Q2 2023 EverQuote Inc Earnings Call

Participants

Jayme Mendal; President, CEO & Director; EverQuote, Inc.

Joseph Sanborn; CFO; EverQuote, Inc.

Cory Alan Carpenter; Analyst; JPMorgan Chase & Co, Research Division

Daniel Paul Day; Senior Equity Research Analyst; B. Riley Securities, Inc., Research Division

Jed Kelly; Director & Senior Analyst; Oppenheimer & Co. Inc., Research Division

Michael Patrick Graham; MD & Senior Equity Analyst; Canaccord Genuity Corp., Research Division

Ralph Edward Schackart; Partner & Technology Analyst; William Blair & Company L.L.C., Research Division

Brinlea C. Johnson; MD; The Blueshirt Group, LLC

Presentation

Operator

Ladies and gentlemen, good afternoon. My name is Abby, and I will be your conference operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the EverQuote's Second Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. (Operator Instructions) And I will now turn the conference over to Brinlea Johnson, Investor Relations. You may begin.

Brinlea C. Johnson

Thank you. Good afternoon, and welcome to EverQuote's Second Quarter 2020 Earnings Call. We'll be discussing the results announced in our press release issued today after the market closed. With me on the call this afternoon is Jayme Mendal, EverQuote's Chief Executive Officer; and Joseph Sanborn, Chief Financial Officer of EverQuote.
During the call, we will make statements related to our business that may be considered forward-looking statements under federal securities laws, including statements concerning our financial guidance for the third quarter of 2023, our growth strategy and our plans to execute on our growth strategy, key initiatives, including our direct-to-consumer agency, our investments in the business, the growth levers we expect to drive our business, our ability to maintain existing and acquire new customers, our expectations regarding recovery of the auto insurance industry and other statements regarding our plans and prospects.
Forward-looking statements may be identified with words and phrases such as we expect, we believe, we intend, we anticipate, we plan, may, upcoming and similar words and phrases. These statements reflect our views only as of today and should not be considered our views as of any subsequent date. We specifically disclaim any obligation to update or revise these forward-looking statements, except as required by law. Forward-looking statements are not promises or guarantees of their future performance and are subject to a variety of risks and uncertainties that could cause the actual results to differ materially from our expectations.
For a discussion of material risks and other important factors that could cause our actual results to differ materially from our expectations, please refer to those contained under the heading Risk Factors in our most recent quarterly report on Form 10-Q, our annual report on Form 10-K that is on file with the Securities and Exchange Commission and available on the Investor Relations section of our website (inaudible) sec.gov. Finally, during the course of today's call, we refer to certain non-GAAP financial measures, which we believe are helpful to investors. A reconciliation of GAAP to non-GAAP measures was included in the press release we issued after the close of market today, which is available on the Investor Relations section of our website at investors.everquote.com. And with that, I'll turn it over to Jayme.

