The downside of minimum wage hikes

Yahoo Finance

California this week mandated a minimum wage of at least $9 an hour, making it the third state to do so, and several more plan to follow suit. President Obama has called for Congress to raise the federal minimum wage to $10.10 an hour, but that proposal has not and is not likely to gain any traction in Washington. Why? Because there are many - like CKE Restaurants CEO Andy Puzder - who argue that "artificially” raising the minimum wage when it’s not justified by economic growth is actually detrimental to workers and the economy.

“When there’s a demand for labor, the cost of labor goes up. When there’s no demand for labor, it goes down and you can’t solve that problem by having the government artificially mandate a wage increase when there’s no economic growth to support that,” says Puzder. “What businesses do is they increase their prices and they move to automation so you have less jobs.”

A study by the Congressional Budget Office found that the president’s proposal to raise the minimum wage to $10.10 an hour would result in the loss of 500,000 jobs by the second half of 2016.

States Go It Alone

One of the results of the state and local minimum wage increases across the country is more young people out of work, according to Puzder. The more entry-level jobs pay, the more willing experienced, qualified workers will be to take them, thereby bumping the young and inexperienced out of the work force. Puzder says that is causing a real problem for the young people of America.

“The real problem with youth is: You have to have these entry-level jobs to get the experience you need to move forward in your life. If they don’t have those jobs, they’re sitting at home – I don’t know – looking at the posters from the last election or waiting for mom to make dinner, as opposed to being out there actually working and getting the experience that they need to go forward in life,” argues Puzder. “The experience is the important part and we’ve got a whole generation of kids ages 16 to 29 who are missing out on that.”

Cause and Effect

Puzder says he believes states and municipalities have the right to raise the minimum wage, but he believes people need to understand the consequences, including higher prices and increased automation, which his company is undertaking using iPads to take orders at some restaurants instead of people.

“When politicians tell people, ‘We’re going to increase the minimum wage and your check will be bigger,’ what they don’t say and [what] the next sentence should be [is]: ‘However, it’s not going to be worth as much as the increase, because everybody’s going to increase their prices so you’re not going to be able to buy as much as you could have if we’d just had economic growth that justified that increase.”

So what does Andy Puzder propose instead of artificially inflated minimum wages? “Government needs to get out of the way. If government gets out of the way, businesses will create jobs,” he says. “Wages will go up and the country will go back to a state of prosperity instead of what we’re in now."

More from Yahoo Finance:

Why Uncle Sam wants YOU to have more kids

'Frozen' tours take off as film tourism reaches a fever pitch

 

Rates

View Comments (276)