exactly what is the smart money, and how do you know? Lately, several fund managers who pass this test have been pounding the table on Chinese internet names.

  • Provocateur Stormy Daniels Takes an Unexpected Turn in the National Spotlight
    Politics
    Time

    Provocateur Stormy Daniels Takes an Unexpected Turn in the National Spotlight

    To understand what it means to be famous like Stormy Daniels, for the reasons she is famous, spend time with her in a public space. On Oct. 15, a California judge threw out the defamation case she filed against Donald Trump. Over the past year, Daniels, 39, has become the Zelig of White House scandals.

  • Goldman Sachs Adds Nvidia To 'Conviction Buy' List
    Business
    Yahoo Finance Video

    Goldman Sachs Adds Nvidia To 'Conviction Buy' List

    Goldman Sachs analyst Toshiya Hari reiterated his 'Buy' rating for Nvidia and added the chip-maker to Goldman’s 'Conviction Buy' list.

  • Business
    Reuters

    Micron to buy Intel's stake in joint venture IM Flash Technologies

    The deal terms include payment of about $1.5 billion in cash, as well as taking over Intel's debt to the venture, which was about $1 billion as of Aug. 30, Micron said. Intel and Micron initially contributed about $1.2 billion each to set up IM Flash Technologies in 2006. IM Flash (Intel-Micron Flash) makes 3D XPoint used in data centres and high-end computers and the joint venture is already consolidated in Micron's reported financial statements.

  • Marijuana stocks to watch: Aurora Cannabis investments may be more valuable than its pot
    News
    MarketWatch

    Marijuana stocks to watch: Aurora Cannabis investments may be more valuable than its pot

    Aurora Cannabis Inc. is a major pot producer, but if its bets on other cannabis companies continue to pay off, it may be able to stop actually growing weed on its own. Aurora (ACBFF)(CA:ACB) said recently its investments were worth more than C$700 million ($540 million) as of Sept. 21, bolstered in part by demand for pot stocks ahead of full legalization of marijuana in Canada on Wednesday. As the entire sector has benefited, so has Aurora’s portfolio, boosting the company’s fiscal fourth-quarter profit to C$79.9 million, after a loss of $20.8 million the year earlier.

  • Home Depot vs. Lowe’s: Both Stocks Are Slumping, So Which One Should You Buy?
    Finance
    GoBankingRates

    Home Depot vs. Lowe’s: Both Stocks Are Slumping, So Which One Should You Buy?

    An analyst downgrade based on housing market outlooks has sent stocks from Lowe’s and Home Depot down over the last two days. Both Home Depot and Lowe’s are in downtrends dating back to September. On Wednesday, shares in Lowe’s and The Home Depot were slumping after disappointing housing market data led a key analyst to downgrade his ratings and slash price targets, and both stocks continued the slump into a second day on Thursday.

  • 7 Stocks Warren Buffett Can’t Stop Buying
    Finance
    InvestorPlace

    7 Stocks Warren Buffett Can’t Stop Buying

    Sometimes identifying the best stocks to buy can be difficult, but you could do a lot worse than checking out the stocks selected by one of the world’s savviest hedge fund managers — Warren Buffett. Buffett’s stock picks are a popular source for investors, and for good reason. The billionaire Buffett is many things: He’s among the world’s most successful fund managers, a legendary philanthropist and owns more than 60 companies.

  • Starbucks selling stores, closing office in Europe
    Business
    Associated Press

    Starbucks selling stores, closing office in Europe

    Starbucks is restructuring its European operations after several years of slowing sales. The Seattle-based coffee chain is selling 83 company-owned stores in France, the Netherlands, Belgium and Luxembourg to its longtime partner, Alsea. Alsea will also provide services to 177 other Starbucks locations in those countries which are owned by franchisees.

