More Japanese Firms Opt to Go Private as Activist Clout Grows
(Bloomberg) -- A growing number of publicly-listed companies in Japan are going private, as regulatory shifts clear the way for activist investors to step up scrutiny and demand changes.
Most Read from Bloomberg
Goldman CEO’s Most Loyal Deputy Is Tested by Mutinous Partners
Tech Stocks Take a Leg Down Ahead of Fed Minutes: Markets Wrap
China Asks Some Funds to Avoid Net Equity Sales as Markets Sink
A total of 135 companies delisted from the country’s stock exchanges last year, almost triple what it was a decade ago, according to Jason Thomas, head of Carlyle Group Inc.’s global research and investment strategy.
Drawn by the promise of fat returns on stocks trading at discounts, activist shareholders are flocking to the world’s third-largest equity market. Reforms in corporate governance guidelines and regulators’ increasing emphasis on equity returns and profitability are further spurring a level of activism that’s driving a surge in privatizations, Thomas said.
Japan is on pace to more than double the number of shareholder proposals that companies field from activists this year, with 67 proposals submitted as of June, compared with a record 58 in all of 2022, according to IR Japan Holdings Ltd. In 2014, publicly-traded companies received four proposals.
Management teams often prefer to restructure their firms as privately-held entities with partners of their choosing and are wary of changes pushed through by activist shareholders, Thomas said. The number of delistings may grow “substantially from here,” he said.
Prominent delistings on the horizon include Toshiba Corp., whose long-delayed $15 billion buyout began Tuesday, as well as semiconductor materials maker JSR Corp., which is slated for a $6.3 billion take-private bid. Both are linchpins Japan’s tech sector, and their privatizations signal how even some of Tokyo Stock Exchange’s longtime members are finding the drawbacks of a public listing outweighing the considerable advantages.
Toshiba, which has activist representatives on its board, is delisting following months-long delays in a bidding process that came about only after multiple fracas with shareholders.
Executives have denied that activism has anything to do with the decision to go private. JSR Corp. Chief Executive Officer Eric Johnson said in June the semiconductor material maker’s decision to agree to a $6.3 billion buyout by government-backed Japan Investment Corp. was to drive scale and growth and catalyze change in the country’s materials sector. He denied the board sought to avoid dealing with activist shareholders’ demands.
The surge in privatizations of publicly-traded companies is part of a global move worldwide that started in the US and other developed-market economies as much as two decades ago, Carlyle’s Thomas said.
The delistings in Japan reflect a shift toward more efficient corporate governance and a focus on increasing capital productivity, he said. In that sense, “this is indeed a positive trend,” he said.
The temptation remains for management to delist to escape increased investor scrutiny and accountability, however. Critics are also wary of management buyouts and exclusively-negotiated acquisitions, because of the risk that they might ignore minority shareholders’ interests.
“A take-over-bid price that’s 30% above the most recent share price can’t be seen fair if someone else is willing to pay 60% more,” said RMB Capital’s Masakazu Hosomizu. “You need pricing transparency by having multiple bidders compete.”
--With assistance from Lianting Tu.
Most Read from Bloomberg Businessweek
Brookfield Chases Rivals for Private Equity’s New Money-Spinner
One Nassau County Has a Housing Crisis, the Other Nassau County Has a Solution
Private Equity Firms Are Slow to Sell Holdings Amid Higher Rates
©2023 Bloomberg L.P.
