South Florida Lawyer Helped Land $10M for Families of Teens Killed in Wrong-Way Crash
Karen E. Terry of Searcy, Denney, Scarola, Barnhart & Shipley. Courtesy photo.
West Palm Beach attorneys Karen E. Terry and Jack Hill of Searcy, Denney, Scarola, Barnhart & Shipley teamed with Port St. Lucie lawyer Roger N. Messer to land a $10 million jury verdict, but no one's jumping up and down at the result. Their clients were the parents of best friends Santia Feketa, 18, and Britney Poindexter, 17, killed in a harrowing crash with a 99-year-old driver.
Michigan tourist Walter Roney was driving the wrong way without headlights down a divided Fort Pierce highway when he struck the teens, killing them instantly. Roney died three days later.
At about 5 p.m. on Feb. 6, 2018, Roney and his 75-year-old girlfriend Carolyn Bruns left Melbourne in a 4,200-pound recreational vehicle. They were going to repair the motorhome, which was the size of a Greyhound bus and riddled with electrical problems, according to Terry.
"They had many opportunities to have this RV repaired in Michigan and every state they passed through to get to Florida, but for some reason they chose to take it to Punta Gorda to get repaired," Terry said.
The worst part, as Terry sees it, was that the couple had planned on leaving earlier but hung back to watch a NASA shuttle launch, meaning they had to drive at night. According to Terry, Roney missed his Interstate 95 exit at Fort Pierce, so looped around to go westbound. Instead he turned too early onto an eastbound lane.
"Probably because their headlights were not on, they did not see at least four signs that said, 'One way,' 'do not enter,' 'wrong way,' 'divided highway.' If they’d have seen any of those they would have known they were on the wrong side of the road," Terry said.
The Poindexters retained Terry and Feketa's family retained Messer, suing Roney's estate in April 2018. They brought separate complaints that were consolidated for trial. The crash hit the community so hard that the case had to be tried out of town in West Palm Beach.
Roger N. Messer of Messer & Messer Law. Courtesy.
"I don’t think they could have gotten a fair jury in St. Lucie County," Messer said. "The emotion here was too high."
In the run-up to trial, Terry and Messer negotiated a $1 million settlement with Bruns —Roney's passenger and the only survivor — using a rare joint enterprise theory over her alleged failures. According to Terry, Bruns was guiding Roney using Google Maps and looking after his medical needs.
"In the weeks before this trip, Roney's passenger, his girlfriend, was signing his care-taking logs and his blood pressure and his heart rate," Terry said. "So we alleged she was his caretaker, at least for purposes of this trip, that she was responsible for making intelligent decisions, i.e. not leaving at 5 o'clock, knowing it’s going to be dark and you don’t have headlights."
Roney collided head-on with Feketa's pick-up truck.
Lawyers for Roney's estate, Carlos A. Garcia, Patrick K. Dahl and Robert Paradela of Wicker Smith, O'Hara, McCoy & Ford in Fort Lauderdale, did not respond to requests for comment before deadline. Counsel to Bruns, David Kirsch of Cole, Scott & Kissane in West Palm Beach, declined comment.
The defense denied fault initially, litigated, but admitted liability at the last minute, which limited what Terry and Messer could show jurors, the attorneys said.
"The reason they did that was to keep out these damning facts of the case," Terry said. "They were very smart to do what they did."
Jurors saw two photographs of the crash and a handwritten to-do list by Roney, featuring a slew of fixes needed for the RV, including "replace headlights." Terry and Messer hired an accident reconstruction expert who confirmed that the headlights weren't on at the time of the crash, though jurors heard it from Florida Highway Patrol to avoid duplicate testimony.
Jurors didn't hear that one of Roney's children texted him about the electrical problems throughout the trip and others had taken the RV keys from him but he'd got them back. The jury knew Roney was 99 but weren't given specifics about his medical problems, which included Alzheimer's disease, cognitive and neuropathy in his hands and feet, according to Terry.
"This guy should not have been driving," Terry said.
That said, Roney had passed his Michigan driving test just months earlier, and passed an additional test for senior citizens — though not with flying colors.
'The judge had red eyes'
Trial lasted two days and featured testimony from those close to Poindexter and Feketa — both heavily involved in volunteer work with special needs children. The jury awarded each family $5 million.
Florida teenagers Britney Poindexter (left) and Santia Feketa (right). Courtesy photo.
"This devastated the community," Terry said. "These girls touched so many lives because of all the things they were involved in."
A few of Messer's cases have made him cry, but this one was something else.
"I’ve been doing trial work for 42 years and this one affected me more than any other case I’ve ever been on," Messer said. "There were tears all over the courtroom. The judge had red eyes when it was over."
According to Messer, U.S. District Judge Robin Rosenberg congratulated defense and plaintiffs counsel for what was a clean trial. Messer recalled Rosenberg saying how lucky the parents were to have had the girls.
"She said, 'I sentence bad kids every day for mistakes they’ve made, and these girls were wonderful,'" Messer said. "My clients appreciated that more than anything else."
Case: Yvonne Poindexter and Stacy Lynne West v. Joseph Zarcharzewski
Case no.: 2:18-cv-14155 and 2:18-cv-14156
Description: Wrongful death
Filing date: April 27, 2018
Verdict date: April 10, 2019
Judge: U.S. District Judge Robin Rosenberg in the Southern District of Florida
Plaintiffs attorneys: Karen Terry and Jack Hill, Searcy, Denney, Scarola, Barnhart & Shipley, West Palm Beach; Roger N. Messer, Messer & Messer, Port St. Lucie
Defense attorneys: Robert Paradela, Patrick Dahl and Carlos Garcia, Wicker Smith, O'Hara, McCoy & Ford, Fort Lauderdale
Verdict amount: $10 million
More verdicts and settlements:
South Florida Lawyers Drive $6 Million Settlement for Cyclist Hit by Porsche
South Florida Attorneys Win $4.8M Over Former Lawyer's 'Preventable' Heart Attack on Birthday Cruise