Jayme Mendal

Thank you, Brinlea, and thank you all for joining us today. In the second quarter, EverQuote reported revenue of $68 million, Variable Marketing Margin, or VMM, of $24.7 million and adjusted EBITDA of negative $2.1 million. We achieved a record high VMM as a percentage of revenue of 36.3%. However, our revenue results fell below our expectations, largely driven by 2 factors that developed in the latter half of the second quarter as auto insurance carriers continue to wrestle with significant profitability challenges.
First, a major carrier partner reduced its budget multiple times over the quarter, resulting in their lowest levels of spend in our marketplace since the auto insurance downturn began in late summer of 2021. Second, we experienced a substantial contraction in agent demand following reductions in carrier marketing subsidies for local agents. We exited the quarter with auto demand at a new low point, which we now expect to persist into the back half of the year. In response to this renewed pullback and continued uncertainty about the timing of a more sustainable auto recovery, we initiated a restructuring of the business in June.
The restructuring included a large reduction in force, an exit of our health insurance vertical and its associated direct-to-consumer agency operations and a scale down of our DTCA operations serving the auto and home verticals. We also took actions to strengthen our balance sheet, which Joseph will cover in more detail. The combination of actions we have taken puts EverQuote in a stronger position to weather a further prolonged period of volatility in the auto insurance market. While the restructuring was catalyzed by the lower for longer auto insurance outlook, the specific decisions we made were informed by a deeper assessment of our overall strategy. We are also restoring greater focus on our most differentiated assets to deliver deeper value to our customers.
These assets include our insurance shopping traffic scale and technology, our local agent network and our proprietary data and associated data science and machine learning capabilities, which we expect to take on greater significance as we continue to identify AI applications for insurance distribution. And in doing so, we reset our cost structure to enable significant adjusted EBITDA expansion and cash generation as the auto insurance market recovers. While we are proud of the health and Medicare business we built over the last 3 years, our decision to exit the vertical reflects our renewed commitment to a greater focus.
As a more people and capital-intensive operation, these verticals operated with materially lower capital efficiency than our other verticals. In addition, the market's constant changing regulatory environment gave us lower conviction in our ability to win. As a result of exiting health and Medicare, our teams will have the resources to go deeper in our remaining vertical markets with a heavier focus on our P&C marketplace. We believe the P&C market will evolve in the coming years as a result of fast-changing underwriting dynamics and that EverQuote is well positioned to partner with carriers and local agents in adapting.
In P&C, we have the industry's largest local agent network and sales operation with an installed base of over 7,000 local agents to whom we can deliver more and better products to support their growth. As the largest online source of P&C insurance shopping traffic, we have a wealth of insurance distribution data. We have been steadfast in applying this data using machine learning to make our P&C operation more effective and efficient. And now with a sharper focus, we believe we can accelerate the rate at which we deploy machine learning and artificial intelligence across aspects of our business, ranging from operational efficiency to traffic bidding.
Our vision remains unchanged, to become the largest online source of insurance policies using data, technology and knowledgeable advisers to make insurance simpler, more affordable and more personalized. While our path to get there is evolving, I'm confident that greater focus and a more capital efficient and streamlined operation will accelerate our ability to provide compelling value to our consumers, insurance provider partners and shareholders. Our team has demonstrated remarkable resilience and adaptability to fast-changing and challenging market conditions. And I have no doubt that this strengthening of our team will pay dividends and enable us to emerge with incredible success when the market recovers.
Before I turn the call over to Joseph, I wanted to thank John Wagner for his 9 years of dedication to EverQuote. I am also excited to welcome Joseph Sanborn to his first EverQuote earnings call as our new Chief Financial Officer. Joseph has been working closely with our executive team and me for the past 4 years, serving in a variety of finance and strategy roles. He possesses deep operational experience in and understanding of our business and brings extensive strategic finance and capital markets experience to the role. Joseph, please go ahead.

