Q1 2023 Domino's Pizza Inc Earnings Call

Participants

Russell J. Weiner; CEO & Director; Domino's Pizza, Inc.

Ryan Goers; VP of Finance & IR; Domino's Pizza, Inc.

Sandeep Reddy; Executive VP & CFO; Domino's Pizza, Inc.

Andrew Michael Charles; MD & Senior Research Analyst; TD Cowen, Research Division

Brian James Harbour; Research Associate; Morgan Stanley, Research Division

Brian John Bittner; MD & Senior Analyst; Oppenheimer & Co. Inc., Research Division

Christopher Emilio Carril; Analyst; RBC Capital Markets, Research Division

Christopher Thomas O'Cull; MD & Senior Analyst; Stifel, Nicolaus & Company, Incorporated, Research Division

David Sterling Palmer; Senior MD & Fundamental Research Analyst; Evercore ISI Institutional Equities, Research Division

Dennis Geiger; Director and Equity Research Analyst of Restaurants; UBS Investment Bank, Research Division

Gregory Ryan Francfort; Director; Guggenheim Securities, LLC, Research Division

John Park

John William Ivankoe; Senior Restaurant Analyst; JPMorgan Chase & Co, Research Division

Joshua C. Long; Analyst; Stephens Inc., Research Division

Lauren Danielle Silberman; Senior Analyst; Crédit Suisse AG, Research Division

Peter Mokhlis Saleh; MD & Senior Restaurant Analyst; BTIG, LLC, Research Division

Sara Harkavy Senatore; MD in Global Equity Research & Senior Analyst; BofA Securities, Research Division

Todd Morrison Brooks; Senior Equity Analyst; The Benchmark Company, LLC, Research Division

Presentation

Operator

Thank you for standing by, and welcome to Domino's Pizza's First Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. (Operator Instructions) As a reminder, today's program is being recorded.
And now I'd like to introduce your host for today's program, Mr. Ryan Goers, Vice President, Finance, Investor Relations. Go ahead, sir.

Ryan Goers

Thank you, and good morning, everyone. Thank you for joining us today for our conversation regarding the results for the first quarter of 2023. Today's call will feature commentary from Chief Executive Officer, Russell Weiner; and Chief Financial Officer, Sandeep Reddy. (Operator Instructions)
I want to remind everyone that the forward-looking statements in this morning's earnings release and 10-Q also apply to our comments on the call today. Both of those documents are available on our website. Actual results or trends could differ materially from our forecast. For more information, please refer to the risk factors discussed in our filings with the SEC.
In addition, please refer to the 8-K earnings release to find disclosures and reconciliations of non-GAAP financial measures that may be referenced on today's call.
(Operator Instructions) Today's call is being webcast and is also being recorded for replay via our website.
With that, I'd like to turn the call over to our Chief Executive Officer, Russell Weiner.

