Should You Be Worried About Negative Interest Rates?
In a normal economy, banks pay out interest to their depositors, use the deposited funds to make loans, and take in interest that's charged to the borrowers.
But when economies go off track, those rules can be thrown out the window. You might have to pay the bank a fee for holding your money, and a lender might pay you to take out a loan.
Welcome to the topsy-turvy world of negative interest rates.
Some countries are already there, within the financial version of the Upside Down from Stranger Things. Experts are speculating that the U.S. may eventually join them.
What are negative interest rates?
Negative interest rates are typically seen during weak economies and periods of deflation — when prices go into a downward spiral.
Businesses and consumers tend to wait to see if prices will go even lower, so they save money instead of spending it. To encourage spending, banks start making it costly to sit on your money.
Instead of earning 2% interest on your savings, you might have to pay a 0.6% annual fee to keep it at the bank. That's considered an interest rate of -0.6%, and it's money that you're losing.
Negative interest works the opposite way for borrowers. To get people and businesses spending, banks extend loans at negative rates — meaning a borrower's interest "charge" is subtracted from the principal, not added to it.
For example, you might be offered a 15-year mortgage with a negative annual interest rate of -0.5%. By the time you finish repaying the loan, you'll have paid less money than the amount you originally borrowed.
Why are we hearing a lot of talk about negative interest rates?
Negative interest rates have been in the news lately because they've been spreading in Europe and Asia.
Commercial banks in Switzerland and Denmark recently announced negative interest rates for wealthy depositors, and the European Central Bank — which has had negative rates for five years — is expected to send its rates even lower.
European Central Bank officials say the below-zero interest is providing important support for Europe's economy, contrary to complaints from banks in Germany and France that the negative rates are causing harm.
Negative interest rates have become a topic in the U.S. because of the recent flip-flop for Treasury bonds. Short-term Treasurys have been paying higher interest than long-term bonds, in what's known as an inverted yield curve.
While that's often seen as an economic warning sign, it's not the same as a negative interest rate. The government is still paying interest on its bonds — and isn't charging people to hold them.
The history of negative interest rates
During the global recession from 2007 to 2009, central banks in Europe lowered interest rates to zero or close to it to get people to start borrowing. However, their economies continued to be sluggish.
This led the central banks to introduce a collection of unconventional policies — including negative interest rates.
It happened first in Sweden, where the central bank in 2009 lowered the rate on some deposits it holds overnight for commercial banks to -0.25%.
Denmark's central bank introduced negative rates in 2012 and has stuck with them ever since, except for one four-month period in 2014. The European Central Bank cut interest rates below zero in 2014, and the Bank of Japan joined the party in 2016.
The moves by the central banks haven't directly impacted consumers. But commercial banks often pass the negative interest along to their customers, by charging them fees to hold their deposits.
Will we see negative interest rates in the US?
While negative interest rates could present some opportunities for borrowers in the U.S. — after all, who wouldn't want to pay back less than they borrowed? — their introduction could be taken as a sign of an economy in serious trouble.
Many experts are predicting that the Federal Reserve might be forced to go negative, because the Fed's benchmark interest rate is already very low and doesn't offer the central bank much room to cut rates if things turn bad.
The Fed's "federal funds rate" is currently between 2% and 2.25%.
If the Fed were to introduce negative interest rates, commercial banks would be charged interest on their deposits. And, as the situation in Europe demonstrates, that negative interest would likely be passed on to consumers.
This means savers would be charged interest by banks to hold their deposits, instead of earning interest.
But the long U.S. economic expansion is still intact, and — other than the inverted yield curve — the economy is showing few of the usual signs that it's about to fall into recession.
So, don't start looking for negative-interest-rate mortgages anytime soon.
Join the MoneyWise mailing list. You’ll get the latest financial tips and news, straight to your inbox.