Joseph Sanborn

Thank you, Jayme, for the warm introduction. Good afternoon, everyone. During my nearly 4 years with EverQuote, I've had the pleasure of meeting many of our investors. As I step into the CFO role, I look forward to continuing our dialogue and sharing with you the progress we are making at EverQuote. I will start by discussing our financial results for the second quarter then update you on recent actions taken since the end of Q2 before providing guidance for the third quarter.
Our total revenue for the second quarter of $68 million represented a decline of 33% year-over-year and was lower than our previous guidance range for Q2 revenue. Despite the revenue shortfall, we delivered Variable Marketing Margin, or VMM, and adjusted EBITDA above the midpoint of our guidance as our operating teams continue to execute well in a deeply challenging environment.
Q2 revenue from our auto insurance vertical decreased 39% year-over-year to $49.7 million, a sequential decline of 45% from Q1. The second quarter is typically a seasonally weaker period in our auto insurance vertical. In addition, substantially weakened demand in Q2 from our largest carrier customer followed a very strong start to the year. Our third party or local agent network was more resilient, representing 50% of total revenues in Q2, but it also experienced a year-over-year revenue decline, primarily driven by another one of our large carrier partners reducing their agent subsidies within the quarter.
As a result, we exited the quarter with auto revenues at a new low point since the downturn began in late summer 2021. Revenue from our other insurance verticals, which includes home and renters, life and health insurance verticals, decreased 11% year-over-year to $18.2 million in the second quarter and represented 27% of revenue. The decline in revenue was mostly attributable to our health insurance vertical, which we made the strategic decision to exit within the quarter in which I will cover in more detail later in my remarks. Excluding health, the other insurance verticals grew quarter-over-quarter, led by the home vertical, which continues to make steady progress.
VMM was $24.7 million for the second quarter. Despite lower monetization, VMM as a percentage of revenue was a record 36.3% for the quarter, driven by 3 main factors: First, our traffic teams were able to quickly drive down customer acquisition costs in a volatile environment. Second, we benefited from a shift in revenue mix towards our local agent network, which often has a higher VMM percentage. And third, we experienced double-digit growth in traffic volume as consumers continue to face large premium increases from auto insurance carriers receiving regulatory approvals for rate hikes. In short, our engine is working.
We're also being disciplined in managing expenses and took multiple actions within the quarter to restructure our operations to reflect the current conditions of the market in which, in aggregate, resulted in the elimination of approximately 30% of positions across our company, including open requisitions. On June 16, we announced plans to implement a structural reduction of over 15% in our non-marketing operating expenses excluding noncash items. As part of the strategic review that identified these savings, we made the decision to exit the health insurance vertical, including the associated direct-to-consumer agency or DTCA.
Our decision to exit the vertical reflects our return to a relatively more asset-light model and renewed commitment to investing in areas where we believe we can build a long-term competitive moat. Also, as we announced today, we sold select assets of our former health insurance vertical to MyPlan Advocate for approximately $13.2 million in cash, subject to customary post-closing adjustment and buyers' assumption of certain related liabilities. The transaction closed on August 1. Included the sale with the $32.2 million commission receivable as of June 30, 2023, which we expected to be collected over the next 7 years. We expect to take a significant noncash charge in Q3 related to the sale of these assets.
For context, the health insurance vertical represented less than 10% of our revenue in fiscal year 2022. If we had continued to operate the health insurance vertical, we expect it to generate incremental adjusted EBITDA in the coming fourth quarter during the annual open enrollment period. That performance, however, would have come at the cost of significant cash consumption in the current year. Given that all traffic and selling costs on policy sales are incurred in the current period, but the majority of commissions from such sales are received over several years.
In addition to the agent support roles associated with the health insurance vertical, we eliminated numerous positions company-wide, including a substantial scale down of our DTCA, serving the P&C markets of the auto and home insurance. Given the cash consumptive nature of the DTCA model, we have concluded that the current environment does not support scaling this operation at this time even in our core P&C markets. Instead, we have elected to maintain a small agent team to focus exclusively on selling auto and home policies. We have learned that having our own agents provides valuable traffic and customer insights and expanded carrier selection for shoppers, which in turn creates a stronger marketplace that better serves our customers.
Turning to the bottom line. In the second quarter, GAAP net loss was $13.2 million and adjusted EBITDA was negative $2.1 million. To note, cost reduction efforts taken in Q2 resulted in a restructuring charge of approximately $3.8 million, which is excluded from adjusted EBITDA. We generated operating cash flow of $3.3 million for the second quarter, a year-over-year and sequential improvement, reflecting favorable timing of working capital, tighter expense management and reduced investment in our DTCA operations. We ended the quarter with cash and cash equivalents on the balance sheet of $31 million.
Subsequent to the close of Q2, we made 2 strategic decisions to strengthen our balance sheet and liquidity position. As I described earlier in my remarks, we sold select assets of our former health insurance vertical for approximately $13.2 million in cash, which will be added to our balance sheet. Second, we modified our existing loan agreement with Western Alliance Bank, provides significantly more flexible terms that better align with our current financial outlook given the prolonged nature of the auto carrier downturn.
As part of this modification, we reduced the line of credit from $35 million to $25 million and eliminated the undrawn $10 million term loan. We have no debt currently outstanding on the Western Alliance debt facility, which runs through to July 2025 and have no plans to draw on the facility. Following these 2 actions after the close of the quarter, we currently have total liquidity in excess of $60 million.
Turning to our outlook, including an update on the market conditions in the auto insurance industry. We ended June with very weak auto carrier demand, resulting in a new low point since the auto insurance downturn began in late summer 2021. We have seen these conditions persist into Q3, like many others in the industry. Based on discussions with our carrier partners and their public commentary on their own profitability, our current expectation is that auto carriers will largely remain on the sidelines through year-end. While moderating inflation and falling used car prices provide reason for some optimism, the exact timing of recovery continues to be uncertain.
We believe nearly all auto insurance carriers are continuing to experience a low levels of profitability, while still working to aggressively increase rates in order to achieve rate adequacy. Although our local agent network has proved to be resilient, the prolonged nature of this downturn has resulted in more reductions of carrier support for their captive agents, and we anticipate the possibility of further reductions which may impact our local agents during the remainder of this year. Ultimately, we remain confident that auto insurance premium increases will improve financial performance for auto insurance carriers and consequently, will increase their demand for new consumer acquisition.
But the timing of this improvement continues to be delayed, therefore impacting our guidance for Q3. We expect revenue to be between $51 million and $56 million, a year-over-year decrease of 48% at the midpoint. We expect VMM to be between $16 million and $18 million, a year-over-year decrease of 47% at the midpoint. And we expect adjusted EBITDA to be between negative $6 million and negative $4 million.
In summary, we delivered solid performance within the second quarter, exceeding the midpoint of our guidance for VMM and adjusted EBITDA. We are executing well and taking market share in a very challenging market. We are focusing on what we can control and taking decisive action to judiciously manage expenses and our own capital. Though we recognize the high level of uncertainty in the near term, we have strong conviction EverQuote will be well positioned to capitalize on the market opportunity and will directly benefit from the normalization of auto insurance carrier demand. Jayme and I will now answer your questions.