Russell J. Weiner

Thank you, Ryan, and good morning, everybody. Thanks for joining us on today's call. I'd like to start this call where we finished our last one, looking back on what we said we were going to do. I am really proud of the actions that our team and our franchisees have taken and the positive results that they delivered. You'll recall that there were 3 themes we discussed last quarter, the first one was the continued evolution of the Domino's brand from a U.S. delivery business to a global pizza company with leadership in both delivery and carryout. And we continued this progress since our last call.
Let me start off with China. We're proud to welcome our partners DPC Dash, our master franchisee there to the growing list of public companies that are developing and operating Domino's Pizza stores across the globe. On March 28, CEO, Aileen Wang and her team completed their IPO on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange. We have got tremendous potential in China where the Dash team believes they've just scrapped the surface of their total opportunity with stores operating in only 17 cities in China.
Now speaking of public companies, as of the end of Q1 2023, 6 of the top 20 public QSRs in the world as measured by market cap, are part of the Domino's family. DPZ is joined by our master franchisees, Jubilant Foodworks, Domino's Pizza Enterprises, ALSEA, Domino's Pizza Group and Alamar, all in the top 20. This to me exemplifies an important strength of our brand. We've got a diverse portfolio of more than 90 markets around the world.
So our international business has both scale and balance. And what this affords us is the ability to weather any short-term headwinds in certain markets should they come up. We've seen this dynamic play out in Q1 with markets performing exceptionally well, balancing out others that are facing more pressures. All of this, though, resulted in positive international same-store sales growth for the first quarter.
Now on to the U.S. In the U.S., we believe that the QSR pizza delivery and carryout businesses continue to be incremental to each other with limited overlap. We're #1 in both segments and believe we've strengthened our position during the first quarter. The balance we have in our stores would carry out contributing around half the orders and 40% of sales has allowed us to mitigate the more recent macro headwind in the delivery category.
The second theme we discussed on our last call was the need to maintain value in what is a competitive marketplace where our customers decide every day where to spend their hard-earned dollars. Value has to do with the right balance of price and service. Our U.S. business delivered on both of these things in Q1, and I'll start with pricing. On pricing, I mentioned that we and our franchisees have got to be mindful that value on our menu exists outside of our national offers.
Menu prices and delivery fees were relatively stable throughout Q1, that means most of the menu pricing increase we saw in the first quarter versus prior year was carryover from changes that were made in 2022. On service and capacity, our stores and our franchisees continue to make progress on both fronts. Estimated average delivery times in the first quarter were over a minute better than the first quarter of 2022. While our goal is to get back to and improve on our delivery service levels from 2019, I'm really encouraged by the continued improvement we and our franchisees have made in this critical measure.
Our system understands that to be the best, you need to beat the best, even when the best may be yourself. And that's why we're launching an important initiative. We're calling it our summer of service training program. We're inviting all of our U.S. franchisees to come to Ann Arbor to be part of one of the largest system training efforts in our history.
Look, we've driven significant improvements in our back-of-house technology and our circle of operations over the last few years and we've got more coming. The summer of service program will allow us to share best practices with our franchisees, who we expect will leave Ann Arbor with specific plans that they create to positively impact service for every one of their stores. I think these changes will also improve the experience for our customers and our team members in our corporate and franchise stores.
Our third theme from the last call was around the need to drive more innovation. While new products are certainly one way to do that, our brand has a history of bringing news to all aspects of the business. We dialed up innovation over the last few months and anticipate this will continue throughout the year and into the future.
Let's start with product innovation. On the product side, we're really pleased with the launch of our Loaded Tots. For consumers, loaded top offer a craveable potato side that delivers extraordinarily well. They also fit nicely into our Mix & Match menu, providing great value and even more variety when consumers build their orders. For franchisees, tots drive healthy ticket, given they've been largely incremental and have a strong margin profile. Early signs point to Loaded Tots performing even better than our last 2 product launches Dips & Twists and the Chicken Taco and Cheeseburger specialty pizza.
To drive news and ordering convenience in our carryout business, we launched a convenient way for consumers to place their orders while they're on the go with Apple CarPlay. This innovation allows customers to place and track their orders on CarPlay via our iOS app. CarPlay ordering is a great alternative to drive-through, because it allows customers to avoid long lines by placing their orders while they're on the go, so their food is hot and fresh and ready when they arrive at their local Domino's. As important as the ordering platform is itself, CarPlay ordering will help drive what we call our techquity, short for technology equity. We've got a history of leveraging technology to improve customer experiences and Domino's CarPlay ordering continues that tradition.
On the delivery innovation side, Domino's fleet of electric vehicles has been expanding. We announced on our last call that the initial order by our corporate stores and franchisees made us the largest electric fleet of pizza delivery vehicles in the country with 800 cars. Today, Domino's has committed to over 1,000 EVs and counting.
The EV fleet is great for our stores and the environment, all while growing the potential pool of drivers by offering opportunities to individuals that may not have access to a car. All of this news contributed to positive U.S. same-store sales growth in Q1 and will provide momentum for Domino's into the future.
Now for more detail on the quarter, I'd like to turn it over to our CFO, Sandeep Reddy. Sandeep?