  • Sky-high salaries at Facebook, Google and tech titans will create opportunities for the proactive
    Finance
    American City Business Journals

    Sky-high salaries at Facebook, Google and tech titans will create opportunities for the proactive

    No matter whether you’re in Silicon Valley, Boston or Birmingham, a dollar is a dollar in the most literal sense.  But in terms of talent or venture capital, it’s not really. The difference is evident in the eye-popping median salaries at Silicon Valley tech giants like Facebook Inc. (Nasdaq: FB) ($240,430), Alphabet Inc.'s Google (Nasdaq: GOOG) ($197,274) and Ebay Inc. (Nasdaq: EBAY) ($122,891), according to recent data compiled by our sister publication. Compare that to the median salary for say, software developers in metro Birmingham ($92,000), and you can see a clear opportunity for Birmingham and similarly positioned communities in the South.

  • Finding a Cure for Kinder Morgan’s Frustration
    Business
    Bloomberg

    Finding a Cure for Kinder Morgan’s Frustration

    Rising profits – Ebitda was up 6 percent, year over year – and that Canadian pipeline sale have helped address Kinder Morgan’s biggest problem, its crushing debt. Thankfully, it provided a strong signal on Wednesday evening that it would.

  • Here's everyone who has dropped out of Saudi Arabia's 'Davos of the Middle East'
    Finance
    Yahoo Finance

    Here's everyone who has dropped out of Saudi Arabia's 'Davos of the Middle East'

    U.S. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin tweeted Thursday that he will not be attending the Future Investment Initiative in Saudi Arabia next week. The news comes after prominent members of the world’s business community have been dropping out of Saudi

  • Employee Accused of Urinating on Production Line at Food Processing Facility
    Business
    WTKR - Norfolk

    Employee Accused of Urinating on Production Line at Food Processing Facility

    Smithfield Foods, Inc. said in a statement Tuesday that it disposed of more than 50,000 pounds of product after reports of an employee urinating at his station at the company’s processing facility in Virginia.

  • Finance
    CNBC

    China's stock market is getting pummeled and history shows that is bad news for US markets

    U.S. stocks are lower about 70 percent of the time in periods when there are big drops of 10 percent or more in Shanghai stocks, according to analytics firm Kensho. The main U.S. indexes lose about 5 percent when Shanghai stocks fall 10 percent or more in a 30-day period. Big blue chips, like Goldman and Caterpillar are among the losers, but copper and oil also fall hard when Shanghai sees a big decline.

  • Facebook admits its camera-equipped listening device can collect your data for ads
    Technology
    The Independent

    Facebook admits its camera-equipped listening device can collect your data for ads

    Facebook's decision to launch a camera-equipped listening device for people's living rooms, just months after one of the biggest data scandals in history, was greeted with a fair amount of suspicion. Given that Facebook's business model relies on using people's data to serve them personalised ads, it seemed fair to assume that the Portal smart speaker could serve a purpose beyond simply acting as a voice-activated home assistant that can handle video calls.

  • Ford Motor Company Earnings: What to Watch For
    Business
    Motley Fool

    Ford Motor Company Earnings: What to Watch For

    Ford Motor Company (NYSE: F) will report its third-quarter earnings results after the markets close on Oct. 24. Wall Street analysts polled by Thomson Reuters expect Ford to report earnings of $0.30 per share, on average, down from $0.43 in the third quarter of 2017. Ford's F-Series pickups continue to sell well and generate good profits, thanks to high-margin versions like this F-150 Limited.

  • Finance
    InvestorPlace

    Will Apple Really Switch Macs Off Intel Chips in 2020?

    Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL) has been selling Mac computers powered by Intel (NASDAQ:INTC) processors since 2006. A noted Apple analyst is predicting Apple will release an ARM-based Mac as soon as 2020, ditching Intel. Apple analyst Ming-Chi Kuo has a reputation for getting things right when it comes to forecasting the company’s moves.

  • The same question that can chart a path to early retirement is the one Warren Buffett used to build Berkshire Hathaway into a powerhouse
    Business
    Business Insider

    The same question that can chart a path to early retirement is the one Warren Buffett used to build Berkshire Hathaway into a powerhouse

    Inversion is a mental model that involves flipping your outlook to prevent the opposite of what you want to happen from happening. Warren Buffett and his business partner Charlie Munger employed inversion as a business strategy to build Berkshire Hathaway into a powerhouse. In a recent podcast with Brandon of the Mad Fientist, who retired early at 34, productivity expert James Clear said the same strategy Buffett used can help set someone on the path for early retirement.