Question and Answer Session

Operator

(Operator Instructions) And we will take our first question from Michael Graham with Canaccord.

Michael Patrick Graham

Okay. I want to wish John Wagner well and Joseph, congratulations. I wanted to ask 2 questions, guys. The first one is on just liquidity and sort of capital needs and just maybe address how you're thinking about your balance sheet and how comfortable you are with it here for the balance of the year, I guess? And then secondly, Jayme, you mentioned in your prepared remarks that you felt like in the auto vertical, where you were sort of maintaining your core business that you feel like you have a good competitive moat that you're building around. Can you just maybe address some of the sort of key points and sort of the focus of like building or maintaining a competitive moat in auto?

Jayme Mendal

Sure. Why don't -- I'll take the second question first, and then I'll turn it over to Joseph to talk about liquidity. As we approach -- as we worked our way through Q2, there was -- we saw a fairly dramatic drawdown in auto demand. And with that, I think we performed a strategic assessment with -- the conclusion of which was we will benefit from greater strategic focus and improved capital utilization and capital efficiency. And that kind of forced the decision to reduce the workforce, exit health and Medicare and really focus on P&C specifically. One of the big motivators behind that was we were -- we took stock of what are our truly differentiated assets. And we believe those to be our local agent network, where we have an installed base of about 7,000 plus local agents who rely on us to grow their agency.
Traffic volume, particularly in P&C and auto and home, where we believe we are the largest source of online insurance traffic in those verticals. And then a lot of the data and technology infrastructure we've built around that. And so in a world where we're making decisions about whether to go wider and less deep or less wide and more deep, we decided to go less wide and more deep and to do so in P&C, where we feel we have these assets that we can really build on and around to deliver more value for customers and ultimately more value for shareholders over time.