Sandeep Reddy

Thank you, Russell, and good morning to everyone on the call. I'll begin my remarks with updates on the actions I've previously outlined to improve our long-term profitability. First, on pricing architecture. During the first quarter, the average year-over-year price increase that was realized across our U.S. system was 6.2%. This included the year-over-year benefit of national pricing changes made in 2022. As a reminder, delivery Mix & Match was updated to $6.99 in March of last year, with carryout Mix & Match updated in October. As we have lapped the delivery Mix & Match national pricing update in March, we expect our second quarter realized year-over-year pricing impact to moderate.
Second, efficiencies in our cost structure as we continue to drive recovery in margin. We saw year-over-year improvement in our operating income margin, which grew by 100 basis points versus Q1 2022. This was despite foreign exchange rates having a negative year-over-year impact on operating income margin of approximately 40 basis points during the quarter.
Third, we had positive same-store sales growth, excluding foreign currency impact in both our U.S. and international businesses for the second consecutive quarter, which also contributed to improving our operating income leverage.
Now for our financial results for the quarter in more detail. When excluding the negative impact of foreign currency, global retail sales grew 5.9% due to positive sales comps and global net store growth over the trailing 4 quarters, lapping 3.6% global retail sales growth, excluding FX for Q1 2022. Breaking down global retail sales growth, U.S. retail sales increased 5.1%, rolling over a prior decrease of 1.4%. International retail sales, excluding the negative impact of foreign currency, grew 6.5%, rolling over the prior year increase of 8.4%.
Turning to comps. During Q1, same-store sales for the U.S. business increased 3.6%, rolling over a prior decrease of 3.6%. The increase in U.S. same-store sales in Q1 was driven by an increase in ticket, which included the 6.2% in pricing actions I mentioned earlier, partially offset by a decline in order counts. The Q1 comps were aided by the Omicron overlap from 2022 as well as the benefit from a boost week in 2023 that we did not run in Q1 last year. Neither of these tailwinds will aid us for the balance of the year as Omicron receded as a headwind, and we ran boost weeks in every quarter last year, starting in Q2.
Now I'll share a few thoughts specifically about the U.S. carryout and delivery businesses. The carryout business was strong in Q1 with U.S. carryout same-store sales 13.4% positive compared to Q1 2022, rolling over a prior year increase of 11.3%. We are very pleased at the strength of our carryout business, but we do expect a moderation in growth rates for the balance of the year as we lap accelerating growth in 2022.
The delivery business remains more pressured. Q1 delivery same-store sales declined by 2.1% relative to Q1 2022, rolling over a prior decline of 10.7%. The delivery business is still challenged by 2 factors that we discussed in our last call. First, a migration of demand from the delivery channel to the sit-down channel as the reversion to pre-pandemic consumer behavior continues. Second, constrained budgets for households with relatively lower disposable income, particularly when factoring fees and tips prompting them to shift their delivery occasion to cooking at home. We are closely monitoring the evolution of growth in real personal consumption expenditures as a consistent inflection in that trend could result in relief on the second headwind to our delivery business.
Shifting to unit count. We and our franchisees added 22 net new stores to the U.S. during Q1. Consisting of 25 store openings and 3 closures, bringing our U.S. system store count to 6,708 stores at the end of the quarter, which brought our 4-quarter net store growth rate in the U.S. to 1.7%. As mentioned on our last call, we expected the U.S. store development pipeline will continue to be pressured by permitting and store construction and supply chain challenges before seeing a gradual recovery starting in the second half of the year, marked by stabilization first before an inflection in trend.
Domino's unit economics remain strong relative to the many pressures faced throughout the year, including staffing challenges and a high inflationary environment for food and labor. We have completed our analysis of estimated average U.S. franchisee store profitability with the final amount coming in at $139,000 for 2022, up from the $137,000 estimate provided on our last call. As previously mentioned, estimated average store profitability was higher in Q4 2022 than Q4 2019, as franchisees are seeing the flow-through benefits of the Mix & Match national pricing increases for both delivery and carryout.
We expect this improvement in profitability to continue in 2023 with the margin flow-through from Loaded Tots being an additional tailwind during the first quarter. We will need further time to evaluate if Loaded Tots will provide an incremental margin dollar lift over the course of the year. Also, as we have completed our analysis on 2022 build costs for stores, relative to our average build cost in 2019, we saw an approximate build cost increase of 20% in 2022. Even with these increased build costs, franchisees are looking at roughly 3-year paybacks on new store openings for 2023 and beyond.
Before we transition to discussing our international business, I would like to briefly touch on our technology costs. To fund additional investments in technology innovation, including a redesign of our e-commerce platform, the technology transaction fee charged to U.S. franchisees will be increased to $0.395 from $0.315 effective the beginning of the second quarter. The technology transaction fee increase covers investments split roughly evenly between G&A and capital expenditures. These investments are included in the annual guidance measures of $425 million to $435 million in G&A spend and $90 million to $100 million capital expenditures for fiscal year 2023.
At the same time, a 25 basis point temporary reduction on contributions to the national advertising fund will go into effect. The net impact of these 2 changes on the increase in technology fee and the 25 basis point reduction of franchisee advertising contributions should be relatively neutral to the estimated average U.S. franchisee store profitability in 2023.
Turning to our international business. Same-store sales, excluding foreign currency impact for our international business increased 1.2%, rolling over the prior increase of 1.2%. We continue to face the headwind of the negative year-over-year impact of the expiration of the 2021 VAT relief in the U.K., our largest international market by retail sales. This was the last full quarter of the negative year-over-year impact with the U.K. VAT relief program being in place through March 31, 2022.
Our international business added 106 net new stores in Q1, comprised of 143 store openings and 37 closures. Our closures were driven by another round of closures in Brazil as our master franchisee there continues its work to optimize the store base in that market as well as some closures in Russia. International store openings in the first quarter were also impacted by the timing of fiscal periods of some of our master franchisees that caused a significant number of openings to shift into the first week of our second quarter. These additional 106 net stores brought our current trailing 4-quarter net store growth rate in international to 6.7%. When combined with our U.S. store growth, our trailing 4-quarter global net store growth rate was 5%.
Turning to EPS. Our diluted EPS in Q1 was $2.93 versus $2.50 in Q1 2022. Breaking down that $0.43 increase in our diluted EPS, our operating results benefited us by $0.36. Changes in foreign currency exchange rates negatively impacted us by $0.09. A lower effective tax rate positively impacted us by $0.04. Lower net interest expense benefited us by $0.06 and a lower diluted share count driven by share repurchases over the trailing 12 months benefited us by $0.06.
We continue to generate sizable free cash flow. During the first quarter, we generated net cash provided by operating activities of approximately $115 million. After deducting for capital expenditures of approximately $19 million, which consisted of investments in our technology initiatives and supply chain centers, we generated free cash flow of approximately $96 million. Free cash flow increased $29 million from the first quarter of 2022, primarily due to the positive impact of changes in working capital and higher net income.
During the quarter, we returned over $30 million to shareholders through share repurchases. As of the end of the quarter, we had approximately $380 million remaining under our Board authorization for share repurchases. In the first quarter, the allocation methodology for certain costs which support internally developed software was updated on a prospective basis. The change in allocation methodology resulted in an estimated increase in U.S. store segment income of $10 million and an estimated increase in international franchise segment income of $2 million, fully offset by a decrease of other segment income of $12 million.
Finally, I would like to provide an update on a few of our annual guidance measures that we previously communicated. We expect a year-over-year market basket increase of 3% to 5% in 2023. Changes in foreign currency rates could have a $2 million to $6 million negative impact on international royalty revenues in 2023. And our tax rate, excluding the impact of equity-based compensation, is expected to range from 22% to 24% in 2023.
Based on current trends, we expect each of these measures will come in towards the low end of their respective ranges. Additionally, we continue to expect our global retail sales growth and global unit growth in 2023 to trend to the low end of our unchanged 2- to 3-year outlook.
Thank you all for joining the call today. And now I'll turn the call back to Russell.