  • Don’t sweat a stock-market selloff with midterms around the corner, says strategist
    News
    MarketWatch

    Don’t sweat a stock-market selloff with midterms around the corner, says strategist

    “On average, the S&P 500 actually has been negative year to date in early October during a midterm year,” said Detrick, in a note. Read: Will midterm elections sink the stock market? As for the market’s dismal performance the past couple of weeks, Detrick expects stocks to remain under pressure in the near term as they had done in 2016 when the S&P 500 slid for nine straight sessions before the election in November.

  • Finance
    Investopedia

    Berkshire Is Undervalued, Says JPMorgan

    Berkshire Hathaway Inc.'s ( BRK.B) Class B shares are cheap if you apply the same metrics that its CEO Warren Buffett does to value companies, according to JPMorgan. In a research note, reported on by CNBC, analyst Sarah DeWitt said Berkshire, a company that investors have historically struggled to value properly because of its many moving parts, suddenly appears to be attractively priced when factoring in all the profits made by the stocks held in its $200 billion equity portfolio into its earnings. “Look-through earnings” take into account current period earnings that show up in financial statements, together with other sources of earnings expected in the long run. This method is used by Buffett as a way to appreciate that companies sometimes retain earnings after paying dividends and later invest them at a higher rate of return.

  • Alibaba (BABA) Dips More Than Broader Markets: What You Should Know
    Finance
    Zacks

    Alibaba (BABA) Dips More Than Broader Markets: What You Should Know

    Investors will be hoping for strength from BABA as it approaches its next earnings release, which is expected to be November 2, 2018. On that day, BABA is projected to report earnings of $1.16 per share, which would represent a year-over-year decline of 10.08%. Investors should also note any recent changes to analyst estimates for BABA.

  • Lockheed Martin (LMT) Dips More Than Broader Markets: What You Should Know
    Finance
    Zacks

    Lockheed Martin (LMT) Dips More Than Broader Markets: What You Should Know

    Lockheed Martin (LMT) closed the most recent trading day at $328.12, moving -1.58% from the previous trading session. In that same time, the Aerospace sector lost 1.77%, while the S&P 500 lost 2.61%. Meanwhile, the Zacks Consensus Estimate for revenue is projecting net sales of $13.14 billion, up 8.02% from the year-ago period.

  • Aurora Cannabis stock leads sector higher after news it will start trading on NYSE next week
    News
    MarketWatch

    Aurora Cannabis stock leads sector higher after news it will start trading on NYSE next week

    Canadian marijuana company Aurora Cannabis Inc.’s shares rose about 4% Thursday after it said shares have been approved for trading on the New York Stock Exchange starting October 23. The stock (CA:ACB)(CA:ACB) which is currently trading on the over-the-counter market, will trade under the ticker symbol “ACB”. The shares are also traded on the Toronto Stock Exchange.

  • Caterpillar (CAT) to Report Q3 Earnings: What's in the Offing?
    Business
    Zacks

    Caterpillar (CAT) to Report Q3 Earnings: What's in the Offing?

    Caterpillar Inc. CAT is slated to report third-quarter 2018 results on Oct 23 before the opening bell. Both the top and bottom line also beat the Zacks Consensus Estimate. Consequently, investors are keen to know whether Caterpillar will be able to maintain the momentum in the third quarter of 2018 as well.

  • 3 takeaways from a conversation between Warren Buffett and Dr. James Reed
    Finance
    American City Business Journals

    3 takeaways from a conversation between Warren Buffett and Dr. James Reed

    The world's third-richest person sat down with the leader of the largest Albany area hospital system to talk about health care and the economy. Billionaire Warren Buffett, chief executive of Berkshire Hathaway, had a public discussion Wednesday with Dr. James Reed, president and CEO of St. Peter's Health Partners. The discussion was held after a Berkshire Hathaway subsidiary bought medical malpractice insurer MLMIC, formerly Medical Liability Mutual Insurance Co. Reed is chairman of the board of MLMIC, New York's largest medical malpractice insurer.