Joseph Sanborn

I'll take your first question, Mike. Thank you for your welcome as well. So in terms of our liquidity position, we ended second quarter with $31 million in cash on the balance sheet. To that, we've done -- we mentioned 2 actions we've taken since the end of the quarter to further strengthen the balance sheet. One was the sale of our health assets add another incremental $13 million. We also modified our loan with Western Alliance Bank to a $25 million facility. Again, not planning to use that facility, but we modified the terms to give us much more flexibility reflecting the current environment. And so adding those all together, we have in excess of $60 million of liquidity.
So we feel that is ample liquidity for the business for a prolonged auto downturn. In terms of cash utilization, as we look through this quarter, what you're seeing is that we're returning to a model where EBITDA will become a closer proxy for cash flow use in the quarter. Obviously, adjusted for ebbs and flows of working capital between quarter end and month-to-month. So we feel we have ample liquidity given the prolonged downturn given the actions we've taken since Q2.

Operator

And we will take our next question from Ralph Schackart with William Blair.

Ralph Edward Schackart

Congrats, Joseph on the new role. During the prepared remarks, Jim, you talked about focusing perhaps on AI and applications for insurance distribution. Just curious if you could provide some more context to that as to the more traditional AI? Or are you looking to leverage Gen AI at some capacity. And then I have a follow-up.

Jayme Mendal

Sure. So our simplistic framework for thinking about this is sort of 2 categories of application. One is in operational efficiency. It's more internal use cases. And then the second in more customer-facing features. The focus to date has been primarily on the first category. And we've already begun to deploy use cases, which are starting to show signs of success and build some adoption internally. And so in a recent example, we leveraged AI capabilities to automate a set of activities in one of our sales functions and that improved the efficiency of that team by about 80%. We have similar examples beginning to take shape in engineering, and we're working on kind of extending it outwards to build adoption internally first.
But I think one of the big opportunities that we have, and again, it's part of the rationale for focusing more narrowly on P&C and going deeper is that we have a wealth of insurance distribution data in this market where we can tie consumer data and attributes that we've collected on millions and millions of consumers to outcomes down funnel with thousands of local agents and agents and dozens of insurance carriers. And I think with that data, there will be opportunities to really apply some of the new technology as it comes out to better match and connect consumers with the right insurance providers for them, to right-price our traffic acquisition as we bid for traffic upmarket and to improve providers' efficiency and their spend with us. So there are a whole bunch of use cases that we see out there, and we're just beginning to step our way through it, but we see a huge opportunity given the unique data that we have to emerge as a leader in the space.

Ralph Edward Schackart

Great. And then maybe just on the sort of the EBITDA burn at this point. Just philosophically, you have a continued prolonged or longer than expected, tough macro environment with your carrier partners. Would there be a certain level that you'd want to manage the burn to? Or would you perhaps look to sort of balance that out with potentially tapping the loan facility?

Jayme Mendal

So let me start, I'll start and you can (inaudible).
I think we -- as we made some of the decisions that we did this quarter, we had a couple of financial objectives. One was to reduce our cash breakeven revenue level. And so we did that successfully. Like we dramatically improved the capital efficiency of the business by taking the actions that we took. And I think in doing so, we've brought down the revenue level that would be required to generate breakeven or better cash flow by 35% to 40%. Then we have the consideration around profitability and adjusted EBITDA based on a set of assumptions about the auto recovery. And for the last 18 to 24 months, Ralph, you know we've seen these peaks and troughs, right? And right now, we happen to be at the lowest trough of the downturn of the sort of volatile period. But as Joseph mentioned in his remarks, like we do expect recovery to build as we get into 2024.
And so what we've done is we made a cut that we felt was appropriate but that enables us to continue to invest in certain parts of the business where we see significant opportunity in our renewed area of focus within P&C. And we're going to continue to operate with sort of very significant discipline on the operating expense line as we progress through the year and watch for the market to begin to recover. So we feel very good about our liquidity position. I think we have the ability to maintain modest investments in areas where we feel it to be important. But we will continue to manage our expenses very, very tightly as we progress through the balance of this year. And as we get into next year, I do think we'll (inaudible).