Russell J. Weiner

Thanks, Sandeep. Before we close out the call, I want to touch on a couple of areas that are important as we move forward in 2023. The first one is store growth. As Sandeep mentioned in his comments, we expect that the U.S. store development pipeline will continue to be pressured by permitting and store construction supply chain challenges before seeing a gradual recovery beginning in the second half of the year.
In my conversations with franchisees and discussions with our team on new commitments to store growth by our system, I'm confident that we will see an inflection in trend towards the end of the year and into '24. Domino's franchisees came out of a challenging 2022 with estimated store EBITDA of almost $140,000. This proves to me and more importantly to them, that building a Domino's store remains one of the best investments in the restaurant industry.
The second point I want to highlight is innovation, giving you a little bit of insight into our e-commerce pipeline. It's not a comprehensive list, but it should help you understand that we're bringing news to our customers while also improving our ability to drive loyalty and a more personalized experience, leveraging our robust customer database. As I mentioned on our last call, we'll be refreshing and improving our Piece of the Pie loyalty program. When we launched it back in 2015, we were more of a delivery company with our carryout business still gaining momentum. So naturally, our loyalty program was designed more around the delivery customer.
One of the key objectives of the refreshed Piece of the Pie program will be to explicitly cater to the carryout customer in addition to the delivery customer. We're excited to add more value and rewards for everybody. We've also started to work on a redesign and rewrite of our entire e-commerce platform. This work will continue into 2024, and we will update you on progress along the way. Our digital ordering clients and tech stack have been a huge part of our strategy and a competitive advantage for us over time. So we need to invest in these forms to ensure we remain in a leadership position.
In closing, when I look back on the first quarter, I can't help, but be encouraged by the resilience of our business model and the competitive advantage that our franchisees and team members bring to Domino's Pizza. I remain bullish on our future and look forward to telling you more of our story and our long-term strategy at our Investor Day, which will be held in late Q4.
With that, we'll open the call to questions.

Question and Answer Session

Operator

And our first question comes from the line of Brian Bittner from Oppenheimer.

Brian John Bittner

Just first, a clarification question from you, Sandeep. As it relates to your outlook, in 2023 for total retail sales to be at the lower end of the 4% to 8% range. Can you talk to us about what the implied same-store sales outlook embedded in this guidance is?
And then, Russell, my main question to you, just as it relates to delivery and the ongoing weakness in this segment, I appreciate the macro pressures that you outlined during this call and previous calls. But -- what are -- are you currently taking market share? And can you just further elaborate on actions that you are taking inside the company to improve your competitive advantage within delivery to set that business up for a strong turn when these macro pressures recede?

Sandeep Reddy

I'll take the first piece, and I think Russell will cover the second piece that you asked. So in terms of the outlook, I think you're asking about the global retail sales outlook of 4% to 8% a rating that is still expected to be at the low end for 2023. And I think when we go back to what we said last time and again, what we're saying this time, not really changing the narrative of what we said, drove that adjustment in the first place, which was the challenges that we were seeing in the U.S. delivery business was the primary driver of the lowered estimation of the global retail sales outlook.
So we feel very confident more broadly about the business, because the carryout business has been great. The international business, as you just heard from Russell, did extremely well as well, notwithstanding the U.K. VAT impact that we were rolling over. So we feel really good about the overall business. But I think until we come through the delivery challenges, and that's what you asked wrestle about, we basically believe that the outlook is appropriate.

Russell J. Weiner

Brian, on the delivery side, it really is -- to answer your question really in 2 parts. First, we grew delivery QSR pizza market share last year. We're continuing to do that in Q1. And so the point that you ask is what can we do in addition to drive that. And it's kind of the same basic things we outlined on the same call. It's driving value, delivery service were a minute better than we were a year ago. Innovation in all areas, not just product, but we have actually delivery innovation out there now with the electric vehicles. We're up to 1,000 vehicles. This new loyalty program is going to do a really good job in driving transactions. And then the majority of our delivery customers were online. And so I think what you're hearing when we're talking about redoing our e-commerce platforms, that's certainly going to help there as well.

Operator

And our next question comes from the line of Peter Saleh from BTIG.

Peter Mokhlis Saleh

Russell, I wanted to ask about the decision to reduce the marketing spend by 25 basis points. I understand it's pretty much an offset to the -- raising the digital fees. But can you just give us a sense on how much total impressions would be down this year with that reduction in spend?

Russell J. Weiner

Sure. I mean the point at the end of the day is we take a holistic look at the franchisees' P&Ls. And we just think that this is a better investment over the course of the next year, because of where we are in our marketing budget. So I don't expect an impression decline, I just think that this is a great overall use of their money for the year.

Sandeep Reddy

And Pete, I'll just add a little bit to that, because I think it's very important to think about this strategically and holistically for both a financial standpoint and kind of what we're looking at. And we were engaged in deep discussions with our franchisees before we actually made this move. And I think over the course of the pandemic, we've actually built up the ad fund reserve to a point where we believe that the resources that are in the ad funds are more than enough to cover the demands that we have from an advertising standpoint this year.
And at the same time, as we looked at innovation and the need to invest in technology, our franchisees and us believe that this was the right way to redeploy investment. And so we've done it very clearly with a view to the long term. And this is, as we said, have been year adjustment that we made. So we'll take a look at it in 1 year's time and decide what to do.

Operator

And our next question comes from the line of Sara Senatore from Bank of America.

Sara Harkavy Senatore

A question and a quick follow-up. You said the boost week won't be continued tailwind. Your outlook on same-store sales in general strikes a note of caution. I was wondering if you can quantify what you think that tailwind was? I'm just trying to understand the underlying run rate might be or what the drivers that Russ highlighted, the magnitude of those might look like as we go forward?
And then just quick follow-up on the comment about shifting back to dine-in. Delivery across the industry is a lot higher than it was as a share of sales pre-COVID. So do you have any thoughts on how long this shift might last? I would expect dine-in probably ends up as a lower share of the total mix. But trying to again, understand how long that headwind persists in your view?

Sandeep Reddy

Sara, quite a few questions in there, but I'll take this. I'll take them in a sequence. So I think you're first talking about some of the things that I pointed out to in the prepared remarks on the benefits that we got in the first quarter on the comp from the tailwinds that we had from lapping Omicron and also the fact that we had a boost week in '23, which we didn't have in '22. And I'm not going to unpack the details of exactly how much that was, but definitely, those were 2 tailwinds, and they're actually a third tailwind also if I think about it, because we have now lapped the national pricing update on delivery. And I think we definitely got the benefit of that pricing impact that actually was embedded in ticket as well.
So when you think about all these different elements, there is going to be an expectation that there will be some deceleration relative to that, because those were tailwinds that we had uniquely in the first quarter. And that's why we actually pointed those out.
And then I think the broader topic of shifting to dine-in, I think our point when we actually did the Q4 call was, we've seen throughout 2022, a shift back into dine-in. And I think -- but when we look at the values of where the dine-in had reached, we were still well below 2019 levels for dine-in. And so the expectation that we had when we set up our outlook for the 2- to 3-year time frame is and particularly on 2023, was to continue to see that shift happening over the course of 2023.

Operator

And our next question comes from the line of Dennis Geiger from UBS.

Dennis Geiger

Russell, you spoke to stepping up the pace of innovation, and you gave some good examples. Just wondering if you could touch a little bit more on what that means? Perhaps how long it takes to kind of get innovation going to where it was a few years back? And anything more you can share in thinking about innovation across menu and technology? And if I could flip a related part in there, is there any update with respect to how you think about third-party aggregator relationships as we think about technology and evolution of the brand?

Russell J. Weiner

Dennis, I maybe take the first -- the second question first to talk a little bit about third party. We've got $1 billion business internationally with aggregators. And I -- and we're learning there every day. I think the number one thing that we've learned is whoever you work with or whoever you compete with, Domino's is better when we're a stickier brand. When we have more to make consumers when they decide where they're going to order to order from us.
And stickiness is getting the value right, it's getting service right. You talked about innovation, so I'll get to that in a second. I think stickiness is also this new loyalty program. The updated loyalty program will make us stickier as well as recognizing that it's time to upgrade our e-commerce site. And so if we're a stickier Domino's Pizza, no matter who we compete with or work with here, we'll be in a place that we can win.
Secondly, the -- or firstly, I guess, would be the -- what was your first question, a question on innovation. I would really ask that folks take a broad definition of innovation. And that's not to couch and say we're not going to be doing a lot of product innovation and stepping up that and we're not going to be doing carryout or delivery innovation. But let me give you an example of something that people maybe wouldn't think of as innovation which is carryout tips.
Carryout tips, the majority of companies, what they call it is a bounce back coupon, and what our marketing people did, did a great job. And they said, you know what, we're incentive of calling it a $3 bounce-back coupon. We're a delivery company. In this case, customers are delivering our pizza, let's call it a tip. They get to $3 to the next week, and it's an incremental purchase. And that's an innovation.
So I think you got product innovation with tots. Value innovation, I don't think anyone talks about value innovation, the way we do. Apple CarPlay is a carryout innovation the cars or EV is delivery innovation. All of those types of innovations are things you should see on a quarterly basis, I expect to be able to update you on these calls.