Joseph Sanborn

Yes. So just adding on to Jayme, so thank you is, we're going to -- as Jayme said, we're going to continue to manage our expenses carefully in a disciplined way. We want to make -- we made these decisions around strategic focus, exiting our health business and focusing more deeply on P&C. Part of the rationale and the level of cuts we took was to make sure we were well positioned for auto recovery. We think that is critical. We've been going through this storm for quite some time. We want to come out of it as a strong leader in the space. And so we think with the reductions we took sets us up to have the resources to continue to be invested positions for that. The second part is we're also mindful of continuing to manage expenses and adapting them appropriately to the environment. What I would say is that our goal as a team is that for the first half of 2024, we will be cash flow breakeven and EBITDA positive in the first half of calendar year '24.

Operator

We will take our next question from Cory Carpenter with JPMorgan.

Cory Alan Carpenter

Joseph, A few questions for you. It sounds like you sold parts of the health business but still retain others. Just curious what do you have left? And how are you thinking about the wind down of that? And then just with that in mind, any context you can give us in terms of what you're assuming for the other vertical in 3Q from a revenue contribution perspective? And then, sorry, third, just -- any color you can give on why you expect VMM margins to decline sequentially in 3Q would be helpful.

Jayme Mendal

Can you repeat that third point Cory.

Cory Alan Carpenter

The VMM guide in 3Q, I think you did 36% in margins in 2Q, you guided to about 32% in 3Q. Just curious of the drivers there?

Joseph Sanborn

Sure. So let me start with the exit of the health vertical. So just to go over what we decided. We entered the health vertical on June 30, meaning there was no health revenues in our business going forth. We exit the vertical completely at that point. So that's the first piece I would tell you. I know the press release says we sold select assets. I think we sold almost every select maybe there's a desk computer left, but that is to appeal to the lawyers and the accountants. We sold all the assets -- with the principal asset was the $32.2 million contract -- commission receivable contract asset we had on the balance sheet. That represented the estimate of the cash flows we expect to receive over the next 7 years.
We sold that for the $13.2 million in cash. In addition to that, as part of the transaction, we sold some -- we helped transition some employees to find employment opportunities with MyPlan Advocate, which is obviously a nice thing for our employees and gave us a smoother transition for them, which we were pleased with. So that's with regards to the health business and the exit. And again, there's no revenue from the health vertical coming into Q3. What you will see in Q3, as we finalize the accounting on the sale of the assets, which took place on August 1, in Q3, there'll be a noncash charge, reflecting the sale of the contract asset for $13.2 million given the contract as we expected to receive over time.
So that will be a charge that will appear in the quarter, and we're finalizing the treatment of that right now, and we'll give that guidance in next quarter. In terms of the other insurance verticals, I'll give you some insight on Q2 to help you think about it, with the health vertical more broadly. So first, last year, the health vertical represents just under 10% of total revenues for the company. If you look at that -- if you look at how that fell across the year, the largest portion of that comes in Q4 during the annual enrollment period for health care. If you look to this year, first half of this year was also less than 10% since the annual enrollment period in Q4.
Within this Q2, we had $18 million approximately in revenue from the other insurance verticals. Of that, about 35-ish percent, 40-ish percent came from health. So I guess that is the guidance I can give you in terms of the facts on Q2. We're not guiding specifically for the other insurance verticals. What I would say is the principal driver of the other insurance verticals is the home vertical, which I commented on in my remarks is having steady progress. As we talked about in our Q1 call, we put additional resources behind that from a leadership perspective to sort of reignite that vertical. We've been pleased with the making steady progress. We had double-digit growth there in Q2 in the home vertical.
And then lastly, on VMM margins to decline in Q3, maybe a little color on that. You're seeing our VMM margins. If you look at the guide sort of in the low 30s, 31.5%, 32.5% range. And I think that really reflects that Q2, we were pleased -- we were very pleased with getting a record VMM margin. We're not assuming that will be sustainable. A couple of things that drove that, I think, was particularly our teams adapted very well to a volatile environment, and we're able to take advantage of that and get near-term benefits. The sustainability that, I think, would be a question in our mind, so we did factor it into our guidance. The other piece I would say is that we also had larger DTCA in Q2, both in health, but also on our P&C side, as Jayme mentioned, we've scaled back our P&C vertical, DTCA as well as exiting health. Those were drivers that contributed to higher VMM. So that's why you see us going back to 1 more of a normal level we had really factoring out the DTCA operation.
Or -- and I guess the last point I'd say on VMM margins, we continue to have a goal of going towards the long term of getting into the 40-ish percent range. We're continuing to make steady progress, and you'll see us continue to do that over time. But we wanted to sort of recalibrate reflecting that Q2, although high was -- we don't want to view that as the starting point for the rest of the year.