Operator

And our next question comes from the line of Gregory Francfort from Guggenheim.

Gregory Ryan Francfort

Russell, just can you talk about what you think the competitive differentiation is of the Domino's business today, and if that's changed from 4 or 5 years ago, I think aggregators have figured out the profitability a little bit better. But can you maybe help us understand the reasons for why you have kind of competitive differentiation versus those platforms and if that's changed over the last 4 or 5 years or not?

Russell J. Weiner

Yes. Sure. thanks for the question. Actually, I think when we talk about broadness and competitiveness, what I'd like to start out with is carryout. We talk a lot about the fact that there's not a lot of overlap between delivery and carryout historically about 15%. And so if you look back at the last 3 years on our U.S. carryout business, it's up almost 30% in same-store sales. So to think that that's a very incremental piece of growth for our business, should hopefully help you understand how we think about diversifying and differentiating and growing ourselves as not only a pizza delivery company, but as a total restaurant.
And I think -- on the delivery piece, again, I'll point to we are growing pizza delivery market share, but we think we can do more. And a lot of it is because certainly, the competition is different. But I think we've learned a lot, Greg, over the last few years. You think of what we learned through COVID. We went through some capacity constraints. We went through driver availability issues. And they say the necessity is the mother of invention. And that's why we're doing this summer of service program here.
We're inviting our franchisees up, because we've made significant improvements and innovations, because of all of this learning, we will now be better in our circle of operations and in our technology, and these are substantial enough that it's not something that we can train people in a video. Every single Domino's U.S. franchisee is coming up here to Ann Arbor for this training, and they will leave with individual plans that they're putting together for their stores when they go back. And at the end of the day in order to really step change ourselves when these macro things go away, it's going to be stepping up service. And I think, hopefully, this is an example of how we're leaning in there.

Operator

And our next question comes from the line of Chris Carril from RBC Capital Markets.

Christopher Emilio Carril

On pricing, Sandeep, you noted the lapping of delivery Mix & Match pricing in March. And with that pricing should moderate here in the 2Q. But appreciating your continued focus on value here. if transactions were to remain stable or potentially improve, how open are you to taking further pricing, particularly if you do see those service levels begin to improve with all the initiatives you have in place?

Sandeep Reddy

I think when we talk about pricing options and value, I think that's a constant. It's not this last year. It's been over the last decade or more that we've been doing this. And so we'll continue to evaluate pricing relative to competition and kind of what the macro environment will actually yield from a demand standpoint, because we always are going to do the work. But I don't think we're particularly in trying to say what we're going to do or not going to do, because it's going to be the outcome of the work.

Operator

And our next question comes from the line of Brian Harbour from Morgan Stanley.

Brian James Harbour

One thing I was curious about just talking about innovation is could you talk about your market share at different dayparts and whether you think that there's specific opportunities to lean into 1 or 2 of those where you perhaps don't have as much share as the others? And can that be a source of product innovation perhaps?

Sandeep Reddy

Are you there?

Brian James Harbour

Yes. Hello. Can you hear me?

Sandeep Reddy

Yes. Sorry, we had a blip on the last question. Do you mind repeating the question, please?

Brian James Harbour

Sorry about that. I was curious just about if you could talk about dayparts and how your market share might differ by daypart and whether you think that that's kind of an innovation opportunity as well to target different dayparts differently?

Russell J. Weiner

I don't think we're going to go into -- by the way, sorry. I don't think we're going to go into the detail of the specific numbers of our dayparts. But your answer is -- or your -- the answer to your question is absolutely. Finding incremental drill sites has been key for this brand. I remember when I joined in 2008, the majority of our stores weren't open for lunch. We gave them a product with sandwiches and then later pasta. And now that's a pretty significant piece of our business.
We also weren't a big carryout company and obviously now carryout's half of the orders that come through Domino's. So what we're -- what our job is to do every day is to find incremental drill sites and dayparts are absolutely one of those areas that we look.

Operator

And our next question comes from the line of David Palmer from Evercore ISI.

David Sterling Palmer

Just a follow-up on the previous question about third-party sites and marketing and collecting orders from those in the U.S. You noted how you do it overseas. But your previous answer, you said you're looking for stickier sales or you found that those have the highest value. Is that your way of saying you're kind of closing the book on this and that you've kind of made up your mind? Or are you evaluating this still? And if you are evaluating it still, what sort of factors and timing should we be thinking about that you're thinking about?

Russell J. Weiner

Yes. I think maybe the way to interpret what I said before is there are opportunities and there are also potential issues with competing with folks or working with folks. And we're not going to think about going into anything unless we're our best Domino's. And the best Domino's we're getting there every day. We're improving our service, and we talked about some of the tech and loyalty pieces. And then we'll be in a better place to compete with or work with anybody.

David Sterling Palmer

This is something you haven't closed the book on, but perhaps some changes that you're making might enable you to pursue that path, not that you're committing at this point, but is something that you haven't closed the book on?

Russell J. Weiner

Maybe I'll refer back to the prior questions. We're always looking for drill sites. If there are incremental drill sites that are smart for us, and this is one of them. You're never going to hear that this team closes the book on things. Right now, we're focused on making ourselves a better Domino's.

Operator

And our next question comes from the line of Joshua Long from Stephens.

Joshua C. Long

Excited to hear more about the summer service program, understanding that all the franchisees are going to be walking away with an individualized plan, but -- this is certainly exciting, but curious if you could talk a little bit more about some of the big pieces that have either already been in test, maybe what you've learned from that? And just help us kind of contextualize what franchisees to be walking away with as they all come up to Ann Arbor later this year?

Russell J. Weiner

Josh, I think the best way to answer that question is to invite you to come up and join us for our Investor Day in Q4. We are really excited to show you what we show our franchisees, which are takeaways on the things that we've learned through some of these capacity issues, driver availability issues. And then more importantly, how that is leading to ideas to reinvent our circle of operations and improve technology to help circle of operations, but also help at the end of the day, the product the customer gets to be as hot as it can be. And also improve what it's like to work at a Domino's pizza. So maybe if there were videos, and I'd be able to show you stuff a little bit more, but this is the old-school phone call. And so you have to come up to Ann Arbor. And we look forward to seeing you.

Operator

And our next question comes from the line of Chris O'Cull from Stifel.

Christopher Thomas O'Cull

Sandeep, you mentioned comparison benefits in the first quarter that won't benefit the second quarter. But I was under the impression that transaction declines were also just as weak in the second quarter last year, implying the comparison should continue to be favorable. And I'm just wondering if that was true? And then if you could just help us understand how meaningful the ticket growth should slow in the second quarter? That would also be helpful.

Sandeep Reddy

Yes. So Chris, you are right that transactions did decline last year in the second quarter as well. So I think that piece is consistent between Q1 and Q2. what is not necessarily consistent is the fact that we had the Omicron tailwind. We had 1 boost week in Q1 of this year, which was not there in Q1 of last year.
And I think you asked -- the second part of your question was about pricing and the national pricing lab. We're not going to really get into the detail at this point. But clearly, it was a pretty significant increase to $6.99 from $5.99. So you can do the math and look for how much that's going to be. But I think it is enough of an impact for me to call it out in terms of that being moderating in Q2.

Operator

And our next question comes from the line of Andrew Charles from Cowen.

Andrew Michael Charles

It's very encouraging to hear you guys talk about confidence in the U.S. performance. But perhaps just from the outside, it looks like trends did deteriorate on a 4-year basis by about 200 basis points from 4Q to 1Q. And I guess you're also talking about the low end of long-term retail sales growth guide in 2023. So can you just help contextualize what's driving the encouragement that externally may not perhaps be as obvious?

Sandeep Reddy

Yes. So Andrew, I think -- thanks for the question. And like I said on the last call, we're not going to look at stacks as a way of measuring our business. And I think it's fair enough that you can actually ask the question, but really, what we want to look at is somethings that are more near term, and that's why we've really talked about the current care comp and the comparison that we're overlapping. So what we really see is a terrific carryout business, a really terrific carryout business. And to basically be lapping 11% last year, it'd be doing 13.5% or 13.4% this year was a great result for us.
And look, delivery, there's a number of things that we're working on. You heard all about the initiatives on value and service and innovation that we're working on. So we are doing everything within our control to drive an improvement in the performance on that part of the business. And even there, look, sequentially, it improved from minus 6.6% in Q4 to minus 2.1% in Q1. We're not happy with negative comps. We want to actually inflect the positive comps. So we're going to keep on working on that. And we have talked about the macro. It's not gone away, and that is impacting us to some extent.
But we don't want to keep making excuses about the macro. We want to focus on what's in our control, and that's why we're really putting our foot forward and actually driving all of those initiatives to get to the outcomes that we need. So super bullish on the long term. I think we just have to work for some of these short-term issues.

Operator

And our next question comes from the line of Lauren Silberman from Credit Suisse.

Lauren Danielle Silberman

Over the past few years, there's been the shift in delivery carryout mix and differences in performance between the channels. Can you just help us understand the differences in average order size as well as profitability per order between the 2? And then just more recently, have you seen any changes in check management across either of the channels?

Sandeep Reddy

Yes. So Lauren, thanks for the question. I think on the delivery carryout business, they're both really good businesses with different margin profiles, but very good businesses. And I think when we look at the profitability to the franchisees, they're both very, very accretive to their profits. And I think that's why when we actually look at the shift that's occurring between delivery and carryout the franchisee profit is not impacted in a significant way because of just the shift. Both businesses are super important, so you don't want to actually decline in delivery, like, unfortunately, we did last year.
But I think overall, from our check size, I'm not going to quantify how big the ticket is on average for delivery versus carryout, but typically, delivery ticket is going to be higher than carryout. But I think the cost of delivery is a little bit more labor intensive for obvious reasons, because you have driver cost in particular. So the flow-through on that in terms of dollars is good, but I think the cost profile is higher, and therefore, the margins are smaller on a delivery transaction versus the carryout transaction.