Operator

(Operator Instructions) We will take our next question from Dan Day with B. Riley Securities.

Daniel Paul Day

So a little more detail just on the pullback to subsidies and agent channel. So how much visibility do you have in terms of how long that will last? Is it any better than the carrier marketplace spending? How aggressive have those reductions been? And really, is it just like 1 or 2 carriers? Or is it fairly broad-based so far?

Jayme Mendal

Yes, sure. Thanks, Dan. So the agent subsidies are primarily -- they're relatively concentrated in a small number of carriers. The big change in Q2 was one of the larger of those carriers cut back subsidies in a number of states, representing a good portion of their agent demand. And so in those states, we saw agents who had less subsidy dollar support from the carrier pullback in terms of their demand. With respect to the expectation going forward, I think it's similar to what we expect for the rest of the marketplace, which is that -- the balance of 2023, we do not expect to see recovery in those subsidy dollars. I do think as we look ahead to 2024, the messaging we're receiving is that we will likely see some of those dollars return, but it wouldn't be like a light switch in the sense that they return to early 2023 levels right at the beginning of 2024. It will likely follow some path of the carrier being able to get sufficient rate to be comfortable with their profitability on a state-by-state basis over the course of 2024.

Daniel Paul Day

Got it. And then just a follow-up. So the decision not to fully exit DTCA in home and health, just you talked a little bit about it, what you like about that business? Maybe just a little more detail on that, why to keep sort of a smaller presence there? And then longer term, like do you see this as just a temporary scale back that, maybe you'll add more P&C agents when the recovery happens? Or is it sort of just -- it is what it is at this point?

Jayme Mendal

Sure. So just to clarify, we exited DTCA entirely in health and Medicare which we exited the verticals. And with that, our DTCA operations, and that represented the majority of our Agent headcount. And then within P&C, which is the other DTCA operation that we have, we significantly reduced the agent headcount. And we did so because we -- because of our renewed commitment to capital efficiency in the business. And so if you go back to the rationale for getting into this -- into the DTCA in the first place, it -- there was a strategic rationale and then there was some growth that it was meant to generate.
And we made this decision at a time when the auto insurance market was in a healthier place. And of course, conditions on the ground have changed, and so we're revisiting some of those assumptions. Where we are today, we have a basically scaled down P&C DTCA operation today. So we have agents who are selling auto and home insurance. The strategic rationale that existed back when continues to exist today and get proven out. And that is that these agents can provide incremental coverage to the marketplace. They can provide options to consumers who come in when we don't have a good third-party option for them. They can generate a lot of insight about what happens with consumers down funnel.
So we've got a lot of real-time data on quality of traffic and LTV profile of consumers that we can use to improve our overall traffic operations. And it serves as a bit of an internal customer, which we treat just like innovation lab as we try and improve our offering for third-party agents as well. So the majority of those things can be accomplished with a smaller footprint, and that's what we're trying to hold on to. I think the piece that -- the notion that we are letting go of is DTCA as a stand-alone growth driver because that's not consistent with our renewed focus on capital efficiency. And so I would expect that its current incarnation, which is a much smaller agent base will be the state in which it persists for the foreseeable future.