Operator

And our next question comes from the line of from JPMorgan.

John William Ivankoe

It's John Ivankoe. I did in the spirit of innovation, I want to ask about where we are in the personalization journey. It's something we've been hearing about the better data-driven companies, which you are certainly the top of, the ability to customize promotions to customers to really elicit a specific behavior. So where are we in that journey? Is there any kind of significant functionality that can come as part of your new loyalty program, maybe some back-end work that you're doing around PULSE 2.0? Just give us a sense of where you are and where you think you will go in the relatively near to medium term?

Russell J. Weiner

John, that's a great question. We are making improvements in, call it, kind of the tweaking of it through AB testing, multivariate testing and things like that. I think the reason we're leaning into a new loyalty program and a redo, I don't think I know and a redo of our e-commerce business is there are certain things that we want to be able to do that we're not doing right now. And this will really let us lean into personalization in a much bigger way. So great question, and the timing is perfect.

Operator

Our next question comes from the line of Zack Fadem from Wells Fargo.

John Park

This is John Park on for Zack. I mean, I guess, again, you guys talked about the lower income demo kind of shying away from delivery a bit given the macro pressures. Can you just provide some color on how that different income cohorts kind of performed within delivery versus takeout?

Sandeep Reddy

Yes. So I think on this, the -- what we pointed out from a macro standpoint was on the last call, more particularly than this call. But -- what we also noted, if you go back to my prepared remarks, I did say that we're going to have to continue to monitor real disposable income and the trends in that. and kind of how that's evolving? Because what you're seeing right now is inflation is on a downward trend, but wage growth seems to be holding up in the U.S. economy. But I think it cuts a little bit differently depending on income strata.
So I think over time, you're going to basically see potentially a change in the dynamic. But as of now, we still see this being a pressure point.

Russell J. Weiner

And I think what I'd add to that is a lot of times we're asked on these calls, do you see any trade down from delivery to carry out, I talked earlier about how there's a little overlap between the two. We're seeing a lot of trade down from non-Domino's carryout into Domino's carryout. And I think it's those consumers we're talking about. So certainly, from a delivery standpoint, there are macro pressures, but I think that's actually an advantage for us on the carryout side.

Operator

And our final question for today comes from the line of Todd Brooks from Benchmark.

Todd Morrison Brooks

Just on the unit growth side. I know Sandeep, you talked about just timing of fiscal quarter end versus some international openings. Is there any way that you can maybe size how many of those openings did occur in the first couple of weeks of the quarter here? Any commentary about what gives you confidence that the frictions on the U.S. construction side will ease in the second half? And then do you continue to be comfortable with at least reaching that low end of that 5% to 7% unit growth guidance?

Sandeep Reddy

So a few things that I'm going to unpack in your questions. And I think let's start with the international unit growth question that you had. There was pretty much a timing issue between our fiscal calendar and our master franchisees, which is going to be a noise factor, frankly, for the -- on many quarters in the year. You'll see quarter-to-quarter noise. But I think overall, when we look at the pipeline of where our master franchisees are projecting the unit openings are going to be. We feel pretty good that we are on track for a full year basis, and that's really incorporated into our global unit growth estimation.
And so I think then I will talk about the U.S. store growth in particular. Look, I mean, we've been saying since the beginning of the year that we expected to see a first half be pressured by the same issues, which is permitting supply chain construction challenges that we are going to get through. But you heard Russell say themselves, which is we've been talking to the system. We've been talking to franchisees. We've been talking to our own internal teams really digging in, because our pipeline is very, very robust.
And frankly, the appetite for store openings is very strong. And that's why we feel that yes. First, we'll see a bit of a stabilization in the second half, and then we're going to see that inflection. And as Russell said, it's into 2024 because we have a pipeline that goes beyond '23 right now. And that's why we have so much confidence.
And I'm going to actually bring in another piece, which you didn't ask, but I'm going to say that this is a very critical element. I talked about the inflection in profits for the franchisees in the fourth quarter. If anything, that inflection is accelerating right now based on our first quarter results. And if you look carefully at the food basket guidance, we're not going towards the low end, all that flows through. And I think overall, the franchisees are in a very good place from a profit standpoint relative to how they started off Q1 of last year. So there's a number of tailwinds that actually will reinforce that confidence in the system is showing in our unit growth projections.

Russell J. Weiner

All right. Well, we'd like to thank everyone for joining us this morning, and we look forward to speaking to you in July to discuss our Q2 results. Until then, talk to you soon.

Operator

Thank you, ladies and gentlemen, for your participation in today's conference. This does conclude the program. You may now disconnect. Good day.