Operator

And we will take our final question from Jed Kelly with Oppenheimer.

Jed Kelly

just looking at sort of the, I guess, nonvariable marketing expenses implied in the guide, I think it's around like $22 million in the third quarter. Is that the proper run rate to assume going forward? And then, Joseph, just circling back on your free cash flow breakeven comments around the first half of next year, sort of what kind of gives you confidence to put that type of guidance out there?

Joseph Sanborn

Sure. So I think first -- so thanks, Jed, for the question. So I think, first, in terms of the operating expense level, I think you've got a reasonable ballpark on that. If you put that in context to where we ended Q2 and what the guidance we've given. We said it was going to be 15% reduction in structural costs and you're us doing that in Q3. So I think that's first. And then as we look to next year, as we think about the business, we think there's -- we do believe there will be some auto recovery in the course of next year -- in the first half of next year. As Jayme's talk touched on, we have dramatically lowered the cash flow breakeven point of the business to the actions we've taken.
We've done it by 35% to 40% versus where we were in the start of the year. So what that means in practice speaking is very modest recovery from current levels even below where we were earlier in the year. It allows us below where we were in Q2, allows us to feel confident of getting to cash flow EBITDA breakeven. And as I said, the difference in EBITDA and cash flow right now very similar. The differences are modest and really is working capital quarter. So versus when we had DTCA, we had a heavy cash investment upfront, where we realize it over time. As we've gone to more of an asset-light model, great emphasis on capital efficiency and return on capital, you're seeing that stronger connection between adjusted EBITDA being a proxy for cash flow in a period.

Jed Kelly

Great. And then just a follow-up. Just I think every insurance marketer is like going through this. Jayme, where do you see the competitive landscape shaking out when this recovery happens? I mean do you think everyone will benefit? Or do you think there'll be much fewer players? Or do you see a period of consolidation? Just -- how do you see things shaking out when we do eventually get to a recovery?

Jayme Mendal

Yes. Thanks, Jed. So I think we've -- well, it's been a challenging period for everyone. We have performed relatively well in that by all measures, if you just sort of track insurance revenue from companies in the competitive set, we have gained market share through the downturn. And we feel very good about our competitive position. As you look ahead, I think the recovery will certainly will lift all -- the rising tide will lift all boats. It's hard for me to speculate on whether or not there will be consolidation. But I feel very good about EverQuote's competitive position as we come out of the downturn, having gained market share and now especially having added focus and emphasis on the auto insurance market, I think we will continue to build on our edge with these local agents, and in doing so, emerge in a fairly differentiated position relative to the rest of the market.

Operator

And there are no further questions at this time. I will now turn the call back to management for closing remarks.

Jayme Mendal

Thanks all for joining us today. So as the auto insurance market volatility persists. We took significant action this quarter to strengthen our position for further prolonged downturn. We dramatically improved our capital efficiency. We strengthened our balance sheet. We streamlined expenses. And we bolstered our focus in areas where we can build on and around our most differentiated assets. I'm confident that the changes we made will accelerate our ability to provide compelling value to our customers, insurance provider partners and our shareholders moving forward. Thanks for your time.

Operator

Ladies and gentlemen, this concludes today's call. We thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.